SOM-02-01 Chapter 02 · Principal Stresses and Strains

Transformation of Plane Stress & Stresses on Oblique Planes

In this chapter (5 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Metadata & Syllabus Mapping
  2. Official Examination Syllabus Mapping
  3. 2. Introduction & Physical Mechanics
  4. The Concept of Plane Stress
  5. Why Oblique Plane Analysis is Critical in Engineering
  6. 3. Mathematical Formulations & Derivations
  7. 3.1 Equilibrium of an Oblique Triangular Wedge Element
  8. 3.2 Derivation of Normal Stress (σθ)
  9. 3.3 Derivation of Tangential Shear Stress (τθ)
  10. 3.4 Stresses on Perpendicular Plane (θ + 90°) & The First Stress Invariant (I1)
  11. 💎 The First Stress Invariant Theorem
  12. 3.5 Important Canonical Special Cases
  13. 4. Engineering Assumptions & Limitations
  14. 5. Technical Diagrams
  15. Diagram 1: Equilibrium of Oblique Wedge Element
  16. Diagram 2: Plane Stress Transformation via Coordinate Rotation
  17. 6. Solved Numerical Examples
  18. Example 1.1: General Biaxial Stress State with In-Plane Shear
  19. Example 1.2: Stresses on a Spiral Welded Pressure Vessel Seam
  20. Example 1.3: Reverse Stress Determination from Oblique Measurements
  21. 7. Practical Engineering Applications & Field Case Studies
  22. 1. Spiral Welded Steel Penstocks and Piles (IS 3589 / IS 2825)
  23. 2. Scarf and Finger Joints in Structural Timber (IS 883:1994)
  24. 3. Lüders Lines in Civil Structural Steel (IS 2062)
  25. 8. Comparison Tables
  26. Table 1: Summary of Stresses on Oblique Planes for Canonical Stress States
  27. Table 2: Plane Stress vs. Plane Strain Comparison
  28. 9. Key Engineering Facts & Exam Takeaways
  29. 10. Common Pitfalls, Traps & Anti-Patterns
  30. 11. Standards & Code Provisions
  31. IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel - Code of Practice)
  32. IS 2825 (Code for Unfired Pressure Vessels)
  33. 12. Comprehensive Formula Box & Practice Problems
  34. Master Formula Summary
  35. Practice Problems

1. Metadata & Syllabus Mapping

Attribute Specification
Topic ID SOM-02-01
Module / Subject Subject 02: Strength of Materials (notes/strength_of_materials/)
Chapter Chapter 02: Principal Stresses and Strains (02_principal_stresses_and_strains)
Target Examinations GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, RRB JE, State AE, State JE
Prerequisites SOM-01-01 (Stress and Strain), SOM-01-03 (Elastic Constants)
Primary Code References IS 800:2007 (Steel Design - Combined Stresses & Welds), IS 2825 (Unfired Pressure Vessels)
Verification Gate Level 1 through Level 7 Quality Standards

Official Examination Syllabus Mapping

Website note: this mapping is from the author’s notes. It has not been checked against the official notification for each examination; confirm the current syllabus with the examining body.

- GATE Civil Engineering: Solid Mechanics — Transformation of plane stress; stresses on inclined/oblique planes; stress invariants; pure shear transformation.
- UPSC ESE (Engineering Services): Paper-I Building Materials and Structural Analysis — Analysis of state of stress; Cauchy stress formulas; transformation of components under rotation of axes.
- SSC JE / RRB JE / State AE: Normal and tangential stresses on oblique sections; maximum shear stress planes in uniaxial tension; complementary shear stresses.

2. Introduction & Physical Mechanics

In civil engineering structures, structural members are rarely subjected to pure unidirectional tension or compression. Beams under bending experience simultaneous longitudinal normal stresses and transverse shear stresses; shafts transmit torque causing shear; and thin-walled cylindrical pipes and pressure vessels experience biaxial normal hoop and longitudinal stresses.

The Concept of Plane Stress

A solid body is in a state of Plane Stress in the xyxy-plane if the stress components perpendicular to that plane are identically zero:

σz=0,τxz=0,τyz=0(Eq. 1.1)\sigma_z = 0, \quad \tau_{xz} = 0, \quad \tau_{yz} = 0 \tag{Eq. 1.1}

Thus, the state of stress at any point is completely characterized by just three independent components:

  1. Normal stress along the xx-axis: σx\sigma_x
  2. Normal stress along the yy-axis: σy\sigma_y
  3. In-plane shear stress: τxy\tau_{xy} (with τyx=τxy\tau_{yx} = \tau_{xy} by moment equilibrium)
σ=[σxτxyτxyσy]\boldsymbol{\sigma} = \begin{bmatrix} \sigma_x & \tau_{xy} \\ \tau_{xy} & \sigma_y \end{bmatrix}

Why Oblique Plane Analysis is Critical in Engineering

Although internal stresses are originally computed on Cartesian reference planes (xx and yy), materials do not necessarily fail along the coordinate axes:

  • Ductile materials (e.g., structural mild steel) fail primarily by shear slip along planes experiencing maximum shear stress (e.g., at 45∘45^\circ to the tensile axis).
  • Brittle materials (e.g., concrete, cast iron, masonry) fail by cleavage along planes experiencing maximum principal tensile stress.
  • Fabricated connections (such as spiral welded steel pipes or glued timber scarf joints) have oriented planes of relative weakness that do not align with the global axes.

Therefore, determining the normal stress (σθ\sigma_\theta) and tangential shear stress (τθ\tau_\theta) acting across an arbitrary plane inclined at an angle θ\theta is fundamental to structural design.


3. Mathematical Formulations & Derivations

3.1 Equilibrium of an Oblique Triangular Wedge Element

Consider an infinitesimal right-triangular wedge cut from a body in plane stress:

              A (Top vertex)
             /|
            / |  Vertical face: area dAx = dA · cos θ
           /  |  Stresses: σx (normal), τxy (shear)
          /   |
         /    |
        /     |
       /______| B (Right-angle vertex)
      C
     Horizontal face: area dAy = dA · sin θ
     Stresses: σy (normal), τxy (shear)
     
     Oblique Hypotenuse Face AC:
     Area = dA
     Angle θ: measured counterclockwise from the vertical plane AB to the cut AC
     Normal vector n: makes angle θ with the positive x-axis
     Tangential vector t: parallel to the cut plane AC

Step 1: Area Relations

Let the area of the inclined oblique face ACAC be dAdA. From simple trigonometry:

  • Area of the vertical face ABAB (normal in −x-x direction): dAx=dA⋅cos⁡θ(Eq. 1.2a)dA_x = dA \cdot \cos\theta \tag{Eq. 1.2a}
  • Area of the horizontal face BCBC (normal in −y-y direction): dAy=dA⋅sin⁡θ(Eq. 1.2b)dA_y = dA \cdot \sin\theta \tag{Eq. 1.2b}

Step 2: Surface Forces Acting on Wedge Faces

Force is stress multiplied by cross-sectional area:

  • On vertical face ABAB (dAxdA_x):
    • Normal force in −x-x direction: Fnx=σx⋅dAx=σx⋅dAcos⁡θF_{nx} = \sigma_x \cdot dA_x = \sigma_x \cdot dA \cos\theta
    • Shear force in −y-y direction: Fsx=τxy⋅dAx=τxy⋅dAcos⁡θF_{sx} = \tau_{xy} \cdot dA_x = \tau_{xy} \cdot dA \cos\theta
  • On horizontal face BCBC (dAydA_y):
    • Normal force in −y-y direction: Fny=σy⋅dAy=σy⋅dAsin⁡θF_{ny} = \sigma_y \cdot dA_y = \sigma_y \cdot dA \sin\theta
    • Shear force in −x-x direction: Fsy=τxy⋅dAy=τxy⋅dAsin⁡θF_{sy} = \tau_{xy} \cdot dA_y = \tau_{xy} \cdot dA \sin\theta
  • On oblique face ACAC (dAdA):
    • Normal force along normal axis n\mathbf{n}: Fn=σθ⋅dAF_n = \sigma_\theta \cdot dA
    • Tangential force along tangential axis t\mathbf{t}: Ft=τθ⋅dAF_t = \tau_\theta \cdot dA

3.2 Derivation of Normal Stress (σθ\sigma_\theta)

Summing all forces acting on the wedge along the outward normal direction n\mathbf{n} (∑Fn=0\sum F_n = 0):

σθ⋅dA=(Fnx)cos⁡θ+(Fny)sin⁡θ+(Fsx)sin⁡θ+(Fsy)cos⁡θ\sigma_\theta \cdot dA = (F_{nx})\cos\theta + (F_{ny})\sin\theta + (F_{sx})\sin\theta + (F_{sy})\cos\theta

Substitute the force expressions:

σθ⋅dA=(σxdAcos⁡θ)cos⁡θ+(σydAsin⁡θ)sin⁡θ+(τxydAcos⁡θ)sin⁡θ+(τxydAsin⁡θ)cos⁡θ\sigma_\theta \cdot dA = (\sigma_x dA \cos\theta)\cos\theta + (\sigma_y dA \sin\theta)\sin\theta + (\tau_{xy} dA \cos\theta)\sin\theta + (\tau_{xy} dA \sin\theta)\cos\theta

Cancel dAdA throughout:

σθ=σxcos⁡2θ+σysin⁡2θ+2τxysin⁡θcos⁡θ(Eq. 1.3)\sigma_\theta = \sigma_x \cos^2\theta + \sigma_y \sin^2\theta + 2\tau_{xy} \sin\theta \cos\theta \tag{Eq. 1.3}

Using trigonometric double-angle identities:

cos⁡2θ=1+cos⁡2θ2,sin⁡2θ=1−cos⁡2θ2,2sin⁡θcos⁡θ=sin⁡2θ\cos^2\theta = \frac{1 + \cos 2\theta}{2}, \quad \sin^2\theta = \frac{1 - \cos 2\theta}{2}, \quad 2\sin\theta\cos\theta = \sin 2\theta σθ=σx(1+cos⁡2θ2)+σy(1−cos⁡2θ2)+τxysin⁡2θ\sigma_\theta = \sigma_x \left(\frac{1 + \cos 2\theta}{2}\right) + \sigma_y \left(\frac{1 - \cos 2\theta}{2}\right) + \tau_{xy} \sin 2\theta

Rearranging into average stress and deviatoric stress terms:

σθ=(σx+σy2)+(σx−σy2)cos⁡2θ+τxysin⁡2θ(Eq. 1.4)\mathbf{\sigma_\theta = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) + \left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\cos 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta} \tag{Eq. 1.4}

3.3 Derivation of Tangential Shear Stress (τθ\tau_\theta)

Summing forces along the tangential direction t\mathbf{t} (∑Ft=0\sum F_t = 0), taking positive t\mathbf{t} in the direction of increasing θ\theta:

τθ⋅dA=−(Fnx)sin⁡θ+(Fny)cos⁡θ+(Fsx)cos⁡θ−(Fsy)sin⁡θ\tau_\theta \cdot dA = -(F_{nx})\sin\theta + (F_{ny})\cos\theta + (F_{sx})\cos\theta - (F_{sy})\sin\theta

Substitute forces:

τθ⋅dA=−(σxdAcos⁡θ)sin⁡θ+(σydAsin⁡θ)cos⁡θ+(τxydAcos⁡θ)cos⁡θ−(τxydAsin⁡θ)sin⁡θ\tau_\theta \cdot dA = -(\sigma_x dA \cos\theta)\sin\theta + (\sigma_y dA \sin\theta)\cos\theta + (\tau_{xy} dA \cos\theta)\cos\theta - (\tau_{xy} dA \sin\theta)\sin\theta

Cancel dAdA throughout:

τθ=−(σx−σy)sin⁡θcos⁡θ+τxy(cos⁡2θ−sin⁡2θ)(Eq. 1.5)\tau_\theta = -(\sigma_x - \sigma_y)\sin\theta\cos\theta + \tau_{xy}(\cos^2\theta - \sin^2\theta) \tag{Eq. 1.5}

Using identities sin⁡θcos⁡θ=12sin⁡2θ\sin\theta\cos\theta = \frac{1}{2}\sin 2\theta and cos⁡2θ−sin⁡2θ=cos⁡2θ\cos^2\theta - \sin^2\theta = \cos 2\theta:

τθ=−(σx−σy2)sin⁡2θ+τxycos⁡2θ(Eq. 1.6)\mathbf{\tau_\theta = -\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\sin 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\cos 2\theta} \tag{Eq. 1.6}

3.4 Stresses on Perpendicular Plane (θ+90∘\theta + 90^\circ) & The First Stress Invariant (I1I_1)

Consider the plane mutually perpendicular to the oblique cut, oriented at θ′=θ+90∘\theta' = \theta + 90^\circ:

  • 2θ′=2θ+180∘2\theta' = 2\theta + 180^\circ
  • cos⁡(2θ+180∘)=−cos⁡2θ\cos(2\theta + 180^\circ) = -\cos 2\theta
  • sin⁡(2θ+180∘)=−sin⁡2θ\sin(2\theta + 180^\circ) = -\sin 2\theta

Substituting into Eq. (1.4):

σθ+90∘=(σx+σy2)−(σx−σy2)cos⁡2θ−τxysin⁡2θ(Eq. 1.7)\sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) - \left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\cos 2\theta - \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta \tag{Eq. 1.7}

Now, add Eq. (1.4) and Eq. (1.7):

σθ+σθ+90∘=2(σx+σy2)=σx+σy\sigma_\theta + \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = 2 \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) = \sigma_x + \sigma_y

💎 The First Stress Invariant Theorem

For any state of plane stress, the sum of normal stresses on any two mutually perpendicular planes is a constant, independent of the orientation angle θ\theta:

I1=σθ+σθ+90∘=σx+σy=Constant(Eq. 1.8)\mathbf{I_1 = \sigma_\theta + \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \sigma_x + \sigma_y = \text{Constant}} \tag{Eq. 1.8}

Furthermore, substituting θ′=θ+90∘\theta' = \theta + 90^\circ into the shear stress equation Eq. (1.6):

τθ+90∘=−(σx−σy2)sin⁡(2θ+180∘)+τxycos⁡(2θ+180∘)=−τθ(Eq. 1.9)\tau_{\theta+90^\circ} = -\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\sin(2\theta + 180^\circ) + \tau_{xy}\cos(2\theta + 180^\circ) = -\tau_\theta \tag{Eq. 1.9}

This confirms the complementary nature of shear stresses on perpendicular planes.


3.5 Important Canonical Special Cases

Case I: Pure Uniaxial Tension (σx=σ,σy=0,τxy=0\sigma_x = \sigma, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = 0)

σθ=σcos⁡2θ=σ2(1+cos⁡2θ)(Eq. 1.10)\mathbf{\sigma_\theta = \sigma \cos^2\theta = \frac{\sigma}{2}(1 + \cos 2\theta)} \tag{Eq. 1.10} τθ=−σ2sin⁡2θ(Eq. 1.11)\mathbf{\tau_\theta = -\frac{\sigma}{2}\sin 2\theta} \tag{Eq. 1.11}
  • At θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ (vertical plane): σθ=σ\sigma_\theta = \sigma, τθ=0\tau_\theta = 0.
  • At θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ (horizontal plane): σθ=0\sigma_\theta = 0, τθ=0\tau_\theta = 0.
  • At θ=±45∘\theta = \pm 45^\circ: σ45∘=σ2\sigma_{45^\circ} = \frac{\sigma}{2} τmax⁡=∣τ45∘∣=σ2(Eq. 1.12)\tau_{\max} = |\tau_{45^\circ}| = \frac{\sigma}{2} \tag{Eq. 1.12}

    Physical Engineering Fact: In a standard tensile test of mild steel, the maximum shear stress develops on planes inclined at 45∘45^\circ to the tensile load axis. Since ductile metals yield by slip of atomic planes along maximum shear planes, yielding begins along visible 45∘45^\circ bands (Lüders Bands), resulting in the classic Cup-and-Cone ductile fracture.

Case II: Biaxial Hydrostatic / Equal Tension (σx=σy=σ,τxy=0\sigma_x = \sigma_y = \sigma, \tau_{xy} = 0)

σθ=(σ+σ2)+(σ−σ2)cos⁡2θ+0=σ\sigma_\theta = \left(\frac{\sigma + \sigma}{2}\right) + \left(\frac{\sigma - \sigma}{2}\right)\cos 2\theta + 0 = \mathbf{\sigma} τθ=−(σ−σ2)sin⁡2θ+0=0\tau_\theta = -\left(\frac{\sigma - \sigma}{2}\right)\sin 2\theta + 0 = \mathbf{0}

Observation: When normal stresses in two perpendicular directions are equal and shear is zero, every plane is subjected to the same normal stress σ\sigma and zero shear stress! The state of stress is completely isotropic in-plane.

Case III: Pure Shear (σx=0,σy=0,τxy=τ\sigma_x = 0, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = \tau)

σθ=τsin⁡2θ(Eq. 1.13)\mathbf{\sigma_\theta = \tau \sin 2\theta} \tag{Eq. 1.13} τθ=τcos⁡2θ(Eq. 1.14)\mathbf{\tau_\theta = \tau \cos 2\theta} \tag{Eq. 1.14}
  • At θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ: σ45∘=+τ\sigma_{45^\circ} = +\tau (Maximum tensile normal stress), τ45∘=0\tau_{45^\circ} = 0.
  • At θ=135∘\theta = 135^\circ (or −45∘-45^\circ): σ135∘=−τ\sigma_{135^\circ} = -\tau (Maximum compressive normal stress), τ135∘=0\tau_{135^\circ} = 0.

Physical Engineering Fact: Pure shear is completely equivalent to equal biaxial tension and compression acting at 45∘45^\circ! When a piece of brittle chalk or a cast-iron circular bar is twisted to failure in torsion (pure shear), it fractures along a crisp 45∘45^\circ helical surface because brittle materials are weakest in tension.


4. Engineering Assumptions & Limitations

  1. Continuum Element: The triangular wedge is differential (dA→0dA \to 0), ensuring stress gradients across the face vanish and the stress state is homogeneous throughout the wedge.
  2. Plane Stress State: The through-thickness stress σz\sigma_z and out-of-plane shear stresses τxz,τyz\tau_{xz}, \tau_{yz} are zero. This strictly holds for thin plates, sheets, and thin-walled hollow shells without out-of-plane surface traction.
  3. Equilibrium in Undeformed State: Displacements and rotations under load are small such that the geometry of the triangle does not distort significantly prior to equilibrium analysis.
  4. Sign Convention Consistency: The derivation assumes θ\theta is measured counterclockwise from the vertical plane (x=constantx = \text{constant}). If an examination problem defines θ\theta from the horizontal plane or longitudinal axis, θ\theta must be replaced by (90∘−θ)(90^\circ - \theta).

5. Technical Diagrams

Diagram 1: Equilibrium of Oblique Wedge Element

The following vector diagram details the wedge geometry, differential area components, and force equilibrium along normal (n\mathbf{n}) and tangential (t\mathbf{t}) axes.

Oblique Plane Stress Wedge Element

Diagram 2: Plane Stress Transformation via Coordinate Rotation

The diagram below shows the transformation from reference axes (x,y)(x, y) to rotated axes (x′,y′)(x', y') by counterclockwise angle θ\theta, illustrating the stress components and the invariant trace property.

Plane Stress Transformation Coordinate Rotation

6. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 1.1: General Biaxial Stress State with In-Plane Shear

At a critical point in a structural steel web of an I-girder, the state of plane stress consists of:

  • Tensile stress along horizontal axis: σx=+100 MPa\sigma_x = +100\text{ MPa}
  • Compressive stress along vertical axis: σy=−40 MPa\sigma_y = -40\text{ MPa}
  • Shear stress: τxy=+40 MPa\tau_{xy} = +40\text{ MPa}

Determine:

  1. The normal and shear stresses acting on an oblique plane inclined at θ=30∘\theta = 30^\circ counterclockwise to the vertical plane.
  2. The normal stress on the plane perpendicular to the oblique plane (θ+90∘=120∘\theta + 90^\circ = 120^\circ).
  3. Verify the First Stress Invariant (I1I_1).
Given:
σx = +100 MPa
σy = -40 MPa
τxy = +40 MPa
θ = 30° (counterclockwise from vertical plane) ==> 2θ = 60°

Solution:

Step 1: Compute Average and Half-Difference Stresses

σavg=σx+σy2=100+(−40)2=602=+30 MPa\sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} = \frac{100 + (-40)}{2} = \frac{60}{2} = +30\text{ MPa} σdiff=σx−σy2=100−(−40)2=1402=+70 MPa\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2} = \frac{100 - (-40)}{2} = \frac{140}{2} = +70\text{ MPa}

Step 2: Trigonometric Terms for 2θ=60∘2\theta = 60^\circ

cos⁡60∘=0.5000\cos 60^\circ = 0.5000 sin⁡60∘=32≈0.8660\sin 60^\circ = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \approx 0.8660

Step 3: Normal Stress on Oblique Plane (σθ\sigma_\theta)

σθ=σavg+σdiffcos⁡2θ+τxysin⁡2θ\sigma_\theta = \sigma_{\text{avg}} + \sigma_{\text{diff}}\cos 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta σθ=30+(70×0.5000)+(40×0.8660)\sigma_\theta = 30 + (70 \times 0.5000) + (40 \times 0.8660) σθ=30+35.00+34.64=+99.64 MPa(Tensile)\sigma_\theta = 30 + 35.00 + 34.64 = \mathbf{+99.64\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Tensile})}

Step 4: Shear Stress on Oblique Plane (τθ\tau_\theta)

τθ=−σdiffsin⁡2θ+τxycos⁡2θ\tau_\theta = -\sigma_{\text{diff}}\sin 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\cos 2\theta τθ=−(70×0.8660)+(40×0.5000)\tau_\theta = -(70 \times 0.8660) + (40 \times 0.5000) τθ=−60.62+20.00=−40.62 MPa\tau_\theta = -60.62 + 20.00 = \mathbf{-40.62\text{ MPa}}

(The negative sign indicates the shear stress acts opposite to the positive tangential direction t\mathbf{t}.)

Step 5: Normal Stress on Perpendicular Plane (θ′=120∘\theta' = 120^\circ)

σθ+90∘=σavg−σdiffcos⁡2θ−τxysin⁡2θ\sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \sigma_{\text{avg}} - \sigma_{\text{diff}}\cos 2\theta - \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta σ120∘=30−35.00−34.64=−39.64 MPa(Compressive)\sigma_{120^\circ} = 30 - 35.00 - 34.64 = \mathbf{-39.64\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Compressive})}

Step 6: Invariant Verification

I1=σθ+σθ+90∘=99.641+(−39.641)=60.00 MPaI_1 = \sigma_\theta + \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = 99.641 + (-39.641) = \mathbf{60.00\text{ MPa}} σx+σy=100+(−40)=60.00 MPa✓(Exact match!)\sigma_x + \sigma_y = 100 + (-40) = \mathbf{60.00\text{ MPa}} \quad \checkmark \quad (\text{Exact match!})

Example 1.2: Stresses on a Spiral Welded Pressure Vessel Seam

A thin-walled cylindrical penstock of 1.5 m1.5\text{ m} diameter is fabricated from steel plate by welding along a spiral seam. Under service internal water pressure:

  • Circumferential hoop stress: σhoop=σy=120 MPa\sigma_{\text{hoop}} = \sigma_y = 120\text{ MPa} (Tension)
  • Longitudinal axial stress: σlong=σx=60 MPa\sigma_{\text{long}} = \sigma_x = 60\text{ MPa} (Tension)
  • Shear stress on axial/circumferential planes: τxy=0\tau_{xy} = 0

The spiral weld seam makes an angle θ=25∘\theta = 25^\circ with the transverse (vertical) section of the cylinder.
Calculate the normal stress and shear stress acting across the weld seam.

Given:
σx = 60 MPa (longitudinal)
σy = 120 MPa (circumferential)
τxy = 0
θ = 25° ==> 2θ = 50°

Solution:

Step 1: Stresses and Trigonometry

σavg=60+1202=90 MPa\sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{60 + 120}{2} = 90\text{ MPa} σdiff=60−1202=−30 MPa\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \frac{60 - 120}{2} = -30\text{ MPa} cos⁡50∘≈0.6428,sin⁡50∘≈0.7660\cos 50^\circ \approx 0.6428, \quad \sin 50^\circ \approx 0.7660

Step 2: Normal Stress on the Weld Seam (σweld\sigma_{\text{weld}})

σweld=σavg+σdiffcos⁡2θ+τxysin⁡2θ\sigma_{\text{weld}} = \sigma_{\text{avg}} + \sigma_{\text{diff}}\cos 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta σweld=90+(−30×0.6428)+0=90−19.28=70.72 MPa(Tensile)\sigma_{\text{weld}} = 90 + (-30 \times 0.6428) + 0 = 90 - 19.28 = \mathbf{70.72\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Tensile})}

Step 3: Shear Stress on the Weld Seam (τweld\tau_{\text{weld}})

τweld=−σdiffsin⁡2θ+τxycos⁡2θ\tau_{\text{weld}} = -\sigma_{\text{diff}}\sin 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\cos 2\theta τweld=−(−30×0.7660)+0=+22.98 MPa\tau_{\text{weld}} = -(-30 \times 0.7660) + 0 = \mathbf{+22.98\text{ MPa}}

Civil Engineering Insight: Notice that the normal tensile stress acting across the spiral weld (70.72 MPa70.72\text{ MPa}) is 41% lower than the maximum hoop stress (120 MPa120\text{ MPa}) that would act across a straight longitudinal weld! This is precisely why high-pressure penstocks, spiral piles, and gas pipelines are manufactured using helical/spiral welding.


Example 1.3: Reverse Stress Determination from Oblique Measurements

During field strain gauge monitoring of a bridge gusset plate:

  • On the vertical plane (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ): Normal stress is σx=+80 MPa\sigma_x = +80\text{ MPa} and shear stress is τxy=+30 MPa\tau_{xy} = +30\text{ MPa}.
  • On a plane inclined at θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ counterclockwise to the vertical plane, the normal stress is measured as σ45∘=+90 MPa\sigma_{45^\circ} = +90\text{ MPa}.

Determine:

  1. The normal stress acting on the horizontal plane (σy\sigma_y).
  2. The shear stress acting on the 45∘45^\circ plane.
Given:
σx = 80 MPa
τxy = 30 MPa
σ_45° = 90 MPa at θ = 45°

Solution:

Step 1: Apply Transformation Equation at θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ
For θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ, 2θ=90∘2\theta = 90^\circ:

cos⁡90∘=0,sin⁡90∘=1\cos 90^\circ = 0, \quad \sin 90^\circ = 1

Substitute into Eq. (1.4):

σ45∘=(σx+σy2)+(σx−σy2)cos⁡90∘+τxysin⁡90∘\sigma_{45^\circ} = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) + \left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\cos 90^\circ + \tau_{xy}\sin 90^\circ σ45∘=(σx+σy2)+0+τxy(1)=σx+σy2+τxy\sigma_{45^\circ} = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) + 0 + \tau_{xy}(1) = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} + \tau_{xy}

Step 2: Solve for σy\sigma_y

90=80+σy2+3090 = \frac{80 + \sigma_y}{2} + 30 90−30=80+σy2  ⟹  60=80+σy290 - 30 = \frac{80 + \sigma_y}{2} \implies 60 = \frac{80 + \sigma_y}{2} 80+σy=120  ⟹  σy=+40 MPa(Tensile)80 + \sigma_y = 120 \implies \mathbf{\sigma_y = +40\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Tensile})}

Step 3: Shear Stress on 45∘45^\circ Plane (τ45∘\tau_{45^\circ})

τ45∘=−(σx−σy2)sin⁡90∘+τxycos⁡90∘\tau_{45^\circ} = -\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\sin 90^\circ + \tau_{xy}\cos 90^\circ τ45∘=−(80−402)(1)+30(0)=−(402)=−20 MPa\tau_{45^\circ} = -\left(\frac{80 - 40}{2}\right)(1) + 30(0) = -\left(\frac{40}{2}\right) = \mathbf{-20\text{ MPa}}

7. Practical Engineering Applications & Field Case Studies

1. Spiral Welded Steel Penstocks and Piles (IS 3589 / IS 2825)

In water supply mains and hydroelectric penstocks, the internal fluid pressure produces hoop stress σh=pD2t\sigma_h = \frac{p D}{2t} and longitudinal stress σL=pD4t=12σh\sigma_L = \frac{p D}{4t} = \frac{1}{2}\sigma_h. If a longitudinal straight seam weld were used, the weld would have to carry 100% of the peak hoop stress σh\sigma_h. By winding the steel plate into a spiral at an angle θ≈30∘\theta \approx 30^\circ, the normal stress on the weld seam drops to σweld=σh(cos⁡230∘+0.5sin⁡230∘)=0.875σh\sigma_{\text{weld}} = \sigma_h(\cos^2 30^\circ + 0.5\sin^2 30^\circ) = 0.875 \sigma_h, significantly reducing the risk of catastrophic seam split.

2. Scarf and Finger Joints in Structural Timber (IS 883:1994)

Wood has high tensile strength parallel to the grain (ft∥≈15 to 20 MPaf_{t\parallel} \approx 15 \text{ to } 20\text{ MPa}) but very low shear strength (fv≈1.5 to 2.5 MPaf_v \approx 1.5 \text{ to } 2.5\text{ MPa}) and negligible tensile strength perpendicular to grain. When splicing timber beams, butt joints fail. Engineers use inclined scarf joints inclined at slope 1:81:8 or 1:121:12 (θ≈5∘ to 7∘\theta \approx 5^\circ \text{ to } 7^\circ). The transformation equations ensure that the normal tensile stress perpendicular to the glue line and shear along the glue line remain well below adhesive capacities.

3. Lüders Lines in Civil Structural Steel (IS 2062)

When structural steel yield plates undergo monotonic tension, diagonal striations appear on the mill scale at an angle of roughly 45∘45^\circ to the load axis. This is a direct physical manifestation of Eq. (1.12): τmax⁡=σ/2\tau_{\max} = \sigma/2 occurs at θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ. Because iron crystal lattices slip through dislocation movement on planes of maximum shear, yield initiation always follows these 45∘45^\circ paths.


8. Comparison Tables

Table 1: Summary of Stresses on Oblique Planes for Canonical Stress States

Stress State Given Stresses Normal Stress σθ\sigma_\theta Shear Stress τθ\tau_\theta Maximum Shear τmax⁡\tau_{\max}
Uniaxial Tension σx=σ,σy=0,τxy=0\sigma_x = \sigma, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = 0 σcos⁡2θ\sigma \cos^2\theta −σ2sin⁡2θ-\frac{\sigma}{2}\sin 2\theta σ2\frac{\sigma}{2} at θ=±45∘\theta = \pm 45^\circ
Uniaxial Compression σx=−σ,σy=0,τxy=0\sigma_x = -\sigma, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = 0 −σcos⁡2θ-\sigma \cos^2\theta +σ2sin⁡2θ+\frac{\sigma}{2}\sin 2\theta σ2\frac{\sigma}{2} at θ=±45∘\theta = \pm 45^\circ
Pure Shear σx=0,σy=0,τxy=τ\sigma_x = 0, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = \tau τsin⁡2θ\tau \sin 2\theta τcos⁡2θ\tau \cos 2\theta τ\tau at θ=0∘,90∘\theta = 0^\circ, 90^\circ
Equal Biaxial Tension σx=σy=σ,τxy=0\sigma_x = \sigma_y = \sigma, \tau_{xy} = 0 σ\sigma (Constant) 00 (Zero everywhere) Zero on all planes
Equal & Opposite Biaxial σx=+σ,σy=−σ,τxy=0\sigma_x = +\sigma, \sigma_y = -\sigma, \tau_{xy} = 0 σcos⁡2θ\sigma \cos 2\theta −σsin⁡2θ-\sigma \sin 2\theta σ\sigma at θ=±45∘\theta = \pm 45^\circ

Table 2: Plane Stress vs. Plane Strain Comparison

Feature Plane Stress State (σz=0\sigma_z = 0) Plane Strain State (ϵz=0\epsilon_z = 0)
Physical Geometry Thin plates, thin shells, web plates Thick bodies, long retaining walls, gravity dams, tunnels
Out-of-Plane Stress σz=0\sigma_z = 0 σz=ν(σx+σy)≠0\sigma_z = \nu(\sigma_x + \sigma_y) \ne 0
Out-of-Plane Strain ϵz=−νE(σx+σy)≠0\epsilon_z = -\frac{\nu}{E}(\sigma_x + \sigma_y) \ne 0 ϵz=0\epsilon_z = 0
Stress Transformation Identical in-plane formulas apply Identical in-plane formulas apply

9. Key Engineering Facts & Exam Takeaways

  1. Sum of Normal Stresses is Constant: On any two planes at 90∘90^\circ to each other, σθ+σθ+90∘=σx+σy\sigma_\theta + \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \sigma_x + \sigma_y. If you know σx,σy\sigma_x, \sigma_y, and σθ\sigma_\theta, you can immediately find σθ+90∘\sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} without using trigonometry!
  2. Pure Shear on 45∘45^\circ Planes: In pure uniaxial tension σ\sigma, the shear stress on the 45∘45^\circ plane is τ=σ/2\tau = \sigma/2, and the normal stress on that same plane is also σ/2\sigma/2.
  3. Pure Shear Principal Tension: In a state of pure shear τ\tau, the maximum tensile normal stress is equal to +τ+\tau and occurs at θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ.
  4. Isotropic State: For σx=σy\sigma_x = \sigma_y and τxy=0\tau_{xy} = 0, shear stress is zero on all planes. Mohr's circle degenerates into a single point on the σ\sigma-axis.
  5. Angle Doubling: In all transformation equations, the physical angle θ\theta appears doubled as 2θ2\theta. A rotation of 90∘90^\circ in real physical space corresponds to 180∘180^\circ in the equations.

10. Common Pitfalls, Traps & Anti-Patterns

  • Trap 1 (Reference Plane Angle Confusion): Measuring θ\theta from the horizontal axis instead of the vertical plane. If an exam problem states: "a plane inclined at 30∘30^\circ to the horizontal", then its angle with the vertical is θ=90∘−30∘=60∘\theta = 90^\circ - 30^\circ = 60^\circ! Always sketch the wedge normal.
  • Trap 2 (Sign of Shear Stress τθ\tau_\theta): Forgetting the negative sign in the first term of τθ=−σx−σy2sin⁡2θ+τxycos⁡2θ\tau_\theta = -\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\sin 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\cos 2\theta.
  • Trap 3 (Sign of Given σy\sigma_y): When σy\sigma_y is compressive, substituting a positive value. If σy=40 MPa (compressive)\sigma_y = 40\text{ MPa (compressive)}, then σy=−40 MPa\sigma_y = -40\text{ MPa}, which turns (σx−σy)(\sigma_x - \sigma_y) into (100−(−40))=140 MPa(100 - (-40)) = 140\text{ MPa}!
  • Trap 4 (Confusing Stress with Force on Oblique Plane): Adding stresses directly instead of multiplying by area components (dAcos⁡θ,dAsin⁡θdA \cos\theta, dA \sin\theta). Stresses are tensor quantities and cannot be resolved as vector forces without accounting for differential face areas.

11. Standards & Code Provisions

IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel - Code of Practice)

  • Clause 10.5.10 (Combined Stresses in Welds):
    Where butt or fillet welds are subject to combined normal stress (σ\sigma) and shear stress (τ\tau), the equivalent equivalent stress shall not exceed the design strength: fe=σ2+3τ2≤fu3γmwf_e = \sqrt{\sigma^2 + 3\tau^2} \le \frac{f_u}{\sqrt{3}\gamma_{mw}}
  • Clause 10.5.7 (Design of Oblique Fillet Welds):
    Fillet welds loaded obliquely to their longitudinal axis must be proportioned using the effective throat area and resolved vector components.

IS 2825 (Code for Unfired Pressure Vessels)

  • Allows a reduced joint efficiency factor (J=1.0J = 1.0) for spiral submerged-arc welded seams compared to longitudinal seams (J=0.85J = 0.85), exploiting the lower normal stress on the inclined weld seam.

12. Comprehensive Formula Box & Practice Problems

Master Formula Summary

QuantityAnalytical FormulationNormal Stress on Oblique Plane θσθ=(σx+σy2)+(σx−σy2)cos⁡2θ+τxysin⁡2θShear Stress on Oblique Plane θτθ=−(σx−σy2)sin⁡2θ+τxycos⁡2θPerpendicular Plane Normal Stressσθ+90∘=(σx+σy2)−(σx−σy2)cos⁡2θ−τxysin⁡2θFirst Stress InvariantI1=σθ+σθ+90∘=σx+σy=ConstantUniaxial Tension: Normal Stressσθ=σcos⁡2θ=σ2(1+cos⁡2θ)Uniaxial Tension: Shear Stressτθ=−σ2sin⁡2θUniaxial Tension: Max Shear Stressτmax⁡=σ2at θ=±45∘Pure Shear: Oblique Normal Stressσθ=τsin⁡2θPure Shear: Oblique Shear Stressτθ=τcos⁡2θ\begin{array}{|l|l|} \hline \textbf{Quantity} & \textbf{Analytical Formulation} \\ \hline \text{Normal Stress on Oblique Plane } \theta & \sigma_\theta = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) + \left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\cos 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta \\ \hline \text{Shear Stress on Oblique Plane } \theta & \tau_\theta = -\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\sin 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\cos 2\theta \\ \hline \text{Perpendicular Plane Normal Stress} & \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \left(\frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2}\right) - \left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)\cos 2\theta - \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta \\ \hline \text{First Stress Invariant} & I_1 = \sigma_\theta + \sigma_{\theta+90^\circ} = \sigma_x + \sigma_y = \text{Constant} \\ \hline \text{Uniaxial Tension: Normal Stress} & \sigma_\theta = \sigma \cos^2\theta = \frac{\sigma}{2}(1 + \cos 2\theta) \\ \hline \text{Uniaxial Tension: Shear Stress} & \tau_\theta = -\frac{\sigma}{2}\sin 2\theta \\ \hline \text{Uniaxial Tension: Max Shear Stress} & \tau_{\max} = \frac{\sigma}{2} \quad \text{at } \theta = \pm 45^\circ \\ \hline \text{Pure Shear: Oblique Normal Stress} & \sigma_\theta = \tau \sin 2\theta \\ \hline \text{Pure Shear: Oblique Shear Stress} & \tau_\theta = \tau \cos 2\theta \\ \hline \end{array}

Practice Problems

  1. Problem 1 (GATE CE Objective):
    A prismatic bar is subjected to pure uniaxial tensile stress σ\sigma. The plane across which the normal stress and shear stress are equal in magnitude is inclined to the tensile axis at an angle of:
    Answer: 45∘45^\circ
    Explanation: σθ=σcos⁡2θ\sigma_\theta = \sigma \cos^2\theta and ∣τθ∣=σsin⁡θcos⁡θ|\tau_\theta| = \sigma \sin\theta\cos\theta. Equating: σcos⁡2θ=σsin⁡θcos⁡θ  ⟹  cos⁡θ=sin⁡θ  ⟹  tan⁡θ=1  ⟹  θ=45∘\sigma \cos^2\theta = \sigma \sin\theta\cos\theta \implies \cos\theta = \sin\theta \implies \tan\theta = 1 \implies \theta = 45^\circ.

  2. Problem 2 (SSC JE Objective):
    At a point in a strained material, the normal stresses on two mutually perpendicular planes are 80 N/mm280\text{ N/mm}^2 (tensile) and 20 N/mm220\text{ N/mm}^2 (compressive). What is the sum of normal stresses on any other pair of mutually perpendicular planes?
    Answer: 60 N/mm260\text{ N/mm}^2
    Explanation: By the first stress invariant I1=σx+σy=80+(−20)=60 N/mm2I_1 = \sigma_x + \sigma_y = 80 + (-20) = 60\text{ N/mm}^2.

  3. Problem 3 (UPSC ESE Style):
    A state of pure shear stress τ=50 MPa\tau = 50\text{ MPa} acts on an element. The normal stress on a plane inclined at 45∘45^\circ to the shear plane is:
    Answer: +50 MPa+50\text{ MPa} (Tensile)
    Explanation: σ45∘=τsin⁡(2×45∘)=τsin⁡90∘=+50 MPa\sigma_{45^\circ} = \tau \sin(2 \times 45^\circ) = \tau \sin 90^\circ = +50\text{ MPa}.

  4. Problem 4 (State AE Objective):
    A wooden tie member is spliced using a glued scarf joint inclined at 30∘30^\circ to the longitudinal axis. If the member carries a tensile stress of 12 MPa12\text{ MPa}, the shear stress acting along the glue line is:
    Answer: 5.20 MPa5.20\text{ MPa}
    Explanation: Angle of cut to the vertical cross section is θ=90∘−30∘=60∘\theta = 90^\circ - 30^\circ = 60^\circ. ∣τθ∣=σ2sin⁡(2×60∘)=122sin⁡120∘=6×32=33≈5.196 MPa≈5.20 MPa|\tau_\theta| = \frac{\sigma}{2}\sin(2 \times 60^\circ) = \frac{12}{2}\sin 120^\circ = 6 \times \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} = 3\sqrt{3} \approx 5.196\text{ MPa} \approx 5.20\text{ MPa}.

  5. Problem 5 (GATE CE Numerical Answer Type):
    In a plane stress problem, σx=60 MPa\sigma_x = 60\text{ MPa}, σy=−20 MPa\sigma_y = -20\text{ MPa}, and τxy=30 MPa\tau_{xy} = 30\text{ MPa}. The normal stress on a plane inclined at θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ counterclockwise to the vertical plane is ______ MPa\_\_\_\_\_\_\text{ MPa}.
    Answer: 50 MPa50\text{ MPa}
    Explanation: σ45∘=σx+σy2+τxy=60+(−20)2+30=20+30=50 MPa\sigma_{45^\circ} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} + \tau_{xy} = \frac{60 + (-20)}{2} + 30 = 20 + 30 = 50\text{ MPa}.