Subject 02: Strength of Materials (notes/strength_of_materials/)
Chapter
Chapter 02: Principal Stresses and Strains (02_principal_stresses_and_strains)
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, RRB JE, State AE, State JE
Prerequisites
SOM-01-01 (Stress and Strain), SOM-02-01 (Stress Transformation on Oblique Planes)
Primary Code References
IS 456:2000 (Shear and Diagonal Tension in Concrete), IS 800:2007 (Combined Bending & Torsion in Steel), IS 2825
Verification Gate
Level 1 through Level 7 Quality Standards
Official Examination Syllabus Mapping
Website note: this mapping is from the author’s notes. It has not been checked against the official notification for each examination; confirm the current syllabus with the examining body.
- GATE Civil Engineering: Solid Mechanics — Principal stresses and principal planes; maximum shear stress; in-plane vs absolute maximum shear; combined bending and torsion in shafts.
- UPSC ESE (Engineering Services): Paper-I Building Materials and Structural Analysis — Determination of principal stresses and planes; orientation of maximum shear planes; 3D stress states.
- SSC JE / RRB JE / State AE: Principal planes; zero shear stress planes; major and minor principal stresses; equivalent bending moment and equivalent twisting moment.
2. Introduction & Physical Mechanics
In any general state of plane stress, the normal stress (σθ) and shear stress (τθ) acting across an internal cut vary continuously as the inclination angle θ is rotated through 360∘.
For structural engineers designing safety-critical components (such as concrete beams, steel bridge girders, drive shafts, or pressure vessels), two questions are of paramount importance:
What is the maximum normal stress developed at this point, and on which plane does it act? (Governs tensile fracture in brittle materials such as concrete, rock, and cast iron).
What is the maximum shear stress developed at this point, and on which plane does it act? (Governs plastic yielding and ductile slip in structural steel, aluminum, and soils).
Definitions
Principal Planes: Planes on which the shear stress is identically zero (τ=0).
Principal Stresses: The normal stresses acting across the principal planes. Because shear stress vanishes on these planes, the normal stresses reach their global stationary extreme values (the absolute maximum and minimum normal stresses possible at that point).
Major Principal Stress (σ1): The algebraically largest normal stress.
Minor Principal Stress (σ2): The algebraically smallest normal stress.
Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress (τmax): The maximum shear stress occurring on any plane perpendicular to the xy-plane.
3. Mathematical Formulations & Derivations
3.1 Derivation of Principal Planes (τθ=0)
From Topic SOM-02-01, the shear stress on an oblique plane inclined at angle θ counterclockwise from the vertical plane is:
τθ=−(2σx−σy)sin2θ+τxycos2θ(Eq. 2.1)
By definition, on a principal plane (θ=θp), the shear stress must vanish:
Fundamental Theorem: At every point in a continuous body, there exist two mutually perpendicular principal planes on which the shear stress is identically zero.
To find the orientations θ where σθ reaches its stationary extremes (maximum or minimum), differentiate with respect to θ and equate to zero:
dθdσθ=−2(2σx−σy)sin2θ+2τxycos2θ=0
Dividing by 2:
−(2σx−σy)sin2θ+τxycos2θ=0
Comparing this expression directly with Eq. (2.1), we observe that:
dθdσθ=2τθ=0⟹τθ=0(Eq. 2.5)
⭐ The Stationary Stress Theorem
The planes of maximum and minimum normal stress are identical to the planes of zero shear stress (the principal planes)! Normal stresses reach their absolute extremes precisely where shear vanishes.
3.3 Derivation of Principal Stress Magnitudes (σ1,σ2)
From Eq. (2.2), we construct a reference right triangle with opposite side τxy and adjacent side 2σx−σy:
Hypotenuse R=(2σx−σy)2+τxy2(Eq. 2.6)
The trigonometric values for 2θp are:
cos2θp=±R2σx−σy,sin2θp=±Rτxy(Eq. 2.7)
Substitute these into the normal stress equation Eq. (2.4):
Notice that the last two terms are identically equal to τθp=0!
Therefore:
σs=σavg=2σx+σy=2σ1+σ2(Eq. 2.15)
⚠️ Critical Engineering Takeaway
The normal stress on the planes of maximum shear stress is NOT ZERO! It is equal to the average normal stress (σavg) acting uniformly on all four faces of the maximum shear element.
3.5 In-Plane vs. Absolute 3D Maximum Shear Stress (τabs, max)
In a state of 2D plane stress, the out-of-plane stress components are zero:
σ3=0(Eq. 2.16)
Thus, at any point in a plane stress body, the three 3D principal stresses are:
σI=σ1,σII=σ2,σIII=σ3=0
From 3D Mohr's circle analysis, the true maximum shear stress acting on any oblique plane in 3D space is:
(The true maximum shear stress occurs on an out-of-plane plane inclined at 45∘ to the z-axis!).
Classic Competitive Exam Trap: In a thin spherical pressure vessel with biaxial tension σ1=σ2=σ, the in-plane maximum shear stress is 2σ−σ=0. However, the absolute 3D maximum shear stress is τabs, max=2σ−0=2σ!
3.6 Combined Bending and Torsion in Circular Shafts
In civil and mechanical drive shafts (e.g., turbine shafts, bascule bridge hoisting shafts, crane winch drives), a circular shaft of diameter d is subjected simultaneously to a bending moment M and a torsional twisting moment T.
Surface Stress State:
Maximum bending normal stress at outermost fibers:
σx=IMy=64πd4M(d/2)=πd332M=ZbM(Eq. 2.19)
Maximum torsional shear stress at outermost fibers:
τxy=JTr=32πd4T(d/2)=πd316T=ZpT=2ZbT(Eq. 2.20)
Continuum Differential Element: Stress distributions across the infinitesimal element are uniform, ensuring true point-stress representation.
Homogeneous, Isotropic Elastic Material: Hooke's Law holds and material response is independent of direction.
Plane Stress Boundary Conditions:σz=τxz=τyz=0. For thick solid components where plane strain or triaxial stress exists, 3D tensor equations must be employed.
Sign Convention Consistency:θp is positive counterclockwise from the vertical plane.
5. Technical Diagrams
Diagram 1: Principal Planes and Principal Stresses Element
The following vector diagram details the rotated principal stress element, the zero-shear condition on all four faces, and the orientation angle θp.
Diagram 2: Maximum In-Plane and Absolute Shear Stress Element
The vector diagram below illustrates the maximum shear stress element rotated at 45∘ to the principal planes, the accompanying average normal stress σavg, and the out-of-plane 3D shear comparison.
6. Solved Numerical Examples
Example 2.1: Principal Stresses with Opposite Signs
At a point on the surface of a crane hook subjected to combined axial tension and bending, the state of plane stress is:
σx=+80 MPa (Tension)
σy=−20 MPa (Compression)
τxy=+40 MPa
Determine:
The orientation of the principal planes (θp1,θp2).
The magnitudes of the major and minor principal stresses (σ1,σ2).
The maximum in-plane shear stress and the orientation of its planes.
The absolute 3D maximum shear stress.
Given:
σx = +80 MPa
σy = -20 MPa
τxy = +40 MPa
Solution:
Step 1: Compute Center and Radius of Mohr's Circle
Crucial Observation: Notice that both σ1 and σ2 are positive (tensile)!
Step 3: Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress
τmax,in-plane=2σ1−σ2=295−45=25.00 MPa
Step 4: Absolute 3D Maximum Shear Stress
In plane stress, the out-of-plane principal stress is σ3=0.
The three principal stresses ordered algebraically are:
Exam Trap Lesson: The true maximum shear stress (τabs, max=47.5 MPa) is 90% higher than the in-plane shear stress (τmax=25 MPa)! If an engineer designs against shear failure using τin-plane, the structure will fail under unexpected out-of-plane shear slip!
Example 2.3: Circular Shaft under Combined Bending and Torsion
A solid transmission shaft of diameter d=80 mm transmits power in a vertical lift bridge mechanism. It is subjected simultaneously to a bending moment M=3.6 kN⋅m and a twisting moment T=4.8 kN⋅m.
Find the equivalent bending moment (Me) and the major principal tensile stress.
Find the equivalent twisting moment (Te) and the maximum shear stress.
Given:
Diameter d = 80 mm
Bending Moment M = 3.6 kN·m = 3.6 × 10⁶ N·mm
Twisting Moment T = 4.8 kN·m = 4.8 × 10⁶ N·mm
7. Practical Engineering Applications & Field Case Studies
1. Diagonal Tension and Web Shear in Reinforced Concrete Beams (IS 456:2000 Cl. 40)
In an RC beam, flexural tensile stress (σx) is maximum at the bottom fibers, while shear stress (τxy) peaks at the neutral axis. Near the supports where bending moment is low but shear force V is high:
σx≈0,σy≈0⟹σ1=+τ,σ2=−τ.
Principal tensile stress σ1=+τ acts at θp=45∘ to the beam axis.
Because concrete has very weak tensile strength (fcr≈0.7fck), diagonal tension cracks open perpendicular to the 45∘ principal tensile trajectory. To bridge these cracks, vertical stirrups or 45∘ bent-up rebars are mandatory!
2. Failure Trajectories in Structural Members (Stress Trajectories)
Lines whose tangents at every point coincide with the directions of the principal stresses are called Isostatics or Stress Trajectories. In photoelasticity and finite element analysis (FEA), stress trajectories reveal the load paths:
In pure torsion of brittle materials (cast iron or chalk), failure occurs along a 45∘ helix (plane of principal tension).
In pure torsion of ductile materials (mild steel), failure occurs along a transverse 90∘ cross-section (plane of maximum shear).
3. Thin Cylindrical and Spherical Pressure Shells (IS 2825)
Cylindrical shell: Hoop stress σh=2tpD, axial stress σL=4tpD. Since shear is zero on axial and hoop planes, these are the principal planes! σ1=σh, σ2=σL.
In-plane max shear: τmax,in-plane=2σh−σL=8tpD.
Absolute 3D max shear: τabs, max=2σh−0=4tpD! (Double the in-plane shear!).
Spherical shell:σ1=σ2=4tpD.
In-plane max shear: τmax,in-plane=0.
Absolute 3D max shear: τabs, max=8tpD.
8. Comparison Tables
Table 1: Principal Planes vs. Maximum Shear Planes
Characteristic
Principal Planes
Maximum In-Plane Shear Planes
Shear Stress (τ)
Strictly Zero (τ=0)
Maximum (τmax=2σ1−σ2)
Normal Stress (σ)
Extreme values (σ1 and σ2)
Average value (σavg=2σ1+σ2=2σx+σy)
Angular Orientation
tan2θp=σx−σy2τxy
θs=θp±45∘ (tan2θs=−2τxyσx−σy)
Number of Planes
Two mutually perpendicular (90∘ apart)
Two mutually perpendicular (90∘ apart)
Failure Relevance
Brittle tensile fracture (Concrete, Cast Iron)
Ductile plastic slip (Steel, Aluminum, Soil)
Table 2: In-Plane Maximum Shear vs. Absolute 3D Maximum Shear
Stress State Condition
Major & Minor Principal Stresses
In-Plane Max Shear τmax,in-plane
Absolute 3D Max Shear τabs, max
Location of Max Shear Plane
Opposite Signs
σ1>0 and σ2<0
2σ1−σ2
2σ1−σ2
In-plane (45∘ in xy-plane)
Both Tensile
σ1>σ2>0
2σ1−σ2
2σ1
Out-of-plane (45∘ to z-axis)
Both Compressive
0>σ1>σ2
2∣σ1−σ2∣
2∣σ2∣
Out-of-plane (45∘ to z-axis)
Pure Uniaxial Tension
σ1=σ,σ2=0
2σ
2σ
Identical on multiple oblique planes
Pure Shear
σ1=+τ,σ2=−τ
τ
τ
In-plane (xy-plane)
Biaxial Equal Tension
σ1=σ2=σ
0
2σ
Purely out-of-plane
9. Key Engineering Facts & Exam Takeaways
Zero Shear on Principal Planes: The hallmark definition of a principal plane is τ=0. If shear stress exists on a plane, that plane cannot be a principal plane!
Mutual 45∘ Orientation: Principal planes and maximum shear planes are separated by exactly 45∘ in real physical space (90∘ on Mohr's circle).
Hydrostatic Normal Stress on Shear Planes: The normal stress on maximum shear planes is never zero (unless σx+σy=0). It is identically equal to σavg=2σx+σy.
Equal Biaxial In-Plane Trap: For σx=σy=σ and τxy=0, every plane in-plane has zero shear stress. The in-plane maximum shear is zero, but the absolute 3D maximum shear is σ/2!
Trap 1 (The Absolute 3D Shear Blunder): Blindly reporting τmax=2σ1−σ2 when σ1 and σ2 have the same sign. If σ1=100 MPa and σ2=60 MPa, τin-plane=20 MPa, but τabs, max=100/2=50 MPa!
Trap 2 (Assuming Zero Normal Stress on Max Shear Planes): Believing that because shear stress is zero on principal planes, normal stress must be zero on maximum shear planes. Normal stress on maximum shear planes is σavg=2σ1+σ2.
Trap 3 (Quadratic Sign Roots in θp): In computing θp=21arctan(σx−σy2τxy), confusing which angle corresponds to σ1 and which to σ2. Always plug θp back into σθ to confirm!
Trap 4 (Polar Modulus vs Bending Modulus in Shafts): Using Zb for torque or Zp for moment. For a solid circle: Zp=2Zb=16πd3, while Zb=32πd3.
11. Standards & Code Provisions
IS 456:2000 (Plain and Reinforced Concrete - Code of Practice)
Clause 40.1 (Nominal Shear Stress):τv=bdVu
Clause 40.2 (Design Shear Strength of Concrete τc):
Based on diagonal tension cracking caused by principal tensile stresses exceeding the tensile capacity of concrete.
IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel - Code of Practice)
Clause 9.3 (Combined Bending and Torsion in Steel Members):
Members subject to combined bending and twisting moments must be proportioned such that equivalent stresses comply with the von Mises yield criterion:
fe=σb2+3τt2≤γm0fy
12. Comprehensive Formula Box & Practice Problems
Master Formula Summary
QuantityOrientation of Principal PlanesMajor Principal Stress (σ1)Minor Principal Stress (σ2)Maximum In-Plane Shear Stress (τmax)Orientation of Max Shear PlanesNormal Stress on Max Shear PlanesAbsolute 3D Maximum Shear StressEquivalent Bending Moment (Shafts)Equivalent Twisting Moment (Shafts)Analytical Formulationtan2θp=σx−σy2τxyσ1=(2σx+σy)+(2σx−σy)2+τxy2σ2=(2σx+σy)−(2σx−σy)2+τxy2τmax,in-plane=2σ1−σ2=(2σx−σy)2+τxy2θs=θp±45∘⟹tan2θs=−2τxyσx−σyσs=σavg=2σx+σy=2σ1+σ2τabs, max=max(2∣σ1−σ2∣,2∣σ1∣,2∣σ2∣)Me=21(M+M2+T2)Te=M2+T2
Practice Problems
Problem 1 (GATE CE Objective):
At a point in a strained body, σx=120 MPa, σy=−40 MPa, and τxy=30 MPa. The radius of Mohr's stress circle is: Answer:85.44 MPa Explanation:R=(2σx−σy)2+τxy2=(2120−(−40))2+302=802+302=6400+900=7300≈85.44 MPa.
Problem 2 (SSC JE Objective):
The angle between the principal plane and the plane of maximum shear stress is always: Answer:45∘ Explanation: By derivation, 2θs=2θp±90∘⟹θs=θp±45∘.
Problem 3 (GATE CE Trap Question):
A thin spherical pressure vessel of diameter D and thickness t is subjected to internal pressure p. The maximum shear stress in the vessel wall is: Answer:8tpD Explanation: In the sphere wall, σ1=σ2=4tpD and σ3=0. While in-plane shear is 2σ1−σ2=0, the absolute 3D maximum shear is τabs, max=2σ1−0=8tpD.
Problem 4 (UPSC ESE Style):
A solid circular steel shaft is subjected to a bending moment M=30 kN⋅m and a torque T=40 kN⋅m. The equivalent twisting moment is: Answer:50 kN⋅m Explanation:Te=M2+T2=302+402=50 kN⋅m.
Problem 5 (State AE Style):
On the plane of maximum in-plane shear stress, the normal stress is equal to: Answer:2σx+σy Explanation: The normal stress on the maximum shear plane equals the hydrostatic center of Mohr's circle: σs=σavg=2σx+σy=2σ1+σ2.