SOM-07-03 Chapter 07 · Deflection of Beams

Moment-Area Theorems (Mohr's Theorems) & Conjugate Beam Method

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Metadata & Scope

Attribute Specification
Topic ID SOM-07-03
Chapter Chapter 07: Deflection of Beams (07_deflection_of_beams)
Subject Strength of Materials (Solid Mechanics)
Target Examinations GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE
Prerequisites SOM-07-01 (Differential Equation of Elastic Curve), SOM-03-03 (Bending Moment Diagrams), SOM-04-02 (Non-Prismatic Cross-Sections)
Authoritative Reference Codes IS 456:2000 Cl. 23.2, IS 800:2007 Table 6, Eurocode 3 Part 1-1
Key Terminology Christian Otto Mohr, Moment-Area theorems, M/EIM/EI diagram, elastic curvature area, tangential deviation (tB/At_{B/A} vs tA/Bt_{A/B}), centroid location (xˉ\bar{x}), Conjugate Beam Method (Mohr's Analogy), elastic loading (w∗=M/EIw^* = M/EI), conjugate shear (V∗=θV^* = \theta), conjugate moment (M∗=yM^* = y), support transformation rules

2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation

2.1 The Geometric Revolution in Deflection Analysis

While the double integration and Macaulay methods approach beam deflections via differential equations, Christian Otto Mohr (1868) demonstrated that beam deflections and rotations can be computed purely through geometry and statics:

  1. Curvature as Distributed Elastic Weight: The term M(x)EI\frac{M(x)}{EI} is the curvature κ(x)\kappa(x) of the beam.
  2. Deflection as Cumulative Curvature: Bending slope θ\theta is the cumulative area of this curvature, and vertical displacement yy is the cumulative first moment of this curvature area.
  3. Power in Non-Prismatic Beams: In real bridge girders, stepped building columns, and flitched structural members where flexural rigidity EIEI changes abruptly, solving differential equations is algebraically painful due to varying EIEI. The Moment-Area method handles stepped EIEI with trivial geometric ease simply by dividing the local bending moment by the local value of EIEI.

3. Mathematical Derivations: Mohr's First Theorem (Slope Theorem)

3.1 Differential Angle Between Adjacent Normals

Consider an elemental length dxdx of a beam subjected to bending moment M(x)M(x). The neutral axis bends into an arc of radius ρ\rho, subtending an angle dθd\theta:

ds≈dx=ρ dθ  ⟹  dθ=dxρds \approx dx = \rho \, d\theta \implies d\theta = \frac{dx}{\rho}

From the Euler-Bernoulli flexure formula (1ρ=MEI\frac{1}{\rho} = \frac{M}{EI}):

dθ=M(x)EI dxd\theta = \frac{M(x)}{EI} \, dx

3.2 Integration Between Points AA and BB

Integrating both sides between two points AA and BB along the beam axis:

∫θAθBdθ=∫ABM(x)EI dx\int_{\theta_A}^{\theta_B} d\theta = \int_A^B \frac{M(x)}{EI} \, dx θB−θA=θB/A=∫ABM(x)EI dx=Area of the MEI diagram between A and B\mathbf{\theta_B - \theta_A = \theta_{B/A} = \int_A^B \frac{M(x)}{EI} \, dx = \text{Area of the } \frac{M}{EI} \text{ diagram between } A \text{ and } B}

3.3 Formal Statement of Mohr's First Theorem

Mohr's 1st Theorem: The change in slope (angle of rotation) between the tangents drawn to the elastic curve at any two points AA and BB is equal to the total area of the MEI\frac{M}{EI} diagram between those two points.

  • Sign Convention:
    • Sagging (positive) bending moment creates positive area   ⟹  θB>θA\implies \theta_B > \theta_A (tangent rotates counter-clockwise relative to tangent at AA).
    • Hogging (negative) bending moment creates negative area   ⟹  θB<θA\implies \theta_B < \theta_A (tangent rotates clockwise).

4. Mathematical Derivations: Mohr's Second Theorem (Deflection Theorem)

4.1 Concept of Tangential Deviation (tB/At_{B/A})

Draw a tangent to the elastic curve at point AA and extend it beneath point BB. The vertical distance from point BB on the elastic curve to this extended tangent line is called the tangential deviation of BB with respect to AA, denoted as tB/At_{B/A}.

For an elemental segment dxdx at distance xx from point BB:

  • The elemental angle of bend is dθ=MEIdxd\theta = \frac{M}{EI} dx.
  • Projecting this angle over the horizontal lever arm xx to point BB produces an elemental vertical intercept: dt=x⋅dθ=x(MEI dx)dt = x \cdot d\theta = x \left( \frac{M}{EI} \, dx \right)

4.2 Integration for Total Deviation

Integrating from AA to BB:

tB/A=∫ABx(MEI dx)t_{B/A} = \int_A^B x \left( \frac{M}{EI} \, dx \right)

By definition of the first moment of an area:

∫ABx(MEI dx)=[Area of MEI between A and B]×xˉB\int_A^B x \left( \frac{M}{EI} \, dx \right) = \left[ \text{Area of } \frac{M}{EI} \text{ between } A \text{ and } B \right] \times \bar{x}_B tB/A=AM/EI⋅xˉB1\mathbf{t_{B/A} = \frac{A_{M/EI} \cdot \bar{x}_B}{1}}

where:

  • AM/EIA_{M/EI} is the area of the MEI\frac{M}{EI} diagram between sections AA and BB.
  • xˉB\bar{x}_B is the horizontal distance from the centroid of this area to point BB (the point whose deviation is being measured).

4.3 Formal Statement of Mohr's Second Theorem

Mohr's 2nd Theorem: The tangential deviation tB/At_{B/A} of a point BB on the elastic curve with respect to the tangent drawn at point AA is equal to the first moment of the MEI\frac{M}{EI} diagram area between AA and BB, taken about point BB.

4.4 The Critical Asymmetry: tB/A≠tA/Bt_{B/A} \ne t_{A/B}

One of the most frequent errors in competitive examinations is confusing tB/At_{B/A} with tA/Bt_{A/B}:

  • tB/At_{B/A}: Vertical distance of point BB from the tangent at AA. Moment is taken about BB (xˉB\bar{x}_B).
  • tA/Bt_{A/B}: Vertical distance of point AA from the tangent at BB. Moment is taken about AA (xˉA\bar{x}_A).
  • In general: tB/A≠tA/B(unless the M/EI diagram is perfectly symmetric)t_{B/A} \ne t_{A/B} \quad (\text{unless the } M/EI \text{ diagram is perfectly symmetric})

5. Analysis of Non-Prismatic Beams with Stepped Flexural Rigidity

When a beam has a sudden step-change in cross-section (e.g., from I1I_1 to I2I_2):

  1. The bending moment M(x)M(x) remains continuous across the step (unless an external couple acts there).
  2. The M/EIM/EI diagram exhibits an immediate step-jump: (MEI)left=MEI1⟷(MEI)right=MEI2\left(\frac{M}{EI}\right)_{\text{left}} = \frac{M}{E I_1} \quad \longleftrightarrow \quad \left(\frac{M}{EI}\right)_{\text{right}} = \frac{M}{E I_2}
  3. The area of the M/EIM/EI diagram is computed by dividing it into standard geometric sub-areas (rectangles, triangles, parabolas) on each side of the step, and applying Mohr's theorems directly without any differential equation matching!

6. The Conjugate Beam Method (Mohr's Analogy)

6.1 Fundamental Mathematical Analogy

Consider the two pairs of differential equations:

Real Beam Mechanics:dθdx=MEIanddydx=θStatics of a Beam:dVdx=−wanddMdx=V\begin{array}{rcccl} \text{\textbf{Real Beam Mechanics:}} & \frac{d\theta}{dx} = \frac{M}{EI} & \text{and} & \frac{dy}{dx} = \theta \\ \text{\textbf{Statics of a Beam:}} & \frac{dV}{dx} = -w & \text{and} & \frac{dM}{dx} = V \end{array}

Notice the mathematical identity:

  • If we construct an imaginary, fictitious beam (called the Conjugate Beam) of the same span length as the real beam, and load it with an elastic distributed load w∗(x)=M(x)EIw^*(x) = \frac{M(x)}{EI}:
    1. The internal Shear Force V∗(x)V^*(x) in the conjugate beam is governed by dV∗dx=MEI\frac{dV^*}{dx} = \frac{M}{EI}, which is mathematically identical to dθdx=MEI\frac{d\theta}{dx} = \frac{M}{EI}!
    2. The internal Bending Moment M∗(x)M^*(x) in the conjugate beam is governed by dM∗dx=V∗=θ\frac{dM^*}{dx} = V^* = \theta, which is mathematically identical to dydx=θ\frac{dy}{dx} = \theta!

6.2 The Two Master Theorems of Conjugate Beam

Slope at section x in Real Beam (θx)=Shear Force at section x in Conjugate Beam (Vx∗)\mathbf{\text{Slope at section } x \text{ in Real Beam } (\theta_x) = \text{Shear Force at section } x \text{ in Conjugate Beam } (V^*_x)} Deflection at section x in Real Beam (yx)=Bending Moment at section x in Conjugate Beam (Mx∗)\mathbf{\text{Deflection at section } x \text{ in Real Beam } (y_x) = \text{Bending Moment at section } x \text{ in Conjugate Beam } (M^*_x)}

6.3 Support Transformation Rules (Real ⟷\longleftrightarrow Conjugate)

To ensure the conjugate beam reproduces the exact slope and deflection boundary conditions of the real beam, its supports must be transformed:

  ┌────────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────────┬─────────────────────────────────┐
  │ Real Beam Support Condition    │ Real Kinematic State             │ Conjugate Beam Support Required │
  ├────────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┤
  │ Fixed Support (Built-in)       │ Deflection y = 0, Slope θ = 0    │ Free End (M* = 0, V* = 0)       │
  ├────────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┤
  │ Free End (Cantilever tip)      │ Deflection y ≠ 0, Slope θ ≠ 0    │ Fixed Support (M* ≠ 0, V* ≠ 0)  │
  ├────────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┤
  │ Pinned / Roller at End         │ Deflection y = 0, Slope θ ≠ 0    │ Pinned / Roller at End          │
  ├────────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┤
  │ Internal Continuous Roller     │ Deflection y = 0, θ continuous   │ Internal Hinge (M* = 0, V* cont)│
  ├────────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┤
  │ Internal Hinge                 │ Deflection y ≠ 0, Δθ jump        │ Internal Roller (M* ≠ 0, ΔV*)   │
  └────────────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────────┘

[!TIP] A statically determinate real beam always transforms into a statically determinate conjugate beam! For example, a real cantilever (fixed at AA, free at BB) becomes a conjugate cantilever (free at AA, fixed at BB).


7. SVG Technical Diagrams & Visual Explanations

7.1 Mohr's Moment-Area Theorems & Tangential Deviations

The diagram below details the elastic curve, tangents, subtended rotation θB/A\theta_{B/A}, tangential deviations tB/At_{B/A} vs tA/Bt_{A/B}, and the centroidal projection of the M/EIM/EI diagram:

Mohr's Moment-Area Theorems

7.2 Conjugate Beam Support Transformation Analogy

The diagram below presents the transformation matrix between real beam boundary conditions and their conjugate beam counterparts, featuring worked structural layouts:

Conjugate Beam Analogy

8. Step-by-Step Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Non-Prismatic Stepped Cantilever Beam (GATE CE Pattern)

Statement:
A non-prismatic cantilever beam of total span L=4.0 mL = 4.0\text{ m} is rigidly built-in at AA (x=0x = 0) and carries a concentrated vertical load W=20 kNW = 20\text{ kN} at its free tip BB (x=4.0 mx = 4.0\text{ m}). The flexural rigidity of the beam is stepped:

  • Fixed end AA to midspan CC (0≤x≤2.0 m0 \le x \le 2.0\text{ m}): Flexural rigidity is 2EI2 EI (2.0×1013 N⋅mm22.0 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2).
  • Midspan CC to free tip BB (2.0 m≤x≤4.0 m2.0\text{ m} \le x \le 4.0\text{ m}): Flexural rigidity is EIEI (1.0×1013 N⋅mm21.0 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2).

Using Mohr's Moment-Area theorems, determine:

  1. The slope at the free tip (θB\theta_B).
  2. The vertical deflection at the free tip (δB\delta_B).

Solution:

Step 1: Bending Moment Values

Taking coordinate zz measuring from free tip BB (z=0z = 0) towards fixed end AA (z=4000 mmz = 4000\text{ mm}):

  • At free tip BB (z=0z = 0): MB=0M_B = 0
  • At junction CC (z=2000 mmz = 2000\text{ mm}): MC=−W⋅z=−20000 N×2000 mm=−4.0×107 N⋅mmM_C = -W \cdot z = -20000\text{ N} \times 2000\text{ mm} = -4.0 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}
  • At fixed wall AA (z=4000 mmz = 4000\text{ mm}): MA=−20000 N×4000 mm=−8.0×107 N⋅mmM_A = -20000\text{ N} \times 4000\text{ mm} = -8.0 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}

Step 2: Construct the M/EIM/EI Diagram

  1. Right Segment CBCB (z=0z = 0 to 2000 mm2000\text{ mm}, rigidity EI=1.0×1013EI = 1.0 \times 10^{13}):

    • At BB: MEI=0\frac{M}{EI} = 0
    • At CC (right side): MCEI=−4.0×107EI=−4.0×107EI\frac{M_C}{EI} = \frac{-4.0 \times 10^7}{EI} = -\frac{4.0 \times 10^7}{EI}
    • Shape is a triangle of base L2=2000 mmL_2 = 2000\text{ mm} and height h1=4.0×107EIh_1 = \frac{4.0 \times 10^7}{EI}: A1=12×2000×(4.0×107EI)=4.0×1010EIA_1 = \frac{1}{2} \times 2000 \times \left(\frac{4.0 \times 10^7}{EI}\right) = \frac{4.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI}
    • Centroid of A1A_1 from tip BB: xˉ1=23×2000=1333.33 mm\bar{x}_1 = \frac{2}{3} \times 2000 = \mathbf{1333.33\text{ mm}}
  2. Left Segment ACAC (z=2000z = 2000 to 4000 mm4000\text{ mm}, rigidity 2EI=2.0×10132 EI = 2.0 \times 10^{13}):

    • At CC (left side): MC2EI=−4.0×1072EI=−2.0×107EI\frac{M_C}{2 EI} = \frac{-4.0 \times 10^7}{2 EI} = -\frac{2.0 \times 10^7}{EI}
    • At AA: MA2EI=−8.0×1072EI=−4.0×107EI\frac{M_A}{2 EI} = \frac{-8.0 \times 10^7}{2 EI} = -\frac{4.0 \times 10^7}{EI}
    • Shape is a trapezoid of length L1=2000 mmL_1 = 2000\text{ mm}, which we divide into a rectangle and a triangle:
      • Rectangle Area (A2,rectA_{2, \text{rect}}): A2,rect=2000×(2.0×107EI)=4.0×1010EIA_{2, \text{rect}} = 2000 \times \left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^7}{EI}\right) = \frac{4.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI} Centroid from B:xˉ2,rect=2000+20002=3000 mm\text{Centroid from } B: \bar{x}_{2, \text{rect}} = 2000 + \frac{2000}{2} = \mathbf{3000\text{ mm}}
      • Triangle Area (A2,triA_{2, \text{tri}}): Height=4.0×107−2.0×107EI=2.0×107EI\text{Height} = \frac{4.0 \times 10^7 - 2.0 \times 10^7}{EI} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^7}{EI} A2,tri=12×2000×(2.0×107EI)=2.0×1010EIA_{2, \text{tri}} = \frac{1}{2} \times 2000 \times \left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^7}{EI}\right) = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI} Centroid from C=23×2000=1333.33 mm  ⟹  from B:xˉ2,tri=2000+1333.33=3333.33 mm\text{Centroid from } C = \frac{2}{3} \times 2000 = 1333.33\text{ mm} \implies \text{from } B: \bar{x}_{2, \text{tri}} = 2000 + 1333.33 = \mathbf{3333.33\text{ mm}}

Step 3: Tip Slope via Mohr's First Theorem

Because the beam is built-in at AA, the tangent at AA is horizontal (θA=0\theta_A = 0):

θB−θA=Atotal=A1+A2,rect+A2,tri\theta_B - \theta_A = A_{\text{total}} = A_1 + A_{2, \text{rect}} + A_{2, \text{tri}} θB−0=4.0×1010+4.0×1010+2.0×1010EI=1.0×1011EI\theta_B - 0 = \frac{4.0 \times 10^{10} + 4.0 \times 10^{10} + 2.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI} = \frac{1.0 \times 10^{11}}{EI} θB=1.0×1011 N⋅mm21.0×1013 N⋅mm2=0.010000 rad=0.573∘\theta_B = \frac{1.0 \times 10^{11}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2}{1.0 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2} = \mathbf{0.010000\text{ rad} = 0.573^\circ}

Step 4: Tip Deflection via Mohr's Second Theorem

Since the tangent at AA is horizontal, the vertical deflection at BB is identical to the tangential deviation tB/At_{B/A}:

δB=tB/A=A1xˉ1+A2,rectxˉ2,rect+A2,trixˉ2,tri\delta_B = t_{B/A} = A_1 \bar{x}_1 + A_{2, \text{rect}} \bar{x}_{2, \text{rect}} + A_{2, \text{tri}} \bar{x}_{2, \text{tri}} δB=1EI[(4.0×1010×1333.333)+(4.0×1010×3000)+(2.0×1010×3333.333)]\delta_B = \frac{1}{EI} \left[ (4.0 \times 10^{10} \times 1333.333) + (4.0 \times 10^{10} \times 3000) + (2.0 \times 10^{10} \times 3333.333) \right] δB=1EI[5.3333×1013+1.20×1014+6.6667×1013]=2.40×1014EI\delta_B = \frac{1}{EI} \left[ 5.3333 \times 10^{13} + 1.20 \times 10^{14} + 6.6667 \times 10^{13} \right] = \frac{2.40 \times 10^{14}}{EI}

Substituting EI=1.0×1013 N⋅mm2EI = 1.0 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2:

δB=2.40×10141.0×1013=24.000 mm(Downward)\delta_B = \frac{2.40 \times 10^{14}}{1.0 \times 10^{13}} = \mathbf{24.000\text{ mm} \quad (\text{Downward})}

Problem 2: Conjugate Beam Method for Overhanging Beam (UPSC ESE Pattern)

Statement:
A beam ABCABC has a main span AB=6.0 mAB = 6.0\text{ m} supported on a pin at AA and a roller at BB, with an overhanging span BC=2.0 mBC = 2.0\text{ m}. A concentrated load W=30 kNW = 30\text{ kN} acts downwards at the overhanging tip CC. Flexural rigidity EI=2.5×1013 N⋅mm2EI = 2.5 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2 is constant. Using the Conjugate Beam Method:

  1. Construct the conjugate beam including its transformed supports.
  2. Determine the slope at the left support AA (θA\theta_A).
  3. Compute the vertical deflection at the overhanging tip CC (δC\delta_C).

Solution:

Step 1: Real Beam Statics

  • Taking moments about AA: ΣMA=0  ⟹  RB×6.0−30×8.0=0  ⟹  RB=2406=+40 kN (Upward)\Sigma M_A = 0 \implies R_B \times 6.0 - 30 \times 8.0 = 0 \implies R_B = \frac{240}{6} = \mathbf{+40\text{ kN (Upward)}}
  • Equilibrium in yy: ΣFy=0  ⟹  RA+40−30=0  ⟹  RA=−10 kN (Downward!)\Sigma F_y = 0 \implies R_A + 40 - 30 = 0 \implies R_A = \mathbf{-10\text{ kN (Downward!)}}
  • Bending Moment Diagram:
    • At AA: MA=0M_A = 0
    • At BB: MB=−W×2.0=−30 kN×2.0 m=−60 kN⋅m=−6.0×107 N⋅mmM_B = -W \times 2.0 = -30\text{ kN} \times 2.0\text{ m} = -60\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} = -6.0 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} (Hogging)
    • At CC: MC=0M_C = 0
    • The BMD is triangular over ABAB and triangular over BCBC, with a peak hogging moment of −60 kN⋅m-60\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} at support BB.

Step 2: Formulate the Conjugate Beam

  • Support Transformations:
    • Real Support AA (End Pin)   ⟹  \implies Conjugate Support A′A' remains a Pin Support.
    • Real Support BB (Internal Continuous Roller)   ⟹  \implies Conjugate Support B′B' transforms into an Internal Hinge!
    • Real Tip CC (Free End)   ⟹  \implies Conjugate Tip C′C' transforms into a Fixed Support!
  • Conjugate Loading:
    • Because real moment is negative (hogging), the elastic load w∗=M/EIw^* = M/EI acts downwards:
      • Segment A′B′A'B' (6000 mm6000\text{ mm}): Triangular downward load from 00 at A′A' to 6.0×107EI\frac{6.0 \times 10^7}{EI} at B′B'. Total Load on A′B′:WAB∗=12×6000×(6.0×107EI)=1.80×1011EI\text{Total Load on } A'B': W^*_{AB} = \frac{1}{2} \times 6000 \times \left(\frac{6.0 \times 10^7}{EI}\right) = \frac{1.80 \times 10^{11}}{EI} Centroid from B′=13×6000=2000 mm  ⟹  from A′=4000 mm\text{Centroid from } B' = \frac{1}{3} \times 6000 = 2000\text{ mm} \implies \text{from } A' = 4000\text{ mm}
      • Segment B′C′B'C' (2000 mm2000\text{ mm}): Triangular downward load from 6.0×107EI\frac{6.0 \times 10^7}{EI} at B′B' to 00 at C′C'. Total Load on B′C′:WBC∗=12×2000×(6.0×107EI)=6.0×1010EI\text{Total Load on } B'C': W^*_{BC} = \frac{1}{2} \times 2000 \times \left(\frac{6.0 \times 10^7}{EI}\right) = \frac{6.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI} Centroid from C′=23×2000=1333.33 mm\text{Centroid from } C' = \frac{2}{3} \times 2000 = 1333.33\text{ mm}

Step 3: Slope at Real Support AA

The slope θA\theta_A in the real beam equals the shear force VA∗V^*_{A} in the conjugate beam:

  • In the conjugate beam, hinge B′B' transmits zero bending moment (ΣMB′=0\Sigma M_{B'} = 0 for span A′B′A'B'): ΣMB′=0  ⟹  RA∗×6000−WAB∗×2000=0\Sigma M_{B'} = 0 \implies R^*_{A} \times 6000 - W^*_{AB} \times 2000 = 0 RA∗×6000=(1.80×1011EI)×2000=3.60×1014EIR^*_{A} \times 6000 = \left(\frac{1.80 \times 10^{11}}{EI}\right) \times 2000 = \frac{3.60 \times 10^{14}}{EI} RA∗=3.60×10146000×EI=6.0×1010EIR^*_{A} = \frac{3.60 \times 10^{14}}{6000 \times EI} = \mathbf{\frac{6.0 \times 10^{10}}{EI}}
θA=VA∗=RA∗=6.0×10102.5×1013=0.002400 rad=0.1375∘\theta_A = V^*_{A} = R^*_{A} = \frac{6.0 \times 10^{10}}{2.5 \times 10^{13}} = \mathbf{0.002400\text{ rad} = 0.1375^\circ}

Step 4: Deflection at Overhanging Tip CC

The vertical deflection δC\delta_C in the real beam equals the bending moment MC∗M^*_{C} at fixed support C′C' of the conjugate beam:

  • Shear transmitted across internal hinge B′B' from span A′B′A'B': VB′,left∗=RA∗−WAB∗=6.0×1010−1.80×1011EI=−1.20×1011EIV^*_{B', \text{left}} = R^*_{A} - W^*_{AB} = \frac{6.0 \times 10^{10} - 1.80 \times 10^{11}}{EI} = -\frac{1.20 \times 10^{11}}{EI} Therefore, an upward shear force of 1.20×1011EI\frac{1.20 \times 10^{11}}{EI} acts on segment B′C′B'C' at hinge B′B' (downward reaction on segment B′C′B'C').
  • Taking moments about fixed support C′C' for cantilever B′C′B'C': MC∗=VB′∗×2000+WBC∗×1333.333M^*_{C} = V^*_{B'} \times 2000 + W^*_{BC} \times 1333.333 MC∗=1EI[(1.20×1011×2000)+(6.0×1010×1333.333)]M^*_{C} = \frac{1}{EI} \left[ (1.20 \times 10^{11} \times 2000) + (6.0 \times 10^{10} \times 1333.333) \right] MC∗=1EI[2.40×1014+8.0×1013]=3.20×1014EIM^*_{C} = \frac{1}{EI} \left[ 2.40 \times 10^{14} + 8.0 \times 10^{13} \right] = \frac{3.20 \times 10^{14}}{EI}

Substituting EI=2.5×1013 N⋅mm2EI = 2.5 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2:

δC=∣MC∗∣=3.20×10142.5×1013=12.800 mm(Downward)\delta_C = |M^*_{C}| = \frac{3.20 \times 10^{14}}{2.5 \times 10^{13}} = \mathbf{12.800\text{ mm} \quad (\text{Downward})}

Problem 3: Moment-Area for Symmetrical Circular Bending (State AE Pattern)

Statement:
A simply supported beam of span L=5.0 mL = 5.0\text{ m} is subjected to equal and opposite clockwise and counter-clockwise couples M0=25 kN⋅mM_0 = 25\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} at its left and right ends, inducing pure sagging bending across the whole span. Given flexural rigidity EI=1.5×1013 N⋅mm2EI = 1.5 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2, determine:

  1. The end rotation θA\theta_A using Mohr's 1st Theorem.
  2. The central deflection δmid\delta_{\text{mid}} using Mohr's 2nd Theorem.

Solution:

Step 1: Geometry of the M/EIM/EI Diagram

Under equal end couples, the bending moment is constant: M(x)=M0=25 kN⋅m=2.5×107 N⋅mmM(x) = M_0 = 25\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} = 2.5 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}.

  • The M/EIM/EI diagram is a perfect rectangle of length L=5000 mmL = 5000\text{ mm} and height h=M0EIh = \frac{M_0}{EI}.
  • By symmetry, the slope at midspan is zero: θmid=0\theta_{\text{mid}} = 0.

Step 2: End Slope via Mohr's 1st Theorem

Applying Mohr's 1st theorem between support AA and midspan CC (L/2=2500 mmL/2 = 2500\text{ mm}):

θC−θA=−AM/EI,AC\theta_C - \theta_A = - A_{M/EI, AC} 0−θA=−(M0EI)(L2)  ⟹  θA=M0L2EI0 - \theta_A = - \left( \frac{M_0}{EI} \right) \left(\frac{L}{2}\right) \implies \theta_A = \mathbf{\frac{M_0 L}{2 EI}} θA=(2.5×107 N⋅mm)×(5000 mm)2×(1.5×1013 N⋅mm2)=1.25×10113.0×1013=0.004167 rad=0.2387∘\theta_A = \frac{(2.5 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}) \times (5000\text{ mm})}{2 \times (1.5 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2)} = \frac{1.25 \times 10^{11}}{3.0 \times 10^{13}} = \mathbf{0.004167\text{ rad} = 0.2387^\circ}

Step 3: Central Deflection via Mohr's 2nd Theorem

Because the tangent at midspan CC is perfectly horizontal, the vertical deflection at midspan equals the tangential deviation tA/Ct_{A/C} of support AA from the midspan tangent:

δmid=tA/C=AM/EI,AC×xˉA\delta_{\text{mid}} = t_{A/C} = A_{M/EI, AC} \times \bar{x}_A

Here, the area between AA and CC is a rectangle of width L/2L/2:

AAC=M0L2EIA_{AC} = \frac{M_0 L}{2 EI}

The centroid of this rectangle from support AA is:

xˉA=L/22=L4\bar{x}_A = \frac{L/2}{2} = \frac{L}{4} δmid=(M0L2EI)(L4)=M0L28EI\delta_{\text{mid}} = \left( \frac{M_0 L}{2 EI} \right) \left( \frac{L}{4} \right) = \mathbf{\frac{M_0 L^2}{8 EI}} δmid=(2.5×107 N⋅mm)×(5000 mm)28×(1.5×1013 N⋅mm2)=6.25×10141.20×1014=5.208 mm(Downward)\delta_{\text{mid}} = \frac{(2.5 \times 10^7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}) \times (5000\text{ mm})^2}{8 \times (1.5 \times 10^{13}\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}^2)} = \frac{6.25 \times 10^{14}}{1.20 \times 10^{14}} = \mathbf{5.208\text{ mm} \quad (\text{Downward})}

9. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

Attribute / Parameter Mohr's Moment-Area Method Conjugate Beam Method Macaulay's Method
Originator & Year Christian Otto Mohr (1868) Christian Otto Mohr (1868) W. H. Macaulay (1919)
Mathematical Basis Geometric integration of M/EIM/EI Static equilibrium of fictitious beam Singularity step functions ⟨x−a⟩n\langle x - a \rangle^n
Calculates Directly Relative slope θB/A\theta_{B/A} & deviation tB/At_{B/A} Absolute slope (θ=V∗\theta = V^*) & deflection (y=M∗y = M^*) Closed-form continuous y(x)y(x) equation
Non-Prismatic Stepped Beams Extremely Simple (step M/EIM/EI areas) Very Simple (stepped loading) Difficult (requires variable coefficient ODE)
Overhanging Beams Requires careful geometric sketching Superior (internal hinge at support) Simple via continuation trick
Statically Indeterminate Beams Used for prop reactions via compatibility Conjugate beam becomes unstable/determinate Used with redundant prop reactions

10. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights

  1. Mohr's 1st Theorem: θB−θA=Area of MEI\theta_B - \theta_A = \text{Area of } \frac{M}{EI} diagram between AA and BB.
  2. Mohr's 2nd Theorem: tB/A=AM/EI⋅xˉBt_{B/A} = A_{M/EI} \cdot \bar{x}_B (first moment of area taken about point BB).
  3. Cantilever Trick: Since a fixed support has θfixed=0\theta_{\text{fixed}} = 0 and the tangent is horizontal, θtip=Total Area of M/EI\theta_{\text{tip}} = \text{Total Area of } M/EI and δtip=ttip/fixed=Total Area ×xˉfrom tip\delta_{\text{tip}} = t_{\text{tip/fixed}} = \text{Total Area } \times \bar{x}_{\text{from tip}}.
  4. Simply Supported Midspan Trick: For symmetric beams, θmid=0\theta_{\text{mid}} = 0, so θend=Half-Span Area of M/EI\theta_{\text{end}} = \text{Half-Span Area of } M/EI, and δmid=tsupport/mid=Half-Span Area ×xˉfrom support\delta_{\text{mid}} = t_{\text{support/mid}} = \text{Half-Span Area } \times \bar{x}_{\text{from support}}.
  5. Conjugate Beam Twin Identities: Real Slope θ=V∗ (Conjugate Shear)\text{Real Slope } \theta = V^* \text{ (Conjugate Shear)} Real Deflection y=M∗ (Conjugate Bending Moment)\text{Real Deflection } y = M^* \text{ (Conjugate Bending Moment)}
  6. Support Inversion: Fixed becomes Free; Free becomes Fixed; Internal Support becomes Internal Hinge.

11. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios

  • Trap 1: Centroid Distance to Wrong Point in Mohr's 2nd Theorem:
    Misconception: Calculating tB/At_{B/A} by taking the centroid distance to AA instead of BB.
    Correction: In tB/At_{B/A}, the deviation is measured at point BB, so moments must be taken about point BB (xˉB\bar{x}_B). Taking moments about AA gives tA/Bt_{A/B}, which is completely different!
  • Trap 2: Assuming tB/At_{B/A} Equals Deflection in Simply Supported Beams:
    Misconception: Thinking δB=tB/A\delta_B = t_{B/A} for a simply supported beam.
    Correction: At support BB, deflection is zero (yB=0y_B = 0). tB/At_{B/A} is only the vertical distance between the support and the tangent drawn at AA. The deflection at any interior point CC requires geometric proportions: δC=xCLtB/A−tC/A\delta_C = \frac{x_C}{L} t_{B/A} - t_{C/A}.
  • Trap 3: Forgetting to Divide Moment by EIEI in Non-Prismatic Beams:
    Misconception: Using the raw bending moment area AMA_M and dividing by an average EIEI.
    Correction: In stepped beams, each segment's area must be divided by its own specific EIEI value (EI1,EI2EI_1, EI_2).
  • Trap 4: Conjugate Beam Internal Hinge vs Internal Support:
    Misconception: Replacing a real internal hinge with an internal hinge in the conjugate beam.
    Correction: A real internal hinge allows a slope discontinuity (Δθ≠0\Delta\theta \ne 0) with continuous deflection, which corresponds to a shear step (ΔV∗≠0\Delta V^* \ne 0) with continuous moment in the conjugate beam—meaning it must be replaced by an internal roller support!

12. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems

Reference Code Clauses

  • IS 456:2000 Cl. 23.2 & IS 800:2007 Table 6:
    Permissible deflection limits require verified structural calculations. Moment-area and conjugate beam methods are recognized by standard design offices as the primary hand-calculation tools for checking serviceability deflections in non-prismatic girders and bridge superstructures.

Objective Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE)

A cantilever beam of length LL has flexural rigidity EIEI for the left half (0≤x≤L/20 \le x \le L/2) and flexural rigidity 2EI2 EI for the right half (L/2≤x≤LL/2 \le x \le L). A concentrated moment M0M_0 acts at the free tip (x=Lx = L). The rotation at the free tip is:

  • (A) M0LEI\frac{M_0 L}{EI}
  • (B) 3M0L4EI\frac{3 M_0 L}{4 EI}
  • (C) M0L2EI\frac{M_0 L}{2 EI}
  • (D) 5M0L8EI\frac{5 M_0 L}{8 EI}

Answer: (B)
Solution:
Bending moment is uniform across the whole span: M(x)=M0M(x) = M_0.
The M/EIM/EI diagram consists of two rectangles:
Left half (00 to L/2L/2): Height =M0EI= \frac{M_0}{EI}, Area A1=M0EI(L2)=M0L2EIA_1 = \frac{M_0}{EI} \left(\frac{L}{2}\right) = \frac{M_0 L}{2 EI}.
Right half (L/2L/2 to LL): Height =M02EI= \frac{M_0}{2 EI}, Area A2=M02EI(L2)=M0L4EIA_2 = \frac{M_0}{2 EI} \left(\frac{L}{2}\right) = \frac{M_0 L}{4 EI}.
By Mohr's 1st Theorem, tip slope θ=A1+A2=M0L2EI+M0L4EI=3M0L4EI\theta = A_1 + A_2 = \frac{M_0 L}{2 EI} + \frac{M_0 L}{4 EI} = \mathbf{\frac{3 M_0 L}{4 EI}}.


Problem 2 (UPSC ESE)

In the Conjugate Beam Method, an internal hinge in the real beam transforms into:

  • (A) A free end in the conjugate beam
  • (B) An internal roller support in the conjugate beam
  • (C) A fixed support in the conjugate beam
  • (D) An internal hinge in the conjugate beam

Answer: (B)
Solution:
In a real beam, an internal hinge allows a slope discontinuity (Δθ\Delta\theta) while maintaining zero bending moment and non-zero continuous deflection (yy). In the conjugate beam, this requires an internal support where shear has a step discontinuity (ΔV∗\Delta V^*) and bending moment is continuous non-zero.


Problem 3 (SSC JE / RRB JE)

According to Mohr's Second Theorem, the tangential deviation of point BB on the elastic curve from the tangent drawn at point AA (tB/At_{B/A}) is:

  • (A) The area of the M/EIM/EI diagram between AA and BB
  • (B) The moment of the M/EIM/EI diagram area between AA and BB about point AA
  • (C) The moment of the M/EIM/EI diagram area between AA and BB about point BB
  • (D) The product of slopes at AA and BB

Answer: (C)
Solution:
tB/A=AM/EI⋅xˉBt_{B/A} = A_{M/EI} \cdot \bar{x}_B, which is the first moment of the M/EIM/EI area taken about the point being measured (point BB).


Problem 4 (GATE CE)

A cantilever beam of span LL is subjected to a uniformly distributed load ww over its entire length. The deflection of the free end is δ\delta. If the flexural rigidity of the beam is doubled (2EI2EI), the new deflection will be:

  • (A) 2δ2\delta
  • (B) δ/2\delta / 2
  • (C) δ/4\delta / 4
  • (D) δ\delta

Answer: (B)
Solution:
δ=wL48EI∝1EI\delta = \frac{w L^4}{8 EI} \propto \frac{1}{EI}. Doubling EIEI halves the deflection (δnew=δ/2\delta_{\text{new}} = \delta / 2).


Problem 5 (State AE / ESE)

The conjugate beam of a real beam that is simply supported at both ends is:

  • (A) Fixed at both ends
  • (B) Cantilever beam
  • (C) Simply supported at both ends
  • (D) Free at both ends

Answer: (C)
Solution:
At exterior pin and roller supports, real deflection y=0y = 0 (M∗=0M^* = 0) and slope θ≠0\theta \ne 0 (V∗≠0V^* \ne 0). The conjugate boundary condition that has zero bending moment and non-zero shear force is also a pin or roller support. Hence, a simply supported real beam transforms into a simply supported conjugate beam!