RCC-07-03 Chapter 07 · Design of Footings and Foundations

Combined Footings and Raft Foundations (Rectangular, Trapezoidal, Strap & Mat Systems)

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Introduction to Combined Foundations
  2. 2. Structural Classification & Selection Criteria
  3. 3. Rectangular Combined Footings: Proportioning for Uniform Pressure
  4. 3.1 Step-by-Step Sizing Procedure
  5. 4. Longitudinal Structural Analysis of Rectangular Combined Footings
  6. 4.1 Factored Distributed Upward Load wu
  7. 4.2 Shear Force Distribution and Point of Zero Shear
  8. 4.3 Transverse Bending Analysis
  9. 5. Trapezoidal Combined Footings: Centroid Alignment
  10. 5.1 Governing Geometric Equations
  11. 5.2 Solution for Dimensions a and b
  12. 6. Strap (Cantilever) Footings: Structural Mechanics & Lever Arm
  13. 6.1 System Anatomy
  14. 6.2 Equilibrium Mechanics and Reactions
  15. 6.3 Design of the Strap Beam
  16. 7. Raft (Mat) Foundations: Structural Typologies & IS 2950 Design Criteria
  17. 7.1 Structural Typologies per IS 2950 (Part 1):1981
  18. 7.2 Modulus of Subgrade Reaction (ks) & Rigidity Criteria
  19. 8. Detailed Engineering Diagrams & Visual Walkthrough
  20. Figure 1: Combined Footings: Rectangular vs Trapezoidal Mechanics
  21. Figure 2: Strap Footings & Raft Foundation Structural Systems
  22. 9. Pre-Calculated Solved Numerical Examples
  23. Problem 1: Complete Design and Longitudinal Moments of a Rectangular Combined Footing
  24. Problem 2: Sizing of a Trapezoidal Combined Footing
  25. Problem 3: Equilibrium and Bending Moments of a Strap Footing
  26. 10. Comprehensive Comparison Table: Combined Foundation Systems
  27. 11. Practical Detailing and Common Field Pitfalls
  28. 12. Competitive Examination Traps & Quick Formula Sheet
  29. Common Exam Traps
  30. Master Formula Sheet
  31. 13. Practice Problems
  32. Problem 1 (GATE CE Format - NAT)
  33. Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Format - Multiple Choice)
  34. Problem 3 (State AE / SSC JE Format)

1. Introduction to Combined Foundations

In structural engineering, while isolated pad footings are the standard economical choice for independent columns, practical site boundaries, architectural column layouts, and poor soil conditions often make isolated footings unfeasible:

  1. Property Line (Boundary) Restrictions: When a column is located directly on a property line, boundary wall, or existing structure, an isolated footing cannot extend outward without encroaching on adjacent property. Placing the column on the edge of an isolated footing introduces heavy eccentricity, leading to severe edge stress concentration and potential overturning.
  2. Proximity of Columns & Overlapping Stress Bulbs: When two adjacent columns carry heavy loads and are closely spaced, their required isolated footing areas overlap, or their subterranean Boussinesq pressure bulbs intersect, causing excessive interactive settlement.
  3. Differential Settlement Mitigation: When two columns carry unequal loads on compressible soils, connecting them with a common rigid footing balances soil contact pressures and drastically curtails relative differential settlement.
  4. Low Geotechnical Bearing Capacity: When the cumulative area required for isolated footings exceeds approximately 50%50\% of the total building footprint area, a continuous raft (mat) foundation supporting all building columns becomes more economical and structurally superior.
       Isolated Overlap Problem:                   Combined Footing Solution:
         Col 1        Col 2                          Col 1        Col 2
          │            │                              │            │
       ┌──┴──┐      ┌──┴──┐                        ┌──┴────────────┴──┐
       │     │Overlap│    │                        │   Continuous     │
       └─────┼──────┼─────┘                        │   Rigid Slab     │
             └──────┘                              └──────────────────┘

2. Structural Classification & Selection Criteria

Depending on geometric constraints, column load ratios, and relative column positions, combined foundations are classified into four major structural systems:

Foundation Type Geometric / Site Condition Load Relationship Structural Behavior
Rectangular Combined Footing Sufficient space available to extend footing beyond interior column Exterior load P1≤P_1 \le Interior load P2P_2 Inverted continuous slab-beam supported at two column points; uniform soil pressure.
Trapezoidal Combined Footing Length LL is strictly restricted on both sides, or exterior column is heavier Exterior load P1>P_1 > Interior load P2P_2 Centroid shifted toward heavier column by tapering width from aa to bb.
Strap (Cantilever) Footing Large distance between columns, making continuous combined slab uneconomical Exterior column on property line Two isolated footings connected by a rigid, non-bearing concrete beam that balances overturning.
Raft (Mat) Foundation Total column footing area >50%> 50\% of footprint, or highly variable/weak soil Multiple columns across 2D grid Continuous thick concrete slab or slab-beam mat covering the entire substructure.

3. Rectangular Combined Footings: Proportioning for Uniform Pressure

To prevent uneven settlement and structural twisting, combined footings are proportioned so that the centroid of the footing plan area coincides exactly with the resultant of the column loads (e=0e = 0). This achieves a uniform upward soil reaction:

        ◄────────────────────────────── Length L ──────────────────────────────►
       ┌───────────────────────────────┬───────────────────────────────────────┐
       │                               │ Resultant R                           │
       │   Col 1 (Exterior)            │ (Centroid L/2)       Col 2 (Interior) │
       │   ┌────┐                      │                      ┌────┐           │
       │   │ P1 │                      │                      │ P2 │           │
Width B│   └────┘                      │                      └────┘           │
       │                               │                                       │
       └───────────────────────────────┴───────────────────────────────────────┘
       ▲   ◄──── x_bar ───────────────►▲
       │   ◄───────────── Spacing S ─────────────────────────►│
       Property Line (x_R from edge)

3.1 Step-by-Step Sizing Procedure

  1. Total Vertical Service Load: Including estimated 10%10\% self-weight of the footing and overburden: Ptotal, service=1.10×(P1+P2)P_{\text{total, service}} = 1.10 \times (P_1 + P_2)
  2. Required Footing Plan Area: Areq=Ptotal, serviceqaA_{\text{req}} = \frac{P_{\text{total, service}}}{q_a} Where qaq_a is the safe bearing capacity of the soil.
  3. Position of Resultant Force xˉ\bar{x} from Column 1 Center: Taking moments about the center of Column 1: xˉ=P2⋅SP1+P2\bar{x} = \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2} Where SS is the center-to-center spacing between Column 1 and Column 2.
  4. Distance of Resultant from Property Line (xRx_R): If Column 1 has width a1a_1 along the length and its outer face is on the property line: xR=a12+xˉ=a12+P2⋅SP1+P2x_R = \frac{a_1}{2} + \bar{x} = \frac{a_1}{2} + \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2}
  5. Total Footing Length LL for Uniform Soil Pressure: Because the centroid of a rectangle lies at mid-length (L/2L/2), setting L/2=xRL/2 = x_R yields: L=2xR=2(a12+P2⋅SP1+P2)\boxed{L = 2 x_R = 2 \left(\frac{a_1}{2} + \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2}\right)}
  6. Required Footing Width BB: B=AreqLB = \frac{A_{\text{req}}}{L}
  7. Cantilever Overhang beyond Column 2 (c2c_2): c2=L−(a12+S)−a22c_2 = L - \left(\frac{a_1}{2} + S\right) - \frac{a_2}{2}

4. Longitudinal Structural Analysis of Rectangular Combined Footings

Structurally, a combined footing acts as an inverted continuous beam supported on the two columns and loaded by the upward net factored soil pressure.

4.1 Factored Distributed Upward Load wuw_u

Using factored ultimate loads Pu1=1.5P1P_{u1} = 1.5 P_1 and Pu2=1.5P2P_{u2} = 1.5 P_2:

qu=Pu1+Pu2L⋅B(kN/m2)q_u = \frac{P_{u1} + P_{u2}}{L \cdot B} \quad (\text{kN/m}^2)

The upward distributed load per unit length of the footing is:

wu=qu×B=Pu1+Pu2L(kN/m)\boxed{w_u = q_u \times B = \frac{P_{u1} + P_{u2}}{L} \quad (\text{kN/m})}
Elevation & Structural Actions:
       P_u1                                                     P_u2
        │                                                        │
        ▼                                                        ▼
     ┌──────┐                                                 ┌──────┐
     │ Col1 │                                                 │ Col2 │
   ──┴──────┴─────────────────────────────────────────────────┴──────┴──
   ▲                                                                   ▲
   └──────────────────────── wu = qu · B ──────────────────────────────┘ (Upward)

Longitudinal Bending Moment:
                  ▲ Hogging Moment (Top face in tension!)
                 / \
   ─────────────/───\─────────────────────────────────────────────────── (Zero line)
   \           /     \           /
    \_________/       \_________/
   Sagging at Col 1   Sagging at Col 2

4.2 Shear Force Distribution and Point of Zero Shear

  1. Starting from the left exterior edge (x=0x = 0):
    • Overhang to Column 1 face: Shear increases linearly upward to V=wu×a12V = w_u \times \frac{a_1}{2}.
    • At Column 1 centerline, the concentrated downward load Pu1P_{u1} acts: Vright of Col 1=wu(a12)−Pu1(Large negative shear)V_{\text{right of Col 1}} = w_u \left(\frac{a_1}{2}\right) - P_{u1} \quad (\text{Large negative shear})
  2. Point of Zero Shear (x0x_0): The shear force passes through zero between Column 1 and Column 2 at distance x0x_0 from the left property edge: V(x)=wu⋅x0−Pu1=0  ⟹  x0=Pu1wuV(x) = w_u \cdot x_0 - P_{u1} = 0 \implies \boxed{x_0 = \frac{P_{u1}}{w_u}}
  3. Maximum Negative (Hogging) Bending Moment: The maximum bending moment occurs at the point of zero shear (x=x0x = x_0): Mu,max⁡=wux022−Pu1(x0−a12)\boxed{M_{u, \max} = w_u \frac{x_0^2}{2} - P_{u1} \left(x_0 - \frac{a_1}{2}\right)}

[!CRITICAL] Rebar Placement in Combined Footings: In isolated footings, main reinforcement is always placed at the bottom. In combined footings, between the columns, the footing bends upward like an inverted beam. This induces severe tensile stresses in the TOP face of the slab. Therefore, heavy longitudinal tensile reinforcement must be provided at the TOP of the footing slab, while bottom reinforcement is provided under the columns and along outer cantilever overhangs!

4.3 Transverse Bending Analysis

In the transverse direction (across width BB), the footing acts as a cantilever projecting outward from the column faces on either side:

  • The column load PuP_u is dispersed across an effective transverse longitudinal band of width: Beff=a+2dB_{\text{eff}} = a + 2 d
  • Factored transverse bending moment at the column face: Mut=qu⋅Beff⋅(B−b2)22M_{ut} = \frac{q_u \cdot B_{\text{eff}} \cdot \left(\frac{B - b}{2}\right)^2}{2}
  • Transverse bottom reinforcement is placed in localized bands beneath each column.

5. Trapezoidal Combined Footings: Centroid Alignment

When the exterior column P1P_1 carries a significantly heavier load than the interior column P2P_2 (P1>P2P_1 > P_2), the resultant force falls close to the exterior property line (xR<L/2x_R < L/2). If a rectangular footing were used, achieving L=2xRL = 2 x_R would restrict length LL so severely that the required width B=A/LB = A/L would become impossibly wide, or the footing would fail to reach Column 2! In such cases, a Trapezoidal Combined Footing is mandatory:

  • Width at heavier exterior end: aa
  • Width at lighter interior end: bb (a>ba > b)
  • Total length: LL (fixed by site boundaries)
                       ◄────────────── Fixed Length L ──────────────►
                      ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────┐
                      │\                                            /│
                      │ \                  • Centroid (x_R)        / │
              Width a │  \                   (Resultant R)        /  │ Width b
             (Heavier)│   \                                      /   │ (Lighter)
                      │    \                                    /    │
                      │     \                                  /     │
                      └──────┴────────────────────────────────┴──────┘

5.1 Governing Geometric Equations

  1. Plan Area Equation: A=(a+b2)L  ⟹  a+b=2AreqLA = \left(\frac{a + b}{2}\right) L \implies \boxed{a + b = \frac{2 A_{\text{req}}}{L}}
  2. Centroid Location Equation: The distance of the centroid xˉtrap\bar{x}_{\text{trap}} from the wider face aa must coincide with the resultant position xRx_R: xR=L3(a+2ba+b)\boxed{x_R = \frac{L}{3} \left(\frac{a + 2b}{a + b}\right)}

5.2 Solution for Dimensions aa and bb

Rearranging the centroid equation:

a+2ba+b=3xRL  ⟹  a+2b=(a+b)(3xRL)\frac{a + 2b}{a + b} = \frac{3 x_R}{L} \implies a + 2b = (a + b) \left(\frac{3 x_R}{L}\right)

Let S1=a+b=2ALS_1 = a + b = \frac{2 A}{L} and η=3xRL\eta = \frac{3 x_R}{L}:

a+2b=S1⋅ηa + 2b = S_1 \cdot \eta

Subtracting (a+b)=S1(a + b) = S_1:

b=S1(η−1)=(2AL)(3xRL−1)\boxed{b = S_1 (\eta - 1) = \left(\frac{2 A}{L}\right) \left(\frac{3 x_R}{L} - 1\right)} a=S1−b=(2AL)−b\boxed{a = S_1 - b = \left(\frac{2 A}{L}\right) - b}

[!NOTE] Boundary Limits for a Valid Trapezoid: For a physically realizable trapezoid (a>0a > 0 and b>0b > 0):

L3<xR<L2\frac{L}{3} < x_R < \frac{L}{2}
  • If xR=L/2  ⟹  a=bx_R = L/2 \implies a = b (collapses to a rectangle).
  • If xR=L/3  ⟹  b=0x_R = L/3 \implies b = 0 (collapses to a triangle).
  • If xR<L/3  ⟹  b<0x_R < L/3 \implies b < 0 (impossible geometry; a strap footing must be used instead!).

6. Strap (Cantilever) Footings: Structural Mechanics & Lever Arm

When the distance between an exterior property-line column and an interior column is large (S>5–6 mS > 5\text{--}6\text{ m}), a continuous combined footing slab requires massive concrete volume and deep sections to resist huge hogging moments. A Strap (Cantilever) Footing provides an elegant, highly economical alternative:

    Property Line
         │
       Col 1 (P1)                                           Col 2 (P2)
         │                                                      │
         ▼                                                      ▼
      ┌──────┐                    RIGID STRAP BEAM           ┌──────┐
      │      ├───────────────────────────────────────────────┤      │
   ───┴──────┴───                                         ───┴──────┴───
   ▲  Footing 1  ▲       (NO SOIL CONTACT UNDER STRAP)    ▲  Footing 2  ▲
   └─── R1 ──────┘                                        └─── R2 ──────┘
    ◄──── L1 ───►                                          ◄──── L2 ───►

6.1 System Anatomy

  1. Footing 1 (Exterior): Built directly beneath the exterior column on the property line. Because the column is at the outer edge, the soil reaction R1R_1 acts at the footing centroid (distance L1/2L_1/2 from boundary), creating an eccentricity e1=L1−a12e_1 = \frac{L_1 - a_1}{2}.
  2. Footing 2 (Interior): A standard concentric isolated pad footing centered beneath Column 2.
  3. The Strap Beam: A narrow, deep, infinitely rigid reinforced concrete beam connecting Column 1 and Column 2.
    • Crucial Rule: The strap beam does NOT bear on the soil. The earth beneath the strap is left uncompacted or cleared with an air gap.
    • The strap beam acts as a rigid cantilever lever arm, transferring the overturning moment P1⋅e1P_1 \cdot e_1 to the interior column.

6.2 Equilibrium Mechanics and Reactions

Taking moments about the centroid of Footing 2 (Column 2 center):

  • Let SS be the center-to-center column spacing.
  • The lever arm between Footing 1 centroid and Column 2 center is: S′=S−e1=S−(L1−a12)S' = S - e_1 = S - \left(\frac{L_1 - a_1}{2}\right)
  • Moment equilibrium about Footing 2: ∑MCol 2=0  ⟹  R1⋅S′=P1⋅S  ⟹  R1=P1(SS′)\sum M_{\text{Col 2}} = 0 \implies R_1 \cdot S' = P_1 \cdot S \implies \boxed{R_1 = P_1 \left(\frac{S}{S'}\right)} Since S′<SS' < S, the soil reaction on the exterior footing is greater than the column load (R1>P1R_1 > P_1).
  • Vertical equilibrium: ∑Fy=0  ⟹  R1+R2=P1+P2  ⟹  R2=(P1+P2)−R1=P2−(R1−P1)\sum F_y = 0 \implies R_1 + R_2 = P_1 + P_2 \implies \boxed{R_2 = (P_1 + P_2) - R_1 = P_2 - (R_1 - P_1)} The soil reaction on the interior footing is reduced by the upward reaction of the strap beam (R2<P2R_2 < P_2).

6.3 Design of the Strap Beam

The strap beam is subjected to a constant shear force and a linear negative bending moment:

  • Factored shear force in the strap beam: Vu,strap=Ru1−Pu1V_{u, \text{strap}} = R_{u1} - P_{u1}
  • Maximum bending moment in the strap beam (at Column 1 center): Mu,strap=Ru1⋅e1\boxed{M_{u, \text{strap}} = R_{u1} \cdot e_1}
  • Because Ru1R_{u1} pushes upward while Pu1P_{u1} pushes downward, the strap beam bends with tension in the top face.
  • Heavy longitudinal reinforcement is detailed at the TOP of the strap beam, fully anchored with 90∘90^\circ standard hooks into Column 1 and Column 2.

7. Raft (Mat) Foundations: Structural Typologies & IS 2950 Design Criteria

A raft foundation is a combined footing that covers the entire footprint beneath all structural walls and columns.

7.1 Structural Typologies per IS 2950 (Part 1):1981

  1. Flat Plate Raft: A solid concrete slab of uniform depth (0.5–1.5 m0.5\text{--}1.5\text{ m}). Simple to excavate and shutter; used for light to medium building loads.
  2. Flat Plate with Column Pedestals / Thickened Slabs: Slabs thickened beneath columns to resist high punching shear without thickening the entire floor mat.
  3. Beam-and-Slab (Ribbed) Raft: Inverted T-beam ribs running in orthogonal directions with a thinner bottom slab. Provides high flexural rigidity with reduced concrete volume; ideal for heavy column loads.
  4. Cellular (Hollow Box) Raft: Two solid slabs (top basement floor slab and bottom foundation slab) interconnected by longitudinal and transverse concrete web walls. Extremely rigid; minimizes differential settlement in deep clay strata and acts as a buoyant foundation.
Flat Plate:                     Beam-and-Slab (Ribbed):           Cellular (Hollow Box):
  │     │     │                   │     │     │                 │     │     │
┌─┴─────┴─────┴─┐               ┌─┴─────┴─────┴─┐             ┌─┴─────┴─────┴─┐ Top Slab
│               │               │ ┌─┐ ┌─┐ ┌─┐   │             │ █   █   █   █ │ Web Walls
└───────────────┘               └─┴─┴─┴─┴─┴─┴───┘             └─┴───┴───┴───┴─┘ Bottom Slab

7.2 Modulus of Subgrade Reaction (ksk_s) & Rigidity Criteria

Per IS 2950 (Part 1), the interaction between the raft slab and the supporting soil is characterized by the modulus of subgrade reaction ksk_s:

ks=qδ(kN/m3)k_s = \frac{q}{\delta} \quad \left(\text{kN/m}^3\right)

Where qq is the contact soil pressure and δ\delta is the vertical settlement.

Raft Rigidity Parameter λ\lambda

The relative stiffness of the raft slab relative to the supporting soil is quantified by the characteristic parameter λ\lambda:

λ=ks⋅B4EI4\boxed{\lambda = \sqrt[4]{\frac{k_s \cdot B}{4 E I}}}

Where:

  • EE is the modulus of elasticity of concrete.
  • II is the moment of inertia of the raft strip per unit width.
  • BB is the strip width.

Rigidity Test:

  • Rigid Raft Analysis: If the column spacing SS satisfies: S≤1.75λ\boxed{S \le \frac{1.75}{\lambda}} The raft can be analyzed using the Conventional Rigid Method. Soil pressure is assumed to vary linearly across the planar base: q=∑PA±∑MxZx±∑MyZyq = \frac{\sum P}{A} \pm \frac{\sum M_x}{Z_x} \pm \frac{\sum M_y}{Z_y}
  • Flexible Raft Analysis: If S>1.75/λS > 1.75 / \lambda, the raft flexes significantly between columns. Analysis must be performed using the Flexible (Winkler Spring) Method or finite element plate-bending software.

8. Detailed Engineering Diagrams & Visual Walkthrough

Figure 1: Combined Footings: Rectangular vs Trapezoidal Mechanics

The diagram below illustrates the structural layout, soil reaction, SFD, and BMD of a rectangular combined footing (highlighting the critical zero-shear location and hogging moment), along with the geometric parameters of a trapezoidal combined footing.

Combined Footings Rectangular vs Trapezoidal Mechanics

Figure 2: Strap Footings & Raft Foundation Structural Systems

The diagram below details the mechanics of a strap (cantilever) footing, showing the non-bearing gap beneath the strap and the reaction formulas, alongside cross-sections of the three primary raft foundation typologies (flat plate, beam-and-slab, cellular).

Strap Footings and Raft Foundation Structural Systems

9. Pre-Calculated Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Complete Design and Longitudinal Moments of a Rectangular Combined Footing

Statement: Two columns are spaced 4.50 m4.50\text{ m} center-to-center.

  • Column 1 (exterior, outer face on property boundary): 400 mm×400 mm400\text{ mm} \times 400\text{ mm}, carrying service load P1=700 kNP_1 = 700\text{ kN} (Pu1=1050 kNP_{u1} = 1050\text{ kN}).
  • Column 2 (interior): 500 mm×500 mm500\text{ mm} \times 500\text{ mm}, carrying service load P2=1100 kNP_2 = 1100\text{ kN} (Pu2=1650 kNP_{u2} = 1650\text{ kN}). The safe bearing capacity of the soil is qa=150 kN/m2q_a = 150\text{ kN/m}^2.
  1. Determine the length LL and width BB of a rectangular combined footing for uniform soil pressure.
  2. Determine the factored upward soil load intensity wuw_u (kN/m\text{kN/m}).
  3. Locate the point of zero shear between the columns.
  4. Calculate the maximum negative (hogging) bending moment Mu,max⁡M_{u, \max}.

Solution:

Step 1: Footing Plan Sizing

  • Total service load with 10%10\% self-weight: Ptotal, service=1.10×(700+1100)=1.10×1800=1980 kNP_{\text{total, service}} = 1.10 \times (700 + 1100) = 1.10 \times 1800 = 1980\text{ kN}
  • Required plan area: Areq=1980150=13.20 m2A_{\text{req}} = \frac{1980}{150} = 13.20\text{ m}^2
  • Resultant position from Column 1 center: xˉ=P2⋅SP1+P2=1100×4.50700+1100=49501800=2.75 m\bar{x} = \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2} = \frac{1100 \times 4.50}{700 + 1100} = \frac{4950}{1800} = 2.75\text{ m}
  • Distance of resultant from property line (left edge of footing): xR=a12+xˉ=0.402+2.75=0.20+2.75=2.95 mx_R = \frac{a_1}{2} + \bar{x} = \frac{0.40}{2} + 2.75 = 0.20 + 2.75 = 2.95\text{ m}
  • Footing length for uniform soil pressure: L=2xR=2×2.95=5.90 m\boxed{L = 2 x_R = 2 \times 2.95 = 5.90\text{ m}}
  • Required width: Breq=AreqL=13.205.90=2.237 m  ⟹  Adopt B=2.30 mB_{\text{req}} = \frac{A_{\text{req}}}{L} = \frac{13.20}{5.90} = 2.237\text{ m} \implies \mathbf{Adopt\text{ }B = 2.30\text{ m}} Aprov=5.90×2.30=13.57 m2A_{\text{prov}} = 5.90 \times 2.30 = 13.57\text{ m}^2
  • Overhang beyond Column 2 center: c2=L−(a12+S)=5.90−(0.20+4.50)=5.90−4.70=1.20 mc_2 = L - \left(\frac{a_1}{2} + S\right) = 5.90 - (0.20 + 4.50) = 5.90 - 4.70 = 1.20\text{ m}

Step 2: Factored Upward Soil Load Intensity wuw_u

Factored column loads: Pu1=1.5×700=1050 kNP_{u1} = 1.5 \times 700 = 1050\text{ kN}, Pu2=1.5×1100=1650 kNP_{u2} = 1.5 \times 1100 = 1650\text{ kN}.

Pu,total=1050+1650=2700 kNP_{u, \text{total}} = 1050 + 1650 = 2700\text{ kN}

Net factored upward soil pressure:

qu=Pu,totalAprov=270013.57=198.97 kPaq_u = \frac{P_{u, \text{total}}}{A_{\text{prov}}} = \frac{2700}{13.57} = 198.97\text{ kPa}

Upward load per meter length:

wu=qu×B=198.97×2.30=457.63 kN/mw_u = q_u \times B = 198.97 \times 2.30 = 457.63\text{ kN/m}

Step 3: Location of Point of Zero Shear (x0x_0)

Taking xx as distance from the left property boundary edge:

V(x)=wu⋅x0−Pu1=0V(x) = w_u \cdot x_0 - P_{u1} = 0 x0=Pu1wu=1050457.63=2.294 m from property line\boxed{x_0 = \frac{P_{u1}}{w_u} = \frac{1050}{457.63} = 2.294\text{ m from property line}}

Distance from Column 1 center:

x0−0.20=2.294−0.20=2.094 mx_0 - 0.20 = 2.294 - 0.20 = 2.094\text{ m}

Step 4: Maximum Negative (Hogging) Bending Moment

Mu,max⁡=wux022−Pu1(x0−0.20)M_{u, \max} = w_u \frac{x_0^2}{2} - P_{u1} \left(x_0 - 0.20\right) Mu,max⁡=457.63×(2.294)22−1050×(2.094)M_{u, \max} = 457.63 \times \frac{(2.294)^2}{2} - 1050 \times (2.094) Mu,max⁡=457.63×2.6312−2198.70=1204.12−2198.70=−994.58 kNmM_{u, \max} = 457.63 \times 2.6312 - 2198.70 = 1204.12 - 2198.70 = -994.58\text{ kNm} Mu,hogging=994.58 kNm (Tension at Top Face)\boxed{M_{u, \text{hogging}} = 994.58\text{ kNm (Tension at Top Face)}}

Conclusion: The maximum design moment is a hogging moment of 994.58 kNm994.58\text{ kNm}, requiring primary longitudinal tensile reinforcement placed in the top face of the footing slab.


Problem 2: Sizing of a Trapezoidal Combined Footing

Statement: Two columns 450 mm×450 mm450\text{ mm} \times 450\text{ mm} are spaced 4.00 m4.00\text{ m} center-to-center.

  • Exterior Column 1: Service load P1=1200 kNP_1 = 1200\text{ kN}.
  • Interior Column 2: Service load P2=800 kNP_2 = 800\text{ kN}. Property boundary limits the footing so it cannot extend more than 0.25 m0.25\text{ m} beyond the center of Column 1. The total length of the footing is strictly restricted to L=5.00 mL = 5.00\text{ m}. Safe bearing capacity of soil qa=200 kPaq_a = 200\text{ kPa}.
  1. Explain why a rectangular footing is impossible.
  2. Determine the widths aa (wider end) and bb (narrower end) of a trapezoidal footing for uniform soil pressure.

Solution:

Step 1: Check Feasibility of a Rectangular Footing

  • Total service load with 10%10\% self-weight: Ptotal, service=1.10×(1200+800)=1.10×2000=2200 kNP_{\text{total, service}} = 1.10 \times (1200 + 800) = 1.10 \times 2000 = 2200\text{ kN}
  • Required area: Areq=2200200=11.00 m2A_{\text{req}} = \frac{2200}{200} = 11.00\text{ m}^2
  • Resultant position from Column 1 center: xˉ=P2⋅SP1+P2=800×4.001200+800=32002000=1.60 m\bar{x} = \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2} = \frac{800 \times 4.00}{1200 + 800} = \frac{3200}{2000} = 1.60\text{ m}
  • Distance of resultant from left boundary: xR=0.25+1.60=1.85 mx_R = 0.25 + 1.60 = 1.85\text{ m}
  • For a rectangular footing of length L=5.00 mL = 5.00\text{ m}, the centroid is fixed at: xˉrect=L2=5.002=2.50 m\bar{x}_{\text{rect}} = \frac{L}{2} = \frac{5.00}{2} = 2.50\text{ m}
  • Because xR=1.85 m≠2.50 mx_R = 1.85\text{ m} \ne 2.50\text{ m}, a rectangular footing would experience massive eccentricity (e=2.50−1.85=0.65 m>L/6=0.833 me = 2.50 - 1.85 = 0.65\text{ m} > L/6 = 0.833\text{ m}), causing severe non-uniform pressure.
  • Therefore, a TRAPEZOIDAL FOOTING is mandatory.

Step 2: Solve for Trapezoidal Dimensions aa and bb

Using the two simultaneous governing equations:

  1. Area Equation: (a+b2)L=A  ⟹  a+b=2AL=2×11.005.00=4.40 m\left(\frac{a + b}{2}\right) L = A \implies a + b = \frac{2 A}{L} = \frac{2 \times 11.00}{5.00} = 4.40\text{ m}
  2. Centroid Equation: xR=L3(a+2ba+b)=1.85 mx_R = \frac{L}{3} \left(\frac{a + 2b}{a + b}\right) = 1.85\text{ m} a+2ba+b=3×1.855.00=5.555.00=1.110\frac{a + 2b}{a + b} = \frac{3 \times 1.85}{5.00} = \frac{5.55}{5.00} = 1.110 a+2b=(a+b)×1.110=4.40×1.110=4.884 ma + 2b = (a + b) \times 1.110 = 4.40 \times 1.110 = 4.884\text{ m}
  3. Subtracting (a+b)(a + b) from (a+2b)(a + 2b): b=4.884−4.40=0.484 mb = 4.884 - 4.40 = 0.484\text{ m} a=4.40−0.484=3.916 ma = 4.40 - 0.484 = 3.916\text{ m}

Conclusion: The trapezoidal footing has:

  • Wider edge near Column 1: a=3.92 ma = 3.92\text{ m}
  • Narrower edge near Column 2: b=0.48 mb = 0.48\text{ m}
  • Length: L=5.00 mL = 5.00\text{ m} (Area =11.00 m2= 11.00\text{ m}^2, Centroid at 1.85 m1.85\text{ m}, matching resultant perfectly).

Problem 3: Equilibrium and Bending Moments of a Strap Footing

Statement: An exterior column 400 mm×400 mm400\text{ mm} \times 400\text{ mm} on a property line carries a service load P1=600 kNP_1 = 600\text{ kN} (Pu1=900 kNP_{u1} = 900\text{ kN}). An interior column 500 mm×500 mm500\text{ mm} \times 500\text{ mm} carries a service load P2=1000 kNP_2 = 1000\text{ kN} (Pu2=1500 kNP_{u2} = 1500\text{ kN}). The columns are spaced S=5.00 mS = 5.00\text{ m} apart. The exterior footing is restricted in length to L1=1.80 mL_1 = 1.80\text{ m}. Safe bearing capacity qa=180 kPaq_a = 180\text{ kPa}.

  1. Calculate the soil reaction R1R_1 on the exterior footing and R2R_2 on the interior footing.
  2. Size both footings.
  3. Calculate the maximum factored bending moment and shear force in the connecting strap beam.

Solution:

Step 1: Equilibrium and Soil Reactions

  • Column 1 center is at a1/2=0.20 ma_1 / 2 = 0.20\text{ m} from the property line.
  • Centroid of Footing 1 (L1=1.80 mL_1 = 1.80\text{ m}) is at L1/2=0.90 mL_1 / 2 = 0.90\text{ m} from the property line.
  • Eccentricity of Column 1 on Footing 1: e1=0.90−0.20=0.70 me_1 = 0.90 - 0.20 = 0.70\text{ m}
  • Effective lever arm between Footing 1 centroid and Column 2 center: S′=S−e1=5.00−0.70=4.30 mS' = S - e_1 = 5.00 - 0.70 = 4.30\text{ m}
  • Taking moments about Column 2: R1×S′=P1×S  ⟹  R1=600×(5.004.30)=697.67 kNR_1 \times S' = P_1 \times S \implies R_1 = 600 \times \left(\frac{5.00}{4.30}\right) = 697.67\text{ kN}
  • Vertical equilibrium: R2=(P1+P2)−R1=(600+1000)−697.67=1600−697.67=902.33 kNR_2 = (P_1 + P_2) - R_1 = (600 + 1000) - 697.67 = 1600 - 697.67 = 902.33\text{ kN}

Step 2: Sizing Footing 1 and Footing 2

  • Footing 1 (Exterior): A1,req=1.10×697.67180=4.264 m2A_{1, \text{req}} = \frac{1.10 \times 697.67}{180} = 4.264\text{ m}^2 B1=A1,reqL1=4.2641.80=2.369 m  ⟹  Adopt L1=1.80 m,B1=2.40 mB_1 = \frac{A_{1, \text{req}}}{L_1} = \frac{4.264}{1.80} = 2.369\text{ m} \implies \mathbf{Adopt\text{ }L_1 = 1.80\text{ m}, B_1 = 2.40\text{ m}}
  • Footing 2 (Interior): A2,req=1.10×902.33180=5.514 m2A_{2, \text{req}} = \frac{1.10 \times 902.33}{180} = 5.514\text{ m}^2 B2=5.514=2.348 m  ⟹  Adopt 2.40 m×2.40 mB_2 = \sqrt{5.514} = 2.348\text{ m} \implies \mathbf{Adopt\text{ }2.40\text{ m} \times 2.40\text{ m}}

Step 3: Design Forces on the Strap Beam

  • Factored column load: Pu1=1.5×600=900 kNP_{u1} = 1.5 \times 600 = 900\text{ kN}.
  • Factored soil reaction: Ru1=1.5×697.67=1046.51 kNR_{u1} = 1.5 \times 697.67 = 1046.51\text{ kN}.
  • Factored Shear Force in Strap Beam: Vu,strap=Ru1−Pu1=1046.51−900.00=146.51 kNV_{u, \text{strap}} = R_{u1} - P_{u1} = 1046.51 - 900.00 = 146.51\text{ kN}
  • Maximum Factored Bending Moment in Strap Beam: The strap beam resists the overturning moment produced by the eccentric reaction: Mu,strap=Ru1×e1=1046.51×0.70=732.56 kNmM_{u, \text{strap}} = R_{u1} \times e_1 = 1046.51 \times 0.70 = 732.56\text{ kNm}
Mu,strap=732.56 kNm (Hogging, Top Steel in Tension)\boxed{M_{u, \text{strap}} = 732.56\text{ kNm (Hogging, Top Steel in Tension)}} Vu,strap=146.51 kN\boxed{V_{u, \text{strap}} = 146.51\text{ kN}}

10. Comprehensive Comparison Table: Combined Foundation Systems

Feature / Criteria Rectangular Combined Footing Trapezoidal Combined Footing Strap (Cantilever) Footing Raft (Mat) Foundation
Typical Column Spacing Close to medium (3–5 m3\text{--}5\text{ m}) Close to medium (3–5 m3\text{--}5\text{ m}) Large (>5–6 m> 5\text{--}6\text{ m}) Multiple orthogonal bays
Column Load Relation Exterior P1≤P_1 \le Interior P2P_2 Exterior P1>P_1 > Interior P2P_2 Exterior P1<P_1 < or >P2> P_2 Variable column loads
Property Line Constraint Space available past Col 2 Space restricted past Col 2 Severe boundary restriction Property-wide footprint
Soil Contact Area Continuous rectangular slab Continuous trapezoidal slab Two isolated pads only Single continuous mat
Strap Beam Required? No No Yes (Rigid, Non-Bearing) Integral ribs in slab-beam
Governing Moment Hogging between columns (Top) Hogging between columns (Top) Hogging in strap beam (Top) Two-way sagging & hogging
Differential Settlement Low Low Very Low Minimal (High stiffness)
Formwork Complexity Low (Rectangular) Moderate (Slanted forms) Moderate (Deep strap beam) High (For cellular/ribbed)

11. Practical Detailing and Common Field Pitfalls

  1. The Top Steel Curtailment Trap:
    • In combined footings, designers often assume that because it is a "footing," bottom steel is primary.
    • Overlooking the huge top hogging bending moment causes catastrophic shear/flexural failure between columns. Top bars must be continuous and detailed with full tension lap splices.
  2. Soil Contact beneath Strap Beams:
    • A strap beam is designed based on the fundamental assumption that it transfers pure shear and moment without direct soil contact.
    • If contractors cast the strap beam directly on hard, unyielding soil, upward soil pressure develops under the strap, altering the reaction distribution and overstressing the interior footing.
  3. Trapezoidal Formwork Errors:
    • When constructing trapezoidal footings, site engineers must ensure that the wider face aa is placed beneath the heavier column P1P_1, not reversed!
  4. Raft Foundation Settlement Joints:
    • Where a high-rise tower sits adjacent to a low-rise podium on a continuous raft, large differential settlement will crack the mat. Provide a temporary pour strip (shrinkage strip) or an engineered settlement joint.

12. Competitive Examination Traps & Quick Formula Sheet

Common Exam Traps

  1. Length of Rectangular Combined Footing:
    • L=2xRL = \mathbf{2 x_R}, where xRx_R is measured from the property line, NOT from the center of Column 1!
  2. Point of Zero Shear Location:
    • x0=Pu1wux_0 = \frac{P_{u1}}{w_u}, measured from the outer edge of the footing.
  3. Trapezoid Centroid Limits:
    • For a trapezoid with wider face aa and narrower face bb, the centroid distance xˉ\bar{x} from face aa satisfies L/3<xˉ<L/2\mathbf{L/3 < \bar{x} < L/2}.
    • If xˉ=L/2  ⟹  \bar{x} = L/2 \implies Rectangle.
    • If xˉ=L/3  ⟹  \bar{x} = L/3 \implies Triangle.
  4. Strap Beam Reaction Multiplier:
    • R1=P1(SS′)R_1 = P_1 \left(\frac{S}{S'}\right). Since S′=S−e1<SS' = S - e_1 < S, R1R_1 is always greater than P1P_1!

Master Formula Sheet

L=2xR=2[a12+P2⋅SP1+P2](Rectangular Footing)\boxed{L = 2 x_R = 2 \left[\frac{a_1}{2} + \frac{P_2 \cdot S}{P_1 + P_2}\right] \quad (\text{Rectangular Footing})} wu=Pu1+Pu2L(kN/m)\boxed{w_u = \frac{P_{u1} + P_{u2}}{L} \quad (\text{kN/m})} x0=Pu1wu(Point of Zero Shear)\boxed{x_0 = \frac{P_{u1}}{w_u} \quad (\text{Point of Zero Shear})} a+b=2AL,xR=L3(a+2ba+b)(Trapezoidal Footing)\boxed{a + b = \frac{2 A}{L}, \quad x_R = \frac{L}{3}\left(\frac{a + 2b}{a + b}\right) \quad (\text{Trapezoidal Footing})} R1=P1(SS−e1),R2=(P1+P2)−R1(Strap Footing)\boxed{R_1 = P_1 \left(\frac{S}{S - e_1}\right), \quad R_2 = (P_1 + P_2) - R_1 \quad (\text{Strap Footing})} Mu,strap=Ru1⋅e1(Top Tension)\boxed{M_{u, \text{strap}} = R_{u1} \cdot e_1 \quad (\text{Top Tension})}

13. Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE Format - NAT)

Two columns P1=500 kNP_1 = 500\text{ kN} and P2=1000 kNP_2 = 1000\text{ kN} are spaced 4.5 m4.5\text{ m} center-to-center. Column 1 is on the boundary line and has width 0.4 m0.4\text{ m}. To achieve a uniform soil pressure, the length LL of a rectangular combined footing must be ________ m\text{m} (round off to 1 decimal place). (Calculation: xˉ=1000×4.5500+1000=45001500=3.0 m\bar{x} = \frac{1000 \times 4.5}{500 + 1000} = \frac{4500}{1500} = 3.0\text{ m}. xR=0.4/2+3.0=0.2+3.0=3.2 mx_R = 0.4/2 + 3.0 = 0.2 + 3.0 = 3.2\text{ m}. L=2×3.2=6.4 mL = 2 \times 3.2 = 6.4\text{ m}. Answer: 6.46.4)

Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Format - Multiple Choice)

In a trapezoidal combined footing of length LL with parallel sides aa and bb (a>ba > b), the distance of the centroid from the side aa must lie in the range:

  • (A) 0≤xˉ≤L/30 \le \bar{x} \le L/3
  • (B) L/3<xˉ<L/2L/3 < \bar{x} < L/2
  • (C) L/2≤xˉ≤2L/3L/2 \le \bar{x} \le 2L/3
  • (D) 2L/3<xˉ≤L2L/3 < \bar{x} \le L (Answer: (B) L/3<xˉ<L/2L/3 < \bar{x} < L/2. At xˉ=L/3\bar{x} = L/3 it becomes a triangle with b=0b=0, and at xˉ=L/2\bar{x} = L/2 it becomes a rectangle with a=ba=b.)

Problem 3 (State AE / SSC JE Format)

In a strap footing, why is the soil beneath the strap beam left uncompacted or cleared with an air gap?

  • (A) To reduce the weight of the strap beam
  • (B) To allow water drainage under the footing
  • (C) To ensure the strap beam transfers moment without developing upward soil pressure
  • (D) To simplify formwork removal (Answer: (C) To ensure the strap beam transfers moment without developing upward soil pressure)