Chapter 06: Torsion of Circular Shafts (06_torsion_of_shafts)
Subject
Strength of Materials (Solid Mechanics)
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE
Prerequisites
SOM-06-01 (Pure Torsion Formula & Kinematics of Circular Shafts), SOM-01-05 (Statically Indeterminate Systems), SOM-04-03 (Composite / Flitched Beams Analog)
Authoritative Reference Codes
IS 2048:1983 (Parallel Keys and Keyways), IS 3688:1990 (Dimensions for Shaft Couplings), IS 2494 (Transmission Shafting)
Key Terminology
Diameter ratio (k=di/Do), weight economy, strength efficiency, shafts in series, shafts in parallel, statically indeterminate torsion, composite concentric shaft, rectangular and square sunk keys, shear failure vs crushing failure of keys, rigid flange coupling, pitch circle diameter (Dp)
2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation
2.1 Why Hollow Shafts Are Vastly Superior in Torsion
In any circular shaft subjected to pure torsion, the shear stress varies strictly linearly from zero at the longitudinal axis (r=0) to a maximum value τmax at the outermost cylindrical surface (r=R).
The contribution of any elemental annular ring to the total torque capacity is:
dT=r⋅dF=r⋅(τ(r)dA)∝r2dA∝r3dr
Consequently, the torque-resisting capacity of any concentric layer is proportional to the fourth power of its radius (r4):
The Core Inefficiency: The central cylindrical core of a solid shaft (where r≤R/2) occupies:
Area Fraction=(RR/2)2=41=25% of the total cross-sectional area (and metal weight)
However, because the polar moment of inertia varies with r4:
Torque Capacity Fraction=(RR/2)4=161=6.25% of the total torque capacity!
Therefore, removing this under-stressed central core removes 25% of the dead weight while sacrificing only 6.25% of the torsional strength!
2.2 Definition of the Diameter Ratio (k)
For a hollow circular shaft with outer diameter Do and inner diameter di:
k=Dodi(0<k<1)
As k→1, the shaft approaches an ultra-thin circular tube, where all material is concentrated at maximum radius and subjected to nearly uniform maximum shear stress (τmin=k⋅τmax≈τmax).
3. Mathematical Derivations: Solid vs Hollow Shafts
3.1 Case A: Equal Strength Criteria (Same Torque T and Same Maximum Shear Stress τmax)
Consider a solid shaft of diameter Ds and a hollow shaft of outer diameter Do and inner diameter di=kDo, made of identical material and having identical length L.
For both shafts to have the exact same maximum shear stress τmax under the same applied torque T:
[!TIP]
By choosing k=0.80, an engineer saves 40% of the steel weight while expanding the outer diameter by only 19.2%. At k=0.90, over half the weight is saved!
3.2 Case B: Equal Weight Criteria (Same Material, Same Cross-Sectional Area Ah=As)
If a hollow shaft is manufactured using the exact same weight and volume of metal as a solid shaft of diameter Ds:
Ah=As⟹4πDo2(1−k2)=4πDs2⟹Do=1−k2Ds
1. Torque Capacity Ratio (Torsional Strength Multiplier):
4. Shafts in Series & Statically Indeterminate Torsion
4.1 Shafts in Series
When two or more shaft segments are joined end-to-end to form a continuous line:
Fixed Support A Free End C
|///|========================|===================|
|///| Segment 1 | Segment 2 |--> Torque T
|///| (L1, D1, G1, J1) | (L2, D2, G2, J2) |
|<---------- L1 ------------>|<------- L2 ------>|
Torque Equilibrium: The torque is transmitted undiminished through every cross-section:
T1=T2=⋯=Tn=T
Angle of Twist Compatibility: The total angle of twist at the free end is the algebraic sum of individual segment twists:
θtotal=θ1+θ2+⋯+θn=i=1∑nGi⋅JiT⋅Li=Ti=1∑nGi⋅JiLi
If the shaft has uniform diameter and material along its entire length (G1=G2,J1=J2):
TA=TB(L1+L2L2),TC=TB(L1+L2L1)
[!NOTE]
The end closer to the applied torque attracts the larger share of the reaction torque (in inverse proportion to length).
5. Shafts in Parallel & Composite Concentric Shafts
5.1 Shafts in Parallel (Concentric / Flitched Shafts)
When a solid core of material 1 is bonded concentrically inside a hollow sleeve of material 2, both components twist together as a single structural unit:
Kinematic Compatibility Condition:
Because the interface is bonded, both materials experience the exact same angle of twist over their common length L:
θ1=θ2=θtotal
Torque Equilibrium Condition:
The total externally applied torque T is resisted by the sum of torques in the core and sleeve:
T=T1+T2
Torque Division by Rigidity:
Using the torsion formula θ=GJTL⟹T=θ⋅(LGJ):
T1=θ(LG1J1),T2=θ(LG2J2)T2T1=G2⋅J2G1⋅J1T1=T[G1J1+G2J2G1J1],T2=T[G1J1+G2J2G2J2]
The diagram below compares solid and hollow circular shafts under both equal strength (τmax) and equal weight (cross-sectional area) criteria across various diameter ratios k=di/Do.
The diagram below details the mechanics of shafts in series (additive twist), shafts in parallel (shared torque), and mechanical torque-transmitting joints (keys and bolted flange couplings).
8. Python-Recalculated Solved Numerical Examples
Numerical Example 1: Composite Concentric Shaft (Shafts in Parallel)
Problem Statement:
A composite concentric shaft of length L=1.5 m=1,500 mm consists of a solid brass core of diameter db=50 mm (Gb=40 GPa=40,000 MPa) encased in a firmly bonded steel sleeve of outer diameter Dso=80 mm and inner diameter Dsi=50 mm (Gs=80 GPa=80,000 MPa).
The composite shaft is subjected to an overall torque T=3.0 kN⋅m=3.0×106 N⋅mm.
Calculate:
The polar moment of inertia and torsional rigidity of the brass core and the steel sleeve.
The portion of total torque resisted by the brass core (Tb) and by the steel sleeve (Ts).
The maximum shear stress in the brass core (τb,max) and in the steel sleeve (τs,max).
The shear stress in the steel sleeve at the bonded interface (τs,inner).
The steel sleeve carries over 91% of the total applied torque!
Shear Stresses:
Maximum shear stress in brass (at outer radius r=25 mm):
τb,max=JbTb⋅(db/2)=6.13592×105247,786.44×25=10.0957 MPa
Maximum shear stress in steel (at outer radius r=40 mm):
τs,max=JsTs⋅(Dso/2)=3.40763×1062,752,213.56×40=32.3063 MPa
Shear stress in steel at the inner interface (r=25 mm):
τs,inner=JsTs⋅(Dsi/2)=3.40763×1062,752,213.56×25=20.1915 MPa(Note the stress discontinuity at the interface: τs,inner/τb,max=20.1915/10.0957=2.0=Gs/Gb, which strictly satisfies strain continuity γ=τ/G.)
Numerical Example 2: Statically Indeterminate Stepped Shaft Fixed at Both Ends
Problem Statement:
A stepped circular shaft is rigidly built-in at both end supports A and C.
Segment AB: Made of steel, length LAB=1.0 m=1,000 mm, diameter DAB=75 mm, GAB=80 GPa=80,000 MPa.
Segment BC: Made of bronze, length LBC=1.5 m=1,500 mm, diameter DBC=90 mm, GBC=45 GPa=45,000 MPa.
At the junction B, a concentrated torque TB=6.0 kN⋅m=6.0×106 N⋅mm is applied.
Determine:
The reactive torques TA and TC developed at the fixed ends.
The maximum torsional shear stress in segments AB and BC.
The angle of rotation at junction B in degrees.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Torsional Stiffness of Each Segment:
Segment AB (Steel):
JAB=32π(75)4=3.10631×106 mm4kAB=LABGAB⋅JAB=1,00080,000×3.10631×106=2.48505×108 N⋅mm/rad
Segment BC (Bronze):
JBC=32π(90)4=6.44125×106 mm4kBC=LBCGBC⋅JBC=1,50045,000×6.44125×106=1.93237×108 N⋅mm/rad
Reaction Torques:
Using the stiffness division formula for fixed-ended indeterminate shafts:
Check via segment BC: θB=1.93237×1082,624,662.47=0.013583 rad=0.7782∘ [Exact match].
Numerical Example 3: Sunk Key & Flange Coupling Design
Problem Statement:
A commercial drive shaft of diameter D=65 mm transmits power P=45 kW at speed N=180 rpm.
Key Design: A standard rectangular sunk key of width w=18 mm and height h=12 mm is used. The allowable shear stress of the key is τallow=55 MPa, and the allowable crushing stress is σb,allow=110 MPa. Determine the required length L of the key to ensure safety against both shear and crushing.
Coupling Design: A rigid flange coupling connects this shaft to an output shaft. The coupling uses n=6 bolts arranged symmetrically on a pitch circle diameter Dp=160 mm. If the allowable shear stress in the bolts is τbolt=45 MPa, calculate the required nominal diameter db of the bolts.
Marine Propulsion Shafting:
Propeller shafts on container ships and submarines transmit megawatts of power over dozens of meters. Because the shaft must also resist axial thrust from the propeller and self-weight sag between bearing supports, hollow forged shafts (k≈0.5 to 0.7) are standard.
High-Speed Rotating Machinery (Whirling Speed Prevention):
The critical whirling frequency of a shaft is proportional to EI/m, where m is mass per unit length. Because hollow shafts provide high flexural second moment of area I with drastically lower mass m, their critical whirling speeds are much higher than solid shafts, preventing catastrophic resonance vibrations in gas turbines and centrifuges.
Flange Couplings in Pumping Stations:
Municipal water distribution pumps use rigid protected-flange couplings fitted with shroud rims to prevent worker clothing entanglement. Bolts are fitted in reamed holes to ensure uniform shear sharing across all bolts.
10. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix
Parameter / Feature
Shafts in Series
Shafts in Parallel
Physical Configuration
End-to-end connection
Concentric or geared side-by-side
Torque Behavior
Torque is CONSTANT:T1=T2=T
Torque is SHARED:Ttotal=T1+T2
Angle of Twist Behavior
Twist is ADDITIVE:θtotal=θ1+θ2
Twist is EQUAL:θ1=θ2=θtotal
Governing Stiffness Rule
Keq1=k11+k21
Keq=k1+k2
Torque Sharing Formula
N/A (100% transmitted to each)
T1/T2=(G1J1)/(G2J2)
Indeterminate Dual-Fixed Case
TA/TC=(G1J1/L1)/(G2J2/L2)
Solved directly by parallel compatibility
11. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights
Equal Strength Weight Saving:WsWh=(1+k21−k2)1/3. At k=0.8, hollow shaft saves ≈40% weight; at k=0.9, it saves >50%.
Equal Weight Strength Multiplier:TsTh=1−k21+k2. At k=0.8, hollow shaft is 2.73× stronger for the exact same mass.
Series Rule:T=constant; θ=θ1+θ2. Stiffer segment twists less.
Parallel Rule:θ=constant; T=T1+T2. Stiffer segment carries more torque (T∝GJ).
Square Key Principle: A square key (w=h) has equal strength in shear and crushing when σb,allow=2τallow.
Coupling Bolt Shear:T=n⋅Fb⋅(Dp/2)⟹Fb=nDp2T.
12. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios
Trap 1: Using Key Total Height h for Crushing Area: Misconception: Calculating crushing area as h⋅L. Correction: Half the key height is embedded in the shaft, and half is in the hub. The projected contact area in either component is strictly (h/2)⋅L.
Trap 2: Mixing Series and Parallel Compatibility in Dual-Fixed Shafts: Misconception: Treating a shaft fixed at both ends with a torque at the center as shafts in series. Correction: The segments share a common twist at the junction and zero twist at the ends (θB/A=θB/C). This is mathematically a parallel system where the applied torque is divided between reactions TA and TC.
Trap 3: Using 1−k4 for Weight Savings: Misconception: Calculating weight savings using polar moment ratio 1−k4. Correction: Weight is proportional to cross-sectional area, which depends on 1−k2, not 1−k4.
13. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems
Reference Code Clauses
IS 2048:1983: Standard dimensions for parallel sunk keys; specifies key width w≈D/4 and key height h≈D/6 for rectangular keys.
IS 3688:1990: Rigid flange couplings: specifies bolt pitch diameter Dp≈3D and number of bolts n=3 for D≤40 mm, n=4 for D≤100 mm, n=6 for D>100 mm.
Objective Practice Problems
Problem 1 (GATE CE)
A solid shaft of diameter D is replaced by a hollow shaft of outer diameter Do and inner diameter di=Do/2 of the same material and length. If both shafts are to have the same strength in torsion, the ratio Do/D is:
(A) (1516)1/3
(B) (1615)1/3
(C) 1516
(D) 1516
Answer:(A) Solution:Zph=Zps⟹Do3(1−k4)=D3. Here k=0.5⟹1−k4=1−0.0625=1615.
Thus, Do3(1615)=D3⟹DDo=(1516)1/3.
Problem 2 (UPSC ESE)
Two shafts A and B of the same material are connected in parallel. Shaft A has diameter D and length L, while shaft B has diameter 2D and length 2L. The ratio of torque carried by shaft B to that by shaft A (TB/TA) is:
(A) 2
(B) 4
(C) 8
(D) 16
Answer:(C) Solution: In parallel, TATB=GJA/LAGJB/LB=JA/LAJB/LB. JB/JA=(2D/D)4=16. LB/LA=2. TATB=216=8.
Problem 3 (SSC JE / RRB JE)
A rectangular sunk key of width w, height h, and length L transmits torque from a shaft of diameter D. If the allowable shear stress is τ and allowable crushing stress is σc, the key will be equally strong in shear and crushing when:
(A) w=h if σc=τ
(B) w=h if σc=2τ
(C) w=2h if σc=2τ
(D) h=2w if σc=τ
Answer:(B) Solution: Shear strength =w⋅L⋅τ. Crushing strength =(h/2)⋅L⋅σc. Equating both: wτ=(h/2)σc⟹hw=2τσc. If σc=2τ, then w=h (square key).
Problem 4 (GATE CE)
A shaft of uniform diameter is rigidly fixed at both ends. A twisting couple T is applied at a point which divides the shaft length in the ratio 1:2. The reaction torque at the closer fixed end is: