SA-07-01 Chapter 07 · Plastic Analysis of Structures

Plastic Hinges, Plastic Moment Capacity (MpM_p) & Shape Factor (SS)

Subject
Structural Analysis
Chapter
07 — Plastic Analysis of Structures
Prerequisites
Flexural Stresses in Beams (SOM-06-01), Moment of Inertia & Centroids (EM-03-01), Bending Moment Diagrams (SOM-05-02).
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE, State JE
Master Directory
civil_/notes/structural_analysis/07_plastic_analysis/01_plastic_hinges_moment_capacity_shape_factor.md
In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Introduction & Conceptual Foundations

1.1 The Elastic Paradigm vs. The Plastic Paradigm

Classical structural analysis relies predominantly on linear elastic behavior governed by Hooke's law (σ=Eϵ\sigma = E \epsilon). Under the allowable stress design (ASD) or working stress method (WSM), a structural element is considered to have reached its capacity as soon as the extreme outer fiber stress reaches the yield stress of the material (fyf_y).

However, ductile structural steel possesses a profound reserve of strength beyond initial yielding. Once the outer fibers yield, they do not rupture; instead, they undergo plastic flow at approximately constant stress while interior fibers, which are stressed below fyf_y, continue to take on additional bending moment until the entire cross-section is plastically yielded. This phenomenon forms the foundation of Plastic Analysis (or Limit State Design / Ultimate Load Theory).

   Elastic Theory (WSM): Capacity reached when sigma_max = f_y (Yield Moment M_y)
   Plastic Theory (USM): Capacity reached when all fibers reach f_y (Plastic Moment M_p)
   Reserve Margin = (M_p - M_y) / M_y = (Shape Factor - 1) * 100%

1.2 Idealized Stress-Strain Relationship

Plastic analysis of structural steel is based on the idealized rigid-perfectly plastic or elastic-perfectly plastic stress-strain material model (Prandtl's body):

  1. Linear Elastic Region (0≤ϵ≤ϵy0 \le \epsilon \le \epsilon_y): σ=Eϵ\sigma = E \epsilon.
  2. Plastic Yield Plateau (ϵy≤ϵ≤ϵst\epsilon_y \le \epsilon \le \epsilon_{st}): σ=fy\sigma = f_y (constant yield plateau, typically spanning strains up to 10ϵy10\epsilon_y to 15ϵy15\epsilon_y before strain hardening commences).
  3. Strain Hardening Neglect: Strain hardening is conservatively ignored in standard plastic collapse design, ensuring an inherent additional factor of safety against total collapse.
Plastic Hinge Concept and Stress Distribution Blocks

2. Core Engineering Principles & Fundamental Assumptions

Plastic analysis is governed by six fundamental assumptions:

  1. Navier-Bernoulli Hypothesis (Planar Strains): Cross-sections that are plane before bending remain plane after bending across both the elastic and fully plastic regimes. Consequently, the longitudinal strain distribution across the depth is strictly linear: ϵ(y)=κ⋅y\epsilon(y) = \kappa \cdot y where κ\kappa is the curvature and yy is the distance from the neutral axis.
  2. Idealized Elastic-Plastic Stress-Strain Relationship: The material exhibits symmetrical behavior in tension and compression with a well-defined yield stress fyf_y and modulus of elasticity EE.
  3. Equal Tension and Compression Yield: fy,t=fy,c=fyf_{y,t} = f_{y,c} = f_y.
  4. Neglect of Secondary Effects: Axial force, shear force, and torsional stresses are initially assumed negligible (or accounted for via interaction equations) so that failure occurs strictly in flexure.
  5. No Local or Lateral-Torsional Buckling: The structural steel section is assumed to be "Plastic" or "Compact" (Class 1 or Class 2 per IS 800:2007, Table 2), ensuring that local flange/web buckling or lateral-torsional instability does not occur prior to full plastic hinge rotation.
  6. Deflections are Small: Deflections prior to plastic collapse are sufficiently small so that the initial undeformed geometry can be used for equilibrium equations.

3. Mathematical Derivations: From Yield Moment to Full Plastic Moment

3.1 The Elastic Neutral Axis (ENA) vs. Plastic Neutral Axis (PNA)

Elastic Neutral Axis (ENA)

In the elastic regime, the stress at distance yy from the neutral axis is σ=Eκy\sigma = E \kappa y. Axial equilibrium requires:

∑Fx=∫Aσ dA=Eκ∫Ay dA=0  ⟹  ∫Ay dA=0\sum F_x = \int_A \sigma \, dA = E \kappa \int_A y \, dA = 0 \implies \int_A y \, dA = 0

Hence, the Elastic Neutral Axis (ENA) passes through the geometric centroid of the cross-section.

Plastic Neutral Axis (PNA)

When the entire cross-section has yielded, the tensile fibers carry stress +fy+f_y and the compressive fibers carry stress −fy-f_y. Axial force equilibrium under pure flexure requires:

∑Fx=∫Ac(−fy) dA+∫At(+fy) dA=0\sum F_x = \int_{A_c} (-f_y) \, dA + \int_{A_t} (+f_y) \, dA = 0 −fyAc+fyAt=0  ⟹  Ac=At=A2-f_y A_c + f_y A_t = 0 \implies A_c = A_t = \frac{A}{2}

Fundamental Theorem: The Plastic Neutral Axis (PNA) is the Equal-Area Axis of the cross-section. For symmetrical sections, the PNA coincides with the ENA (centroid). For unsymmetrical sections (e.g., T-sections, unsymmetrical I-sections), the PNA does not pass through the centroid.

3.2 Yield Moment (MyM_y) and Elastic Section Modulus (ZeZ_e)

The yield moment MyM_y is the bending moment at which the outermost fiber first reaches yield stress fyf_y:

My=fy⋅Ze=fy⋅Ixxymax⁡M_y = f_y \cdot Z_e = f_y \cdot \frac{I_{xx}}{y_{\max}}

where:

  • IxxI_{xx} is the second moment of area about the centroidal ENA.
  • ymax⁡y_{\max} is the distance from the ENA to the most remote outer fiber.
  • ZeZ_e is the elastic section modulus (Ze=I/ymax⁡Z_e = I / y_{\max}).

3.3 Plastic Moment Capacity (MpM_p) and Plastic Section Modulus (ZpZ_p)

At full plastic yield, every fiber above the PNA is in compression at −fy-f_y, and every fiber below the PNA is in tension at +fy+f_y. The internal resisting couple is:

Mp=∫Acfy⋅yc dA+∫Atfy⋅yt dA=fy[∫Acyc dA+∫Atyt dA]M_p = \int_{A_c} f_y \cdot y_c \, dA + \int_{A_t} f_y \cdot y_t \, dA = f_y \left[ \int_{A_c} y_c \, dA + \int_{A_t} y_t \, dA \right] Mp=fy(Acyˉc+Atyˉt)M_p = f_y \left( A_c \bar{y}_c + A_t \bar{y}_t \right)

Since Ac=At=A2A_c = A_t = \frac{A}{2}:

Mp=fy⋅A2(yˉc+yˉt)=fy⋅ZpM_p = f_y \cdot \frac{A}{2} (\bar{y}_c + \bar{y}_t) = f_y \cdot Z_p

where:

  • yˉc\bar{y}_c is the distance from the PNA to the centroid of the compressive area AcA_c.
  • yˉt\bar{y}_t is the distance from the PNA to the centroid of the tensile area AtA_t.
  • Zp=A2(yˉc+yˉt)Z_p = \frac{A}{2} (\bar{y}_c + \bar{y}_t) is the Plastic Section Modulus.
  • dp=yˉc+yˉtd_p = \bar{y}_c + \bar{y}_t is the lever arm between the resultant plastic compressive and tensile forces: C=T=fyA2,Mp=C⋅dp=T⋅dpC = T = f_y \frac{A}{2}, \quad M_p = C \cdot d_p = T \cdot d_p

3.4 The Shape Factor (SS)

The Shape Factor (SS) is a dimensionless geometric property of a cross-section defined as the ratio of its plastic moment capacity to its yield moment capacity:

S=MpMy=fyZpfyZe=ZpZeS = \frac{M_p}{M_y} = \frac{f_y Z_p}{f_y Z_e} = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e}

Physical Significance of Shape Factor

  1. Reserve Strength: The quantity (S−1)×100%(S - 1) \times 100\% indicates the percentage increase in flexural load-carrying capacity from the onset of yielding to complete plastification.
  2. Cross-Sectional Efficiency: Sections with mass concentrated near the neutral axis (e.g., diamonds, triangles) have high shape factors (S=2.0S = 2.0 to 2.342.34), meaning low elastic efficiency but high plastic reserve. Sections with mass concentrated far from the neutral axis (e.g., I-beams) have low shape factors (S≈1.12−1.18S \approx 1.12 - 1.18), meaning high elastic efficiency and a smaller plastic reserve.

3.5 Load Factor (QQ) and Margin of Safety

  • Load Factor (λ\lambda or QQ): Ratio of collapse load (WcW_c) to working load (WW): λ=WcW=Plastic Collapse LoadWorking / Service Load\lambda = \frac{W_c}{W} = \frac{\text{Plastic Collapse Load}}{\text{Working / Service Load}}
  • In statically determinate beams, the plastic collapse occurs at the formation of a single plastic hinge: λ=Factor of Safety (FOS)×Shape Factor (S)\lambda = \text{Factor of Safety (FOS)} \times \text{Shape Factor } (S) where FOS=fyσallowable\text{FOS} = \frac{f_y}{\sigma_{\text{allowable}}}.

4. Exact Formulations for Standard Structural Cross-Sections

The table below summarizes the exact mathematical formulas for centroid, PNA, ZeZ_e, ZpZ_p, and Shape Factor SS across canonical engineering cross-sections:

Cross-Section Geometry Dimensions Elastic Section Modulus ZeZ_e Plastic Section Modulus ZpZ_p Shape Factor S=Zp/ZeS = Z_p / Z_e Reserve Capacity (S−1)(S-1)
Solid Rectangle Width bb, Depth dd bd26≈0.1667bd2\frac{b d^2}{6} \approx 0.1667 b d^2 bd24=0.2500bd2\frac{b d^2}{4} = 0.2500 b d^2 1.500\mathbf{1.500} 50.0%50.0\%
Solid Circle Diameter DD πD332≈0.0982D3\frac{\pi D^3}{32} \approx 0.0982 D^3 D36≈0.1667D3\frac{D^3}{6} \approx 0.1667 D^3 163π≈1.698\frac{16}{3\pi} \approx \mathbf{1.698} 69.8%69.8\%
Thin Circular Ring Mean Dia DD, thickness tt πD2t4≈0.7854D2t\frac{\pi D^2 t}{4} \approx 0.7854 D^2 t D2t=1.0000D2tD^2 t = 1.0000 D^2 t 4π≈1.273\frac{4}{\pi} \approx \mathbf{1.273} 27.3%27.3\%
Solid Diamond (Rhombus) Diagonals b,db, d (axis along dd) bd224≈0.0417bd2\frac{b d^2}{24} \approx 0.0417 b d^2 bd212≈0.0833bd2\frac{b d^2}{12} \approx 0.0833 b d^2 2.000\mathbf{2.000} 100.0%100.0\%
Isosceles Triangle (Apex Up) Base bb, Height hh (axis ∥b\| b) bh224≈0.0417bh2\frac{b h^2}{24} \approx 0.0417 b h^2 bh2122≈0.0589bh2\frac{b h^2}{12 \sqrt{2}} \approx 0.0589 b h^2 22−1?\frac{2\sqrt{2}-1}{?} ≈2.343\approx \mathbf{2.343} 134.3%134.3\%
Standard Wide-Flange I-Beam B×DB \times D, flange tft_f, web twt_w BD3−(B−tw)dw36D\frac{B D^3 - (B-t_w)d_w^3}{6D} Btf(D−tf)+twdw2/41\frac{B t_f (D - t_f) + t_w d_w^2 / 4}{1} 1.12−1.18\mathbf{1.12 - 1.18} 12%−18%12\% - 18\%
Thin-Walled Tube (Square) Outer BB, thickness t≪Bt \ll B 43B2t\frac{4}{3} B^2 t 32B2t\frac{3}{2} B^2 t 1.125\mathbf{1.125} 12.5%12.5\%

Derivation for Solid Diamond (Rhombus)

For a diamond of width bb and height dd with horizontal neutral axis:

  • Area A=12bdA = \frac{1}{2} b d.
  • Ixx=2×b(d/2)312=bd348I_{xx} = 2 \times \frac{b (d/2)^3}{12} = \frac{b d^3}{48}.
  • ymax⁡=d/2  ⟹  Ze=bd3/48d/2=bd224y_{\max} = d/2 \implies Z_e = \frac{b d^3 / 48}{d/2} = \frac{b d^2}{24}.
  • For plastic modulus: Half-area above NA is a triangle of base bb and height d/2d/2.
    • Area A1=12⋅b⋅d2=bd4A_1 = \frac{1}{2} \cdot b \cdot \frac{d}{2} = \frac{b d}{4}.
    • Centroid yˉ1=13(d2)=d6\bar{y}_1 = \frac{1}{3} \left(\frac{d}{2}\right) = \frac{d}{6}.
    • Zp=2A1yˉ1=2(bd4)(d6)=bd212Z_p = 2 A_1 \bar{y}_1 = 2 \left( \frac{bd}{4} \right) \left( \frac{d}{6} \right) = \frac{b d^2}{12}.
  • Shape Factor: S=ZpZe=bd2/12bd2/24=2.000S = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e} = \frac{b d^2 / 12}{b d^2 / 24} = \mathbf{2.000}

Derivation for Solid Circle

  • Area A=πD24A = \frac{\pi D^2}{4}. Ixx=πD464I_{xx} = \frac{\pi D^4}{64}.
  • Ze=πD4/64D/2=πD332Z_e = \frac{\pi D^4 / 64}{D/2} = \frac{\pi D^3}{32}.
  • Half-area above NA is a semicircle: A1=πD28A_1 = \frac{\pi D^2}{8}.
  • Centroid of semicircle from diameter: yˉ1=4(D/2)3π=2D3π\bar{y}_1 = \frac{4 (D/2)}{3\pi} = \frac{2D}{3\pi}.
  • Zp=2A1yˉ1=2(πD28)(2D3π)=D36Z_p = 2 A_1 \bar{y}_1 = 2 \left( \frac{\pi D^2}{8} \right) \left( \frac{2D}{3\pi} \right) = \frac{D^3}{6}.
  • Shape Factor: S=ZpZe=D3/6πD3/32=326π=163π≈1.6977S = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e} = \frac{D^3 / 6}{\pi D^3 / 32} = \frac{32}{6\pi} = \frac{\mathbf{16}}{\mathbf{3\pi}} \approx \mathbf{1.6977}

5. Length of Plastic Hinge & Moment-Curvature (M−ϕM-\phi) Relationship

5.1 Moment-Curvature Relationship (M−ϕM-\phi)

The curvature ϕ\phi of a beam is related to the extreme fiber strain ϵmax⁡\epsilon_{\max} by ϕ=ϵmax⁡d/2\phi = \frac{\epsilon_{\max}}{d/2}.

  1. Elastic Stage (M≤MyM \le M_y): ϕ=MEI,linear relationship with slope EI\phi = \frac{M}{EI}, \quad \text{linear relationship with slope } EI
  2. Elasto-Plastic Stage (My<M<MpM_y < M < M_p): Yielding penetrates inward from outer fibers to depth ypy_p. For a rectangular section: M=Mp[1−13(ϕyϕ)2]M = M_p \left[ 1 - \frac{1}{3}\left( \frac{\phi_y}{\phi} \right)^2 \right] As ϕ→∞\phi \to \infty, M→MpM \to M_p.
  3. Fully Plastic Stage (M=MpM = M_p): The section undergoes rotation at constant moment MpM_p. It acts as a Plastic Hinge, permitting infinite rotation (theoretically) while sustaining MpM_p.
Moment Curvature and Length of Plastic Hinge

5.2 Definition & Mathematical Formulation of Plastic Hinge Length (LpL_p)

In a real beam subjected to distributed or point loads, the bending moment varies along the span. The fully plastic moment MpM_p occurs at the section of maximum moment. However, all adjacent cross-sections where the bending moment exceeds the yield moment (M(x)≥MyM(x) \ge M_y) undergo partial yielding (elasto-plastic deformation).

The physical zone along the span where M(x)≥MyM(x) \ge M_y is termed the Length of the Plastic Hinge (LpL_p).

Case A: Simply Supported Beam with Central Concentrated Load WcW_c

At collapse, the mid-span moment reaches Mp=WcL4M_p = \frac{W_c L}{4}. The bending moment varies linearly:

M(x)=Wc2x=2MpLx(0≤x≤L2)M(x) = \frac{W_c}{2} x = \frac{2 M_p}{L} x \quad \left(0 \le x \le \frac{L}{2}\right)

At the boundary of the plastic zone, M(x1)=MyM(x_1) = M_y:

2MpLx1=My=MpS  ⟹  x1=L2S\frac{2 M_p}{L} x_1 = M_y = \frac{M_p}{S} \implies x_1 = \frac{L}{2S}

The yielding extends on both sides of the center:

Lp=L−2x1=L−2(L2S)=L(1−1S)L_p = L - 2 x_1 = L - 2\left(\frac{L}{2S}\right) = L \left(1 - \frac{1}{S}\right)
  • For a Rectangular Section (S=1.5S = 1.5): Lp=L(1−11.5)=L3≈0.3333LL_p = L \left( 1 - \frac{1}{1.5} \right) = \frac{L}{3} \approx 0.3333 L
  • For an I-Section (S=1.15S = 1.15): Lp=L(1−11.15)≈0.1304LL_p = L \left( 1 - \frac{1}{1.15} \right) \approx 0.1304 L

Case B: Simply Supported Beam with Uniformly Distributed Load wcw_c

At collapse, the mid-span moment reaches Mp=wcL28M_p = \frac{w_c L^2}{8}. The bending moment equation referenced from mid-span (z=0z = 0 at mid-span, −L/2≤z≤L/2-L/2 \le z \le L/2) is:

M(z)=Mp(1−4z2L2)M(z) = M_p \left( 1 - \frac{4 z^2}{L^2} \right)

At the boundary of the plastic zone, M(z1)=My=MpSM(z_1) = M_y = \frac{M_p}{S}:

Mp(1−4z12L2)=MpS  ⟹  4z12L2=1−1SM_p \left( 1 - \frac{4 z_1^2}{L^2} \right) = \frac{M_p}{S} \implies \frac{4 z_1^2}{L^2} = 1 - \frac{1}{S} 2z1=L1−1S2 z_1 = L \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{S}}

Since Lp=2z1L_p = 2 z_1:

Lp=L1−1SL_p = L \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{S}}
  • For a Rectangular Section (S=1.5S = 1.5): Lp=L1−11.5=L13=L3≈0.5774LL_p = L \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{1.5}} = L \sqrt{\frac{1}{3}} = \frac{L}{\sqrt{3}} \approx \mathbf{0.5774 L}
  • For an I-Section (S=1.15S = 1.15): Lp=L1−11.15=L0.1304≈0.3612LL_p = L \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{1.15}} = L \sqrt{0.1304} \approx \mathbf{0.3612 L}

6. Practical Engineering Applications & Codal Provisions (IS 800:2007)

  1. Classification of Cross-Sections (IS 800:2007, Clause 3.7):
    • Class 1 (Plastic): Cross-sections can develop plastic moment capacity MpM_p and possess sufficient rotation capacity (θp≥3θy\theta_p \ge 3 \theta_y) to form a plastic mechanism. Only Class 1 sections are permitted for plastic analysis.
    • Class 2 (Compact): Cross-sections can develop MpM_p but have limited rotation capacity due to local buckling. Allowed in elastic analysis with limit state design, but not for plastic redistribution.
    • Class 3 (Semi-Compact): Extreme fiber reaches fyf_y (MyM_y), but local buckling prevents development of MpM_p.
    • Class 4 (Slender): Local buckling occurs before the yield stress is reached in extreme fibers.
  2. Width-to-Thickness Ratio Limits (b/tb/t, d/twd/t_w): For rolled I-sections to qualify as Class 1 (Plastic):
    • Flange projection: b/tf≤9.4ϵb/t_f \le 9.4 \epsilon, where ϵ=250/fy\epsilon = \sqrt{250 / f_y}.
    • Web under neutral axis at mid-depth: d/tw≤84ϵd/t_w \le 84 \epsilon.
  3. Effect of High Shear Force on Plastic Moment Capacity (Clause 9.2.2): When the factored shear force V≤0.6VdV \le 0.6 V_d, the plastic moment capacity is unaffected (Mdv=MdM_{dv} = M_d). When V>0.6VdV > 0.6 V_d ("High Shear"): Mdv=Md−β(Md−Mfd)≤1.2Zefy/γm0M_{dv} = M_d - \beta (M_d - M_{fd}) \le 1.2 Z_e f_y / \gamma_{m0} where β=(2VVd−1)2\beta = \left(\frac{2V}{V_d} - 1\right)^2 and MfdM_{fd} is the plastic moment capacity of the flanges only.

7. Worked Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Unsymmetric T-Section (ENA vs PNA, ZeZ_e, ZpZ_p, and Shape Factor)

Statement: A structural steel T-section has a flange of 150 mm×20 mm150\text{ mm} \times 20\text{ mm} and a web of 20 mm×180 mm20\text{ mm} \times 180\text{ mm}. The steel yield strength is fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}.

  1. Determine the position of the Elastic Neutral Axis (ENA) and the Plastic Neutral Axis (PNA) from the top fiber.
  2. Calculate the elastic section modulus (ZeZ_e) and yield moment (MyM_y).
  3. Calculate the plastic section modulus (ZpZ_p) and plastic moment capacity (MpM_p).
  4. Compute the Shape Factor (SS) and the shift between ENA and PNA (Δy\Delta y).
        <--------- 150 mm --------->
       +----------------------------+  ^ 20 mm
       |          Flange            |  v
       +------------+---+-----------+
                    |   |
                    | W |
                    | e |  180 mm
                    | b |
                    |   |  (Width = 20 mm)
                    +---+

Solution:

Step 1: Total Area and Location of Elastic Neutral Axis (ENA)

  • Flange Area: A1=150×20=3000 mm2A_1 = 150 \times 20 = 3000\text{ mm}^2, centroid from top: y1=10 mmy_1 = 10\text{ mm}.
  • Web Area: A2=20×180=3600 mm2A_2 = 20 \times 180 = 3600\text{ mm}^2, centroid from top: y2=20+1802=110 mmy_2 = 20 + \frac{180}{2} = 110\text{ mm}.
  • Total Area: A=A1+A2=3000+3600=6600 mm2A = A_1 + A_2 = 3000 + 3600 = 6600\text{ mm}^2.
  • Centroid from top fiber (yˉtop\bar{y}_{\text{top}}): yˉtop=A1y1+A2y2A=(3000×10)+(3600×110)6600=30000+3960006600=4260006600=64.5455 mm\bar{y}_{\text{top}} = \frac{A_1 y_1 + A_2 y_2}{A} = \frac{(3000 \times 10) + (3600 \times 110)}{6600} = \frac{30000 + 396000}{6600} = \frac{426000}{6600} = \mathbf{64.5455\text{ mm}}
  • Distance to bottom fiber: yˉbot=200−64.5455=135.4545 mm\bar{y}_{\text{bot}} = 200 - 64.5455 = \mathbf{135.4545\text{ mm}} Since yˉbot>yˉtop\bar{y}_{\text{bot}} > \bar{y}_{\text{top}}, ymax⁡=135.4545 mmy_{\max} = 135.4545\text{ mm}.

Step 2: Moment of Inertia (IxxI_{xx}) and Elastic Modulus (ZeZ_e) Using the parallel axis theorem:

  • Flange: Ix1=150×20312+3000×(64.5455−10)2=100000+3000×(54.5455)2=100000+8925620=9,025,620 mm4I_{x1} = \frac{150 \times 20^3}{12} + 3000 \times (64.5455 - 10)^2 = 100000 + 3000 \times (54.5455)^2 = 100000 + 8925620 = 9,025,620\text{ mm}^4
  • Web: Ix2=20×180312+3600×(110−64.5455)2=9720000+3600×(45.4545)2=9720000+7438016=17,158,016 mm4I_{x2} = \frac{20 \times 180^3}{12} + 3600 \times (110 - 64.5455)^2 = 9720000 + 3600 \times (45.4545)^2 = 9720000 + 7438016 = 17,158,016\text{ mm}^4
  • Total IxxI_{xx}: Ixx=9025620+17158016=26.1836×106 mm4I_{xx} = 9025620 + 17158016 = \mathbf{26.1836 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4}
  • Elastic Section Modulus (ZeZ_e): Ze=Ixxymax⁡=26.1836×106135.4545=193,302.01 mm3Z_e = \frac{I_{xx}}{y_{\max}} = \frac{26.1836 \times 10^6}{135.4545} = \mathbf{193,302.01\text{ mm}^3}
  • Yield Moment: My=fy⋅Ze=250×193302.01×10−6=48.3255 kNmM_y = f_y \cdot Z_e = 250 \times 193302.01 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{48.3255\text{ kNm}}

Step 3: Location of Plastic Neutral Axis (PNA) The PNA divides the section into two equal areas: At=Ac=A2=66002=3300 mm2A_t = A_c = \frac{A}{2} = \frac{6600}{2} = 3300\text{ mm}^2.

  • Flange area is 3000 mm2<3300 mm23000\text{ mm}^2 < 3300\text{ mm}^2, hence the PNA must lie within the web.
  • Let ypy_p be the depth into the web from the junction of flange and web: Aflange+tw⋅yp=3300  ⟹  3000+20⋅yp=3300  ⟹  yp=30020=15.0 mmA_{\text{flange}} + t_w \cdot y_p = 3300 \implies 3000 + 20 \cdot y_p = 3300 \implies y_p = \frac{300}{20} = 15.0\text{ mm}
  • Distance of PNA from top fiber: yPNA=20+15=35.0000 mmy_{\text{PNA}} = 20 + 15 = \mathbf{35.0000\text{ mm}}
  • Shift between ENA and PNA: Δy=yˉtop−yPNA=64.5455−35.0000=29.5455 mm\Delta y = \bar{y}_{\text{top}} - y_{\text{PNA}} = 64.5455 - 35.0000 = \mathbf{29.5455\text{ mm}}

Step 4: Plastic Section Modulus (ZpZ_p) and Plastic Moment (MpM_p) Taking first moments of area about the PNA:

  • Compression zone (above PNA, depth 35 mm35\text{ mm}):
    • Flange (150×20150 \times 20): area Ac1=3000 mm2A_{c1} = 3000\text{ mm}^2, lever arm to PNA =35−10=25 mm= 35 - 10 = 25\text{ mm}.
    • Web portion (20×1520 \times 15): area Ac2=300 mm2A_{c2} = 300\text{ mm}^2, lever arm to PNA =15/2=7.5 mm= 15 / 2 = 7.5\text{ mm}.
    • Compressive first moment: Acyˉc=(3000×25)+(300×7.5)=75000+2250=77,250 mm3A_c \bar{y}_c = (3000 \times 25) + (300 \times 7.5) = 75000 + 2250 = 77,250\text{ mm}^3
  • Tension zone (below PNA, depth 200−35=165 mm200 - 35 = 165\text{ mm}):
    • Remaining web (20×16520 \times 165): area At=3300 mm2A_t = 3300\text{ mm}^2, lever arm to PNA =165/2=82.5 mm= 165 / 2 = 82.5\text{ mm}.
    • Tensile first moment: Atyˉt=3300×82.5=272,250 mm3A_t \bar{y}_t = 3300 \times 82.5 = 272,250\text{ mm}^3
  • Total Plastic Section Modulus: Zp=Acyˉc+Atyˉt=77250+272250=349,500.00 mm3Z_p = A_c \bar{y}_c + A_t \bar{y}_t = 77250 + 272250 = \mathbf{349,500.00\text{ mm}^3}
  • Plastic Moment Capacity: Mp=fy⋅Zp=250×349500×10−6=87.3750 kNmM_p = f_y \cdot Z_p = 250 \times 349500 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{87.3750\text{ kNm}}

Step 5: Shape Factor (SS)

S=ZpZe=349500.00193302.01=1.8081S = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e} = \frac{349500.00}{193302.01} = \mathbf{1.8081}

(The section possesses an 80.81% reserve flexural strength beyond elastic yield).


Problem 2: Built-Up Symmetric I-Section (IS 800 Class Check & Shape Factor)

Statement: A built-up I-girder consists of two flange plates of 200 mm×12 mm200\text{ mm} \times 12\text{ mm} and a web plate of 10 mm×276 mm10\text{ mm} \times 276\text{ mm}. Total overall depth is D=300 mmD = 300\text{ mm}. Yield stress fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}.

  1. Verify the section classification per IS 800:2007 (Class 1 Plastic).
  2. Calculate IxxI_{xx}, ZeZ_e, and MyM_y.
  3. Calculate ZpZ_p, MpM_p, and Shape Factor SS.

Solution:

Step 1: Section Classification (IS 800:2007 Table 2)

  • ϵ=250/250=1.0\epsilon = \sqrt{250 / 250} = 1.0.
  • Flange outstand b=B−tw2=200−102=95 mmb = \frac{B - t_w}{2} = \frac{200 - 10}{2} = 95\text{ mm}.
  • Flange ratio: btf=9512=7.917≤9.4ϵ\frac{b}{t_f} = \frac{95}{12} = 7.917 \le 9.4 \epsilon (9.49.4)   ⟹  \implies Flange is Class 1 (Plastic).
  • Web depth between flanges: dw=300−2(12)=276 mmd_w = 300 - 2(12) = 276\text{ mm}.
  • Web ratio: dwtw=27610=27.6≤84ϵ\frac{d_w}{t_w} = \frac{276}{10} = 27.6 \le 84 \epsilon (8484)   ⟹  \implies Web is Class 1 (Plastic).
  • Therefore, the cross-section is Class 1 (Plastic) and can develop full plastic hinge rotation.

Step 2: Elastic Properties (Ixx,Ze,MyI_{xx}, Z_e, M_y)

  • By symmetry, ENA and PNA both lie at mid-depth: yˉ=150 mm\bar{y} = 150\text{ mm}.
  • Moment of inertia using subtraction method: Ixx=BD312−(B−tw)dw312=200×300312−190×276312I_{xx} = \frac{B D^3}{12} - \frac{(B - t_w) d_w^3}{12} = \frac{200 \times 300^3}{12} - \frac{190 \times 276^3}{12} Ixx=450×106−190×21,024,57612=450×106−332.88912×106=117.11088×106 mm4I_{xx} = 450 \times 10^6 - \frac{190 \times 21,024,576}{12} = 450 \times 10^6 - 332.88912 \times 10^6 = \mathbf{117.11088 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4}
  • Elastic Modulus: Ze=IxxD/2=117.11088×106150=780,739.20 mm3Z_e = \frac{I_{xx}}{D/2} = \frac{117.11088 \times 10^6}{150} = \mathbf{780,739.20\text{ mm}^3}
  • Yield Moment: My=250×780739.20×10−6=195.1848 kNmM_y = 250 \times 780739.20 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{195.1848\text{ kNm}}

Step 3: Plastic Properties (Zp,Mp,SZ_p, M_p, S) By symmetry, Zp=2×(First moment of half-area about PNA)Z_p = 2 \times (\text{First moment of half-area about PNA}):

  • Half-flange: area Af1=200×12=2400 mm2A_{f1} = 200 \times 12 = 2400\text{ mm}^2, lever arm =150−6=144 mm= 150 - 6 = 144\text{ mm}.
  • Half-web: area Aw1=10×138=1380 mm2A_{w1} = 10 \times 138 = 1380\text{ mm}^2, lever arm =138/2=69 mm= 138 / 2 = 69\text{ mm}.
  • First moment of half-area: Qhalf=(2400×144)+(1380×69)=345600+95220=440,820 mm3Q_{\text{half}} = (2400 \times 144) + (1380 \times 69) = 345600 + 95220 = 440,820\text{ mm}^3
  • Total Plastic Section Modulus: Zp=2×440820=881,640.00 mm3Z_p = 2 \times 440820 = \mathbf{881,640.00\text{ mm}^3}
  • Plastic Moment Capacity: Mp=250×881640.00×10−6=220.4100 kNmM_p = 250 \times 881640.00 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{220.4100\text{ kNm}}
  • Shape Factor: S=ZpZe=881640.00780739.20=1.1292S = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e} = \frac{881640.00}{780739.20} = \mathbf{1.1292}

(Reserve capacity is 12.92%, typical for well-proportioned I-sections).


Problem 3: Length of Plastic Hinge (Point Load vs. UDL Comparison)

Statement: A simply supported beam of rectangular cross-section (b=150 mm,d=300 mmb = 150\text{ mm}, d = 300\text{ mm}) spans L=6.0 mL = 6.0\text{ m}. Yield stress fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}.

  1. Find MyM_y and MpM_p.
  2. If the beam carries a central concentrated load, find the collapse load WcW_c and the total length of the plastic hinge LpL_p.
  3. If the beam carries a uniformly distributed load over its entire span, find the collapse load wcw_c and the total length of the plastic hinge LpL_p.
  4. Compare the plastic hinge lengths for the two load cases.

Solution:

Step 1: Section Moduli & Moment Capacities

  • Rectangular section: Ze=bd26=150×30026=2.25×106 mm3Z_e = \frac{b d^2}{6} = \frac{150 \times 300^2}{6} = 2.25 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 My=250×2.25×106×10−6=562.50 kNmM_y = 250 \times 2.25 \times 10^6 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{562.50\text{ kNm}} Zp=bd24=150×30024=3.375×106 mm3Z_p = \frac{b d^2}{4} = \frac{150 \times 300^2}{4} = 3.375 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 Mp=250×3.375×106×10−6=843.75 kNmM_p = 250 \times 3.375 \times 10^6 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{843.75\text{ kNm}} S=ZpZe=3.3752.25=1.500S = \frac{Z_p}{Z_e} = \frac{3.375}{2.25} = \mathbf{1.500}

Step 2: Central Concentrated Load

  • Collapse occurs when mid-span moment reaches MpM_p: Mmax⁡=WcL4=Mp  ⟹  Wc=4MpL=4×843.756.0=562.50 kNM_{\max} = \frac{W_c L}{4} = M_p \implies W_c = \frac{4 M_p}{L} = \frac{4 \times 843.75}{6.0} = \mathbf{562.50\text{ kN}}
  • Yield load (when outer fiber yields): Wy=4MyL=4×562.506.0=375.00 kNW_y = \frac{4 M_y}{L} = \frac{4 \times 562.50}{6.0} = 375.00\text{ kN}
  • Plastic Hinge Length LpL_p: Lp=L(1−1S)=6.0(1−11.5)=6.0×13=2.000 m=L3L_p = L \left(1 - \frac{1}{S}\right) = 6.0 \left(1 - \frac{1}{1.5}\right) = 6.0 \times \frac{1}{3} = \mathbf{2.000\text{ m}} = \frac{L}{3} (Plastic yielding extends 1.0 m1.0\text{ m} on either side of the concentrated load).

Step 3: Uniformly Distributed Load (UDL)

  • Collapse occurs when mid-span moment reaches MpM_p: Mmax⁡=wcL28=Mp  ⟹  wc=8MpL2=8×843.756.02=675036=187.50 kN/mM_{\max} = \frac{w_c L^2}{8} = M_p \implies w_c = \frac{8 M_p}{L^2} = \frac{8 \times 843.75}{6.0^2} = \frac{6750}{36} = \mathbf{187.50\text{ kN/m}}
  • Yield load: wy=8MyL2=8×562.5036=125.00 kN/mw_y = \frac{8 M_y}{L^2} = \frac{8 \times 562.50}{36} = 125.00\text{ kN/m}
  • Plastic Hinge Length LpL_p: Lp=L1−1S=6.0×1−11.5=6.0×13=6.03=23≈3.4641 m≈0.5774LL_p = L \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{S}} = 6.0 \times \sqrt{1 - \frac{1}{1.5}} = 6.0 \times \sqrt{\frac{1}{3}} = \frac{6.0}{\sqrt{3}} = 2\sqrt{3} \approx \mathbf{3.4641\text{ m}} \approx 0.5774 L (Plastic yielding extends 1.732 m1.732\text{ m} on either side of the center).

Step 4: Comparison & Observation

  • Under central point load: Lp=2.000 mL_p = 2.000\text{ m} (33.33%33.33\% of span).
  • Under UDL: Lp=3.464 mL_p = 3.464\text{ m} (57.74%57.74\% of span).
  • The plastic hinge length under UDL is 1.7321.732 times greater (3\sqrt{3} times) than under a central point load because the bending moment diagram has a flat parabolic peak compared to a sharp triangular apex.

8. Common Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls

[!CAUTION]

  1. PNA Does Not Always Pass Through Centroid: For any unsymmetric section (T-section, unequal angle, channel loaded in symmetry plane), the PNA is strictly the equal-area axis, whereas the ENA is the centroidal axis. The distance between ENA and PNA (Δy=yˉ−yp\Delta y = \bar{y} - y_p) creates an internal eccentricity.
  2. Plastic Hinge is Not a Frictionless Mechanical Pin: A mechanical hinge transmits zero bending moment (M=0M = 0). A plastic hinge transmits a constant, non-zero resisting moment equal to the full plastic capacity (M=MpM = M_p).
  3. Curvature at Plastic Hinge: In idealized rigid-plastic theory, curvature at a plastic hinge is mathematically infinite (ϕ→∞\phi \to \infty), meaning there is a finite slope discontinuity (kink θ\theta). In reality, strain hardening limits the localized strain.
  4. Shape Factor is Purely Geometric: The shape factor S=Zp/ZeS = Z_p / Z_e depends solely on the geometric shape of the cross-section and is independent of material yield stress fyf_y or Young's modulus EE.
  5. Hinge Length Under UDL vs. Point Load: Do not confuse Lp=L(1−1/S)L_p = L(1 - 1/S) with Lp=L1−1/SL_p = L\sqrt{1 - 1/S}. The square root applies strictly to parabolic moment distributions (UDL).

9. Comparative Summary & Formula Matrix

Property / Parameter Elastic Bending (WSM) Fully Plastic Bending (Limit State)
Stress Distribution Linear (σ=Eκy\sigma = E \kappa y) Biform Constant (+fy+f_y tension, −fy-f_y compression)
Neutral Axis Position Centroidal Axis (∫ydA=0\int y dA = 0) Equal-Area Axis (Ac=At=A/2A_c = A_t = A/2)
Section Modulus Ze=I/ymax⁡Z_e = I / y_{\max} Zp=A/2⋅(yˉc+yˉt)Z_p = A/2 \cdot (\bar{y}_c + \bar{y}_t)
Resisting Moment My=fyZeM_y = f_y Z_e Mp=fyZpM_p = f_y Z_p
Curvature ϕ\phi Finite: ϕ=M/EI\phi = M / EI Theoretical kink (ϕ→∞\phi \to \infty at hinge)
Rotation Capacity Negligible plastic rotation Substantial plastic rotation (θp\theta_p) required
Governing Limit Extreme fiber reach fyf_y Whole section plastified (M=MpM = M_p)

10. Practice Questions & Competitive Examination Problems

Multiple Choice & Objective Questions

  1. [GATE CE] The shape factor of a diamond cross-section with diagonals placed horizontally and vertically is:

    • (A) 1.501.50
    • (B) 1.701.70
    • (C) 2.002.00
    • (D) 2.342.34
      Answer: (C) S=2.00S = 2.00.
  2. [ESE CE] A simply supported beam of span LL and rectangular section is subjected to a concentrated load at mid-span. At plastic collapse, the length of the plastic hinge is:

    • (A) L/2L/2
    • (B) L/3L/3
    • (C) L/4L/4
    • (D) L/3L / \sqrt{3}
      Answer: (B) L(1−1/S)=L(1−1/1.5)=L/3L(1 - 1/S) = L(1 - 1/1.5) = L/3.
  3. [SSC JE] The ratio of plastic section modulus to elastic section modulus is known as:

    • (A) Load factor
    • (B) Factor of safety
    • (C) Shape factor
    • (D) Plasticity index
      Answer: (C) Shape factor.
  4. [State AE] In an unsymmetric cross-section subjected to pure bending, the plastic neutral axis:

    • (A) Coincides with the centroidal axis
    • (B) Divides the section into equal areas
    • (C) Divides the section into equal moments of inertia
    • (D) Passes through the extreme fiber
      Answer: (B) Divides the section into equal areas (Ac=AtA_c = A_t).

11. References & Code Standards

  • IS 800:2007: General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice, Section 3 (Classification of Cross-Sections), Section 8 (Design of Members Subjected to Bending), Section 12 (Plastic Design).
  • IS 808:1989: Dimensions for Rolled Steel Beam, Column, Channel and Angle Sections.
  • AISC 360-16: Specification for Structural Steel Buildings, American Institute of Steel Construction.
  • Eurocode 3 (EN 1993-1-1): Design of Steel Structures — General Rules and Rules for Buildings.
  • Baker, J. F., & Heyman, J. (1969). Plastic Design of Frames. Cambridge University Press.