SOM-06-03 Chapter 06 · Torsion of Shafts

Combined Bending, Torsion & Axial Loading on Shafts

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Topic Metadata & Scope
  2. 2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation
  3. 2.1 Why Real Transmission Shafts Experience Combined Loading
  4. 2.2 Identification of the Critical Surface Element
  5. 3. Mathematical Derivations: Combined Stresses on Circular Shafts
  6. 3.1 2D Plane Stress Tensor at the Extreme Fiber
  7. 3.2 Principal Normal Stresses
  8. 3.3 Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress
  9. 4. Equivalent Twisting Moment (Te)
  10. 4.1 Formal Engineering Definition
  11. 4.2 Derivation
  12. 4.3 Design Equation for Ductile Shafts (Guest-Tresca Theory)
  13. 5. Equivalent Bending Moment (Me)
  14. 5.1 Formal Engineering Definition
  15. 5.2 Derivation
  16. 5.3 Design Equation for Brittle Shafts (Rankine Theory)
  17. 6. Combined Axial Force, Bending, and Torsion
  18. 6.1 Total Direct Stress along Shaft Axis
  19. 6.2 Modified Equivalent Bending and Twisting Moments
  20. 7. Failure Theories Applied to Power Transmission Shafts
  21. 7.1 Maximum Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises Theory)
  22. 7.2 Quantitative Comparison of Required Diameters
  23. 8. SVG Technical Diagrams & Visual Explanations
  24. 8.1 3D Loading, Critical Stress Element & Mohr's Circle
  25. 8.2 Failure Theories Interaction Loci & Sizing Comparison
  26. 9. Step-by-Step Solved Numerical Examples
  27. Problem 1: Transmission Shaft Design under Combined M and T (GATE CE Pattern)
  28. Problem 2: Hollow Shaft under Combined Bending, Torsion & Axial Tension (UPSC ESE Pattern)
  29. Problem 3: Analytical Proof on the Conservatism of Equivalent Moments
  30. 10. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix
  31. 11. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights
  32. 12. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios
  33. 13. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems
  34. Reference Code Clauses
  35. Objective Practice Problems

1. Topic Metadata & Scope

Attribute Specification
Topic ID SOM-06-03
Chapter Chapter 06: Torsion of Circular Shafts (06_torsion_of_shafts)
Subject Strength of Materials (Solid Mechanics)
Target Examinations GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE
Prerequisites SOM-02-02 (Principal Stresses & Planes), SOM-02-05 (Theories of Elastic Failure), SOM-04-01 (Flexure Formula), SOM-06-01 (Pure Torsion Formula)
Authoritative Reference Codes ASME Code for Transmission Shafting, IS 2494:1994 (V-Belt Drives - Shaft Design Rules), IS 800:2007 Cl. 9 (Combined Forces)
Key Terminology Transmission shaft, combined bending and torsion, direct axial thrust, plane stress element, principal normal stresses (σ1,σ2\sigma_1, \sigma_2), maximum shear stress (τmax⁡\tau_{\max}), Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e), Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e), Rankine theory, Tresca theory, von Mises distortion energy theory

2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation

2.1 Why Real Transmission Shafts Experience Combined Loading

In mechanical power transmission and civil/structural engineering, a rotating or stationary circular shaft is virtually never subjected to pure torsion alone:

  1. Transverse Loads from Power Transmission Elements:
    • Belts and pulleys impart radial tension forces (T1+T2T_1 + T_2).
    • Meshing spur and helical gears impart tangential forces (FtF_t), radial separation forces (FrF_r), and axial thrust forces (FaF_a).
    • Sprockets and chains exert heavy lateral pulls.
    • These transverse loads act perpendicular to the shaft axis across bearing spans, generating substantial transverse bending moments (MM) along the shaft.
  2. Torque Transmission (TT):
    • The shaft simultaneously delivers mechanical power PP at angular velocity ω\omega, maintaining a continuous twisting moment (T=P/ωT = P/\omega).
  3. Axial Loads (PP):
    • Helical gears, bevel gears, ship propeller shafts, and turbine shafts impose significant axial tensile or compressive thrusts (PP).

2.2 Identification of the Critical Surface Element

Consider a solid or hollow circular shaft of outer diameter DD subjected to combined bending moment MM (about the horizontal axis) and torque TT (about the longitudinal axis):

  • Bending Stress Distribution: σb(y)=M⋅yI\sigma_b(y) = \frac{M \cdot y}{I}
    • The bending stress is zero at the neutral axis (y=0y = 0).
    • It reaches its maximum tensile value +σmax⁡+\sigma_{\max} at the topmost fiber (y=+D/2y = +D/2).
    • It reaches its maximum compressive value −σmax⁡-\sigma_{\max} at the bottommost fiber (y=−D/2y = -D/2).
  • Torsional Shear Stress Distribution: τ(r)=T⋅rJ\tau(r) = \frac{T \cdot r}{J}
    • The torsional shear stress is zero at the center line (r=0r = 0).
    • It is uniformly distributed at its maximum value τmax⁡\tau_{\max} everywhere along the outermost cylindrical circumference (r=D/2r = D/2).
  • The Critical Point:
    • The critical cross-sectional points are the top and bottom surface fibers where the maximum bending normal stress and maximum torsional shear stress occur simultaneously at the exact same physical coordinates (r=y=D/2r = y = D/2).
    • Because the outer cylindrical surface is exposed to air (free boundary), the radial stress is identically zero: σr=σz=0\sigma_r = \sigma_z = 0
    • Consequently, the material at the extreme fiber is in a state of pure plane stress (2D stress state).

3. Mathematical Derivations: Combined Stresses on Circular Shafts

3.1 2D Plane Stress Tensor at the Extreme Fiber

For a solid circular shaft of diameter DD:

  • Bending Normal Stress: σx=MZ=MπD332=32MπD3\sigma_x = \frac{M}{Z} = \frac{M}{\frac{\pi D^3}{32}} = \frac{32 M}{\pi D^3}
  • Circumferential / Radial Normal Stress: σy=0\sigma_y = 0
  • Torsional Shear Stress: τxy=TZp=TπD316=16TπD3\tau_{xy} = \frac{T}{Z_p} = \frac{T}{\frac{\pi D^3}{16}} = \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3}

The plane stress tensor [σ][\boldsymbol{\sigma}] on the surface element is:

[σ]=[σxτxyτxy0]=[32MπD316TπD316TπD30][\boldsymbol{\sigma}] = \begin{bmatrix} \sigma_x & \tau_{xy} \\ \tau_{xy} & 0 \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \frac{32 M}{\pi D^3} & \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3} \\ \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3} & 0 \end{bmatrix}

3.2 Principal Normal Stresses

Using the standard 2D transformation formula from SOM-02-02:

σ1,2=σx+σy2±(σx−σy2)2+τxy2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2}

Substituting σy=0\sigma_y = 0:

σ1,2=σx2±(σx2)2+τxy2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{\sigma_x}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2}

Now substitute the expressions for σx\sigma_x and τxy\tau_{xy}:

σx2=12(32MπD3)=16MπD3\frac{\sigma_x}{2} = \frac{1}{2} \left(\frac{32 M}{\pi D^3}\right) = \frac{16 M}{\pi D^3} τxy=16TπD3\tau_{xy} = \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3}

Factoring out the term 16πD3\frac{16}{\pi D^3}:

σ1,2=16MπD3±(16MπD3)2+(16TπD3)2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{16 M}{\pi D^3} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{16 M}{\pi D^3}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{16 T}{\pi D^3}\right)^2} σ1,2=16πD3[M±M2+T2]\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \left[ M \pm \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right]
  • Major Principal Stress (Maximum Tensile Stress): σ1=16πD3[M+M2+T2]\sigma_1 = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right]
  • Minor Principal Stress (Maximum Compressive Stress): σ2=16πD3[M−M2+T2]\sigma_2 = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \left[ M - \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right]

Notice that since M2+T2≥M\sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \ge M, the minor principal stress σ2\sigma_2 is always negative (compressive) whenever T≠0T \ne 0.

3.3 Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress

The maximum shear stress on the surface element is given by the radius of Mohr's circle:

τmax⁡=σ1−σ22=(σx2)2+τxy2\tau_{\max} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2}{2} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} τmax⁡=16πD3M2+T2\tau_{\max} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}

4. Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e)

4.1 Formal Engineering Definition

Definition: The Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e) is defined as an imaginary, fictitious twisting moment that, if acting alone on the shaft, would produce the same maximum shear stress (τmax⁡\tau_{\max}) as that produced by the combined action of actual bending moment MM and torque TT.

4.2 Derivation

  1. Under pure torque TeT_e acting alone: τmax⁡=16TeπD3\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3}
  2. Under combined bending moment MM and torque TT: τmax⁡=16πD3M2+T2\tau_{\max} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}
  3. Equating both expressions: 16TeπD3=16πD3M2+T2\frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}
Te=M2+T2\mathbf{T_e = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}}

4.3 Design Equation for Ductile Shafts (Guest-Tresca Theory)

According to the Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca / Guest's Theory), yield failure is avoided when the maximum shear stress does not exceed the allowable shear stress τallow\tau_{\text{allow}}:

τmax⁡=16TeπD3≤τallow\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3} \le \tau_{\text{allow}}
  • Solid Shaft Sizing:

    D≥[16Teπ τallow]1/3=[16M2+T2π τallow]1/3D \ge \left[ \frac{16 T_e}{\pi \, \tau_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3} = \left[ \frac{16 \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}}{\pi \, \tau_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3}
  • Hollow Shaft Sizing (k=di/Dok = d_i / D_o):

    τmax⁡=16TeπDo3(1−k4)≤τallow  ⟹  Do≥[16Teπ τallow(1−k4)]1/3\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D_o^3 (1 - k^4)} \le \tau_{\text{allow}} \implies D_o \ge \left[ \frac{16 T_e}{\pi \, \tau_{\text{allow}} (1 - k^4)} \right]^{1/3}

5. Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e)

5.1 Formal Engineering Definition

Definition: The Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e) is defined as an imaginary, fictitious bending moment that, if acting alone on the shaft, would produce the same maximum tensile principal stress (σ1\sigma_1) as that produced by the combined action of actual bending moment MM and torque TT.

5.2 Derivation

  1. Under pure bending moment MeM_e acting alone: σmax⁡=32MeπD3\sigma_{\max} = \frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3}
  2. Under combined bending moment MM and torque TT: σ1=16πD3[M+M2+T2]\sigma_1 = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right]
  3. Equating both expressions: 32MeπD3=16πD3[M+M2+T2]\frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right]

Multiplying both sides by πD332\frac{\pi D^3}{32}:

Me=12[M+M2+T2]=M+Te2\mathbf{M_e = \frac{1}{2} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right] = \frac{M + T_e}{2}}

5.3 Design Equation for Brittle Shafts (Rankine Theory)

According to the Maximum Principal Stress Theory (Rankine's Theory), fracture is avoided when the maximum tensile stress σ1\sigma_1 does not exceed the allowable tensile stress σallow\sigma_{\text{allow}}:

σ1=32MeπD3≤σallow\sigma_1 = \frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}}
  • Solid Shaft Sizing:

    D≥[32Meπ σallow]1/3=[16(M+M2+T2)π σallow]1/3D \ge \left[ \frac{32 M_e}{\pi \, \sigma_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3} = \left[ \frac{16 \left( M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right)}{\pi \, \sigma_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3}
  • Hollow Shaft Sizing (k=di/Dok = d_i / D_o):

    Do≥[32Meπ σallow(1−k4)]1/3D_o \ge \left[ \frac{32 M_e}{\pi \, \sigma_{\text{allow}} (1 - k^4)} \right]^{1/3}

6. Combined Axial Force, Bending, and Torsion

When a shaft transmits an axial thrust force PP (tension +P+P or compression −P-P) in addition to bending moment MM and torque TT:

6.1 Total Direct Stress along Shaft Axis

The total normal stress σx\sigma_x at the outer fiber becomes the algebraic sum of bending stress and axial stress:

σx=σb±σaxial=±32MπD3+4PπD2\sigma_x = \sigma_b \pm \sigma_{\text{axial}} = \pm \frac{32 M}{\pi D^3} + \frac{4 P}{\pi D^2}
  • Topmost Fiber (Point A): σx,top=+32MπD3+4PπD2=32πD3[M+P⋅D8]\sigma_{x, \text{top}} = +\frac{32 M}{\pi D^3} + \frac{4 P}{\pi D^2} = \frac{32}{\pi D^3} \left[ M + \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \right]
  • Bottommost Fiber (Point B): σx,bot=−32MπD3+4PπD2=−32πD3[M−P⋅D8]\sigma_{x, \text{bot}} = -\frac{32 M}{\pi D^3} + \frac{4 P}{\pi D^2} = -\frac{32}{\pi D^3} \left[ M - \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \right]

6.2 Modified Equivalent Bending and Twisting Moments

Defining an effective modified bending moment:

M∗=M+P⋅D8(for maximum tension)M^* = M + \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \quad (\text{for maximum tension})

The equivalent moments with axial load become:

Te∗=(M+P⋅D8)2+T2T_e^* = \sqrt{\left( M + \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \right)^2 + T^2} Me∗=12[(M+P⋅D8)+(M+P⋅D8)2+T2]M_e^* = \frac{1}{2} \left[ \left( M + \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \right) + \sqrt{\left( M + \frac{P \cdot D}{8} \right)^2 + T^2} \right]

[!NOTE] For hollow shafts with diameter ratio k=di/Dok = d_i / D_o, the axial stress is σa=4PπDo2(1−k2)\sigma_a = \frac{4P}{\pi D_o^2 (1 - k^2)}, which leads to an effective axial moment term PDo(1+k2)8\frac{P D_o (1 + k^2)}{8}.


7. Failure Theories Applied to Power Transmission Shafts

The choice of design formula depends strictly on the shaft material behavior:

                          Combined Loading on Shaft (M & T)
                                       │
        ┌──────────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────────┐
        ▼                                                             ▼
   Ductile Materials (Mild Steel, Alloy Steel)               Brittle Materials (Cast Iron)
        │                                                             │
        ├─────────────────────────────┐                               ▼
        ▼                             ▼                   Max Principal Stress (Rankine)
Max Shear Stress (Tresca)      Distortion Energy (von Mises)             │
        │                             │                                  ▼
        ▼                             ▼                          σ₁ = 32 M_e / (π D³)
τ_max = 16 T_e / (π D³)      σ_v = 32 M_e,vm / (π D³)                    │
        │                             │                                  ▼
Standard Indian / ASME code      Most accurate, ~15% lighter       M_e = ½ [M + √(M² + T²)]

7.1 Maximum Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises Theory)

For ductile metals, the von Mises equivalent stress σv\sigma_v under plane stress (σy=0\sigma_y = 0) is:

σv=σx2−σxσy+σy2+3τxy2=σx2+3τxy2\sigma_v = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 - \sigma_x \sigma_y + \sigma_y^2 + 3 \tau_{xy}^2} = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 + 3 \tau_{xy}^2}

Substituting σx=32MπD3\sigma_x = \frac{32 M}{\pi D^3} and τxy=16TπD3\tau_{xy} = \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3}:

σv=(32MπD3)2+3(16TπD3)2\sigma_v = \sqrt{\left(\frac{32 M}{\pi D^3}\right)^2 + 3 \left(\frac{16 T}{\pi D^3}\right)^2}

Factoring out 32πD3\frac{32}{\pi D^3}:

σv=32πD3M2+3(12T)2=32πD3M2+34T2\sigma_v = \frac{32}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + 3 \left(\frac{1}{2} T\right)^2} = \frac{32}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}

Hence, the von Mises Equivalent Bending Moment (Me,vmM_{e, \text{vm}}) is:

Me,vm=M2+34T2\mathbf{M_{e, \text{vm}} = \sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}}

And the von Mises Equivalent Twisting Moment (Te,vmT_{e, \text{vm}}) is:

Te,vm=43M2+T2\mathbf{T_{e, \text{vm}} = \sqrt{\frac{4}{3} M^2 + T^2}}

7.2 Quantitative Comparison of Required Diameters

Assume a shaft material where yield strength σy=200 MPa\sigma_y = 200\text{ MPa}, Factor of Safety =2.0  ⟹  σallow=100 MPa= 2.0 \implies \sigma_{\text{allow}} = 100\text{ MPa}, and τallow=σallow/2=50 MPa\tau_{\text{allow}} = \sigma_{\text{allow}} / 2 = 50\text{ MPa}:

Design Theory Governing Equation Effective Moment (M=3,T=4 kNmM=3, T=4\text{ kNm}) Required Diameter DD
Guest-Tresca (Max Shear) τmax⁡=16TeπD3≤50 MPa\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3} \le 50\text{ MPa} Te=32+42=5.000 kN⋅mT_e = \sqrt{3^2 + 4^2} = 5.000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} 79.86 mm79.86\text{ mm}
von Mises (Distortion Energy) σv=32Me,vmπD3≤100 MPa\sigma_v = \frac{32 M_{e, \text{vm}}}{\pi D^3} \le 100\text{ MPa} Me,vm=32+0.75(42)=4.583 kN⋅mM_{e, \text{vm}} = \sqrt{3^2 + 0.75(4^2)} = 4.583\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} 77.57 mm77.57\text{ mm}
Rankine (Max Normal) σ1=32MeπD3≤100 MPa\sigma_1 = \frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3} \le 100\text{ MPa} Me=3+52=4.000 kN⋅mM_e = \frac{3 + 5}{2} = 4.000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} 74.13 mm74.13\text{ mm}

[!WARNING] While Rankine gives the smallest diameter (74.13 mm74.13\text{ mm}), Rankine is unsafe for ductile steels! Under pure torsion (M=0M = 0), Rankine requires only D∝(T/2)1/3D \propto (T/2)^{1/3}, underestimating the shear danger by a dangerous factor. For ductile steels, Tresca or von Mises must always be used.


8. SVG Technical Diagrams & Visual Explanations

8.1 3D Loading, Critical Stress Element & Mohr's Circle

The diagram below illustrates the 3D shaft under combined loads, the isolated plane stress square at the top fiber, and the resulting Mohr's circle showing principal stresses σ1,σ2\sigma_1, \sigma_2 and maximum shear stress τmax⁡\tau_{\max}:

Combined Bending, Torsion & Axial Loading

8.2 Failure Theories Interaction Loci & Sizing Comparison

The diagram below presents the mathematical curves for equivalent moments, the normalized interaction loci in the (M,T)(M, T) design plane, and the sizing bar chart:

Equivalent Moments and Failure Theories

9. Step-by-Step Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Transmission Shaft Design under Combined MM and TT (GATE CE Pattern)

Statement:
A solid steel shaft of circular cross-section is subjected to a bending moment M=3.0 kN⋅mM = 3.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} and a twisting moment T=4.0 kN⋅mT = 4.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}. The material has an allowable tensile stress σallow=100 MPa\sigma_{\text{allow}} = 100\text{ MPa} and an allowable shear stress τallow=50 MPa\tau_{\text{allow}} = 50\text{ MPa}. Determine:

  1. The Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e) and Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e).
  2. The minimum required shaft diameter using the Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca).
  3. The minimum required shaft diameter using the Maximum Principal Stress Theory (Rankine).
  4. The percentage difference in required shaft volume between the two theories.

Solution:

Step 1: Calculate Equivalent Moments

  • Equivalent Twisting Moment: Te=M2+T2=(3.0×106)2+(4.0×106)2=5.000×106 N⋅mm=5.000 kN⋅mT_e = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} = \sqrt{(3.0 \times 10^6)^2 + (4.0 \times 10^6)^2} = 5.000 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = \mathbf{5.000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}
  • Equivalent Bending Moment: Me=12[M+M2+T2]=3.0×106+5.0×1062=4.000×106 N⋅mm=4.000 kN⋅mM_e = \frac{1}{2} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right] = \frac{3.0 \times 10^6 + 5.0 \times 10^6}{2} = \mathbf{4.000 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 4.000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Step 2: Sizing by Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca)

τmax⁡=16TeπD3≤τallow=50 MPa\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3} \le \tau_{\text{allow}} = 50\text{ MPa} D3≥16×(5.000×106 N⋅mm)π×50 N/mm2=80×106157.0796=509295.82 mm3D^3 \ge \frac{16 \times (5.000 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm})}{\pi \times 50\text{ N/mm}^2} = \frac{80 \times 10^6}{157.0796} = 509295.82\text{ mm}^3 DTresca≥(509295.82)1/3=79.86 mm(Select standard 80 mm)D_{\text{Tresca}} \ge (509295.82)^{1/3} = \mathbf{79.86\text{ mm}} \quad (\text{Select standard } 80\text{ mm})

Step 3: Sizing by Maximum Principal Stress Theory (Rankine)

σ1=32MeπD3≤σallow=100 MPa\sigma_1 = \frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3} \le \sigma_{\text{allow}} = 100\text{ MPa} D3≥32×(4.000×106 N⋅mm)π×100 N/mm2=128×106314.1593=407436.65 mm3D^3 \ge \frac{32 \times (4.000 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm})}{\pi \times 100\text{ N/mm}^2} = \frac{128 \times 10^6}{314.1593} = 407436.65\text{ mm}^3 DRankine≥(407436.65)1/3=74.13 mm(Select standard 75 mm)D_{\text{Rankine}} \ge (407436.65)^{1/3} = \mathbf{74.13\text{ mm}} \quad (\text{Select standard } 75\text{ mm})

Step 4: Volume Comparison

Since length is constant, volume is proportional to D2D^2:

VTrescaVRankine=(DTrescaDRankine)2=(79.8674.13)2=(1.0773)2=1.1606\frac{V_{\text{Tresca}}}{V_{\text{Rankine}}} = \left(\frac{D_{\text{Tresca}}}{D_{\text{Rankine}}}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{79.86}{74.13}\right)^2 = (1.0773)^2 = 1.1606 % Excess Material Required by Tresca=(1.1606−1)×100%=+16.06%\% \text{ Excess Material Required by Tresca} = (1.1606 - 1) \times 100\% = \mathbf{+16.06\%}

Problem 2: Hollow Shaft under Combined Bending, Torsion & Axial Tension (UPSC ESE Pattern)

Statement:
A hollow circular transmission shaft has an outer diameter Do=120 mmD_o = 120\text{ mm} and an inner diameter di=72 mmd_i = 72\text{ mm} (diameter ratio k=72/120=0.60k = 72/120 = 0.60). The shaft is subjected simultaneously to:

  • A bending moment M=8.0 kN⋅mM = 8.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
  • A twisting moment T=10.0 kN⋅mT = 10.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
  • An axial tensile force P=120 kNP = 120\text{ kN}

Calculate:

  1. The cross-sectional properties (A,Z,ZpA, Z, Z_p).
  2. The direct normal stresses due to bending and axial load.
  3. The principal stresses (σ1,σ2\sigma_1, \sigma_2) and maximum shear stress (τmax⁡\tau_{\max}) at the topmost fiber.
  4. The principal stresses and maximum shear stress at the bottommost fiber.

Solution:

Step 1: Geometric Properties

  • Area: A=π4(Do2−di2)=π4(1202−722)=π4(14400−5184)=π4(9216)=7238.23 mm2A = \frac{\pi}{4} (D_o^2 - d_i^2) = \frac{\pi}{4} (120^2 - 72^2) = \frac{\pi}{4} (14400 - 5184) = \frac{\pi}{4} (9216) = \mathbf{7238.23\text{ mm}^2}
  • Second Moment of Area: I=π64(Do4−di4)=π64(1204−724)=π64(207360000−26873856)=π64(180486144)=8.85959×106 mm4I = \frac{\pi}{64} (D_o^4 - d_i^4) = \frac{\pi}{64} (120^4 - 72^4) = \frac{\pi}{64} (207360000 - 26873856) = \frac{\pi}{64} (180486144) = 8.85959 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4
  • Elastic Section Modulus: Z=IDo/2=8.85959×10660=147659.88 mm3Z = \frac{I}{D_o / 2} = \frac{8.85959 \times 10^6}{60} = \mathbf{147659.88\text{ mm}^3}
  • Polar Section Modulus: Zp=2Z=2×147659.88=295319.76 mm3Z_p = 2 Z = 2 \times 147659.88 = \mathbf{295319.76\text{ mm}^3}

Step 2: Individual Component Stresses

  • Axial Normal Stress (uniform tension across entire cross-section): σaxial=PA=120×103 N7238.23 mm2=+16.58 MPa\sigma_{\text{axial}} = \frac{P}{A} = \frac{120 \times 10^3\text{ N}}{7238.23\text{ mm}^2} = \mathbf{+16.58\text{ MPa}}
  • Bending Normal Stress at extreme fiber (y=60 mmy = 60\text{ mm}): σb=MZ=8.0×106 N⋅mm147659.88 mm3=54.18 MPa\sigma_b = \frac{M}{Z} = \frac{8.0 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}}{147659.88\text{ mm}^3} = \mathbf{54.18\text{ MPa}}
  • Torsional Shear Stress at outer circumference (r=60 mmr = 60\text{ mm}): τxy=TZp=10.0×106 N⋅mm295319.76 mm3=33.86 MPa\tau_{xy} = \frac{T}{Z_p} = \frac{10.0 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}}{295319.76\text{ mm}^3} = \mathbf{33.86\text{ MPa}}

Step 3: Stresses at Topmost Fiber (Point A)

At the top fiber, bending produces tension (+σb+\sigma_b):

σx,top=σb+σaxial=54.18+16.58=+70.76 MPa\sigma_{x, \text{top}} = \sigma_b + \sigma_{\text{axial}} = 54.18 + 16.58 = \mathbf{+70.76\text{ MPa}} τxy=33.86 MPa\tau_{xy} = 33.86\text{ MPa}
  • Principal Stresses: σ1,2=σx,top2±(σx,top2)2+τxy2=70.762±(35.38)2+(33.86)2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{\sigma_{x, \text{top}}}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_{x, \text{top}}}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} = \frac{70.76}{2} \pm \sqrt{(35.38)^2 + (33.86)^2} 1251.74+1146.50=2398.24=48.97 MPa\sqrt{1251.74 + 1146.50} = \sqrt{2398.24} = 48.97\text{ MPa} σ1,top=35.38+48.97=+84.35 MPa (Tension)\sigma_{1, \text{top}} = 35.38 + 48.97 = \mathbf{+84.35\text{ MPa} \text{ (Tension)}} σ2,top=35.38−48.97=−13.59 MPa (Compression)\sigma_{2, \text{top}} = 35.38 - 48.97 = \mathbf{-13.59\text{ MPa} \text{ (Compression)}}
  • Maximum Shear Stress: τmax⁡,top=48.97 MPa\tau_{\max, \text{top}} = \mathbf{48.97\text{ MPa}}

Step 4: Stresses at Bottommost Fiber (Point B)

At the bottom fiber, bending produces compression (−σb-\sigma_b):

σx,bot=−σb+σaxial=−54.18+16.58=−37.60 MPa\sigma_{x, \text{bot}} = -\sigma_b + \sigma_{\text{axial}} = -54.18 + 16.58 = \mathbf{-37.60\text{ MPa}} τxy=33.86 MPa\tau_{xy} = 33.86\text{ MPa}
  • Principal Stresses: σ1,2=−37.602±(−37.602)2+(33.86)2=−18.80±(−18.80)2+(33.86)2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{-37.60}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{-37.60}{2}\right)^2 + (33.86)^2} = -18.80 \pm \sqrt{(-18.80)^2 + (33.86)^2} 353.44+1146.50=1499.94=38.73 MPa\sqrt{353.44 + 1146.50} = \sqrt{1499.94} = 38.73\text{ MPa} σ1,bot=−18.80+38.73=+19.93 MPa (Tension)\sigma_{1, \text{bot}} = -18.80 + 38.73 = \mathbf{+19.93\text{ MPa} \text{ (Tension)}} σ2,bot=−18.80−38.73=−57.53 MPa (Compression)\sigma_{2, \text{bot}} = -18.80 - 38.73 = \mathbf{-57.53\text{ MPa} \text{ (Compression)}}
  • Maximum Shear Stress: τmax⁡,bot=38.73 MPa\tau_{\max, \text{bot}} = \mathbf{38.73\text{ MPa}}

[!TIP] The top fiber is the critical location because tensile axial thrust superimposes constructively with tensile bending stress, raising the peak principal tension to 84.35 MPa84.35\text{ MPa} compared to only 19.93 MPa19.93\text{ MPa} at the bottom fiber.


Problem 3: Analytical Proof on the Conservatism of Equivalent Moments

Statement:
Prove analytically that for any transmission shaft carrying non-zero bending moment M>0M > 0 and non-zero torque T>0T > 0, the Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e) is strictly greater than the Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e). Furthermore, prove that under equal allowable stresses (τallow=0.5σallow\tau_{\text{allow}} = 0.5 \sigma_{\text{allow}}), design by Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca) will always yield a strictly larger shaft diameter than design by Maximum Normal Stress Theory (Rankine).

Solution:

Part 1: Proving Te>MeT_e > M_e

By definition:

Te=M2+T2T_e = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} Me=12[M+M2+T2]=M+Te2M_e = \frac{1}{2} \left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right] = \frac{M + T_e}{2}

Subtracting MeM_e from TeT_e:

Te−Me=Te−M+Te2=2Te−M−Te2=Te−M2T_e - M_e = T_e - \frac{M + T_e}{2} = \frac{2 T_e - M - T_e}{2} = \frac{T_e - M}{2}

Now examine the term Te−MT_e - M:

Te−M=M2+T2−MT_e - M = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} - M

Since T>0T > 0, we have M2+T2>M2M^2 + T^2 > M^2. Taking the positive square root:

M2+T2>M2=M  ⟹  Te>M\sqrt{M^2 + T^2} > \sqrt{M^2} = M \implies T_e > M

Therefore:

Te−Me=Te−M2>0  ⟹  Te>Me∀  T>0T_e - M_e = \frac{T_e - M}{2} > 0 \implies \mathbf{T_e > M_e \quad \forall \; T > 0}

Part 2: Comparison of Required Shaft Diameters

From Tresca's Theory:

DTresca=[16Teπτallow]1/3D_{\text{Tresca}} = \left[ \frac{16 T_e}{\pi \tau_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3}

Given τallow=0.5σallow\tau_{\text{allow}} = 0.5 \sigma_{\text{allow}}:

DTresca=[16Teπ(0.5σallow)]1/3=[32Teπσallow]1/3D_{\text{Tresca}} = \left[ \frac{16 T_e}{\pi (0.5 \sigma_{\text{allow}})} \right]^{1/3} = \left[ \frac{32 T_e}{\pi \sigma_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3}

From Rankine's Theory:

DRankine=[32Meπσallow]1/3D_{\text{Rankine}} = \left[ \frac{32 M_e}{\pi \sigma_{\text{allow}}} \right]^{1/3}

Taking the ratio of the two diameters:

DTrescaDRankine=(TeMe)1/3\frac{D_{\text{Tresca}}}{D_{\text{Rankine}}} = \left( \frac{T_e}{M_e} \right)^{1/3}

Since we proved Te>MeT_e > M_e, the ratio Te/Me>1T_e / M_e > 1. Therefore:

DTresca>DRankinefor all T>0\mathbf{D_{\text{Tresca}} > D_{\text{Rankine}} \quad \text{for all } T > 0}

This rigorously establishes that Tresca's theory is always more conservative than Rankine's theory for power transmission shafts.


10. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

Parameter / Feature Equivalent Twisting Moment (TeT_e) Equivalent Bending Moment (MeM_e) von Mises Moment (Me,vmM_{e, \text{vm}})
Governing Failure Theory Maximum Shear Stress (Guest-Tresca) Maximum Normal Stress (Rankine) Distortion Energy (von Mises)
Target Material Class Ductile metals (Mild steel, structural alloys) Brittle materials (Cast iron, ceramics) Ductile metals (Best accuracy)
Mathematical Expression M2+T2\mathbf{\sqrt{M^2 + T^2}} 12[M+M2+T2]\mathbf{\frac{1}{2}\left[M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}\right]} M2+34T2\mathbf{\sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4}T^2}}
Pure Bending Case (T=0T = 0) Te=MT_e = M Me=MM_e = M Me,vm=MM_{e, \text{vm}} = M
Pure Torsion Case (M=0M = 0) Te=TT_e = T Me=T/2M_e = T/2 Me,vm=32T≈0.866TM_{e, \text{vm}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} T \approx 0.866 T
Magnitude Hierarchy Always Largest (Te≥MeT_e \ge M_e) Smallest (Me≤TeM_e \le T_e) Intermediate (Me≤Me,vm≤TeM_e \le M_{e, \text{vm}} \le T_e)
Sizing Equation D=[16Teπτallow]1/3D = \left[\frac{16 T_e}{\pi \tau_{\text{allow}}}\right]^{1/3} D=[32Meπσallow]1/3D = \left[\frac{32 M_e}{\pi \sigma_{\text{allow}}}\right]^{1/3} D=[32Me,vmπσallow]1/3D = \left[\frac{32 M_{e, \text{vm}}}{\pi \sigma_{\text{allow}}}\right]^{1/3}
Code Preference Prescribed by IS 2494 & ASME Prohibited for ductile transmission Used in aerospace & advanced piping

11. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights

  1. Master Formula for TeT_e: Te=M2+T2T_e = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}. It equates maximum shear stress under combined loading to pure torsion.
  2. Master Formula for MeM_e: Me=12[M+M2+T2]=M+Te2M_e = \frac{1}{2}\left[ M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \right] = \frac{M + T_e}{2}. It equates maximum normal stress to pure bending.
  3. Pure Torsion Exam Trap: Under pure torsion (M=0M = 0), Te=TT_e = T, while Me=T/2M_e = T/2. If an exam asks for the equivalent bending moment of a shaft subjected only to torque TT, the answer is T/2T/2, NOT TT!
  4. Pure Bending Exam Trap: Under pure bending (T=0T = 0), Te=MT_e = M and Me=MM_e = M.
  5. Ratio Rule: When M=TM = T, Te=2M≈1.414MT_e = \sqrt{2} M \approx 1.414 M, and Me=1+22M≈1.207MM_e = \frac{1 + \sqrt{2}}{2} M \approx 1.207 M.
  6. von Mises Coefficient: The von Mises equivalent moment is Me,vm=M2+34T2M_{e, \text{vm}} = \sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}. Note the factor of 3/43/4 (or 0.750.75) multiplying T2T^2.
  7. Axial Load Adjustment: When axial thrust PP acts, simply replace MM with M∗=M+PD8M^* = M + \frac{P D}{8} in both formulas.

12. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios

  • Trap 1: Confusing 16 and 32 in the Sizing Formulas:
    Misconception: Using 32 with TeT_e or 16 with MeM_e.
    Correction: τmax⁡=16TeπD3\tau_{\max} = \frac{16 T_e}{\pi D^3} (because Zp=πD3/16Z_p = \pi D^3 / 16), whereas σ1=32MeπD3\sigma_1 = \frac{32 M_e}{\pi D^3} (because Z=πD3/32Z = \pi D^3 / 32). Mixing these up results in an incorrect factor of 2 in stress.
  • Trap 2: Forgetting the 1/21/2 Factor in MeM_e:
    Misconception: Writing Me=M+M2+T2M_e = M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}.
    Correction: MeM_e must be divided by 2: Me=12[M+M2+T2]M_e = \frac{1}{2}[M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}].
  • Trap 3: Designing Mild Steel Shafts with MeM_e:
    Misconception: Sizing a ductile steel shaft based on MeM_e and tensile strength.
    Correction: Ductile metals fail in shear across slip planes. Sizing by Rankine (MeM_e) is dangerously non-conservative under heavy torque. Sizing must be done using TeT_e (Tresca) or Me,vmM_{e, \text{vm}} (von Mises).
  • Trap 4: Overlooking Minor Principal Stress Sign:
    Misconception: Assuming σ2\sigma_2 is tensile.
    Correction: Since M2+T2>M\sqrt{M^2 + T^2} > M whenever T>0T > 0, σ2=16πD3[M−M2+T2]\sigma_2 = \frac{16}{\pi D^3}[M - \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}] is strictly negative (compressive). On Mohr's circle, the origin OO lies between σ1\sigma_1 and σ2\sigma_2.

13. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems

Reference Code Clauses

  • ASME Code for Transmission Shafting:
    Prescribes the maximum shear stress design formula including shock and fatigue factors: Te=(Km⋅M)2+(Kt⋅T)2T_e = \sqrt{(K_m \cdot M)^2 + (K_t \cdot T)^2} where KmK_m is the numerical bending shock factor (1.51.5 to 2.02.0) and KtK_t is the torsional shock factor (1.01.0 to 1.51.5). Allowable shear stress is limited to τallow=0.30σy≤0.18σu\tau_{\text{allow}} = 0.30 \sigma_y \le 0.18 \sigma_u, with an additional 18%18\% reduction if keyways are cut into the shaft.
  • IS 2494:1994:
    Standard provisions for industrial drives; requires transmission shafts to be checked for both strength (TeT_e) and torsional rigidity (θ≤0.25∘ per meter\theta \le 0.25^\circ \text{ per meter}).

Objective Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE)

A solid circular shaft is subjected to a bending moment MM and a twisting moment TT. If the maximum normal stress is twice the maximum shear stress (σ1=2τmax⁡\sigma_1 = 2 \tau_{\max}), the ratio of bending moment to twisting moment (M/TM/T) is:

  • (A) 2\sqrt{2}
  • (B) 11
  • (C) 00
  • (D) Infinite (pure bending)

Answer: (D)
Solution:
σ1=16πD3[M+M2+T2]\sigma_1 = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} [M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}] and τmax⁡=16πD3M2+T2\tau_{\max} = \frac{16}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}.
Given σ1=2τmax⁡\sigma_1 = 2 \tau_{\max}:

M+M2+T2=2M2+T2  ⟹  M=M2+T2M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} = 2 \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} \implies M = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}

Squaring both sides: M2=M2+T2  ⟹  T2=0  ⟹  T=0M^2 = M^2 + T^2 \implies T^2 = 0 \implies T = 0.
Since T=0T = 0, M/T→∞M/T \to \infty (pure bending).


Problem 2 (UPSC ESE)

A circular shaft of diameter DD is subjected to a twisting moment TT only (no bending moment). The equivalent bending moment for the shaft is:

  • (A) TT
  • (B) T/2T/2
  • (C) 2T2T
  • (D) 2T\sqrt{2} T

Answer: (B)
Solution:
Equivalent bending moment is Me=12[M+M2+T2]M_e = \frac{1}{2}[M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}].
For M=0M = 0:

Me=12[0+0+T2]=T2M_e = \frac{1}{2}[0 + \sqrt{0 + T^2}] = \frac{T}{2}

.


Problem 3 (SSC JE / RRB JE)

The equivalent twisting moment TeT_e for a circular shaft subjected to bending moment MM and twisting moment TT is given by:

  • (A) M+TM + T
  • (B) 12(M+T)\frac{1}{2}(M + T)
  • (C) M2+T2\sqrt{M^2 + T^2}
  • (D) M2−T2\sqrt{M^2 - T^2}

Answer: (C)
Solution:
By definition, Te=M2+T2T_e = \sqrt{M^2 + T^2}.


Problem 4 (GATE CE)

A shaft is subjected to simultaneous bending moment M=400 N⋅mM = 400\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} and twisting moment T=300 N⋅mT = 300\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. The ratio of maximum shear stress to maximum tensile stress (τmax⁡/σ1\tau_{\max} / \sigma_1) in the shaft is:

  • (A) 5/95/9
  • (B) 9/59/5
  • (C) 4/34/3
  • (D) 3/43/4

Answer: (A)
Solution:
M2+T2=4002+3002=500 N⋅m\sqrt{M^2 + T^2} = \sqrt{400^2 + 300^2} = 500\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.
τmax⁡∝M2+T2=500\tau_{\max} \propto \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} = 500.
σ1∝M+M2+T2=400+500=900\sigma_1 \propto M + \sqrt{M^2 + T^2} = 400 + 500 = 900.
Therefore: τmax⁡σ1=500900=59\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\sigma_1} = \frac{500}{900} = \frac{5}{9}.


Problem 5 (State AE / ESE)

According to the Maximum Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises), the equivalent bending moment Me,vmM_{e, \text{vm}} for a circular shaft under combined bending MM and torsion TT is:

  • (A) M2+T2\sqrt{M^2 + T^2}
  • (B) M2+34T2\sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}
  • (C) 34M2+T2\sqrt{\frac{3}{4} M^2 + T^2}
  • (D) 12M2+3T2\frac{1}{2} \sqrt{M^2 + 3 T^2}

Answer: (B)
Solution:
σv=σx2+3τxy2=(32MπD3)2+3(16TπD3)2=32πD3M2+34T2\sigma_v = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 + 3 \tau_{xy}^2} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{32M}{\pi D^3}\right)^2 + 3 \left(\frac{16T}{\pi D^3}\right)^2} = \frac{32}{\pi D^3} \sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}.
Equating to 32Me,vmπD3\frac{32 M_{e, \text{vm}}}{\pi D^3} yields Me,vm=M2+34T2M_{e, \text{vm}} = \sqrt{M^2 + \frac{3}{4} T^2}.