SOM-09-01 Chapter 09 · Thin and Thick Cylinders

Thin Cylinders and Spherical Shells Under Internal Pressure

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Title & Metadata Header

  • Topic ID: SOM-09-01
  • Module / Subject: Strength of Materials (Mechanics of Solids)
  • Chapter 09: Thin and Thick Cylinders & Spherical Shells
  • Topic Title: Thin Cylinders and Spherical Shells Under Internal Fluid Pressure
  • Prerequisites: SOM-01-01 (Stress and Strain Definitions), SOM-02-01 to SOM-02-03 (Biaxial Stress Transformation & Mohr's Circle), SOM-02-05 (Theories of Failure).
  • Target Examinations: GATE CE, UPSC ESE (Civil), SSC JE (Civil), State AE/JE, RRB JE (Civil).
  • Quality Assurance Gate: Level 1 through Level 7 Verification Protocol Enforced.

2. Introduction & Physical Engineering Significance

In civil, mechanical, and petrochemical infrastructure, fluid containment structures operating under positive internal pressure are ubiquitous. Common civil engineering examples include:

  • Municipal water supply penstocks and trunk distribution mains,
  • Steel rising mains in sewage pumping systems,
  • High-pressure compressed air receivers in tunneling and pneumatic foundation caissons,
  • Gas storage vessels and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) spherical bullets ("Hortonspheres"),
  • Submerged hydraulic tunnels subjected to internal hydrodynamic head.

When a vessel contains fluid under internal gauge pressure pp, the contained fluid exerts a normal pressure uniformly outward against all internal surfaces. This pressure induces tensile membrane stresses in the vessel walls.

Depending on the ratio of wall thickness tt to internal diameter dd, pressure vessels are fundamentally classified into two distinct mechanical regimes:

  1. Thin Shells (t/d≤1/20t / d \le 1/20 or 0.050.05): The radial variation of stress across the wall thickness is negligible (<5%<5\%). Stresses can be treated as uniformly distributed across the wall thickness (membrane state of stress).
  2. Thick Shells (t/d>1/20t / d > 1/20): Radial stress cannot be ignored, and circumferential stress varies hyperbolically across the wall, requiring Lamé's differential equations (SOM-09-03).

3. Foundational Assumptions & Governing Criteria

Thin shell membrane theory rests upon the following core engineering assumptions:

  1. Geometry Criterion: The wall thickness tt is small compared to the internal diameter dd, satisfying: td≤120(or tr≤110)\frac{t}{d} \le \frac{1}{20} \quad \left(\text{or } \frac{t}{r} \le \frac{1}{10}\right) For most commercial pipelines and vessels (t/dt/d typically ranges from 1/501/50 to 1/2001/200).
  2. Uniform Stress Across Thickness: Because t≪dt \ll d, bending stiffness of the shell wall is neglected. The circumferential (hoop) stress σh\sigma_h and longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L are assumed perfectly uniform throughout the wall thickness tt.
  3. Radial Stress Neglect: The radial stress σr\sigma_r varies from compressive magnitude −p-p at the inner surface to 00 (atmospheric) at the outer surface. Since p≪σhp \ll \sigma_h (by a factor of 2t/d≤0.102t/d \le 0.10), radial compressive stress σr\sigma_r is neglected when calculating membrane yielding, treating the vessel wall as a state of plane stress (σ3≈0\sigma_3 \approx 0).
  4. Fluid Statically Maintained: The internal fluid has negligible shearing resistance and exerts purely normal pressure perpendicular to the metal boundary.
  5. No End Discontinuity Effects: Away from rigid flanges, end caps, and support saddles, the membrane state is free from secondary bending moments (Saint-Venant's principle).

4. Mathematical Derivations of Membrane Stresses

4.1 Circumferential (Hoop) Stress in a Thin Cylinder (σh\sigma_h)

Consider a thin cylindrical shell of inside diameter dd, wall thickness tt, length LL, containing fluid under internal gauge pressure pp.

To determine the circumferential stress, consider a virtual longitudinal cutting plane passing through the diametral centerline of the cylinder, dividing it into two symmetrical semicircular halves.

       PROJECTED AREA = d × L
       BURSTING FORCE F_b = p · d · L  (acting vertically upward)
       RESISTING FORCE F_r = 2 · (σ_h · t · L)  (acting vertically downward)
  1. Total Upward Bursting Force (FbF_b): The internal pressure pp acts normal to every point of the curved semicircular inner wall. Consider an elemental strip at angle θ\theta subtending an angle dθd\theta:

    dA=r dθ⋅L=d2 dθ⋅LdA = r \, d\theta \cdot L = \frac{d}{2} \, d\theta \cdot L

    The radial bursting force on this strip is dF=p⋅dA=p(d2dθ⋅L)dF = p \cdot dA = p \left(\frac{d}{2} d\theta \cdot L\right). Resolving vertically:

    dFy=dFcos⁡θ=p⋅d2Lcos⁡θ dθdF_y = dF \cos \theta = p \cdot \frac{d}{2} L \cos \theta \, d\theta

    Integrating over the semicircle from θ=−π2\theta = -\frac{\pi}{2} to θ=+π2\theta = +\frac{\pi}{2}:

    Fb=∫−π/2π/2pd2Lcos⁡θ dθ=pd2L[sin⁡θ]−π/2π/2=pd2L(1−(−1))=p⋅d⋅LF_b = \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} p \frac{d}{2} L \cos \theta \, d\theta = p \frac{d}{2} L [\sin \theta]_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} = p \frac{d}{2} L (1 - (-1)) = p \cdot d \cdot L

    (Physical Principle: The resultant fluid force in any direction equals the pressure multiplied by the projected area perpendicular to that direction: Aprojected=d⋅LA_{\text{projected}} = d \cdot L.)

  2. Total Downward Resisting Force (FrF_r): The shell wall cut exposes two rectangular cross-sections of area t⋅Lt \cdot L on each side:

    Ametal=2⋅(t⋅L)A_{\text{metal}} = 2 \cdot (t \cdot L)

    The total tensile resisting force developed in the wall is:

    Fr=2⋅(σh⋅t⋅L)F_r = 2 \cdot (\sigma_h \cdot t \cdot L)
  3. Equilibrium Equation: Equating bursting force to resisting force (ΣFy=0\Sigma F_y = 0):

    2⋅σh⋅t⋅L=p⋅d⋅L2 \cdot \sigma_h \cdot t \cdot L = p \cdot d \cdot L

    Cancelling length LL from both sides:

    σh=p⋅d2t=p⋅rt\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} = \frac{p \cdot r}{t}

4.2 Longitudinal (Axial) Stress in a Thin Cylinder (σL\sigma_L)

To find the longitudinal stress resisting the axial bursting force on closed end caps, consider a transverse cutting plane perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the cylinder.

  1. Total Axial Bursting Force (Fb,axialF_{b,\text{axial}}): The internal pressure pp acts on the circular end cap of internal area Acap=π4d2A_{\text{cap}} = \frac{\pi}{4} d^2:

    Fb,axial=p⋅π4d2F_{b,\text{axial}} = p \cdot \frac{\pi}{4} d^2
  2. Total Axial Resisting Force (Fr,axialF_{r,\text{axial}}): The transverse cut exposes an annular metal ring of inside diameter dd and thickness tt. For a thin cylinder, the cross-sectional area of the annular ring is approximated by its mean circumference multiplied by thickness:

    Aring=π⋅d⋅tA_{\text{ring}} = \pi \cdot d \cdot t

    The resisting force developed by uniform longitudinal tensile stress σL\sigma_L is:

    Fr,axial=σL⋅(π⋅d⋅t)F_{r,\text{axial}} = \sigma_L \cdot (\pi \cdot d \cdot t)
  3. Equilibrium Equation: Equating axial forces along the cylinder axis (ΣFx=0\Sigma F_x = 0):

    σL⋅(π⋅d⋅t)=p⋅(π4d2)\sigma_L \cdot (\pi \cdot d \cdot t) = p \cdot \left(\frac{\pi}{4} d^2\right)

    Cancelling π⋅d\pi \cdot d:

    σL=p⋅d4t=p⋅r2t\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} = \frac{p \cdot r}{2 t}

4.3 Fundamental Stress Ratio

Comparing the two principal membrane stresses:

σh=2⋅σL⟺σL=σh2\sigma_h = 2 \cdot \sigma_L \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad \sigma_L = \frac{\sigma_h}{2}

Key Design Insight: The circumferential (hoop) stress is twice as large as the longitudinal stress. Consequently:

  • A thin cylinder subjected to excessive internal pressure will always rupture longitudinally (splitting along its length), not circumferentially.
  • In fabricated or welded steel pipes, longitudinal welded joints carry twice the stress of circumferential joints. Longitudinal seams must be designed with higher joint efficiency or subjected to stricter non-destructive testing (NDT).

4.4 Membrane Stress in a Thin Spherical Shell (σsphere\sigma_{\text{sphere}})

Consider a thin spherical pressure vessel of internal diameter dd and wall thickness tt subjected to internal fluid pressure pp.

By spherical symmetry, any plane passing through the center of the sphere divides it into two identical hemispherical bowls.

  1. Bursting Force on Projected Circular Area: Fb=p⋅Aprojected=p⋅π4d2F_b = p \cdot A_{\text{projected}} = p \cdot \frac{\pi}{4} d^2
  2. Resisting Force in Annular Wall Rim: Fr=σ⋅(π⋅d⋅t)F_r = \sigma \cdot (\pi \cdot d \cdot t)
  3. Equilibrium (ΣFz=0\Sigma F_z = 0): σ⋅πdt=p⋅π4d2  ⟹  σsphere=p⋅d4t\sigma \cdot \pi d t = p \cdot \frac{\pi}{4} d^2 \implies \sigma_{\text{sphere}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t}

Because of complete spherical point-symmetry, every normal direction in the tangent plane of the sphere is a principal direction, and the two principal stresses are equal:

σ1=σ2=σsphere=p⋅d4t\sigma_1 = \sigma_2 = \sigma_{\text{sphere}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t}

5. State of Stress & 3D Mohr's Circle Analysis

An elemental block taken from the surface of a thin cylindrical pressure vessel is subjected to a triaxial state of stress:

σ1=σh=pd2t(Circumferential tensile)\sigma_1 = \sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t} \quad (\text{Circumferential tensile}) σ2=σL=pd4t(Longitudinal tensile)\sigma_2 = \sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t} \quad (\text{Longitudinal tensile}) σ3=σr≈0(Radial stress on outer surface)\sigma_3 = \sigma_r \approx 0 \quad (\text{Radial stress on outer surface})

(Note: On the inner wall surface, σ3=−p\sigma_3 = -p. Since p=σh⋅2tdp = \sigma_h \cdot \frac{2t}{d}, the ratio ∣σ3∣σ1=2td≤110\frac{|\sigma_3|}{\sigma_1} = \frac{2t}{d} \le \frac{1}{10}. Neglecting σ3\sigma_3 introduces an error under 5%5\%, which is standard for thin shell analysis.)

5.1 Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress vs. Absolute Maximum Shear Stress

This is one of the most critical and frequently tested distinctions in GATE CE and UPSC ESE:

  1. Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress (τmax⁡,in-plane\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}}): The maximum shear stress acting on planes perpendicular to the cylinder surface (rotated 45∘45^\circ between the hoop and longitudinal axes):

    τmax⁡,in-plane=σ1−σ22=σh−σL2=pd2t−pd4t2=p⋅d8t\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2}{2} = \frac{\sigma_h - \sigma_L}{2} = \frac{\frac{p d}{2 t} - \frac{p d}{4 t}}{2} = \frac{p \cdot d}{8 t}
  2. Absolute Maximum Shear Stress (τmax⁡,abs\tau_{\max,\text{abs}}): The true maximum shear stress in the 3-dimensional material occurs on planes inclined at 45∘45^\circ to the vessel surface, cutting through the wall thickness (governed by the largest and smallest principal stresses σ1\sigma_1 and σ3\sigma_3):

    τmax⁡,abs=σmax⁡−σmin⁡2=σ1−σ32=pd2t−02=p⋅d4t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}}{2} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{\frac{p d}{2 t} - 0}{2} = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t}

Crucial Warning:

τmax⁡,abs=2⋅τmax⁡,in-plane=p⋅d4t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = 2 \cdot \tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t}

If a ductile pressure vessel yields according to Tresca's Maximum Shear Stress Theory, yielding begins when:

τmax⁡,abs=fy2  ⟹  pd4t=fy2  ⟹  σh=pd2t=fy\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{f_y}{2} \implies \frac{p d}{4 t} = \frac{f_y}{2} \implies \sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t} = f_y

Calculating Tresca yield using τmax⁡,in-plane=pd8t\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{p d}{8 t} underestimates the actual shear stress by 50%50\% and produces a catastrophic, unsafe design!

5.2 Shear Stress in a Thin Spherical Shell

For a spherical vessel:

σ1=σ2=pd4t,σ3=0\sigma_1 = \sigma_2 = \frac{p d}{4 t}, \quad \sigma_3 = 0
  • In-Plane Shear Stress: τmax⁡,in-plane=σ1−σ22=pd4t−pd4t2=0\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2}{2} = \frac{\frac{p d}{4 t} - \frac{p d}{4 t}}{2} = 0 (All in-plane planes are principal planes; in-plane Mohr's circle degenerates to a single point!)
  • Absolute Maximum Shear Stress: τmax⁡,abs=σ1−σ32=pd4t−02=p⋅d8t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{\frac{p d}{4 t} - 0}{2} = \frac{p \cdot d}{8 t}

5.3 Yield Criteria Comparison for Thin Cylinders

For a thin cylinder governed by yield strength fyf_y:

  • Tresca (Maximum Shear Stress Theory): σ1−σ3=fy  ⟹  pd2t−0=fy  ⟹  tTresca=pd2fy\sigma_1 - \sigma_3 = f_y \implies \frac{p d}{2 t} - 0 = f_y \implies t_{\text{Tresca}} = \frac{p d}{2 f_y}
  • von Mises (Distortion Energy Theory): σv=σ12−σ1σ2+σ22≤fy\sigma_v = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - \sigma_1 \sigma_2 + \sigma_2^2} \le f_y Substituting σ2=0.5σ1\sigma_2 = 0.5 \sigma_1: σv=σ12−σ1(0.5σ1)+(0.5σ1)2=σ12(1−0.5+0.25)=σ10.75=32σ1≈0.866 σh\sigma_v = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - \sigma_1 (0.5 \sigma_1) + (0.5 \sigma_1)^2} = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 (1 - 0.5 + 0.25)} = \sigma_1 \sqrt{0.75} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \sigma_1 \approx 0.866 \, \sigma_h Setting σv=fy\sigma_v = f_y: σh=fy3/2=23fy≈1.155 fy  ⟹  tvon Mises=32pd2fy≈0.866 tTresca\sigma_h = \frac{f_y}{\sqrt{3}/2} = \frac{2}{\sqrt{3}} f_y \approx 1.155 \, f_y \implies t_{\text{von Mises}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \frac{p d}{2 f_y} \approx 0.866 \, t_{\text{Tresca}} (Von Mises theory predicts a 15.5% higher pressure containment capacity, or 13.4% thinner wall, than Tresca for cylindrical pressure vessels.)

6. Architectural Comparison & Structural Shell Efficiency

Metric / Parameter Thin Cylindrical Vessel Thin Spherical Vessel Cylindrical with Hemispherical Ends
Governing Membrane Stress σh=pd2tcyl\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t_{\text{cyl}}} σ=pd4tsph\sigma = \frac{p d}{4 t_{\text{sph}}} σh=pd2tcyl\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t_{\text{cyl}}} (body), σ=pd4tend\sigma = \frac{p d}{4 t_{\text{end}}} (heads)
Required Wall Thickness (tt) t=pd2σallowt = \frac{p d}{2 \sigma_{\text{allow}}} t=pd4σallow=0.5 tcylt = \frac{p d}{4 \sigma_{\text{allow}}} = 0.5 \, t_{\text{cyl}} tcyl=pd2σallowt_{\text{cyl}} = \frac{p d}{2 \sigma_{\text{allow}}}, tend=0.5 tcylt_{\text{end}} = 0.5 \, t_{\text{cyl}}
Volume-to-Surface Ratio Moderate (V/A≈d/4V/A \approx d/4 for long cylinder) Maximum theoretical (V/A=d/6V/A = d/6) High
Material Mass for Given Volume Higher (Baseline 100%100\%) Lowest (Saves 20%20\% to 50%50\% steel mass) Economical compromise
Manufacturing Complexity Low (roll plate into cylinder, straight seams) High (dishing/pressing double-curvature petals) Standard industrial practice
Typical Practical Use Pipes, boilers, air receivers, silos High-capacity gas storage bullets, space craft High-pressure commercial vessels

7. SVG Technical Illustrations

7.1 Thin Cylinder Membrane Stress Equilibrium

The diagram below illustrates the free body diagrams for the longitudinal diametral cut (yielding hoop stress σh\sigma_h) and the transverse circular cut (yielding longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L).

Thin Cylinder Stress Equilibrium

7.2 Spherical Shell Membrane Stress & 3D Mohr's Circle

The diagram below shows the hemispherical cut equilibrium, the 3D Mohr's circles comparing in-plane vs. absolute maximum shear stresses, and the crucial exam pitfalls.

Cylinder vs Sphere Membrane Stress

8. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 8.1: Air Receiver Stress & Maximum Permissible Pressure

Problem Statement:
A cylindrical compressed air receiver has an internal diameter of d=1200 mmd = 1200\text{ mm} and a wall thickness of t=8 mmt = 8\text{ mm}. The internal working pressure is p=1.5 MPap = 1.5\text{ MPa} (1.5 N/mm21.5\text{ N/mm}^2).

  1. Verify whether the thin cylinder theory applies.
  2. Calculate the circumferential (hoop) stress and longitudinal stress in the shell.
  3. Determine the maximum in-plane shear stress and the absolute maximum shear stress.
  4. If the permissible tensile stress for the steel plate is σallow=120 MPa\sigma_{\text{allow}} = 120\text{ MPa}, determine the factor of safety under current operating pressure, and the maximum safe working pressure pmax⁡p_{\max}.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Check Thin Cylinder Applicability:

    td=8 mm1200 mm=1150≈0.00667\frac{t}{d} = \frac{8\text{ mm}}{1200\text{ mm}} = \frac{1}{150} \approx 0.00667

    Since td=1150≪120\frac{t}{d} = \frac{1}{150} \ll \frac{1}{20} (0.050.05), thin cylinder membrane theory is strictly valid.

  2. Membrane Stresses:

    • Circumferential (Hoop) Stress: σh=p⋅d2t=1.5 N/mm2×1200 mm2×8 mm=180016=112.50 MPa (Tensile)\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} = \frac{1.5\text{ N/mm}^2 \times 1200\text{ mm}}{2 \times 8\text{ mm}} = \frac{1800}{16} = 112.50\text{ MPa (Tensile)}
    • Longitudinal Stress: σL=p⋅d4t=σh2=112.502=56.25 MPa (Tensile)\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} = \frac{\sigma_h}{2} = \frac{112.50}{2} = 56.25\text{ MPa (Tensile)}
  3. Shear Stresses:

    • Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress: τmax⁡,in-plane=σh−σL2=112.50−56.252=56.252=28.125 MPa\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{\sigma_h - \sigma_L}{2} = \frac{112.50 - 56.25}{2} = \frac{56.25}{2} = 28.125\text{ MPa}
    • Absolute Maximum Shear Stress: With σ1=112.50 MPa\sigma_1 = 112.50\text{ MPa}, σ2=56.25 MPa\sigma_2 = 56.25\text{ MPa}, and σ3=0 MPa\sigma_3 = 0\text{ MPa}: τmax⁡,abs=σ1−σ32=112.50−02=56.25 MPa\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{112.50 - 0}{2} = 56.25\text{ MPa}
  4. Factor of Safety & Maximum Permissible Pressure:

    • Factor of Safety (governed by maximum normal stress σh\sigma_h): FOS=σallowσh=120 MPa112.50 MPa=1.0667≈1.07\text{FOS} = \frac{\sigma_{\text{allow}}}{\sigma_h} = \frac{120\text{ MPa}}{112.50\text{ MPa}} = 1.0667 \approx 1.07
    • Maximum Safe Working Pressure (pmax⁡p_{\max}): pmax⁡=2⋅t⋅σallowd=2×8 mm×120 N/mm21200 mm=19201200=1.60 MPap_{\max} = \frac{2 \cdot t \cdot \sigma_{\text{allow}}}{d} = \frac{2 \times 8\text{ mm} \times 120\text{ N/mm}^2}{1200\text{ mm}} = \frac{1920}{1200} = 1.60\text{ MPa}

Example 8.2: Comparative Steel Mass — Spherical vs. Cylindrical Storage Vessel

Problem Statement:
A chemical plant requires a pressurized storage vessel with a capacity of V=10 m3V = 10\text{ m}^3 to store gas at an internal pressure of p=2.0 MPap = 2.0\text{ MPa}. The permissible tensile stress of the steel is σallow=125 MPa\sigma_{\text{allow}} = 125\text{ MPa}, and steel density is ρ=7850 kg/m3\rho = 7850\text{ kg/m}^3. Compare:

  1. A completely spherical vessel.
  2. A cylindrical vessel with hemispherical ends whose total cylindrical length equals twice its diameter (Lcyl=2dL_{\text{cyl}} = 2 d).
    (Assume the hemispherical ends are sized to the required spherical thickness and disregard joints/nozzles).
    Determine the dimensions, required wall thicknesses, total metal masses, and the percentage steel mass saved by choosing the spherical design.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Spherical Vessel Design:

    • Internal Volume: V=43πR3=π6ds3=10 m3  ⟹  ds=(6×10π)1/3=(60π)1/3≈2.6730 mV = \frac{4}{3} \pi R^3 = \frac{\pi}{6} d_s^3 = 10\text{ m}^3 \implies d_s = \left(\frac{6 \times 10}{\pi}\right)^{1/3} = \left(\frac{60}{\pi}\right)^{1/3} \approx 2.6730\text{ m}
    • Required Wall Thickness (tst_s): ts=p⋅ds4σallow=2.0 MPa×2.6730 m4×125 MPa=5.346500=0.010692 m=10.69 mmt_s = \frac{p \cdot d_s}{4 \sigma_{\text{allow}}} = \frac{2.0\text{ MPa} \times 2.6730\text{ m}}{4 \times 125\text{ MPa}} = \frac{5.346}{500} = 0.010692\text{ m} = 10.69\text{ mm}
    • Surface Area & Metal Mass: As=πds2=π×(2.6730)2≈22.447 m2A_s = \pi d_s^2 = \pi \times (2.6730)^2 \approx 22.447\text{ m}^2 Vmetal,s=As⋅ts=22.447 m2×0.010692 m≈0.2400 m3V_{\text{metal},s} = A_s \cdot t_s = 22.447\text{ m}^2 \times 0.010692\text{ m} \approx 0.2400\text{ m}^3 Ms=Vmetal,s×ρ=0.2400 m3×7850 kg/m3=1884.0 kgM_s = V_{\text{metal},s} \times \rho = 0.2400\text{ m}^3 \times 7850\text{ kg/m}^3 = 1884.0\text{ kg}
  2. Cylindrical Vessel with Hemispherical Ends (Lcyl=2dcL_{\text{cyl}} = 2 d_c):

    • Internal Volume (Cylinder + Two Hemispheres = Cylinder + Sphere): V=π4dc2⋅Lcyl+π6dc3=π4dc2(2dc)+π6dc3=(π2+π6)dc3=23πdc3=10 m3V = \frac{\pi}{4} d_c^2 \cdot L_{\text{cyl}} + \frac{\pi}{6} d_c^3 = \frac{\pi}{4} d_c^2 (2 d_c) + \frac{\pi}{6} d_c^3 = \left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \frac{\pi}{6}\right) d_c^3 = \frac{2}{3} \pi d_c^3 = 10\text{ m}^3 dc=(3×102π)1/3=(15π)1/3≈1.6839 md_c = \left(\frac{3 \times 10}{2 \pi}\right)^{1/3} = \left(\frac{15}{\pi}\right)^{1/3} \approx 1.6839\text{ m} Lcyl=2×1.6839=3.3678 mL_{\text{cyl}} = 2 \times 1.6839 = 3.3678\text{ m}
    • Required Wall Thicknesses:
      • Cylindrical body: tcyl=p⋅dc2σallow=2.0×1.68392×125=0.013471 m=13.47 mmt_{\text{cyl}} = \frac{p \cdot d_c}{2 \sigma_{\text{allow}}} = \frac{2.0 \times 1.6839}{2 \times 125} = 0.013471\text{ m} = 13.47\text{ mm}
      • Hemispherical heads: themi=p⋅dc4σallow=tcyl2=6.74 mm=0.006736 mt_{\text{hemi}} = \frac{p \cdot d_c}{4 \sigma_{\text{allow}}} = \frac{t_{\text{cyl}}}{2} = 6.74\text{ mm} = 0.006736\text{ m}
    • Metal Volume and Mass:
      • Cylindrical shell: Acyl=πdcLcyl=π×1.6839×3.3678≈17.816 m2A_{\text{cyl}} = \pi d_c L_{\text{cyl}} = \pi \times 1.6839 \times 3.3678 \approx 17.816\text{ m}^2 Vmetal,cyl=Acyl⋅tcyl=17.816×0.013471≈0.2400 m3V_{\text{metal,cyl}} = A_{\text{cyl}} \cdot t_{\text{cyl}} = 17.816 \times 0.013471 \approx 0.2400\text{ m}^3
      • Two hemispherical heads (full sphere surface): Ahemi=πdc2=π×(1.6839)2≈8.908 m2A_{\text{hemi}} = \pi d_c^2 = \pi \times (1.6839)^2 \approx 8.908\text{ m}^2 Vmetal,hemi=Ahemi⋅themi=8.908×0.006736≈0.0600 m3V_{\text{metal,hemi}} = A_{\text{hemi}} \cdot t_{\text{hemi}} = 8.908 \times 0.006736 \approx 0.0600\text{ m}^3
      • Total metal volume: Vmetal,total=0.2400+0.0600=0.3000 m3V_{\text{metal,total}} = 0.2400 + 0.0600 = 0.3000\text{ m}^3
      • Total cylinder mass: Mc=0.3000 m3×7850 kg/m3=2355.0 kgM_c = 0.3000\text{ m}^3 \times 7850\text{ kg/m}^3 = 2355.0\text{ kg}
  3. Comparison & Mass Savings:

    McMs=2355.01884.0=1.250(25% heavier)\frac{M_c}{M_s} = \frac{2355.0}{1884.0} = 1.250 \quad (25\%\text{ heavier}) Mass Saved by Spherical Vessel=Mc−MsMc×100%=2355.0−1884.02355.0×100%=20.0%\text{Mass Saved by Spherical Vessel} = \frac{M_c - M_s}{M_c} \times 100\% = \frac{2355.0 - 1884.0}{2355.0} \times 100\% = 20.0\%

(Conclusion: The spherical vessel achieves an immediate 20.0%20.0\% reduction in total required steel mass for identical storage volume and pressure containment).


Example 8.3: Combined Internal Pressure and Applied Torsion (GATE Advanced Level)

Problem Statement:
A thin-walled circular cylindrical steel shaft of internal diameter d=200 mmd = 200\text{ mm} and wall thickness t=5 mmt = 5\text{ mm} is subjected simultaneously to an internal fluid pressure of p=3.0 MPap = 3.0\text{ MPa} and an external twisting torque T=12.0 kN⋅mT = 12.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.

  1. Calculate the normal stresses due to internal pressure.
  2. Calculate the torsional shear stress τxy\tau_{xy} in the shell wall using thin-tube theory.
  3. Determine the principal stresses σ1\sigma_1 and σ2\sigma_2 at the outer surface.
  4. Determine the maximum in-plane shear stress and absolute maximum shear stress.
  5. Determine the orientation of the principal planes with respect to the longitudinal axis of the shaft.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Normal Stresses from Internal Pressure:

    σh=p⋅d2t=3.0 N/mm2×200 mm2×5 mm=60.00 MPa\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} = \frac{3.0\text{ N/mm}^2 \times 200\text{ mm}}{2 \times 5\text{ mm}} = 60.00\text{ MPa} σL=p⋅d4t=3.0 N/mm2×200 mm4×5 mm=30.00 MPa\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} = \frac{3.0\text{ N/mm}^2 \times 200\text{ mm}}{4 \times 5\text{ mm}} = 30.00\text{ MPa}
  2. Torsional Shear Stress (τxy\tau_{xy}): Using thin-walled circular tube torsion formula (mean radius rm≈r=100 mmr_m \approx r = 100\text{ mm}):

    J≈2πr3t=2π(100)3(5)=107π mm4J \approx 2 \pi r^3 t = 2 \pi (100)^3 (5) = 10^7 \pi\text{ mm}^4 τxy=T⋅rJ=12×106 N⋅mm×100 mm107π mm4=120π≈38.197 MPa\tau_{xy} = \frac{T \cdot r}{J} = \frac{12 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} \times 100\text{ mm}}{10^7 \pi\text{ mm}^4} = \frac{120}{\pi} \approx 38.197\text{ MPa}

    (Alternatively, using Bredt-Batho shear flow q=T2A0q = \frac{T}{2 A_0}: A0=πr2=π(100)2=10000π mm2A_0 = \pi r^2 = \pi (100)^2 = 10000 \pi\text{ mm}^2, τ=T2A0t=12×1062×(10000π)×5=120π=38.197 MPa\tau = \frac{T}{2 A_0 t} = \frac{12 \times 10^6}{2 \times (10000 \pi) \times 5} = \frac{120}{\pi} = 38.197\text{ MPa}. Exactly identical).

  3. Principal Stresses (σ1,σ2\sigma_1, \sigma_2): Taking coordinate axes: x=x = longitudinal axis (σx=σL=30.0 MPa\sigma_x = \sigma_L = 30.0\text{ MPa}), y=y = hoop axis (σy=σh=60.0 MPa\sigma_y = \sigma_h = 60.0\text{ MPa}), τxy=38.197 MPa\tau_{xy} = 38.197\text{ MPa}.

    • Average Normal Stress: σavg=σx+σy2=30.0+60.02=45.00 MPa\sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} = \frac{30.0 + 60.0}{2} = 45.00\text{ MPa}
    • Radius of Mohr's Circle (RR): R=(σy−σx2)2+τxy2=(60.0−30.02)2+(38.197)2=(15.0)2+1459.0=225+1459.0=1684.0≈41.037 MPaR = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_y - \sigma_x}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{60.0 - 30.0}{2}\right)^2 + (38.197)^2} = \sqrt{(15.0)^2 + 1459.0} = \sqrt{225 + 1459.0} = \sqrt{1684.0} \approx 41.037\text{ MPa}
    • Major Principal Stress: σ1=σavg+R=45.00+41.04=86.04 MPa (Tensile)\sigma_1 = \sigma_{\text{avg}} + R = 45.00 + 41.04 = 86.04\text{ MPa (Tensile)}
    • Minor Principal Stress: σ2=σavg−R=45.00−41.04=3.96 MPa (Tensile)\sigma_2 = \sigma_{\text{avg}} - R = 45.00 - 41.04 = 3.96\text{ MPa (Tensile)}
  4. Maximum Shear Stresses:

    • Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress: τmax⁡,in-plane=R=41.04 MPa\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = R = 41.04\text{ MPa}
    • Absolute Maximum Shear Stress (since σ3=0\sigma_3 = 0 on outer surface): τmax⁡,abs=σ1−σ32=86.04−02=43.02 MPa\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{86.04 - 0}{2} = 43.02\text{ MPa}
  5. Orientation of Principal Planes:

    tan⁡2θp=2τxyσx−σy=2×38.19730.0−60.0=76.394−30.0=−2.5465\tan 2\theta_p = \frac{2 \tau_{xy}}{\sigma_x - \sigma_y} = \frac{2 \times 38.197}{30.0 - 60.0} = \frac{76.394}{-30.0} = -2.5465 2θp=arctan⁡(−2.5465)=−68.56∘  ⟹  2θp=180∘−68.56∘=111.44∘2\theta_p = \arctan(-2.5465) = -68.56^\circ \implies 2\theta_p = 180^\circ - 68.56^\circ = 111.44^\circ θp1=55.72∘relative to the longitudinal axis\theta_{p1} = 55.72^\circ \quad \text{relative to the longitudinal axis}

    (Or θ=34.28∘\theta = 34.28^\circ relative to the circumferential hoop direction).


9. Indian Standard Code Provisions & Engineering Practice

  1. IS 2825:1969 (Code for Unfired Pressure Vessels):

    • Classifies vessels into Class I (severe duties, toxic/lethal fluids, high pressure), Class II (medium service), and Class III (light duty, water supply).
    • Specifies joint efficiencies (η\eta):
      • Fully radiographed double-welded butt joint: η=1.00\eta = 1.00.
      • Spot radiographed butt joint: η=0.85\eta = 0.85.
      • Non-radiographed welded joint: η=0.70\eta = 0.70.
    • Pressure vessel design formulas incorporate joint efficiency: σh=p⋅d2tηL  ⟹  treq=p⋅d2σallowηL−p+c\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t \eta_L} \implies t_{\text{req}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 \sigma_{\text{allow}} \eta_L - p} + c where cc is the statutory corrosion allowance (typically 1.5 mm1.5\text{ mm} to 3.0 mm3.0\text{ mm} for carbon steel exposed to water/steam).
  2. IS 5822:1994 (Code of Practice for Laying of Welded Steel Pipes for Water Supply):

    • Stipulates minimum wall thickness based on internal working pressure, surge head (water hammer), and external earth cover loads.
    • Requires field hydrostatic testing at 1.5×1.5 \times working pressure or 1.0×1.0 \times design pressure, whichever is greater.
  3. ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (BPVC) Section VIII, Division 1:

    • Incorporates the mid-radius correction for thin cylindrical shells under internal pressure: t=p⋅RiSE−0.6pt = \frac{p \cdot R_i}{S E - 0.6 p} where SS is allowable stress and EE is joint efficiency. When p≪SEp \ll S E, this simplifies precisely to the classic thin-shell formula t=pdi2SEt = \frac{p d_i}{2 S E}.

10. Common Misconceptions & High-Yield Exam Traps

  1. Confusing In-Plane vs. Absolute Maximum Shear Stress:

    • Trap: When asked for "maximum shear stress", calculating σh−σL2=pd8t\frac{\sigma_h - \sigma_L}{2} = \frac{p d}{8 t}.
    • Correction: The absolute maximum shear stress in a cylinder is σ1−σ32=σh−02=pd4t\frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{\sigma_h - 0}{2} = \frac{p d}{4 t}. Always select pd4t\frac{p d}{4 t} unless the question explicitly specifies in-plane.
  2. In-Plane Shear in a Sphere is ZERO, not pd/8tp d / 8 t:

    • Trap: Assuming the sphere has in-plane shear pd8t\frac{p d}{8 t}.
    • Correction: In a spherical vessel, σ1=σ2=pd4t\sigma_1 = \sigma_2 = \frac{p d}{4 t}. Therefore, in-plane shear σ1−σ22=0\frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_2}{2} = 0. The value pd8t\frac{p d}{8 t} is its absolute maximum shear stress (σ1−02\frac{\sigma_1 - 0}{2}).
  3. Confusing Inside vs. Outside Diameter in pd/2tp d / 2 t:

    • Trap: Using outside diameter DoD_o instead of inside diameter dd without adjusting.
    • Correction: The internal fluid acts directly across the internal diameter dd. In strict theoretical derivations, bursting force uses internal diameter dd (or mean diameter dm=d+td_m = d + t). In thin shells where t≪dt \ll d, the difference between did_i, dmd_m, and dod_o is <1%<1\%, but exam numericals strictly specify internal diameter.
  4. Assuming Longitudinal Joint Resists Longitudinal Stress:

    • Trap: Thinking a longitudinal welded seam resists longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L.
    • Correction: A longitudinal joint runs parallel to the cylinder axis; opening this joint requires circumferential tension. Therefore, longitudinal seams resist circumferential (hoop) stress σh\sigma_h, while circumferential (girth) seams resist longitudinal stress σL\sigma_L!
  5. Failure Mode of Pressurized Cylinders:

    • Trap: Expecting cylindrical pipes to burst into two halves crosswise.
    • Correction: Because σh=2σL\sigma_h = 2 \sigma_L, a pressurized pipe splits longitudinally along its length like an overcooked sausage.

11. Previous Year Competitive Exam Questions

Question 1 (GATE CE — 2 Marks)

A thin cylindrical shell of diameter dd, length LL, and wall thickness tt is subjected to internal pressure pp. The ratio of circumferential stress to longitudinal stress is:

  • (A) 0.50.5
  • (B) 1.01.0
  • (C) 2.02.0
  • (D) 4.04.0

Answer: (C)
Solution: σh=pd2t\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t}, σL=pd4t\sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t}. Ratio σhσL=pd/2tpd/4t=2.0\frac{\sigma_h}{\sigma_L} = \frac{p d / 2 t}{p d / 4 t} = 2.0.


Question 2 (UPSC ESE — Objective)

A thin cylindrical tube closed at both ends is subjected to internal pressure pp. A point on the tube surface is in a state of stress with principal stresses σ1\sigma_1 and σ2\sigma_2. The absolute maximum shear stress in the cylinder wall is:

  • (A) pd8t\frac{p d}{8 t}
  • (B) pd4t\frac{p d}{4 t}
  • (C) pd2t\frac{p d}{2 t}
  • (D) Zero

Answer: (B)
Solution: The 3 principal stresses are σ1=σh=pd2t\sigma_1 = \sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t}, σ2=σL=pd4t\sigma_2 = \sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t}, and σ3=0\sigma_3 = 0. Absolute maximum shear stress τmax⁡,abs=σ1−σ32=pd/2t−02=pd4t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} = \frac{p d / 2 t - 0}{2} = \frac{p d}{4 t}.


Question 3 (SSC JE / State AE)

For a thin spherical shell of diameter DD and thickness tt subjected to internal pressure PP, the volumetric strain is given by:

  • (A) PD4tE(1−ν)\frac{P D}{4 t E} (1 - \nu)
  • (B) 3PD4tE(1−ν)\frac{3 P D}{4 t E} (1 - \nu)
  • (C) PD2tE(1−2ν)\frac{P D}{2 t E} (1 - 2\nu)
  • (D) 3PD2tE(1−2ν)\frac{3 P D}{2 t E} (1 - 2\nu)

Answer: (B)
Solution: Since ϵ1=ϵ2=PD4tE(1−ν)\epsilon_1 = \epsilon_2 = \frac{P D}{4 t E} (1 - \nu) and ϵv=3ϵ1\epsilon_v = 3 \epsilon_1, ϵv=3PD4tE(1−ν)\epsilon_v = \frac{3 P D}{4 t E} (1 - \nu). (Detailed in SOM-09-02).


Question 4 (GATE CE — Numerical Answer Type)

A seamless spherical vessel of inside diameter 1.0 m1.0\text{ m} and thickness 5 mm5\text{ mm} is filled with gas. If the maximum tensile stress is limited to 100 MPa100\text{ MPa}, the maximum permissible gas pressure is _______ MPa\text{MPa} (answer in integer).

Answer: 2 MPa2\text{ MPa}
Solution:
For a sphere, σ=pd4t\sigma = \frac{p d}{4 t}.

100=p×10004×5=1000p20=50p  ⟹  p=10050=2.0 MPa100 = \frac{p \times 1000}{4 \times 5} = \frac{1000 p}{20} = 50 p \implies p = \frac{100}{50} = 2.0\text{ MPa}

12. Comprehensive Summary & Formula Sheet

Structural Element Formula / Expression Physical Interpretation
Thin Shell Criterion td≤120\frac{t}{d} \le \frac{1}{20} (or 0.050.05) Validates uniform membrane stress assumption
Cylinder Hoop Stress (σh\sigma_h) σh=p⋅d2t\sigma_h = \frac{p \cdot d}{2 t} Tensile stress acting circumferentially
Cylinder Longitudinal Stress (σL\sigma_L) σL=p⋅d4t=σh2\sigma_L = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} = \frac{\sigma_h}{2} Tensile stress acting axially on closed ends
Spherical Shell Membrane Stress (σsph\sigma_{\text{sph}}) σsph=p⋅d4t\sigma_{\text{sph}} = \frac{p \cdot d}{4 t} Uniform equibiaxial tensile stress
Cylinder In-Plane Max Shear (τin-plane\tau_{\text{in-plane}}) τmax⁡,in-plane=σh−σL2=pd8t\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = \frac{\sigma_h - \sigma_L}{2} = \frac{p d}{8 t} Acting on 45∘45^\circ surface planes
Cylinder Absolute Max Shear (τabs\tau_{\text{abs}}) τmax⁡,abs=σh−02=pd4t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_h - 0}{2} = \frac{p d}{4 t} Governs Tresca yield criterion (through thickness)
Sphere In-Plane Max Shear τmax⁡,in-plane=0\tau_{\max,\text{in-plane}} = 0 Biaxial stresses equal; zero in-plane shear
Sphere Absolute Max Shear τmax⁡,abs=σsph−02=pd8t\tau_{\max,\text{abs}} = \frac{\sigma_{\text{sph}} - 0}{2} = \frac{p d}{8 t} Out-of-plane maximum shear
Welded Joint Efficiency (ηL,ηc\eta_L, \eta_c) σh=pd2tηL,σL=pd4tηc\sigma_h = \frac{p d}{2 t \eta_L}, \quad \sigma_L = \frac{p d}{4 t \eta_c} Accounts for reduced joint strength
Von Mises Equivalent Stress (σv\sigma_v) σv=32σh≈0.866 σh\sigma_v = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \sigma_h \approx 0.866 \, \sigma_h Cylinder capacity is 15.5%15.5\% higher under von Mises