SA-04-02 Chapter 04 · Influence Line Diagrams & Moving Loads

Moving Loads & Maximum Internal Force Envelopes

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Module Header & Metadata Block
  2. 2. Theoretical Foundations & Physical Concepts
  3. 2.1 The Nature of Live Loads on Bridge Structures
  4. 2.2 Definitions of Key Governing Concepts
  5. 3. Mathematical Derivations & Analytical Formulations
  6. 3.1 Single Concentrated Moving Load (W)
  7. 3.2 Uniformly Distributed Load (UDL) Longer Than the Span (w, Length u ≥ L)
  8. 3.3 Uniformly Distributed Load (UDL) Shorter Than the Span (w, Length u < L)
  9. 3.4 System of Concentrated Moving Loads (Train of Axle Loads)
  10. 3.5 Absolute Maximum Bending Moment Across the Entire Span: The Focal Point Theorem
  11. 4. Critical Conditions & Governing Theorems
  12. 4.1 Step-by-Step Procedure to Find Absolute Maximum Bending Moment
  13. 4.2 Maximum Shear Force Under a Wheel Train
  14. 5. Cross-Sectional & Engineering Schematics
  15. 5.1 Maximum Shear Force and Bending Moment Envelopes
  16. 5.2 The Focal Point Theorem for Axle Trains
  17. 6. Solved Numerical Examples
  18. Example 1: Envelopes for Single Concentrated Load and Short UDL
  19. Example 2: Critical Wheel and Maximum Bending Moment at a Specified Section
  20. Example 3: Absolute Maximum Bending Moment using Focal Point Theorem
  21. 7. Engineering Design Applications & Field Practice
  22. 7.1 Bridge Girder Flange Cover Plate Cut-offs
  23. 7.2 Web Plate Stiffener Spacing
  24. 7.3 Standard Design Vehicle Load Models
  25. 8. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix
  26. 8.1 Summary of Governing Formulas for Simply Supported Span L
  27. 9. Common Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls
  28. 10. Previous Years' Examination Analysis & Reference Questions
  29. 10.1 Typical Exam Questions
  30. 11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys
  31. Problem 1 (Point Load Envelope)
  32. Problem 2 (Short UDL on Bridge Girder)
  33. Problem 3 (Two Wheel Loads)
  34. 12. Comprehensive Subject & Examination Mapping

1. Module Header & Metadata Block

  • Topic ID: SA-04-02
  • Module: Structural Analysis (Subject 03)
  • Chapter: Chapter 04: Influence Line Diagrams & Moving Loads
  • Title: Moving Loads & Maximum Internal Force Envelopes
  • Target Examinations:
    • GATE Civil Engineering (Structural Engineering)
    • UPSC Engineering Services Examination (ESE/IES Paper-I)
    • SSC JE Civil Engineering (Theory of Structures)
    • State Public Service Commission Assistant Engineer (AE) & Junior Engineer (JE) Examinations
    • Railway Recruitment Board Junior Engineer (RRB JE)
  • Prerequisites:
    • Topic SA-04-01: Influence Lines for Determinate Beams & Girders
    • Topic SOM-03-01 to SOM-03-04: Shear Force and Bending Moment Diagrams
  • Learning Objectives:
    1. Distinguish mathematically and conceptually between the maximum internal force at a specified section and the absolute maximum internal force across the entire span.
    2. Construct maximum positive and negative shear force envelopes and maximum bending moment envelopes for rolling concentrated loads and uniformly distributed loads (UDL).
    3. Formulate and apply the Average Load Criterion to determine the critical wheel load producing the maximum bending moment at any given cross-section.
    4. Derive and apply the Focal Point Theorem (Center of Gravity Theorem) to compute the absolute maximum bending moment under a system of moving axle loads.
    5. Apply moving load envelopes to real-world highway and railway bridge girder design according to Indian Road Congress (IRC:6) and Railway Board standards.

2. Theoretical Foundations & Physical Concepts

2.1 The Nature of Live Loads on Bridge Structures

Unlike buildings where gravity dead loads dominate, bridge superstructures (highway overpasses, railway truss spans, plate girder bridges) are primarily governed by transient, moving live loads. Highway traffic consists of multi-axle commercial vehicles (trucks, tractor-trailers, abnormal permit loads), while railway bridges experience heavy locomotive trains followed by freight wagons.

As a vehicular system traverses a bridge span:

  1. The magnitude and distribution of shear force and bending moment vary continuously at every section.
  2. The maximum internal force experienced by a specific cross-section does not occur simultaneously with the maximum internal force at adjacent cross-sections.
  3. Therefore, an ordinary Shear Force Diagram (SFD) or Bending Moment Diagram (BMD)—which represents internal forces for a fixed, stationary load configuration—is insufficient for structural design.

2.2 Definitions of Key Governing Concepts

Maximum Internal Force at a Specific Section xx

The peak shear force (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x), Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x)) or bending moment (Mmax⁡(x)M_{\max}(x)) that develops at cross-section xx as the moving load system rolls across the span from one support to the other.

Absolute Maximum Internal Force Across the Span

The single largest value of shear force (Vabs,max⁡V_{\text{abs},\max}) or bending moment (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}) that can occur at any cross-section throughout the entire length LL of the beam for any possible position of the moving load system:

Vabs,max⁡=max⁡x∈[0,L]{Vmax⁡(x)},Mabs,max⁡=max⁡x∈[0,L]{Mmax⁡(x)}V_{\text{abs},\max} = \max_{x \in [0, L]} \{ V_{\max}(x) \}, \quad M_{\text{abs},\max} = \max_{x \in [0, L]} \{ M_{\max}(x) \}

Internal Force Envelope

A continuous graphical curve that plots the maximum positive and negative design values (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x), Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x), Mmax⁡(x)M_{\max}(x)) as a function of the spatial coordinate xx along the span. The structural engineer designs each cross-section (or determines plate thicknesses and flange cover-plate curtailment cut-offs) to safely envelop this maximum internal force curve.


3. Mathematical Derivations & Analytical Formulations

Consider a simply supported beam ABAB of span LL resting on a pin support at AA (x=0x = 0) and a roller support at BB (x=Lx = L).


3.1 Single Concentrated Moving Load (WW)

Let a single point load of magnitude WW traverse the span from left to right.

          W (Moving ->)
          v
   A o==================o B
  x=0        Span L    x=L

(a) Maximum Positive Shear Force Envelope (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x))

Recall from SA-04-01 that the Influence Line Diagram (ILD) for shear force at section xx has:

  • A positive ordinate to the right of xx, with peak value +(L−x)/L+ (L - x)/L occurring when the load is placed immediately to the right of section xx (x+x^+).
  • Therefore, the maximum positive shear force at section xx is: Vmax⁡+(x)=W(L−xL)V_{\max}^+(x) = W \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right)
  • Boundary Values:
    • At support AA (x=0x = 0): Vmax⁡+(0)=+WV_{\max}^+(0) = +W
    • At midspan (x=L/2x = L/2): Vmax⁡+(L/2)=+W/2V_{\max}^+(L/2) = +W/2
    • At support BB (x=Lx = L): Vmax⁡+(L)=0V_{\max}^+(L) = 0
  • Envelope Profile: A straight line descending linearly from +W+W at AA to 00 at BB.

(b) Maximum Negative Shear Force Envelope (Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x))

The ILD has a negative ordinate to the left of xx, with peak value −x/L- x/L occurring when the load is placed immediately to the left of section xx (x−x^-).

  • The maximum negative shear force at section xx is: Vmax⁡−(x)=−W(xL)V_{\max}^-(x) = - W \left(\frac{x}{L}\right)
  • Boundary Values:
    • At support AA (x=0x = 0): Vmax⁡−(0)=0V_{\max}^-(0) = 0
    • At midspan (x=L/2x = L/2): Vmax⁡−(L/2)=−W/2V_{\max}^-(L/2) = -W/2
    • At support BB (x=Lx = L): Vmax⁡−(L)=−WV_{\max}^-(L) = -W
  • Envelope Profile: A straight line descending linearly from 00 at AA to −W-W at BB.
  • Absolute Maximum Shear Force: Vabs,max⁡=±W(Occurs at the supports A and B)V_{\text{abs},\max} = \pm W \quad \text{(Occurs at the supports } A \text{ and } B\text{)}

(c) Maximum Bending Moment Envelope (Mmax⁡(x)M_{\max}(x))

For any cross-section xx, the ILD for bending moment is triangular, with a maximum ordinate at section xx:

ηmax⁡(x)=x(L−x)L\eta_{\max}(x) = \frac{x (L - x)}{L}
  • Maximum moment occurs when the concentrated load WW sits directly over section xx: Mmax⁡(x)=W⋅ηmax⁡(x)=Wx(L−x)LM_{\max}(x) = W \cdot \eta_{\max}(x) = \frac{W x (L - x)}{L}
  • Equation of the Envelope: Notice that Mmax⁡(x)=WL(Lx−x2)M_{\max}(x) = \frac{W}{L} (L x - x^2). This is the equation of a symmetrical second-degree parabola with vertex at midspan: dMmax⁡dx=WL(L−2x)=0  ⟹  x=L2\frac{d M_{\max}}{dx} = \frac{W}{L} (L - 2x) = 0 \implies x = \frac{L}{2}
  • Absolute Maximum Bending Moment: Mabs,max⁡=Mmax⁡(L2)=W(L/2)(L/2)L=WL4M_{\text{abs},\max} = M_{\max}\left(\frac{L}{2}\right) = \frac{W (L/2)(L/2)}{L} = \frac{W L}{4}

3.2 Uniformly Distributed Load (UDL) Longer Than the Span (ww, Length u≥Lu \ge L)

Let a continuous UDL of intensity ww (kN/m\text{kN/m}) and length u≥Lu \ge L cross the bridge.

(a) Maximum Positive Shear Force Envelope (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x))

To maximize positive shear, the UDL must cover the entire positive segment of the shear ILD (from section xx to support BB, length L−xL - x):

Vmax⁡+(x)=w×[Area of positive triangle]=w×[12(L−x)(L−xL)]=w(L−x)22LV_{\max}^+(x) = w \times [\text{Area of positive triangle}] = w \times \left[\frac{1}{2} (L - x) \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right)\right] = \frac{w (L - x)^2}{2L}
  • Profile: A parabolic curve of second degree, concave upwards.
  • At x=0x = 0: Vmax⁡+(0)=wL2V_{\max}^+(0) = \frac{w L}{2}
  • At x=L/2x = L/2: Vmax⁡+(L/2)=wL8V_{\max}^+(L/2) = \frac{w L}{8}
  • At x=Lx = L: Vmax⁡+(L)=0V_{\max}^+(L) = 0

(b) Maximum Negative Shear Force Envelope (Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x))

To maximize negative shear, the UDL must cover the negative segment of the shear ILD (from support AA to section xx, length xx):

Vmax⁡−(x)=−w×[Area of negative triangle]=−w×[12x(xL)]=−wx22LV_{\max}^-(x) = - w \times [\text{Area of negative triangle}] = - w \times \left[\frac{1}{2} x \left(\frac{x}{L}\right)\right] = - \frac{w x^2}{2L}
  • Profile: A parabolic curve of second degree.
  • At x=0x = 0: Vmax⁡−(0)=0V_{\max}^-(0) = 0
  • At x=L/2x = L/2: Vmax⁡−(L/2)=−wL8V_{\max}^-(L/2) = - \frac{w L}{8}
  • At x=Lx = L: Vmax⁡−(L)=−wL2V_{\max}^-(L) = - \frac{w L}{2}
  • Absolute Maximum Shear Force: Vabs,max⁡=±wL2(At the supports)V_{\text{abs},\max} = \pm \frac{w L}{2} \quad \text{(At the supports)}

(c) Maximum Bending Moment Envelope (Mmax⁡(x)M_{\max}(x))

Since the bending moment ILD is entirely positive across the span, the bending moment at any section xx is maximized when the entire span is loaded (00 to LL):

Mmax⁡(x)=w×[Total area of ILD]=w×[12L(x(L−x)L)]=wx(L−x)2M_{\max}(x) = w \times [\text{Total area of ILD}] = w \times \left[\frac{1}{2} L \left(\frac{x(L - x)}{L}\right)\right] = \frac{w x (L - x)}{2}
  • This is identical to the standard static BMD of a simply supported beam under full UDL!
  • Absolute Maximum Bending Moment: Mabs,max⁡=wL28at midspan x=L2M_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{w L^2}{8} \quad \text{at midspan } x = \frac{L}{2}

3.3 Uniformly Distributed Load (UDL) Shorter Than the Span (ww, Length u<Lu < L)

Let a UDL of intensity ww and total length uu (u<Lu < L) roll across the beam. Total load W=w⋅uW = w \cdot u.

(a) Maximum Shear Force at Section xx

  • Maximum Positive Shear (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x)):
    • Case 1: If (L−x)≥u(L - x) \ge u, the head of the UDL is placed exactly at section xx, extending to the right by distance uu. The area under the ILD is a trapezoid with height L−xL\frac{L - x}{L} at xx and L−x−uL\frac{L - x - u}{L} at x+ux + u: Vmax⁡+(x)=w×u2[L−xL+L−x−uL]=wuL(L−x−u2)V_{\max}^+(x) = w \times \frac{u}{2} \left[\frac{L - x}{L} + \frac{L - x - u}{L}\right] = \frac{w u}{L} \left(L - x - \frac{u}{2}\right)
    • Case 2: If (L−x)<u(L - x) < u, the load extends all the way to support BB. The effective loaded length is (L−x)(L - x): Vmax⁡+(x)=w(L−x)22LV_{\max}^+(x) = \frac{w (L - x)^2}{2L}
  • Maximum Negative Shear (Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x)):
    • Case 1: If x≥ux \ge u, the tail of the UDL is placed at section xx, extending to the left by distance uu: Vmax⁡−(x)=−wuL(x−u2)V_{\max}^-(x) = - \frac{w u}{L} \left(x - \frac{u}{2}\right)
    • Case 2: If x<ux < u, the load extends all the way to support AA: Vmax⁡−(x)=−wx22LV_{\max}^-(x) = - \frac{w x^2}{2L}

(b) Maximum Bending Moment at Section xx (The Average Load Criterion)

Let the UDL of length uu straddle section xx, with length x1x_1 lying to the left of xx and length x2=u−x1x_2 = u - x_1 to the right:

           <--- x1 ---> <--- x2 --->
          |===========|=============|   UDL w (length u)
   A -----+-----------+-------------+----- B
   0                  x                   L

The bending moment at section xx is:

M(x)=w∫[ILD ordinates under load]M(x) = w \int [\text{ILD ordinates under load}]

To maximize M(x)M(x) with respect to position, let the load shift by an infinitesimal distance dξd\xi to the right:

dM=w⋅ηhead⋅dξ−w⋅ηtail⋅dξ=w(ηhead−ηtail)dξdM = w \cdot \eta_{\text{head}} \cdot d\xi - w \cdot \eta_{\text{tail}} \cdot d\xi = w (\eta_{\text{head}} - \eta_{\text{tail}}) d\xi

For maximum moment, dMdξ=0  ⟹  ηhead=ηtail\frac{dM}{d\xi} = 0 \implies \eta_{\text{head}} = \eta_{\text{tail}}.

From the linear geometry of the triangular ILD:

ηtail=(x(L−x)L)(x−x1x)=(x−x1)(L−x)L\eta_{\text{tail}} = \left(\frac{x(L - x)}{L}\right) \left(\frac{x - x_1}{x}\right) = \frac{(x - x_1)(L - x)}{L} ηhead=(x(L−x)L)((L−x)−x2L−x)=x(L−x−x2)L\eta_{\text{head}} = \left(\frac{x(L - x)}{L}\right) \left(\frac{(L - x) - x_2}{L - x}\right) = \frac{x (L - x - x_2)}{L}

Equating ηtail=ηhead\eta_{\text{tail}} = \eta_{\text{head}}:

(x−x1)(L−x)=x(L−x−x2)(x - x_1)(L - x) = x (L - x - x_2) x(L−x)−x1(L−x)=x(L−x)−x⋅x2  ⟹  x1(L−x)=x⋅x2x(L - x) - x_1(L - x) = x(L - x) - x \cdot x_2 \implies x_1(L - x) = x \cdot x_2 x1x=x2L−x=x1+x2x+(L−x)=uL\frac{x_1}{x} = \frac{x_2}{L - x} = \frac{x_1 + x_2}{x + (L - x)} = \frac{u}{L}

[!IMPORTANT] Governing Criterion for Maximum Bending Moment under a Short UDL: The section xx must divide the load length uu in the exact same proportion as it divides the span LL:

x1x=x2L−x  ⟺  x1=u(xL),x2=u(L−xL)\frac{x_1}{x} = \frac{x_2}{L - x} \iff x_1 = u \left(\frac{x}{L}\right), \quad x_2 = u \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right)

Physical Interpretation (Average Load Equality):

Load on Left Segment ACLength of Left Segment AC=Load on Right Segment CBLength of Right Segment CB=Total Load on SpanTotal Span Length\frac{\text{Load on Left Segment } AC}{\text{Length of Left Segment } AC} = \frac{\text{Load on Right Segment } CB}{\text{Length of Right Segment } CB} = \frac{\text{Total Load on Span}}{\text{Total Span Length}}

Quantitative Formula for Mmax⁡(x)M_{\max}(x)

The area under the ILD over the loaded length uu is a trapezoid of width uu, parallel sides ηtail\eta_{\text{tail}} and ηmax⁡\eta_{\max}:

ηtail=x(L−x)L(1−uL)\eta_{\text{tail}} = \frac{x(L - x)}{L} \left(1 - \frac{u}{L}\right) Area=12u(ηtail+ηmax⁡)=12ux(L−x)L[(1−uL)+1]=ux(L−x)L(1−u2L)\text{Area} = \frac{1}{2} u (\eta_{\text{tail}} + \eta_{\max}) = \frac{1}{2} u \frac{x(L - x)}{L} \left[\left(1 - \frac{u}{L}\right) + 1\right] = \frac{u x (L - x)}{L} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right)

Multiplying by intensity ww (where total load W=wuW = w u):

Mmax⁡(x)=wux(L−x)L(1−u2L)=Wx(L−x)L(1−u2L)M_{\max}(x) = \frac{w u x (L - x)}{L} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) = \frac{W x (L - x)}{L} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right)

Absolute Maximum Bending Moment (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max})

Since x(L−x)x(L - x) is maximized at midspan (x=L/2x = L/2):

Mabs,max⁡=WL4(1−u2L)=wuL4−wu28M_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{W L}{4} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) = \frac{w u L}{4} - \frac{w u^2}{8}

3.4 System of Concentrated Moving Loads (Train of Axle Loads)

When a train of wheel loads W1,W2,W3,…,WnW_1, W_2, W_3, \dots, W_n traverses a beam, we must solve two distinct problems:

  1. Maximum bending moment at a specified section CC (xx).
  2. Absolute maximum bending moment across the entire span.
       W1       W2           W3       W4
       |        |            |        |      -> Moving
       v        v            v        v
  A ---+--------+------------+--------+-------- B
  0                                             L

3.4.1 Maximum Bending Moment at a Specified Section xx: The Rate of Change Criterion

Let the total resultant of all loads currently on the span be R=∑WiR = \sum W_i. Let the sum of loads currently to the left of section xx be WleftW_{\text{left}}.

As the train rolls a small distance Δξ\Delta \xi to the right:

  • All loads to the left climb up the positive slope +(L−x)/L+ (L - x)/L of the ILD.
  • All loads to the right descend along the negative slope −x/L- x/L of the ILD. The net change in bending moment at section xx is:
ΔM=∑i∈leftWi(+L−xL)Δξ−∑j∈rightWj(xL)Δξ\Delta M = \sum_{i \in \text{left}} W_i \left(+\frac{L - x}{L}\right) \Delta \xi - \sum_{j \in \text{right}} W_j \left(\frac{x}{L}\right) \Delta \xi

Since ∑leftWi=Wleft\sum_{\text{left}} W_i = W_{\text{left}} and ∑rightWj=R−Wleft\sum_{\text{right}} W_j = R - W_{\text{left}}:

ΔMΔξ=Wleft(L−xL)−(R−Wleft)(xL)=Wleft−R(xL)\frac{\Delta M}{\Delta \xi} = W_{\text{left}} \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right) - (R - W_{\text{left}})\left(\frac{x}{L}\right) = W_{\text{left}} - R \left(\frac{x}{L}\right)

For the bending moment to increase (ΔM>0\Delta M > 0):

Wleftx>RL\frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x} > \frac{R}{L}

For the bending moment to decrease (ΔM<0\Delta M < 0):

Wleftx<RL\frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x} < \frac{R}{L}

[!IMPORTANT] The Critical Wheel Condition: The maximum bending moment at a section occurs when a wheel load WkW_k sits directly over the section such that, as WkW_k crosses from the right to the left of the section, the average load on the left transitions from less than the average load on the total span to greater:

Wleft−Wkx<RL≤Wleftx\frac{W_{\text{left}} - W_k}{x} < \frac{R}{L} \le \frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x}

The wheel load WkW_k that satisfies this condition is called the critical wheel.


3.5 Absolute Maximum Bending Moment Across the Entire Span: The Focal Point Theorem

The absolute maximum bending moment in a simply supported beam does not generally occur at midspan! Instead, it occurs directly beneath one of the wheel loads (usually the one closest to the resultant RR).

Rigorous Calculus Derivation of the Focal Point Theorem

                     Span Centerline (L/2)
                               |
              <- dc/2 ->       |       <- dc/2 ->
                 Wc            |            R
                  |            |            |
                  v            |            v
    A o-----------+------------+------------+-----------o B
   x=0            |                         |          x=L
             x_c = L/2 - dc/2          x_R = L/2 + dc/2
  1. Definitions:

    • Let the resultant of the wheel train be R=∑WiR = \sum W_i, situated at distance xRx_R from the left support AA.
    • Let WcW_c be a chosen candidate critical wheel, situated at fixed distance dcd_c from the resultant RR.
    • Without loss of generality, assume WcW_c is to the left of RR, so the position of WcW_c from AA is: xc=xR−dcx_c = x_R - d_c
  2. Support Reactions: By taking moments about support BB:

    RA⋅L=R(L−xR)  ⟹  RA=R(L−xR)LR_A \cdot L = R (L - x_R) \implies R_A = \frac{R (L - x_R)}{L}
  3. Bending Moment Under Wheel WcW_c: The moment at the section where WcW_c is situated is:

    Mc=RA⋅xc−∑i<cWi(xc−xi)M_c = R_A \cdot x_c - \sum_{i < c} W_i (x_c - x_i)

    Notice that the term ∑i<cWi(xc−xi)\sum_{i < c} W_i (x_c - x_i) represents the sum of moments of all loads to the left of WcW_c about WcW_c. Because axle spacings are rigid, this term is a pure constant (CLC_L):

    Mc=R(L−xR)(xR−dc)L−CLM_c = \frac{R (L - x_R)(x_R - d_c)}{L} - C_L
  4. Maximization via First Derivative: To find the longitudinal position xRx_R that maximizes McM_c, differentiate with respect to xRx_R:

    dMcdxR=RLddxR[LxR−Ldc−xR2+dcxR]=0\frac{d M_c}{d x_R} = \frac{R}{L} \frac{d}{d x_R} \left[ L x_R - L d_c - x_R^2 + d_c x_R \right] = 0 RL[L−2xR+dc]=0\frac{R}{L} [ L - 2 x_R + d_c ] = 0 2xR=L+dc  ⟹  xR=L2+dc22 x_R = L + d_c \implies x_R = \frac{L}{2} + \frac{d_c}{2}
  5. Location of the Critical Wheel WcW_c:

    xc=xR−dc=(L2+dc2)−dc=L2−dc2x_c = x_R - d_c = \left(\frac{L}{2} + \frac{d_c}{2}\right) - d_c = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{d_c}{2}
  6. Second Derivative Test (Concavity):

    d2McdxR2=−2RL<0(Strictly a maximum!)\frac{d^2 M_c}{d x_R^2} = - \frac{2R}{L} < 0 \quad (\text{Strictly a maximum!})

[!IMPORTANT] Statutory Enunciation of the Focal Point Theorem: The absolute maximum bending moment in a simply supported beam traversed by a train of wheel loads occurs directly under a critical wheel load WcW_c when the centerline of the span bisects the distance between the critical wheel WcW_c and the resultant RR of the entire load system:

Distance from Midspan to Wc=Distance from Midspan to R=dc2\text{Distance from Midspan to } W_c = \text{Distance from Midspan to } R = \frac{d_c}{2}

Formula for Absolute Maximum Bending Moment

Substituting xR=L/2+dc/2x_R = L/2 + d_c/2 and xc=L/2−dc/2x_c = L/2 - d_c/2:

RA=R[L−(L/2+dc/2)]L=R(L−dc)2LR_A = \frac{R [L - (L/2 + d_c/2)]}{L} = \frac{R (L - d_c)}{2L} Mabs,max⁡=RA⋅xc−CL=R(L−dc)2L⋅L−dc2−CLM_{\text{abs},\max} = R_A \cdot x_c - C_L = \frac{R (L - d_c)}{2L} \cdot \frac{L - d_c}{2} - C_L Mabs,max⁡=R4L(L−dc)2−∑i<cWiaiM_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{R}{4L} (L - d_c)^2 - \sum_{i < c} W_i a_i

where aia_i is the distance from load WiW_i to the critical wheel WcW_c.


4. Critical Conditions & Governing Theorems

4.1 Step-by-Step Procedure to Find Absolute Maximum Bending Moment

  1. Compute Total Resultant: R=∑i=1nWiR = \sum_{i=1}^n W_i.
  2. Find Position of Resultant: Take moments of all loads about the leading axle W1W_1: xˉ=∑WidiR\bar{x} = \frac{\sum W_i d_i}{R}
  3. Identify Candidate Critical Wheels: Identify which wheel loads are closest to the resultant RR. Typically, test the wheel immediately to the left of RR and the wheel immediately to the right of RR. (Heavier wheels closer to RR dominate).
  4. Apply Bisection Positioning: For each candidate wheel:
    • Compute distance dc=∣xˉ−dwheel∣d_c = |\bar{x} - d_{\text{wheel}}|.
    • Position the wheel at x=L/2−dc/2x = L/2 - d_c/2 and the resultant at x=L/2+dc/2x = L/2 + d_c/2.
    • Check Span Boundaries: Verify that all axles originally assumed to be on the span remain on the span (0≤xi≤L0 \le x_i \le L). If any axle rolls off, recompute RR and xˉ\bar{x} for the reduced load group.
  5. Calculate Moment: Evaluate Mc=R4L(L−dc)2−∑WiaiM_c = \frac{R}{4L}(L - d_c)^2 - \sum W_i a_i. The largest calculated moment is Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}.

4.2 Maximum Shear Force Under a Wheel Train

To produce the maximum positive shear force at any section xx:

  1. Place one of the wheel loads directly at the section (x+x^+), with as many other wheels as possible to the right of the section.
  2. A wheel WkW_k yields the peak shear if advancing the train so the next wheel Wk+1W_{k+1} reaches the section causes the shear to drop: RL<Wkdk\frac{R}{L} < \frac{W_k}{d_k} where dkd_k is the spacing between wheel WkW_k and Wk+1W_{k+1}.
  3. For absolute maximum shear across the span, the leading or second axle is placed directly over support AA (x=0x = 0).

5. Cross-Sectional & Engineering Schematics

5.1 Maximum Shear Force and Bending Moment Envelopes

The following diagram illustrates the continuous envelopes for a single concentrated load and a uniformly distributed load (UDL) traversing a simply supported beam:

Maximum Shear Force and Bending Moment Envelopes
Figure 1: Maximum shear force and bending moment envelopes for rolling loads on a simply supported span. Note the linear shear envelope for a point load vs the parabolic shear envelope for a UDL, and the symmetrical parabolic bending moment envelope peaking at midspan.

5.2 The Focal Point Theorem for Axle Trains

The following schematic visualizes the bisection geometry of the Focal Point Theorem and the resulting segmented bending moment diagram:

Focal Point Theorem for Wheel Train
Figure 2: The Focal Point Theorem geometry. The centerline of the span (CL) strictly bisects the distance dcd_c between the critical wheel WcW_c and the resultant RR. The absolute maximum moment occurs directly under WcW_c.

6. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 1: Envelopes for Single Concentrated Load and Short UDL

Problem Statement: A simply supported girder has a clear span of L=20.0 mL = 20.0\text{ m}. Determine:

  1. The maximum positive shear force, maximum negative shear force, and maximum bending moment at a section CC located x=6.0 mx = 6.0\text{ m} from the left support AA, caused by a rolling point load P=120.0 kNP = 120.0\text{ kN}.
  2. The absolute maximum bending moment across the entire span caused by PP.
  3. The maximum positive shear force, maximum negative shear force, and maximum bending moment at the same section CC (x=6.0 mx = 6.0\text{ m}) caused by a rolling UDL of intensity w=40.0 kN/mw = 40.0\text{ kN/m} and length u=6.0 mu = 6.0\text{ m}.
  4. The absolute maximum bending moment in the girder caused by this UDL.

Solution:

Step 1: Analysis for Concentrated Load P=120.0 kNP = 120.0\text{ kN}

Given L=20.0 mL = 20.0\text{ m}, x=6.0 mx = 6.0\text{ m}, so a=6.0 ma = 6.0\text{ m}, b=L−x=14.0 mb = L - x = 14.0\text{ m}.

  • Maximum Positive Shear at CC (VC,max⁡+V_{C,\max}^+): Occurs when PP is placed immediately to the right of CC (x+x^+):

    VC,max⁡+=P(L−xL)=120.0×(14.020.0)=120.0×0.70=+84.0 kNV_{C,\max}^+ = P \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right) = 120.0 \times \left(\frac{14.0}{20.0}\right) = 120.0 \times 0.70 = \mathbf{+84.0\text{ kN}}
  • Maximum Negative Shear at CC (VC,max⁡−V_{C,\max}^-): Occurs when PP is placed immediately to the left of CC (x−x^-):

    VC,max⁡−=−P(xL)=−120.0×(6.020.0)=−120.0×0.30=−36.0 kNV_{C,\max}^- = - P \left(\frac{x}{L}\right) = - 120.0 \times \left(\frac{6.0}{20.0}\right) = - 120.0 \times 0.30 = \mathbf{-36.0\text{ kN}}
  • Maximum Bending Moment at CC (MC,max⁡M_{C,\max}): Occurs when PP is placed directly over section CC:

    MC,max⁡=Pa⋅bL=120.0×6.0×14.020.0=120.0×4.20=504.0 kNmM_{C,\max} = P \frac{a \cdot b}{L} = 120.0 \times \frac{6.0 \times 14.0}{20.0} = 120.0 \times 4.20 = \mathbf{504.0\text{ kNm}}
  • Absolute Maximum Bending Moment across the Span (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}): Occurs when PP is at midspan (x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}):

    Mabs,max⁡=PL4=120.0×20.04=600.0 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{P L}{4} = \frac{120.0 \times 20.0}{4} = \mathbf{600.0\text{ kNm}}

Step 2: Analysis for Short UDL (w=40.0 kN/mw = 40.0\text{ kN/m}, u=6.0 mu = 6.0\text{ m})

Total load W=w⋅u=40.0×6.0=240.0 kNW = w \cdot u = 40.0 \times 6.0 = 240.0\text{ kN}.

  • Maximum Positive Shear at CC (VC,max⁡+V_{C,\max}^+): Since (L−x)=14.0 m≥u=6.0 m(L - x) = 14.0\text{ m} \ge u = 6.0\text{ m}, the UDL can be placed entirely between CC and BB, with its leading edge at CC:

    VC,max⁡+=wuL(L−x−u2)=40.0×6.020.0(14.0−6.02)=12.0×(14.0−3.0)=12.0×11.0=+132.0 kNV_{C,\max}^+ = \frac{w u}{L} \left(L - x - \frac{u}{2}\right) = \frac{40.0 \times 6.0}{20.0} \left(14.0 - \frac{6.0}{2}\right) = 12.0 \times (14.0 - 3.0) = 12.0 \times 11.0 = \mathbf{+132.0\text{ kN}}
  • Maximum Negative Shear at CC (VC,max⁡−V_{C,\max}^-): Since x=6.0 m=ux = 6.0\text{ m} = u, the UDL can be placed entirely between AA and CC, with its trailing edge at CC:

    VC,max⁡−=−wuL(x−u2)=−40.0×6.020.0(6.0−6.02)=−12.0×3.0=−36.0 kNV_{C,\max}^- = - \frac{w u}{L} \left(x - \frac{u}{2}\right) = - \frac{40.0 \times 6.0}{20.0} \left(6.0 - \frac{6.0}{2}\right) = - 12.0 \times 3.0 = \mathbf{-36.0\text{ kN}}
  • Maximum Bending Moment at CC (MC,max⁡M_{C,\max}): Section CC must divide the load length u=6.0 mu = 6.0\text{ m} in the ratio a:b=6:14a:b = 6:14:

    x1=u(xL)=6.0×(6.020.0)=1.80 m to the left of Cx_1 = u \left(\frac{x}{L}\right) = 6.0 \times \left(\frac{6.0}{20.0}\right) = 1.80\text{ m to the left of } C x2=u(L−xL)=6.0×(14.020.0)=4.20 m to the right of Cx_2 = u \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right) = 6.0 \times \left(\frac{14.0}{20.0}\right) = 4.20\text{ m to the right of } C

    Using the derived formula:

    MC,max⁡=WabL(1−u2L)=240.0×6.0×14.020.0(1−6.02×20.0)M_{C,\max} = \frac{W a b}{L} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) = \frac{240.0 \times 6.0 \times 14.0}{20.0} \left(1 - \frac{6.0}{2 \times 20.0}\right) MC,max⁡=1008.0×(1−0.15)=1008.0×0.85=856.80 kNmM_{C,\max} = 1008.0 \times (1 - 0.15) = 1008.0 \times 0.85 = \mathbf{856.80\text{ kNm}}
  • Absolute Maximum Bending Moment across the Span (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}): Occurs at midspan (x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}), where the load is centered (x1=x2=3.0 mx_1 = x_2 = 3.0\text{ m}):

    Mabs,max⁡=WL4(1−u2L)=240.0×20.04(1−0.15)=1200.0×0.85=1020.0 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{W L}{4} \left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) = \frac{240.0 \times 20.0}{4} (1 - 0.15) = 1200.0 \times 0.85 = \mathbf{1020.0\text{ kNm}}

Example 2: Critical Wheel and Maximum Bending Moment at a Specified Section

Problem Statement: A train of four wheel loads crosses a simply supported bridge girder of span L=24.0 mL = 24.0\text{ m} from left to right:

  • Wheel 1 (leading): W1=60.0 kNW_1 = 60.0\text{ kN}
  • Wheel 2: W2=120.0 kNW_2 = 120.0\text{ kN} (spaced 2.0 m2.0\text{ m} behind W1W_1)
  • Wheel 3: W3=120.0 kNW_3 = 120.0\text{ kN} (spaced 3.0 m3.0\text{ m} behind W2W_2)
  • Wheel 4 (trailing): W4=80.0 kNW_4 = 80.0\text{ kN} (spaced 2.0 m2.0\text{ m} behind W3W_3)

Determine the critical wheel load and calculate the maximum bending moment at a section CC located x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m} from the left support AA.

       W1=60kN      W2=120kN         W3=120kN      W4=80kN
          |            |                |             |     -> Moving
          +--- 2.0m ---+----- 3.0m -----+--- 2.0m ----+

Solution:

Step 1: System Properties

  • Total load: R=60.0+120.0+120.0+80.0=380.0 kNR = 60.0 + 120.0 + 120.0 + 80.0 = 380.0\text{ kN}.
  • Total wheel base length: 2.0+3.0+2.0=7.0 m<24.0 m2.0 + 3.0 + 2.0 = 7.0\text{ m} < 24.0\text{ m} (all wheels can fit on the span).
  • Average load on total span: RL=380.024.0=15.833 kN/m\frac{R}{L} = \frac{380.0}{24.0} = 15.833\text{ kN/m}

Step 2: Testing Critical Wheel at Section CC (x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m})

  1. Test Wheel 1 (W1=60 kNW_1 = 60\text{ kN}) at Section CC:

    • Wheel 1 is at x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m}. All other wheels are to the right.
    • Load to the left including W1W_1: Wleft=60.0 kNW_{\text{left}} = 60.0\text{ kN}.
    • Average load on left segment: Wleftx=60.08.0=7.50 kN/m<15.833 kN/m\frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x} = \frac{60.0}{8.0} = 7.50\text{ kN/m} < 15.833\text{ kN/m}
    • Since 7.50<15.8337.50 < 15.833, moment is still increasing as the train advances. W1W_1 is not critical.
  2. Test Wheel 2 (W2=120 kNW_2 = 120\text{ kN}) at Section CC:

    • Wheel 2 is at x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m}. Wheel 1 is at 8.0−2.0=6.0 m8.0 - 2.0 = 6.0\text{ m}.
    • Load to left before W2W_2 crosses: Wleft−W2=60.0 kNW_{\text{left}} - W_2 = 60.0\text{ kN}. 60.08.0=7.50 kN/m<15.833 kN/m\frac{60.0}{8.0} = 7.50\text{ kN/m} < 15.833\text{ kN/m}
    • Load to left after W2W_2 reaches the section: Wleft=60.0+120.0=180.0 kNW_{\text{left}} = 60.0 + 120.0 = 180.0\text{ kN}. 180.08.0=22.50 kN/m>15.833 kN/m\frac{180.0}{8.0} = 22.50\text{ kN/m} > 15.833\text{ kN/m}
    • Condition Satisfied: Wleft−W2x<RL≤Wleftx\frac{W_{\text{left}} - W_2}{x} < \frac{R}{L} \le \frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x} (7.50<15.833≤22.507.50 < 15.833 \le 22.50).
    • Conclusion: Wheel 2 is the governing critical wheel!

Step 3: Compute Bending Moment with Wheel 2 at Section CC (x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m})

  • Wheel positions from left support AA:
    • x1=6.0 mx_1 = 6.0\text{ m} (W1=60 kNW_1 = 60\text{ kN})
    • x2=8.0 mx_2 = 8.0\text{ m} (W2=120 kNW_2 = 120\text{ kN}, at section CC)
    • x3=8.0+3.0=11.0 mx_3 = 8.0 + 3.0 = 11.0\text{ m} (W3=120 kNW_3 = 120\text{ kN})
    • x4=11.0+2.0=13.0 mx_4 = 11.0 + 2.0 = 13.0\text{ m} (W4=80 kNW_4 = 80\text{ kN})
  • Position of resultant RR: Take moments of loads about AA: R⋅xR=60(6.0)+120(8.0)+120(11.0)+80(13.0)R \cdot x_R = 60(6.0) + 120(8.0) + 120(11.0) + 80(13.0) 380⋅xR=360+960+1320+1040=3680 kNm  ⟹  xR=3680380=18419≈9.6842 m380 \cdot x_R = 360 + 960 + 1320 + 1040 = 3680\text{ kNm} \implies x_R = \frac{3680}{380} = \frac{184}{19} \approx 9.6842\text{ m}
  • Left reaction RAR_A: RA=R(L−xR)L=380.0×(24.0−9.6842)24.0=380.0×14.315824.0=226.667 kNR_A = \frac{R (L - x_R)}{L} = \frac{380.0 \times (24.0 - 9.6842)}{24.0} = \frac{380.0 \times 14.3158}{24.0} = 226.667\text{ kN}
  • Bending moment at section CC (x=8.0 mx = 8.0\text{ m}): MC=RA×8.0−W1×(8.0−6.0)=226.667×8.0−60.0×2.0M_C = R_A \times 8.0 - W_1 \times (8.0 - 6.0) = 226.667 \times 8.0 - 60.0 \times 2.0 MC=1813.333−120.0=1693.333 kNm(169313 kNm=50803 kNm)M_C = 1813.333 - 120.0 = \mathbf{1693.333\text{ kNm}} \quad \left(1693\frac{1}{3}\text{ kNm} = \frac{5080}{3}\text{ kNm}\right)

Example 3: Absolute Maximum Bending Moment using Focal Point Theorem

Problem Statement: For the same wheel load train as Example 2 (W1=60 kN,W2=120 kN,W3=120 kN,W4=80 kNW_1 = 60\text{ kN}, W_2 = 120\text{ kN}, W_3 = 120\text{ kN}, W_4 = 80\text{ kN}; spacings 2.0 m,3.0 m,2.0 m2.0\text{ m}, 3.0\text{ m}, 2.0\text{ m}; span L=24.0 mL = 24.0\text{ m}): Determine:

  1. The position of all loads to produce the absolute maximum bending moment anywhere in the girder.
  2. The exact numerical magnitude of this absolute maximum bending moment (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}).

Solution:

Step 1: Centroid of the Load System

Taking moments about the lead wheel W1W_1:

xˉ=∑WidiR=60(0)+120(2.0)+120(5.0)+80(7.0)380.0=0+240+600+560380.0=1400.0380.0=7019≈3.6842 m\bar{x} = \frac{\sum W_i d_i}{R} = \frac{60(0) + 120(2.0) + 120(5.0) + 80(7.0)}{380.0} = \frac{0 + 240 + 600 + 560}{380.0} = \frac{1400.0}{380.0} = \frac{70}{19} \approx 3.6842\text{ m}

The resultant R=380 kNR = 380\text{ kN} acts at 3.6842 m3.6842\text{ m} behind wheel 1.

Step 2: Identification of Candidate Critical Wheels

Distances from resultant RR to adjacent wheels:

  • Distance to Wheel 2 (at 2.0 m2.0\text{ m} from W1W_1): dc2=3.6842−2.0=1.6842 m(3219 m)d_{c2} = 3.6842 - 2.0 = 1.6842\text{ m} \quad \left(\frac{32}{19}\text{ m}\right)
  • Distance to Wheel 3 (at 5.0 m5.0\text{ m} from W1W_1): dc3=5.0−3.6842=1.3158 m(2519 m)d_{c3} = 5.0 - 3.6842 = 1.3158\text{ m} \quad \left(\frac{25}{19}\text{ m}\right)

Because dc3<dc2d_{c3} < d_{c2} (1.3158 m<1.6842 m1.3158\text{ m} < 1.6842\text{ m}) and both wheels have identical magnitude (120 kN120\text{ kN}), Wheel 3 is closest to the resultant and is the prime candidate. We will test both to provide an irrefutable proof.


Step 3: Application of Focal Point Theorem for Wheel 3 (W3W_3)

Wheel 3 lies to the right of resultant RR by dc3=2519 m≈1.3158 md_{c3} = \frac{25}{19}\text{ m} \approx 1.3158\text{ m}. By the Focal Point Theorem, the midspan of the beam (L/2=12.0 mL/2 = 12.0\text{ m}) must bisect the distance between RR and W3W_3:

  • Position of Resultant RR:

    xR=L2−dc32=12.0−2538=43138≈11.3421 m from Ax_R = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{d_{c3}}{2} = 12.0 - \frac{25}{38} = \frac{431}{38} \approx 11.3421\text{ m from } A
  • Position of Critical Wheel W3W_3:

    x3=L2+dc32=12.0+2538=48138≈12.6579 m from Ax_3 = \frac{L}{2} + \frac{d_{c3}}{2} = 12.0 + \frac{25}{38} = \frac{481}{38} \approx 12.6579\text{ m from } A
  • Check positions of all wheels on span:

    • x1=x3−5.0=12.6579−5.0=7.6579 m>0x_1 = x_3 - 5.0 = 12.6579 - 5.0 = 7.6579\text{ m} > 0 (On span)
    • x2=x3−3.0=12.6579−3.0=9.6579 mx_2 = x_3 - 3.0 = 12.6579 - 3.0 = 9.6579\text{ m} (On span)
    • x4=x3+2.0=12.6579+2.0=14.6579 m<24.0 mx_4 = x_3 + 2.0 = 12.6579 + 2.0 = 14.6579\text{ m} < 24.0\text{ m} (On span) All four wheels are completely on the span!
  • Left reaction RAR_A:

    RA=R(L−xR)L=380.0×(24.0−11.3421)24.0=380.0×12.657924.0=200.4167 kNR_A = \frac{R (L - x_R)}{L} = \frac{380.0 \times (24.0 - 11.3421)}{24.0} = \frac{380.0 \times 12.6579}{24.0} = 200.4167\text{ kN}

    (Notice that L−xR=x3L - x_R = x_3, so RA=R⋅x3/LR_A = R \cdot x_3 / L!)

  • Maximum Moment under Wheel 3:

    Mmax⁡(W3)=RA⋅x3−W1(x3−x1)−W2(x3−x2)M_{\max}^{(W_3)} = R_A \cdot x_3 - W_1 (x_3 - x_1) - W_2 (x_3 - x_2) Mmax⁡(W3)=200.4167×12.6579−60.0×5.0−120.0×3.0M_{\max}^{(W_3)} = 200.4167 \times 12.6579 - 60.0 \times 5.0 - 120.0 \times 3.0 Mmax⁡(W3)=2536.8531−300.0−360.0=2536.8531−660.0=1876.853 kNmM_{\max}^{(W_3)} = 2536.8531 - 300.0 - 360.0 = 2536.8531 - 660.0 = \mathbf{1876.853\text{ kNm}}

    In closed rational form:

    Mmax⁡(W3)=855845456 kNm≈1876.853 kNmM_{\max}^{(W_3)} = \frac{855845}{456}\text{ kNm} \approx \mathbf{1876.853\text{ kNm}}

Step 4: Verification under Candidate Wheel 2 (W2W_2)

For completeness, test Wheel 2 (dc2=3219 m≈1.6842 md_{c2} = \frac{32}{19}\text{ m} \approx 1.6842\text{ m}, to the left of RR):

  • Midspan (12.0 m12.0\text{ m}) bisects W2W_2 and RR: x2=12.0−3238=42438≈11.1579 mx_2 = 12.0 - \frac{32}{38} = \frac{424}{38} \approx 11.1579\text{ m} xR=12.0+3238=48838≈12.8421 mx_R = 12.0 + \frac{32}{38} = \frac{488}{38} \approx 12.8421\text{ m}
  • Left reaction: RA=380.0×(24.0−12.8421)24.0=176.6667 kNR_A = \frac{380.0 \times (24.0 - 12.8421)}{24.0} = 176.6667\text{ kN}
  • Moment under Wheel 2: Mmax⁡(W2)=RA⋅x2−W1×2.0=176.6667×11.1579−120.0=1971.2281−120.0=1851.228 kNmM_{\max}^{(W_2)} = R_A \cdot x_2 - W_1 \times 2.0 = 176.6667 \times 11.1579 - 120.0 = 1971.2281 - 120.0 = 1851.228\text{ kNm}

Step 5: Final Comparison & Conclusion

Mmax⁡(W3)=1876.853 kNm>Mmax⁡(W2)=1851.228 kNmM_{\max}^{(W_3)} = 1876.853\text{ kNm} > M_{\max}^{(W_2)} = 1851.228\text{ kNm}

Therefore:

Mabs,max⁡=1876.853 kNm\mathbf{M_{\text{abs},\max} = 1876.853\text{ kNm}}

It occurs directly under Wheel 3 when Wheel 3 is positioned at 12.658 m12.658\text{ m} from the left support AA (with the resultant at 11.342 m11.342\text{ m}).


7. Engineering Design Applications & Field Practice

7.1 Bridge Girder Flange Cover Plate Cut-offs

In steel plate girder bridges (governed by IRC:24 and IS:800), the required section modulus Zreq(x)=Mmax⁡(x)/σallowZ_{\text{req}}(x) = M_{\max}(x) / \sigma_{\text{allow}} varies along the span according to the parabolic bending moment envelope.

  • Instead of using a constant heavy flange plate throughout the entire span, fabricators curtail the flange plates:
    • Base flange plate runs the full span.
    • First cover plate is added over the middle 60–70%60\text{–}70\% of the span.
    • Second cover plate is added over the middle 30–40%30\text{–}40\% of the span.
  • The theoretical cut-off points are obtained by intersecting the moment resistance capacities of the curtailed sections with the Moving Load Moment Envelope.
  Moment (kNm)
     ^             /-----------\  <-- Full Section Capacity
     |            / /---------\ \ <-- 1 Cover Plate Capacity
     |           / / /-------\ \ \ <-- Base Flange Capacity
     |          | | | M_env   | | |
     +----------+-+-+---------+-+-+-----> Span x
               Cut-off 1     Cut-off 2

7.2 Web Plate Stiffener Spacing

The maximum shear force envelope (Vmax⁡+(x)V_{\max}^+(x) and Vmax⁡−(x)V_{\max}^-(x)) governs the design of plate girder webs:

  • Near the supports (x→0,x→Lx \to 0, x \to L), shear force reaches its absolute peak (Vabs,max⁡V_{\text{abs},\max}). Web plates require thick web thickness and closely spaced vertical stiffeners (spacing d≈0.5dwd \approx 0.5 d_w to 0.8dw0.8 d_w).
  • Near midspan (x≈L/2x \approx L/2), shear force drops to its minimum (Vmax⁡≈W/2V_{\max} \approx W/2 or wL/8wL/8). Stiffener spacing can be increased to maximum allowable spacing (d≈1.5dwd \approx 1.5 d_w).

7.3 Standard Design Vehicle Load Models

Authority / Standard Vehicle Class / Designation Axle Configuration & Magnitude Application
IRC:6 (Highway) Class 70R (Tracked) 700 kN700\text{ kN} total weight over two tracks (4.57 m4.57\text{ m} length) Heavy military and industrial highways
IRC:6 (Highway) Class 70R (Wheeled) 7 axles totaling 1000 kN1000\text{ kN} (W1=80,W2=120,W3=120,W4=170,W5=170,W6=170,W7=170 kNW_1=80, W_2=120, W_3=120, W_4=170, W_5=170, W_6=170, W_7=170\text{ kN}) Multi-lane national highway bridges
IRC:6 (Highway) Class A 8 axles totaling 554 kN554\text{ kN} (W1=27,W2=27,W3=114,W4=114,W5=68,W6=68,W7=68,W8=68 kNW_1=27, W_2=27, W_3=114, W_4=114, W_5=68, W_6=68, W_7=68, W_8=68\text{ kN}) Standard permanent road bridges
Indian Railways (IRS) 25 t Loading (Broad Gauge) 2 locomotives (4×245.25 kN4 \times 245.25\text{ kN} per loco) + trailing train of 80.93 kN/m80.93\text{ kN/m} Mainline heavy freight and passenger corridors
AASHTO (USA) HL-93 Design truck (35.6+142.3+142.3 kN35.6 + 142.3 + 142.3\text{ kN}) + design lane load (9.34 kN/m9.34\text{ kN/m}) US interstate and state highway bridges

8. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

8.1 Summary of Governing Formulas for Simply Supported Span LL

Load Type Maximum Positive Shear at xx (Vmax⁡+V_{\max}^+) Maximum Negative Shear at xx (Vmax⁡−V_{\max}^-) Maximum Bending Moment at xx (Mmax⁡M_{\max}) Absolute Maximum Moment (Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}) Location of Mabs,max⁡M_{\text{abs},\max}
Single Concentrated Load (WW) +W(L−xL)+W \left(\frac{L - x}{L}\right) −W(xL)-W \left(\frac{x}{L}\right) Wx(L−x)L\frac{W x (L - x)}{L} WL4\frac{W L}{4} Exactly at Midspan (x=L/2x = L/2)
Full UDL (ww, u≥Lu \ge L) +w(L−x)22L+\frac{w(L - x)^2}{2L} −wx22L-\frac{w x^2}{2L} wx(L−x)2\frac{w x (L - x)}{2} wL28\frac{w L^2}{8} Exactly at Midspan (x=L/2x = L/2)
Short UDL (ww, u<Lu < L, W=wuW=wu) +wuL(L−x−u2)+\frac{w u}{L}\left(L - x - \frac{u}{2}\right) −wuL(x−u2)-\frac{w u}{L}\left(x - \frac{u}{2}\right) Wx(L−x)L(1−u2L)\frac{W x (L - x)}{L}\left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) WL4(1−u2L)\frac{W L}{4}\left(1 - \frac{u}{2L}\right) Exactly at Midspan (x=L/2x = L/2)
Two Concentrated Loads (W1,W2W_1, W_2, spacing dd) Leading or trailing wheel at section Leading or trailing wheel at section Critical wheel at section (average load criterion) R4L(L−dc)2\frac{R}{4L}(L - d_c)^2 under heavier wheel Distance dc/2d_c/2 from Midspan
Train of Axle Loads (W1…WnW_1 \dots W_n) Wheel at section satisfying RL<Wkdk\frac{R}{L} < \frac{W_k}{d_k} Wheel at section satisfying negative criterion Wheel at section where Wleft−Wkx<RL≤Wleftx\frac{W_{\text{left}}-W_k}{x} < \frac{R}{L} \le \frac{W_{\text{left}}}{x} R4L(L−dc)2−∑Wiai\frac{R}{4L}(L - d_c)^2 - \sum W_i a_i under critical wheel WcW_c Under WcW_c placed at x=L2−dc2x = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{d_c}{2}

9. Common Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls

[!CAUTION] Trap 1: Assuming Absolute Maximum Moment for a Wheel Train Always Occurs at Midspan
Students routinely place the resultant RR or the critical wheel WcW_c at midspan (x=L/2x = L/2).
Reality: Midspan must bisect the distance between RR and WcW_c. Thus, both RR and WcW_c are shifted away from midspan by dc/2d_c/2. The peak moment occurs directly under WcW_c at x=L/2−dc/2x = L/2 - d_c/2, never at midspan (unless dc=0d_c = 0, i.e., WcW_c coincides with RR).

[!WARNING] Trap 2: Forgetting to Check if Wheels Roll Off the Span
When applying the Focal Point Theorem, positioning the critical wheel at L/2−dc/2L/2 - d_c/2 shifts the entire train. If a lead or trail wheel drops off the bridge (xi<0x_i < 0 or xi>Lx_i > L), the resultant RR and its position xˉ\bar{x} change!
Remedy: Always verify 0≤xi≤L0 \le x_i \le L for every wheel. If a wheel leaves the span, recompute RR without that wheel.

[!WARNING] Trap 3: Confusing the Shear Step with Negative Shear
For a rolling point load, the maximum positive shear at xx is +W(L−x)/L+W(L-x)/L (load at x+x^+) and the maximum negative shear is −Wx/L-W x/L (load at x−x^-). The algebraic difference between them is +W(L−x)/L−(−Wx/L)=W+W(L-x)/L - (-W x/L) = W, which is the magnitude of the load! Do not confuse this with zero shear.

[!NOTE] Trap 4: Average Load Criterion for Short UDL
When maximizing bending moment at section xx for a short UDL (u<Lu < L), students often place the center of the load at xx.
Reality: The center of the load is placed at xx only if x=L/2x = L/2 (midspan). For any other section, the section must divide the load in the ratio x/(L−x)x / (L - x), which means x1=u(x/L)≠u/2x_1 = u(x/L) \ne u/2.


10. Previous Years' Examination Analysis & Reference Questions

10.1 Typical Exam Questions

Question 1 (GATE Civil Engineering)

A simply supported beam of span 10 m10\text{ m} is subjected to a moving point load of 100 kN100\text{ kN}. The absolute maximum bending moment in the beam is:

  • (A) 200 kNm200\text{ kNm}
  • (B) 250 kNm250\text{ kNm}
  • (C) 500 kNm500\text{ kNm}
  • (D) 1000 kNm1000\text{ kNm} Solution: Mabs,max⁡=WL4=100×104=250 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{W L}{4} = \frac{100 \times 10}{4} = \mathbf{250\text{ kNm}}. Correct option is (B).

Question 2 (UPSC ESE / IES)

Two concentrated loads of 40 kN40\text{ kN} and 60 kN60\text{ kN} spaced 2 m2\text{ m} apart move across a simply supported girder of span 10 m10\text{ m} from left to right, with the 40 kN40\text{ kN} load leading. The absolute maximum bending moment occurs:

  • (A) At midspan under the 40 kN40\text{ kN} load
  • (B) At midspan under the 60 kN60\text{ kN} load
  • (C) Under the 60 kN60\text{ kN} load at a distance of 4.6 m4.6\text{ m} from the left support
  • (D) Under the 60 kN60\text{ kN} load at a distance of 4.6 m4.6\text{ m} from the right support Solution:
  • Total load R=40+60=100 kNR = 40 + 60 = 100\text{ kN}.
  • Centroid from 60 kN60\text{ kN} load: dc=40×2.0100=0.8 md_c = \frac{40 \times 2.0}{100} = 0.8\text{ m} towards the 40 kN40\text{ kN} load.
  • Absolute maximum moment occurs under the heavier 60 kN60\text{ kN} load.
  • Midspan (5.0 m5.0\text{ m}) bisects the distance between 60 kN60\text{ kN} load and RR (dc=0.8 md_c = 0.8\text{ m}).
  • Distance of 60 kN60\text{ kN} load from nearest support: 5.0−0.82=4.6 m5.0 - \frac{0.8}{2} = 4.6\text{ m}. Correct option is (C) (or (D) by symmetry).

Question 3 (SSC JE / State AE)

When a uniformly distributed load shorter than the span moves over a simply supported beam, the bending moment at any section is maximum when:

  • (A) The head of the load is at the section
  • (B) The tail of the load is at the section
  • (C) The section divides the load in the same ratio as it divides the span
  • (D) The center of the load is at the section Solution: Option (C).

11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys

Problem 1 (Point Load Envelope)

A simply supported crane runway girder has an effective span of 12.0 m12.0\text{ m}. A wheel load of 80.0 kN80.0\text{ kN} rolls across the girder.

  • (a) Compute the maximum positive shear force at x=3.0 mx = 3.0\text{ m} from the left support.
  • (b) Compute the maximum negative shear force at x=3.0 mx = 3.0\text{ m}.
  • (c) Compute the maximum bending moment at x=3.0 mx = 3.0\text{ m}.
  • (d) Compute the absolute maximum bending moment in the girder.

Answer Key:

  • (a) Vmax⁡+=80×(9/12)=+60.0 kNV_{\max}^+ = 80 \times (9/12) = \mathbf{+60.0\text{ kN}}
  • (b) Vmax⁡−=−80×(3/12)=−20.0 kNV_{\max}^- = -80 \times (3/12) = \mathbf{-20.0\text{ kN}}
  • (c) Mmax⁡(3m)=80×(3×9)/12=180.0 kNmM_{\max}(3\text{m}) = 80 \times (3 \times 9)/12 = \mathbf{180.0\text{ kNm}}
  • (d) Mabs,max⁡=80×12/4=240.0 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = 80 \times 12 / 4 = \mathbf{240.0\text{ kNm}} (at x=6.0 mx = 6.0\text{ m})

Problem 2 (Short UDL on Bridge Girder)

A highway girder of span 16.0 m16.0\text{ m} is traversed by a rolling UDL of 30.0 kN/m30.0\text{ kN/m} having a length of 5.0 m5.0\text{ m}. Determine:

  • (a) The maximum positive shear force at x=4.0 mx = 4.0\text{ m}.
  • (b) The maximum bending moment at x=4.0 mx = 4.0\text{ m}.
  • (c) The absolute maximum bending moment across the span.

Answer Key:

  • (a) L−x=12.0 m≥u=5.0 mL - x = 12.0\text{ m} \ge u = 5.0\text{ m}. Vmax⁡+=30×516(12.0−2.5)=15016×9.5=+89.06 kNV_{\max}^+ = \frac{30 \times 5}{16} (12.0 - 2.5) = \frac{150}{16} \times 9.5 = \mathbf{+89.06\text{ kN}}
  • (b) x1=5×(4/16)=1.25 mx_1 = 5 \times (4/16) = 1.25\text{ m}, x2=3.75 mx_2 = 3.75\text{ m}. Mmax⁡(4m)=150×4×1216(1−532)=450×(2732)=379.69 kNmM_{\max}(4\text{m}) = \frac{150 \times 4 \times 12}{16}\left(1 - \frac{5}{32}\right) = 450 \times \left(\frac{27}{32}\right) = \mathbf{379.69\text{ kNm}}
  • (c) Mabs,max⁡=150×164(1−532)=600×(2732)=506.25 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = \frac{150 \times 16}{4}\left(1 - \frac{5}{32}\right) = 600 \times \left(\frac{27}{32}\right) = \mathbf{506.25\text{ kNm}} (at midspan)

Problem 3 (Two Wheel Loads)

Two wheel loads of 100.0 kN100.0\text{ kN} and 50.0 kN50.0\text{ kN} spaced 3.0 m3.0\text{ m} apart cross a span of 15.0 m15.0\text{ m} with the 100.0 kN100.0\text{ kN} load leading. Calculate the absolute maximum bending moment developed in the span.

Answer Key:

  • R=150.0 kNR = 150.0\text{ kN}.
  • Centroid from 100 kN100\text{ kN} load: dc=50×3.0150=1.0 md_c = \frac{50 \times 3.0}{150} = 1.0\text{ m} towards the 50 kN50\text{ kN} load.
  • Distance between 100 kN100\text{ kN} load and RR is dc=1.0 md_c = 1.0\text{ m}.
  • Position 100 kN100\text{ kN} load at x=15/2−1.0/2=7.0 mx = 15/2 - 1.0/2 = 7.0\text{ m} from left support; RR is at 8.0 m8.0\text{ m}.
  • RA=150×(15−8)15=70.0 kNR_A = \frac{150 \times (15 - 8)}{15} = 70.0\text{ kN}.
  • Mabs,max⁡=70.0×7.0=490.0 kNmM_{\text{abs},\max} = 70.0 \times 7.0 = \mathbf{490.0\text{ kNm}} (occurring under the 100 kN100\text{ kN} load at x=7.0 mx = 7.0\text{ m}).

12. Comprehensive Subject & Examination Mapping

Competitive Examination Relevant Section / Paper Expected Weightage Typical Question Style
GATE CE Structural Analysis / Structural Engineering 2–4 Marks2\text{–}4\text{ Marks} Numerical Answer Type (NAT) on absolute maximum bending moment, position of critical load under wheel train, or short UDL moment.
UPSC ESE Paper-I (Structural Analysis) 8–16 Marks8\text{–}16\text{ Marks} Objective multiple choice on Focal Point Theorem geometry, and conventional numerical derivation of maximum bending moment envelope.
SSC JE Structural Engineering (Theory of Structures) 2–4 Marks2\text{–}4\text{ Marks} Direct formula recognition (WL/4WL/4, wL2/8wL^2/8, average load criterion, linear vs parabolic envelopes).
State AE / JE Civil Engineering Paper-I 3–6 Marks3\text{–}6\text{ Marks} Bisection of distance between resultant and wheel load, maximum shear at supports, and critical wheel identification.
RRB JE Civil & Allied Engineering (Structural Mechanics) 2–3 Marks2\text{–}3\text{ Marks} Conceptual questions on moving loads, impact factor, and maximum moment at midspan.