SOM-09-02 Chapter 09 · Thin and Thick Cylinders

Volumetric Strain, Wire-Wound Cylinders & Joint Efficiency

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Title & Metadata Header

  • Topic ID: SOM-09-02
  • Module / Subject: Strength of Materials (Mechanics of Solids)
  • Chapter 09: Thin and Thick Cylinders & Spherical Shells
  • Topic Title: Volumetric Strain, Joint Efficiency, and Wire-Wound Thin Cylinders
  • Prerequisites: SOM-01-03 (Elastic Constants & Generalized Hooke's Law), SOM-09-01 (Thin Cylinder & Spherical Membrane Stresses).
  • Target Examinations: GATE CE, UPSC ESE (Civil), SSC JE (Civil), State AE/JE, RRB JE (Civil).
  • Quality Assurance Gate: Level 1 through Level 7 Verification Protocol Enforced.

2. Introduction & Physical Mechanics

When a thin cylindrical or spherical pressure vessel is subjected to internal fluid pressure, its walls expand elastically under the action of biaxial tensile membrane stresses (σh\sigma_h and σL\sigma_L). This multi-directional expansion causes three simultaneous dimensional changes:

  1. Increase in internal diameter (δd>0\delta d > 0),
  2. Increase in overall length (δL>0\delta L > 0),
  3. Expansion of internal volume (ΔV>0\Delta V > 0).

Accurate determination of volumetric dilatation is vital in civil and structural engineering:

  • Proof & Hydrostatic Acceptance Testing: Water transmission pipelines, penstocks, and pressure vessels are tested by pumping in water to a specified proof pressure (typically 1.5×1.5 \times operating pressure). Because water is slightly compressible, the total volume of water injected into the vessel during testing equals the vessel volume increase plus the elastic compression volume of the test fluid.
  • Joint Efficiency: Fabricated steel pipes and boilers are constructed by rolling steel plates and joining them via longitudinal and circumferential welded or riveted seams. Because joints exhibit lower strength than solid parent metal, joint efficiencies (ηL\eta_L and ηc\eta_c) directly govern the permissible internal pressure.
  • Prestressing via Wire Winding: For high-pressure applications, winding high-tensile wire under tension around a thin cylinder pre-compresses the cylinder wall, significantly reducing tensile hoop stresses during operation. This classical principle is the direct forefather of modern Prestressed Concrete Cylinder Pipes (PCCP / IS 784) and aerospace Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels (COPVs).

3. Circumferential & Longitudinal Strains in Thin Shells

Consider an elemental block on the surface of a thin cylindrical pressure vessel subjected to internal gauge pressure pp. The block is in a state of plane stress with principal stresses:

σ1=σh=p⋅d2t(Circumferential hoop stress)\sigma_1 = \sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} \quad (\text{Circumferential hoop stress}) σ2=σL=p⋅d4t(Longitudinal axial stress)\sigma_2 = \sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} \quad (\text{Longitudinal axial stress}) σ3=σr≈0(Radial stress negligible)\sigma_3 = \sigma_r \approx 0 \quad (\text{Radial stress negligible})

3.1 Circumferential (Diametral) Strain (ϵ1\epsilon_1)

The circumferential strain ϵ1\epsilon_1 represents the fractional change in circumference. For a circular cross-section of initial diameter dd:

Initial circumference=πd,Expanded circumference=π(d+δd)\text{Initial circumference} = \pi d, \quad \text{Expanded circumference} = \pi (d + \delta d) ϵ1=π(d+δd)−πdπd=δdd\epsilon_1 = \frac{\pi (d + \delta d) - \pi d}{\pi d} = \frac{\delta d}{d}

(Fundamental Theorem: Circumferential strain equals diametral strain!)

Applying Generalized Hooke's Law for a biaxial stress field:

ϵ1=σ1E−νσ2E=σhE−νσLE\epsilon_1 = \frac{\sigma_1}{E} - \nu \frac{\sigma_2}{E} = \frac{\sigma_h}{E} - \nu \frac{\sigma_L}{E}

Substituting σh=pd2t\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t} and σL=pd4t\sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t}:

ϵ1=1E[pd2t−νpd4t]=pd4tE(2−ν)\epsilon_1 = \frac{1}{E} \left[ \frac{p d}{2 t} - \nu \frac{p d}{4 t} \right] = \frac{p d}{4 t E} (2 - \nu)

The total increase in internal diameter is:

δd=ϵ1⋅d=p⋅d24tE(2−ν)\delta d = \epsilon_1 \cdot d = \frac{p \cdot d^2}{4 t E} (2 - \nu)

3.2 Longitudinal (Axial) Strain (ϵ2\epsilon_2)

The longitudinal strain ϵ2\epsilon_2 represents the fractional change in length:

ϵ2=δLL=σ2E−νσ1E=σLE−νσhE\epsilon_2 = \frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{\sigma_2}{E} - \nu \frac{\sigma_1}{E} = \frac{\sigma_L}{E} - \nu \frac{\sigma_h}{E}

Substituting σh=pd2t\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t} and σL=pd4t\sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t}:

ϵ2=1E[pd4t−νpd2t]=pd4tE(1−2ν)\epsilon_2 = \frac{1}{E} \left[ \frac{p d}{4 t} - \nu \frac{p d}{2 t} \right] = \frac{p d}{4 t E} (1 - 2\nu)

The total increase in length is:

δL=ϵ2⋅L=p⋅d⋅L4tE(1−2ν)\delta L = \epsilon_2 \cdot L = \frac{p \cdot d \cdot L}{4 t E} (1 - 2\nu)

Physical Significance of Poisson's Ratio on Length: Notice the factor (1−2ν)(1 - 2\nu):

  • If ν<0.5\nu < 0.5 (e.g., structural steel where ν≈0.3\nu \approx 0.3), (1−2(0.3))=0.4>0(1 - 2(0.3)) = 0.4 > 0. The cylinder elongates under internal pressure (δL>0\delta L > 0).
  • If an incompressible material were used (ν=0.5\nu = 0.5), (1−2(0.5))=0(1 - 2(0.5)) = 0, meaning length remains unchanged (δL=0\delta L = 0).
  • If ν>0.5\nu > 0.5, the cylinder would actually shorten axially under internal pressure!

4. Volumetric Strain of Thin Cylinders and Spherical Shells

4.1 Thin Cylindrical Shell Volumetric Strain (ϵv\epsilon_v)

The internal capacity of a cylinder of diameter dd and length LL is:

V=π4d2LV = \frac{\pi}{4} d^2 L

Taking the natural logarithm of both sides:

ln⁡V=ln⁡(π4)+2ln⁡d+ln⁡L\ln V = \ln\left(\frac{\pi}{4}\right) + 2 \ln d + \ln L

Differentiating both sides:

dVV=2ddd+dLL\frac{dV}{V} = 2 \frac{dd}{d} + \frac{dL}{L}

In terms of engineering strains:

ϵv=ΔVV=2ϵ1+ϵ2\epsilon_v = \frac{\Delta V}{V} = 2 \epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2

Now substitute the expressions for ϵ1\epsilon_1 and ϵ2\epsilon_2:

ϵv=2[pd4tE(2−ν)]+[pd4tE(1−2ν)]\epsilon_v = 2 \left[ \frac{p d}{4 t E} (2 - \nu) \right] + \left[ \frac{p d}{4 t E} (1 - 2\nu) \right] ϵv=pd4tE[2(2−ν)+(1−2ν)]=pd4tE[4−2ν+1−2ν]\epsilon_v = \frac{p d}{4 t E} \left[ 2(2 - \nu) + (1 - 2\nu) \right] = \frac{p d}{4 t E} [4 - 2\nu + 1 - 2\nu] ϵv=p⋅d4tE(5−4ν)\epsilon_v = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t E} (5 - 4\nu)

The total increase in cylinder capacity ΔV\Delta V is:

ΔV=V⋅ϵv=(π4d2L)[pd4tE(5−4ν)]=π⋅p⋅d3⋅L16tE(5−4ν)\Delta V = V \cdot \epsilon_v = \left(\frac{\pi}{4} d^2 L\right) \left[ \frac{p d}{4 t E} (5 - 4\nu) \right] = \frac{\pi \cdot p \cdot d^3 \cdot L}{16 t E} (5 - 4\nu)

4.2 Thin Spherical Shell Volumetric Strain

For a thin spherical shell of diameter dd, the surface is in a state of uniform equibiaxial tension:

σ1=σ2=σ=pd4t\sigma_1 = \sigma_2 = \sigma = \frac{p d}{4 t}

Diametral strain in any direction:

ϵ1=ϵ2=σE−νσE=σE(1−ν)=pd4tE(1−ν)\epsilon_1 = \epsilon_2 = \frac{\sigma}{E} - \nu \frac{\sigma}{E} = \frac{\sigma}{E}(1 - \nu) = \frac{p d}{4 t E} (1 - \nu)

The volume of a sphere is V=π6d3V = \frac{\pi}{6} d^3. Taking logarithms and differentiating:

ln⁡V=ln⁡(π6)+3ln⁡d  ⟹  dVV=3δdd=3ϵ1\ln V = \ln\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) + 3 \ln d \implies \frac{dV}{V} = 3 \frac{\delta d}{d} = 3 \epsilon_1

Therefore:

ϵv=3ϵ1=3[pd4tE(1−ν)]=3pd4tE(1−ν)\epsilon_v = 3 \epsilon_1 = 3 \left[ \frac{p d}{4 t E} (1 - \nu) \right] = \frac{3 p d}{4 t E} (1 - \nu)

The total volumetric expansion is:

ΔV=V⋅ϵv=(π6d3)[3pd4tE(1−ν)]=π⋅p⋅d48tE(1−ν)\Delta V = V \cdot \epsilon_v = \left(\frac{\pi}{6} d^3\right) \left[ \frac{3 p d}{4 t E} (1 - \nu) \right] = \frac{\pi \cdot p \cdot d^4}{8 t E} (1 - \nu)

4.3 Quantitative Comparison for Structural Steel (ν=0.3\nu = 0.3)

  • Cylinder: ϵv=pd4tE[5−4(0.3)]=3.80(pd4tE)\epsilon_v = \frac{p d}{4 t E} [5 - 4(0.3)] = 3.80 \left(\frac{p d}{4 t E}\right)
  • Sphere: ϵv=pd4tE[3(1−0.3)]=2.10(pd4tE)\epsilon_v = \frac{p d}{4 t E} [3(1 - 0.3)] = 2.10 \left(\frac{p d}{4 t E}\right)
ϵv,sphereϵv,cyl=2.103.80≈0.553(44.7% less volumetric expansion)\frac{\epsilon_{v,\text{sphere}}}{\epsilon_{v,\text{cyl}}} = \frac{2.10}{3.80} \approx 0.553 \quad (44.7\%\text{ less volumetric expansion})

5. Hydrostatic Pressure Testing & Fluid Compressibility

During a hydrostatic proof test, the vessel is completely filled with a liquid (usually water) and pressurized using a positive-displacement pump.

Liquids are slightly compressible, characterized by their Bulk Modulus of Elasticity (KK):

K=−ΔpΔVf/V0  ⟹  (ΔVfV0)=pKK = - \frac{\Delta p}{\Delta V_f / V_0} \implies \left(\frac{\Delta V_f}{V_0}\right) = \frac{p}{K}

where ΔVf\Delta V_f is the reduction in fluid volume due to compression.

To raise the pressure from 00 to pp:

  1. The metal vessel expands by ΔVvessel=V0⋅ϵv\Delta V_{\text{vessel}} = V_0 \cdot \epsilon_v.
  2. The fluid already inside compresses, requiring additional liquid ΔVfluid=V0⋅pK\Delta V_{\text{fluid}} = V_0 \cdot \frac{p}{K} to occupy that compressed space.

The total volume of liquid required to be pumped in (ΔVpump\Delta V_{\text{pump}}) is the sum:

ΔVpump=ΔVvessel+ΔVfluid=V0[ϵv+pK]\Delta V_{\text{pump}} = \Delta V_{\text{vessel}} + \Delta V_{\text{fluid}} = V_0 \left[ \epsilon_v + \frac{p}{K} \right]

For water, K≈2.2 GPa=2200 MPaK \approx 2.2\text{ GPa} = 2200\text{ MPa}. In long municipal pipelines, the fluid compression volume ΔVfluid\Delta V_{\text{fluid}} often equals or exceeds the metal expansion volume!


6. Joint Efficiency in Fabricated Vessels

Commercial pressure vessels and pipes are fabricated by rolling flat steel plates into cylinders and joining them by welding or riveting. Because joints contain heat-affected zones, microscopic flaws, or rivet holes, they are weaker than the seamless parent metal.

This weakness is quantified by the Joint Efficiency factor (η≤1.0\eta \le 1.0):

η=Strength of JointStrength of Solid Plate\eta = \frac{\text{Strength of Joint}}{\text{Strength of Solid Plate}}

6.1 Longitudinal Joint Efficiency (ηL\eta_L)

A longitudinal seam runs parallel to the axis of the cylinder. As demonstrated in SOM-09-01, circumferential (hoop) stress σh\sigma_h acts perpendicular to this seam, attempting to tear it apart:

σh=p⋅d2tηL≤σallow\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t \eta_L} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}}

Therefore, the permissible pressure governed by the longitudinal joint is:

pL=2⋅t⋅ηL⋅σallowdp_L = \frac{2 \cdot t \cdot \eta_L \cdot \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d}

6.2 Circumferential Joint Efficiency (ηc\eta_c)

A circumferential (girth) seam runs around the circumference of the cylinder. Longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L acts perpendicular to this seam:

σL=p⋅d4tηc≤σallow\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t \eta_c} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}}

Therefore, the permissible pressure governed by the circumferential joint is:

pc=4⋅t⋅ηc⋅σallowdp_c = \frac{4 \cdot t \cdot \eta_c \cdot \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d}

6.3 Rule of Equal Joint Strength

Equating the allowable pressures pL=pcp_L = p_c:

2tηLσallowd=4tηcσallowd  ⟹  2ηL=4ηc  ⟹  ηc=ηL2\frac{2 t \eta_L \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d} = \frac{4 t \eta_c \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d} \implies 2 \eta_L = 4 \eta_c \implies \eta_c = \frac{\eta_L}{2}

Key Fabrication Rule: To provide equal safety against bursting, the circumferential joint needs to have only half the efficiency of the longitudinal joint (ηc≥0.5ηL\eta_c \ge 0.5 \eta_L).

  • Longitudinal joints are typically full-penetration double-welded butt joints with 100%100\% radiographic examination (ηL≈0.85−1.00\eta_L \approx 0.85 - 1.00).
  • Circumferential joints can use single-welded joints or spot radiography (ηc≈0.50−0.70\eta_c \approx 0.50 - 0.70).

7. Wire-Wound Thin Cylinders (Prestressing Mechanics)

For high-pressure conduits, guns, and hydraulic cylinders, the required wall thickness becomes large, reducing structural efficiency and risking brittle fracture.

To overcome this limitation, a thin cylinder can be prestressed by winding high-tensile steel wire around its exterior under initial tension σw0\sigma_{w0}.

  INITIAL STATE (p = 0):
  Wire in Tension (+σ_w0)  ======>  Puts Cylinder Wall into Compression (-σ_c0)

  WORKING STATE (Fluid Pressure p admitted):
  Fluid Pressure creates Tensile Increment (+Δσ) in both Wall and Wire
  Resultant Cylinder Stress = Δσ - σ_c0  (Greatly reduced tension!)
  Resultant Wire Stress     = σ_w0 + Δσ  (Safe in high-strength wire)

7.1 Initial Prestress State (Before Fluid Admitted, p=0p = 0)

Let:

  • d=d = internal diameter of cylinder,
  • tc=t_c = wall thickness of cylinder,
  • dw=d_w = diameter of wire, wound at pitch ss (for tight coil, s=dws = d_w),
  • Aw=A_w = equivalent cross-sectional area of wire per unit length of cylinder: Aw=π4dw2sA_w = \frac{\frac{\pi}{4} d_w^2}{s}
  • σw0=\sigma_{w0} = initial tensile winding stress in wire,
  • σc0=\sigma_{c0} = initial compressive stress induced in cylinder wall.

Consider a longitudinal cut of unit length (L=1L = 1). Equating total wire tensile force to cylinder compressive force:

2⋅(Aw⋅σw0)=2⋅(tc⋅σc0)2 \cdot (A_w \cdot \sigma_{w0}) = 2 \cdot (t_c \cdot \sigma_{c0}) σc0=(Awtc)σw0\sigma_{c0} = \left(\frac{A_w}{t_c}\right) \sigma_{w0}

7.2 Working State (Internal Pressure pp Admitted)

When fluid pressure pp is admitted, the cylinder expands radially. By displacement compatibility, the wire and cylinder wall must experience identical circumferential strain increments:

Δϵcyl=Δϵwire\Delta \epsilon_{\text{cyl}} = \Delta \epsilon_{\text{wire}}

Neglecting the Poisson effect from longitudinal stress (standard for wire-wound analysis):

ΔσcEc=ΔσwEw  ⟹  Δσw=m⋅Δσc\frac{\Delta \sigma_c}{E_c} = \frac{\Delta \sigma_w}{E_w} \implies \Delta \sigma_w = m \cdot \Delta \sigma_c

where m=EwEcm = \frac{E_w}{E_c} is the modular ratio (if wire and cylinder are the same material, Ew=Ec  ⟹  m=1E_w = E_c \implies m = 1, and Δσw=Δσc=Δσ\Delta \sigma_w = \Delta \sigma_c = \Delta \sigma).

Equilibrium of bursting force per unit length:

Bursting Force=p⋅d\text{Bursting Force} = p \cdot d Resisting Force=2⋅(Δσc⋅tc+Δσw⋅Aw)=2Δσc(tc+mAw)\text{Resisting Force} = 2 \cdot (\Delta \sigma_c \cdot t_c + \Delta \sigma_w \cdot A_w) = 2 \Delta \sigma_c (t_c + m A_w)

Equating forces:

Δσc=p⋅d2(tc+mAw)\Delta \sigma_c = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 (t_c + m A_w)}

If Ew=EcE_w = E_c (m=1m = 1):

Δσ=p⋅d2(tc+Aw)\Delta \sigma = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 (t_c + A_w)}

7.3 Final Resultant Stresses

  1. In the Cylinder Wall: σc,final=Δσc−σc0=p⋅d2(tc+mAw)−(Awtc)σw0\sigma_{c,\text{final}} = \Delta \sigma_c - \sigma_{c0} = \frac{p \cdot d}{2(t_c + m A_w)} - \left(\frac{A_w}{t_c}\right)\sigma_{w0}
  2. In the Wire: σw,final=σw0+Δσw=σw0+m[p⋅d2(tc+mAw)]\sigma_{w,\text{final}} = \sigma_{w0} + \Delta \sigma_w = \sigma_{w0} + m \left[ \frac{p \cdot d}{2(t_c + m A_w)} \right]

8. SVG Technical Illustrations

8.1 Volumetric Strain & Dimensional Expansion

The illustration below demonstrates diametral and longitudinal expansions under pressure, the logarithmic derivation of volumetric strain, and joint efficiency mechanics.

Volumetric Strain and Joint Efficiency

8.2 Wire-Wound Cylinder Prestressing & Superposition

The diagram below details the physical cross-section of wire-wound cylinders, the equilibrium of initial winding tension, and the 3-stage stress superposition resulting in dramatic wall stress reduction.

Wire-Wound Cylinder Prestress

9. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 9.1: Volumetric Dilatation & Hydrostatic Testing Volume

Problem Statement:
A thin cylindrical water pipe has an internal diameter of d=1000 mmd = 1000\text{ mm}, length L=3.0 mL = 3.0\text{ m} (3000 mm3000\text{ mm}), and wall thickness t=10 mmt = 10\text{ mm}. The pipe is subjected to an internal hydrostatic test pressure of p=2.5 MPap = 2.5\text{ MPa} (2.5 N/mm22.5\text{ N/mm}^2).
Given: Steel modulus E=200 GPa=2.0×105 MPaE = 200\text{ GPa} = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa}, Poisson's ratio ν=0.3\nu = 0.3, and Bulk Modulus of water Kw=2.2 GPa=2200 MPaK_w = 2.2\text{ GPa} = 2200\text{ MPa}.

  1. Calculate the circumferential and longitudinal strains.
  2. Calculate the change in internal diameter δd\delta d and change in length δL\delta L.
  3. Calculate the volumetric strain ϵv\epsilon_v and the physical volume increase of the pipe ΔVpipe\Delta V_{\text{pipe}}.
  4. Calculate the additional volume of water that must be pumped in to reach test pressure, accounting for the compressibility of water.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Membrane Stresses:

    σh=p⋅d2t=2.5×10002×10=125.00 MPa\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} = \frac{2.5 \times 1000}{2 \times 10} = 125.00\text{ MPa} σL=p⋅d4t=125.002=62.50 MPa\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} = \frac{125.00}{2} = 62.50\text{ MPa}
  2. Circumferential & Longitudinal Strains:

    ϵ1=p⋅d4tE(2−ν)=2.5×10004×10×200000(2−0.3)=25008×106×1.7=3.125×10−4×1.7=5.3125×10−4\epsilon_1 = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t E}(2 - \nu) = \frac{2.5 \times 1000}{4 \times 10 \times 200000} (2 - 0.3) = \frac{2500}{8 \times 10^6} \times 1.7 = 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \times 1.7 = 5.3125 \times 10^{-4} ϵ2=p⋅d4tE(1−2ν)=3.125×10−4×(1−0.6)=3.125×10−4×0.4=1.2500×10−4\epsilon_2 = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t E}(1 - 2\nu) = 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \times (1 - 0.6) = 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \times 0.4 = 1.2500 \times 10^{-4}
  3. Dimensional Changes:

    δd=ϵ1⋅d=5.3125×10−4×1000 mm=0.5312 mm\delta d = \epsilon_1 \cdot d = 5.3125 \times 10^{-4} \times 1000\text{ mm} = 0.5312\text{ mm} δL=ϵ2⋅L=1.2500×10−4×3000 mm=0.3750 mm\delta L = \epsilon_2 \cdot L = 1.2500 \times 10^{-4} \times 3000\text{ mm} = 0.3750\text{ mm}
  4. Volumetric Dilatation:

    • Volumetric Strain: ϵv=2ϵ1+ϵ2=2(5.3125×10−4)+1.2500×10−4=1.0625×10−3+0.1250×10−3=1.1875×10−3\epsilon_v = 2 \epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2 = 2(5.3125 \times 10^{-4}) + 1.2500 \times 10^{-4} = 1.0625 \times 10^{-3} + 0.1250 \times 10^{-3} = 1.1875 \times 10^{-3} (Alternatively: ϵv=pd4tE(5−4ν)=3.125×10−4×(5−1.2)=3.125×10−4×3.8=1.1875×10−3\epsilon_v = \frac{pd}{4tE}(5 - 4\nu) = 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \times (5 - 1.2) = 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \times 3.8 = 1.1875 \times 10^{-3}).
    • Initial Volume (V0V_0): V0=π4d2L=π4(1.0)2(3.0)=3π4≈2.356195 m3=2356.195 LitresV_0 = \frac{\pi}{4} d^2 L = \frac{\pi}{4} (1.0)^2 (3.0) = \frac{3\pi}{4} \approx 2.356195\text{ m}^3 = 2356.195\text{ Litres}
    • Volume Increase of Pipe (ΔVpipe\Delta V_{\text{pipe}}): ΔVpipe=V0⋅ϵv=2356.195 L×1.1875×10−3=2.7980 Litres\Delta V_{\text{pipe}} = V_0 \cdot \epsilon_v = 2356.195\text{ L} \times 1.1875 \times 10^{-3} = 2.7980\text{ Litres}
  5. Additional Water to be Pumped In:

    • Water volume compression: ΔVwater=V0⋅(pKw)=2356.195 L×(2.5 MPa2200 MPa)=2356.195×1.13636×10−3=2.6775 Litres\Delta V_{\text{water}} = V_0 \cdot \left(\frac{p}{K_w}\right) = 2356.195\text{ L} \times \left(\frac{2.5\text{ MPa}}{2200\text{ MPa}}\right) = 2356.195 \times 1.13636 \times 10^{-3} = 2.6775\text{ Litres}
    • Total Water Injected: ΔVpump=ΔVpipe+ΔVwater=2.7980 L+2.6775 L=5.4755 Litres\Delta V_{\text{pump}} = \Delta V_{\text{pipe}} + \Delta V_{\text{water}} = 2.7980\text{ L} + 2.6775\text{ L} = 5.4755\text{ Litres}

(Engineering Observation: Fluid compressibility accounts for 48.9%48.9\% of the total water injected by the pump during the test!).


Example 9.2: Joint Efficiencies & Safe Working Pressure

Problem Statement:
A fabricated cylindrical steel boiler shell has an internal diameter of d=1.5 md = 1.5\text{ m} (1500 mm1500\text{ mm}) and a wall thickness of t=12 mmt = 12\text{ mm}. The plates are joined by longitudinal and circumferential riveted seams with joint efficiencies:

  • Longitudinal joint efficiency: ηL=80%=0.80\eta_L = 80\% = 0.80
  • Circumferential joint efficiency: ηc=45%=0.45\eta_c = 45\% = 0.45 The maximum permissible tensile stress in the steel plate is σallow=110 MPa\sigma_{\text{allow}} = 110\text{ MPa}. Determine:
  1. The safe working pressure limited by the longitudinal joint.
  2. The safe working pressure limited by the circumferential joint.
  3. The overall safe working pressure of the boiler and specify which joint governs.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Pressure Limited by Longitudinal Joint (ηL=0.80\eta_L = 0.80): The longitudinal joint resists hoop stress σh\sigma_h:

    σh=p⋅d2tηL≤σallow\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t \eta_L} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}} pL=2⋅t⋅ηL⋅σallowd=2×12 mm×0.80×110 N/mm21500 mm=21121500=1.408 MPap_L = \frac{2 \cdot t \cdot \eta_L \cdot \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d} = \frac{2 \times 12\text{ mm} \times 0.80 \times 110\text{ N/mm}^2}{1500\text{ mm}} = \frac{2112}{1500} = 1.408\text{ MPa}
  2. Pressure Limited by Circumferential Joint (ηc=0.45\eta_c = 0.45): The circumferential joint resists longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L:

    σL=p⋅d4tηc≤σallow\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t \eta_c} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}} pc=4⋅t⋅ηc⋅σallowd=4×12 mm×0.45×110 N/mm21500 mm=23761500=1.584 MPap_c = \frac{4 \cdot t \cdot \eta_c \cdot \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d} = \frac{4 \times 12\text{ mm} \times 0.45 \times 110\text{ N/mm}^2}{1500\text{ mm}} = \frac{2376}{1500} = 1.584\text{ MPa}
  3. Governing Safe Working Pressure:

    psafe=min⁡(pL,pc)=min⁡(1.408 MPa,1.584 MPa)=1.408 MPap_{\text{safe}} = \min(p_L, p_c) = \min(1.408\text{ MPa}, 1.584\text{ MPa}) = 1.408\text{ MPa}

Critical Exam Takeaway: Although the circumferential joint efficiency is much lower (45%45\% vs. 80%80\%), the longitudinal joint still governs failure because the hoop bursting force is twice as large as the axial bursting force!
For the circumferential joint to govern, its efficiency would have to drop below ηL2=0.802=0.40\frac{\eta_L}{2} = \frac{0.80}{2} = 0.40 (40%40\%).


Example 9.3: Wire-Wound Cylinder Prestressing & Stress Reduction

Problem Statement:
A cast-iron pipe of internal diameter d=300 mmd = 300\text{ mm} and wall thickness tc=6 mmt_c = 6\text{ mm} is closely wound with a single layer of high-tensile steel wire of diameter dw=3 mmd_w = 3\text{ mm} under an initial tensile winding stress of σw0=80 MPa\sigma_{w0} = 80\text{ MPa}. The wire coils touch each other tightly (pitch s=dw=3 mms = d_w = 3\text{ mm}).
An internal fluid pressure of p=4.0 MPap = 4.0\text{ MPa} is then admitted into the pipe.
Assume Ec=Ew=200 GPaE_c = E_w = 200\text{ GPa}.

  1. Calculate the initial compressive hoop stress induced in the pipe wall before fluid is admitted.
  2. Calculate the stress increment in the wall and wire upon application of internal fluid pressure.
  3. Determine the final resultant hoop stress in the pipe wall and the final tensile stress in the wire.
  4. Calculate what the tensile stress in the pipe wall would have been if there had been no wire winding, and find the percentage reduction in tensile stress achieved.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Geometry of Winding: For a tightly wound layer of pitch s=3 mms = 3\text{ mm}, each 1 mm1\text{ mm} length of pipe carries 1/31/3 wire coil.
    Equivalent cross-sectional area of wire per millimetre length of cylinder:

    Aw=π4dw2s=π4(3)23=9π/43=3π4≈2.3562 mm2/mmA_w = \frac{\frac{\pi}{4} d_w^2}{s} = \frac{\frac{\pi}{4} (3)^2}{3} = \frac{9\pi / 4}{3} = \frac{3\pi}{4} \approx 2.3562\text{ mm}^2/\text{mm}
  2. Initial Prestress in Pipe Wall (p=0p = 0): Equating wire tension to pipe wall compression on 1 mm1\text{ mm} length:

    2⋅(Aw⋅σw0)=2⋅(tc⋅σc0)2 \cdot (A_w \cdot \sigma_{w0}) = 2 \cdot (t_c \cdot \sigma_{c0}) σc0=(Awtc)σw0=(2.3562 mm26.0 mm)×80 MPa=0.3927×80=31.416 MPa (Compression)\sigma_{c0} = \left(\frac{A_w}{t_c}\right) \sigma_{w0} = \left(\frac{2.3562\text{ mm}^2}{6.0\text{ mm}}\right) \times 80\text{ MPa} = 0.3927 \times 80 = 31.416\text{ MPa (Compression)}
  3. Stress Increment from Fluid Pressure (p=4.0 MPap = 4.0\text{ MPa}): Because Ew=EcE_w = E_c, strain compatibility gives Δσw=Δσc=Δσ\Delta \sigma_w = \Delta \sigma_c = \Delta \sigma.
    Total bursting force on 1 mm1\text{ mm} length:

    Fb=p⋅d⋅(1)=4.0 N/mm2×300 mm=1200 NF_b = p \cdot d \cdot (1) = 4.0\text{ N/mm}^2 \times 300\text{ mm} = 1200\text{ N}

    Resisting force on 1 mm1\text{ mm} length:

    Fr=2⋅(Δσ⋅tc+Δσ⋅Aw)=2Δσ(tc+Aw)=2Δσ(6.0+2.3562)=16.7124 ΔσF_r = 2 \cdot (\Delta \sigma \cdot t_c + \Delta \sigma \cdot A_w) = 2 \Delta \sigma (t_c + A_w) = 2 \Delta \sigma (6.0 + 2.3562) = 16.7124 \, \Delta \sigma

    Equating Fr=FbF_r = F_b:

    Δσ=120016.7124≈71.803 MPa (Tension)\Delta \sigma = \frac{1200}{16.7124} \approx 71.803\text{ MPa (Tension)}
  4. Final Working Stresses:

    • Net Stress in Pipe Wall: σc,final=Δσ−σc0=71.803−31.416=40.387 MPa (Tension)\sigma_{c,\text{final}} = \Delta \sigma - \sigma_{c0} = 71.803 - 31.416 = 40.387\text{ MPa (Tension)}
    • Net Stress in Wire: σw,final=σw0+Δσ=80.00+71.803=151.803 MPa (Tension)\sigma_{w,\text{final}} = \sigma_{w0} + \Delta \sigma = 80.00 + 71.803 = 151.803\text{ MPa (Tension)}
  5. Comparison with Plain (Unwound) Cylinder: If the pipe had not been wire-wound:

    σplain=p⋅d2tc=4.0×3002×6.0=120012=100.00 MPa (Tension)\sigma_{\text{plain}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t_c} = \frac{4.0 \times 300}{2 \times 6.0} = \frac{1200}{12} = 100.00\text{ MPa (Tension)}
    • Stress Reduction Achieved: Reduction=100.00−40.39100.00×100%=59.61%\text{Reduction} = \frac{100.00 - 40.39}{100.00} \times 100\% = 59.61\%

(Conclusion: Wire winding slashes the peak tensile stress in the cast iron cylinder wall from 100.0 MPa100.0\text{ MPa} to just 40.39 MPa40.39\text{ MPa}, preventing brittle bursting while safely transferring the high tensile load to high-strength steel wire).


10. Indian Standard Code Provisions & Industrial Practice

  1. IS 2825:1969 (Code for Unfired Pressure Vessels):

    • Mandates joint efficiencies (η\eta) based on weld inspection category:
      • Class 1 vessels: Full radiographed welds   ⟹  η=1.00\implies \eta = 1.00.
      • Class 2 vessels: Spot radiographed welds   ⟹  η=0.85\implies \eta = 0.85.
      • Class 3 vessels: Visual inspection only   ⟹  η=0.70\implies \eta = 0.70.
    • Shell thickness formula incorporating joint efficiency and static corrosion allowance (cc): t=p⋅d2σallowηL−p+ct = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 \sigma_{\text{allow}} \eta_L - p} + c
  2. IS 784:2001 (Prestressed Concrete Pipes — Specification):

    • Applies the wire-winding prestress principle directly to concrete water mains (PCCP).
    • High-tensile steel wire (IS 1785) is helically wrapped under high tension around a concrete core pipe to induce circumferential pre-compression.
    • The pre-compression ensures that under maximum surge and working pressure, the concrete core remains strictly in compression, preventing cracking and leakage.
  3. ASME BPVC Section VIII Division 1 (UW-12):

    • Details Type 1 (butt joints with full penetration), Type 2 (single welded with backing strip), and Type 3 (single welded butt without backing strip), establishing explicit joint efficiency tables for longitudinal vs. circumferential seams.

11. Common Misconceptions & High-Yield Exam Traps

  1. Forgetting Poisson's Coupling in Circumferential Strain:

    • Trap: Writing ϵ1=σhE=pd2tE\epsilon_1 = \frac{\sigma_h}{E} = \frac{p d}{2 t E}.
    • Correction: The vessel is under biaxial tension. Circumferential expansion is partially constrained by longitudinal tension via Poisson's ratio: ϵ1=σh−νσLE=pd4tE(2−ν)\epsilon_1 = \frac{\sigma_h - \nu \sigma_L}{E} = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(2 - \nu).
  2. Confusing Volume Dilatation Factor (5−4ν)(5 - 4\nu) with (5−2ν)(5 - 2\nu):

    • Trap: Mis-deriving ϵv=2ϵ1+ϵ2\epsilon_v = 2 \epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2.
    • Correction: ϵv=2[pd4tE(2−ν)]+[pd4tE(1−2ν)]=pd4tE[4−2ν+1−2ν]=pd4tE(5−4ν)\epsilon_v = 2\left[\frac{pd}{4tE}(2-\nu)\right] + \left[\frac{pd}{4tE}(1-2\nu)\right] = \frac{pd}{4tE}[4 - 2\nu + 1 - 2\nu] = \frac{pd}{4tE}(5 - 4\nu).
  3. Assuming Longitudinal Joint Resists Longitudinal Stress:

    • Trap: Applying ηL\eta_L to calculate longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L.
    • Correction: The longitudinal joint runs lengthwise; it splits open under hoop stress. Hence, ηL\eta_L modifies hoop stress σh\sigma_h, and ηc\eta_c modifies longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L!
  4. Ignoring Fluid Compressibility in Hydrostatic Test Calculations:

    • Trap: Calculating the water needed to raise pressure by computing only the vessel expansion ΔVpipe\Delta V_{\text{pipe}}.
    • Correction: Liquid is compressible (ΔVwater=V0pK\Delta V_{\text{water}} = V_0 \frac{p}{K}). The pump must supply ΔVpipe+ΔVwater\Delta V_{\text{pipe}} + \Delta V_{\text{water}}.
  5. Believing Winding Wire Reduces Longitudinal Stress:

    • Trap: Thinking wire coils reduce longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L.
    • Correction: Wires are wound around the circumference; they act purely in the hoop direction. Wire winding reduces hoop stress σh\sigma_h only; longitudinal stress remains pd4tc\frac{p d}{4 t_c}.

12. Previous Year Competitive Exam Questions

Question 1 (GATE CE)

A thin cylindrical shell of diameter dd, length LL, and thickness tt is subjected to internal pressure pp. The Poisson's ratio of the material is ν\nu and Young's modulus is EE. The ratio of circumferential strain to longitudinal strain is:

  • (A) 1−2ν2−ν\frac{1 - 2\nu}{2 - \nu}
  • (B) 2−ν1−2ν\frac{2 - \nu}{1 - 2\nu}
  • (C) 2−ν1−ν\frac{2 - \nu}{1 - \nu}
  • (D) 5−4ν1−2ν\frac{5 - 4\nu}{1 - 2\nu}

Answer: (B)
Solution:
ϵ1=pd4tE(2−ν)\epsilon_1 = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(2 - \nu), ϵ2=pd4tE(1−2ν)\epsilon_2 = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(1 - 2\nu).
Ratio ϵ1ϵ2=2−ν1−2ν\frac{\epsilon_1}{\epsilon_2} = \frac{2 - \nu}{1 - 2\nu}.


Question 2 (UPSC ESE)

For an incompressible material (ν=0.5\nu = 0.5), what is the longitudinal strain in a thin cylindrical pressure vessel subjected to internal pressure?

  • (A) pd4tE\frac{p d}{4 t E}
  • (B) pd8tE\frac{p d}{8 t E}
  • (C) Zero
  • (D) Negative

Answer: (C)
Solution:
ϵ2=pd4tE(1−2ν)\epsilon_2 = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(1 - 2\nu). Setting ν=0.5  ⟹  (1−2(0.5))=0  ⟹  ϵ2=0\nu = 0.5 \implies (1 - 2(0.5)) = 0 \implies \epsilon_2 = 0.


Question 3 (SSC JE)

A thin spherical shell of diameter DD, thickness tt, Young's modulus EE, and Poisson's ratio μ\mu is subjected to internal pressure pp. The volumetric strain of the sphere is:

  • (A) 3pD4tE(1−μ)\frac{3 p D}{4 t E} (1 - \mu)
  • (B) pD4tE(1−μ)\frac{p D}{4 t E} (1 - \mu)
  • (C) pD2tE(1−2μ)\frac{p D}{2 t E} (1 - 2\mu)
  • (D) 3pD2tE(1−μ)\frac{3 p D}{2 t E} (1 - \mu)

Answer: (A)
Solution:
In a sphere, ϵ1=ϵ2=pD4tE(1−μ)\epsilon_1 = \epsilon_2 = \frac{p D}{4 t E}(1 - \mu). Since V∝D3V \propto D^3, ϵv=3ϵ1=3pD4tE(1−μ)\epsilon_v = 3 \epsilon_1 = \frac{3 p D}{4 t E}(1 - \mu).


Question 4 (State AE)

In a cylindrical boiler, the longitudinal joint has an efficiency of 70%70\%. To have the same factor of safety in both seams, the circumferential joint efficiency should be at least:

  • (A) 70%70\%
  • (B) 50%50\%
  • (C) 35%35\%
  • (D) 80%80\%

Answer: (C)
Solution:
For equal allowable pressure: ηc=ηL2=70%2=35%\eta_c = \frac{\eta_L}{2} = \frac{70\%}{2} = 35\%.


13. Comprehensive Summary & Formula Sheet

Parameter / Phenomenon Mathematical Formula Key Assumptions & Conditions
Circumferential Strain (ϵ1\epsilon_1) ϵ1=δdd=pd4tE(2−ν)\epsilon_1 = \frac{\delta d}{d} = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(2 - \nu) Plane stress Hooke's Law, thin shell (t/d≤1/20t/d \le 1/20)
Longitudinal Strain (ϵ2\epsilon_2) ϵ2=δLL=pd4tE(1−2ν)\epsilon_2 = \frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(1 - 2\nu) Closed ends, axial stress present
Cylinder Volumetric Strain (ϵv\epsilon_v) ϵv=ΔVV=pd4tE(5−4ν)\epsilon_v = \frac{\Delta V}{V} = \frac{p d}{4 t E}(5 - 4\nu) Sum of principal strains: ϵv=2ϵ1+ϵ2\epsilon_v = 2\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2
Sphere Volumetric Strain (ϵv\epsilon_v) ϵv=ΔVV=3pd4tE(1−ν)\epsilon_v = \frac{\Delta V}{V} = \frac{3 p d}{4 t E}(1 - \nu) Equibiaxial expansion: ϵv=3ϵ1\epsilon_v = 3\epsilon_1
Fluid Compression Volume (ΔVf\Delta V_f) ΔVf=V0⋅pK\Delta V_f = V_0 \cdot \frac{p}{K} K=K = Bulk modulus of test liquid (water ≈2.2 GPa\approx 2.2\text{ GPa})
Total Test Injection Volume ΔVpump=V0[ϵv+pK]\Delta V_{\text{pump}} = V_0 [\epsilon_v + \frac{p}{K}] Critical for hydrostatic pipeline commissioning
Longitudinal Joint Stress σh=pd2tηL\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t \eta_L} ηL=\eta_L = longitudinal weld/rivet joint efficiency
Circumferential Joint Stress σL=pd4tηc\sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t \eta_c} ηc=\eta_c = circumferential weld/rivet joint efficiency
Equal Joint Strength Rule ηc=ηL2\eta_c = \frac{\eta_L}{2} Circumferential joint needs only half efficiency
Initial Wire Prestress in Wall σc0=(Awtc)σw0\sigma_{c0} = \left(\frac{A_w}{t_c}\right) \sigma_{w0} Initial compression in pipe wall (p=0p = 0)
Pressure Stress Increment (Δσ\Delta \sigma) Δσ=pd2(tc+mAw)\Delta \sigma = \frac{p d}{2 (t_c + m A_w)} Shared strain compatibility condition (m=Ew/Ecm = E_w/E_c)
Net Wall Stress in Wire-Wound Pipe σc,final=Δσ−σc0\sigma_{c,\text{final}} = \Delta \sigma - \sigma_{c0} Tensile stress reduced by initial compression