SA-05-01 Chapter 05 · Arches & Suspension Cables

Three-Hinged Arches & Eddy's Theorem

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Module Header & Metadata Block

  • Topic ID: SA-05-01
  • Module: Structural Analysis (Subject 03)
  • Chapter: Chapter 05: Arches & Suspension Cables
  • Title: Three-Hinged Arches & Eddy's Theorem
  • Target Examinations:
    • GATE Civil Engineering (Structural Engineering)
    • UPSC Engineering Services Examination (ESE/IES Paper-I)
    • SSC JE Civil Engineering (Theory of Structures)
    • State Public Service Commission Assistant Engineer (AE) & Junior Engineer (JE) Examinations
    • Railway Recruitment Board Junior Engineer (RRB JE)
  • Prerequisites:
    • Topic SA-01-01: Static Indeterminacy of Trusses & Arches
    • Topic SOM-03-01 to SOM-03-04: Shear Force and Bending Moment Diagrams
    • Topic SA-04-03: Influence Lines for Trusses & Three-Hinged Arches
  • Learning Objectives:
    1. Understand the fundamental structural mechanics of arch action and differentiate arch compressive thrust from beam flexure.
    2. Derive the geometric profile equations and tangent slopes for standard three-hinged parabolic and circular (segmental) arches.
    3. Formulate the equations of equilibrium for three-hinged arches with springings at the same level and at different levels.
    4. Calculate the internal force resultants: Bending Moment (MM), Normal Thrust (NN), and Radial Shear (QQ) at any cross-section.
    5. State, prove, and apply Eddy's Theorem to determine bending moments graphically and analytically from the line of thrust (funicular polygon).
    6. Prove analytically why temperature changes and support settlements induce zero internal stress in three-hinged arches, and calculate the resulting kinematic crown displacement.

2. Theoretical Foundations & Physical Concepts

2.1 The Evolution of Arch Action

From antiquity (Roman aqueducts and medieval cathedral vaults) to modern long-span bridges, the arch represents one of humanity's most efficient structural forms:

  • Beams: Carry transverse loads purely by flexural internal moments (MM) and transverse shear (VV), creating severe tensile and compressive bending stresses: σ=±MyI\sigma = \pm \frac{M y}{I} For long spans, dead load flexure causes massive girder depths and excessive self-weight.
  • Arches: Curved structural members spanning across an opening, resting on abutments capable of resisting both vertical downward reactions and horizontal inward thrusts (HH). The horizontal thrust generates a counter-acting hogging moment (H⋅yH \cdot y) that directly relieves the beam sagging moment: March(x)=Mbeam(x)−H⋅y(x)M_{\text{arch}}(x) = M_{\text{beam}}(x) - H \cdot y(x) By shaping the arch rib to closely follow the funicular polygon (line of thrust) of the dominant gravity loads, the flexural bending moment is minimized or completely eliminated throughout the span, allowing the structure to carry massive loads primarily in direct axial compression.

2.2 Static Determinacy & Geometric Stability of the Three-Hinged Arch

A three-hinged arch consists of two curved structural segments connected to each other by an internal hinge at the crown (CC), and connected to rigid abutments by pin supports at the springings (AA and BB).

                      Crown Hinge C
                           (o)
                          /   \
                         /     \
                        /       \
                       /         \
        Pin A (o)-----+-----------+-----(o) Pin B
              x=0                        x=L

Static Determinacy Evaluation:

  • Support reactions: r=4r = 4 (VA,HAV_A, H_A at AA; VB,HBV_B, H_B at BB).
  • Global equations of static equilibrium: 33 (∑Fx=0,∑Fy=0,∑Mz=0\sum F_x = 0, \sum F_y = 0, \sum M_z = 0).
  • Special internal condition equations: c=1c = 1 (Internal hinge at crown CC enforces MC=0M_C = 0).
  • Degree of static indeterminacy: Ds=r−(3+c)=4−(3+1)=0(Statically Determinate)D_s = r - (3 + c) = 4 - (3 + 1) = \mathbf{0} \quad (\text{Statically Determinate})

Stability Requirement (Non-Collinearity of Hinges):

For geometric stability, the three hinges (A,B,CA, B, C) must not lie on a single straight line. If the three hinges become collinear (h→0h \to 0), the arch degenerates into a three-pinned toggle mechanism that undergoes catastrophic rigid-body collapse under vertical loads (∑MC  ⟹  H⋅0≠0\sum M_C \implies H \cdot 0 \ne 0).


3. Mathematical Derivations & Analytical Formulations


3.1 Geometry of Standard Arch Ribs

3.1.1 Parabolic Arch with Supports at the Same Level

Let the origin (0,0)(0, 0) be taken at the left springing AA.

  • Span =L= L, Central rise =h= h.
  • Crown hinge CC is at (L/2,h)(L/2, h), and right support BB is at (L,0)(L, 0).

The equation of a symmetric parabola passing through (0,0)(0,0), (L/2,h)(L/2, h), and (L,0)(L, 0) is:

y(x)=4hL2x(L−x)y(x) = \frac{4h}{L^2} x(L - x)

The slope of the arch axis at any cross-section xx is:

tan⁡θ=dydx=4hL2(L−2x)\tan \theta = \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{4h}{L^2}(L - 2x)
  • At left support AA (x=0x = 0): tan⁡θA=4hL\tan \theta_A = \frac{4h}{L}
  • At crown CC (x=L/2x = L/2): tan⁡θC=0  ⟹  θC=0∘\tan \theta_C = 0 \implies \theta_C = 0^\circ (horizontal)
  • At right support BB (x=Lx = L): tan⁡θB=−4hL\tan \theta_B = - \frac{4h}{L}

Trigonometric relations at section xx:

cos⁡θ=11+tan⁡2θ,sin⁡θ=tan⁡θ1+tan⁡2θ\cos \theta = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 + \tan^2 \theta}}, \quad \sin \theta = \frac{\tan \theta}{\sqrt{1 + \tan^2 \theta}}

3.1.2 Circular (Segmental) Arch with Supports at the Same Level

Let an arch rib form a circular segment of radius RR, span LL, and central rise hh.

               Crown C
                 ---
              /   h   \
       A o---+---------+---o B
             |<- L/2 ->|
             |         |
             |  R - h  |
             |         |
                 (O) Center of Curvature
  1. Radius of Curvature (RR): By the intersecting chords theorem for a circle:

    h(2R−h)=(L2)2  ⟹  2Rh−h2=L24h (2R - h) = \left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^2 \implies 2R h - h^2 = \frac{L^2}{4} R=L28h+h2R = \frac{L^2}{8h} + \frac{h}{2}
  2. Equation of Arch Rib: With origin at the left support AA (0≤x≤L0 \le x \le L): The horizontal distance from the center of curvature (vertical centerline of span) is x′=L/2−xx' = L/2 - x. By the Pythagorean theorem:

    (x′)2+[y+(R−h)]2=R2(x')^2 + [y + (R - h)]^2 = R^2 y(x)=R2−(L2−x)2−(R−h)y(x) = \sqrt{R^2 - \left(\frac{L}{2} - x\right)^2} - (R - h)
  3. Slope of Circular Rib:

    sin⁡θ=L/2−xR,cos⁡θ=y+(R−h)R\sin \theta = \frac{L/2 - x}{R}, \quad \cos \theta = \frac{y + (R - h)}{R}

3.1.3 Parabolic Arch with Supports at Different Levels (Springings Differing by h′h')

Let the left support AA be at vertical depth h1h_1 below the crown CC, and the right support BB be at vertical depth h2h_2 below CC.

  • Total horizontal span: L=L1+L2L = L_1 + L_2, where L1L_1 is the horizontal distance from AA to crown CC, and L2L_2 is from CC to BB.
  • Difference in springing levels: h′=∣h2−h1∣h' = |h_2 - h_1|.
                      Crown Hinge C (0,0)
                           (o)
                          /   \
           Rise h1       /     \
             v          /       \
      Pin A (o)--------+         \     Rise h2
                                  \      v
                             ------+---(o) Pin B
               <-- L1 --> <---- L2 ---->
               <---------- L ---------->

With the origin at the crown hinge CC (x=0,y=0x = 0, y = 0, measuring yy downward):

  • Left segment CACA: y=c⋅x2  ⟹  h1=c⋅L12  ⟹  c=h1L12y = c \cdot x^2 \implies h_1 = c \cdot L_1^2 \implies c = \frac{h_1}{L_1^2}
  • Right segment CBCB: y=c⋅x2  ⟹  h2=c⋅L22  ⟹  c=h2L22y = c \cdot x^2 \implies h_2 = c \cdot L_2^2 \implies c = \frac{h_2}{L_2^2}

Equating the parabolic constant cc:

h1L12=h2L22  ⟹  L1h1=L2h2\frac{h_1}{L_1^2} = \frac{h_2}{L_2^2} \implies \frac{L_1}{\sqrt{h_1}} = \frac{L_2}{\sqrt{h_2}}

Using the ratio theorem (ab=cd=a+cb+d\frac{a}{b} = \frac{c}{d} = \frac{a+c}{b+d}):

L1h1=L2h2=L1+L2h1+h2=Lh1+h2\frac{L_1}{\sqrt{h_1}} = \frac{L_2}{\sqrt{h_2}} = \frac{L_1 + L_2}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}} = \frac{L}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}}

[!IMPORTANT] Horizontal Position of the Crown for Unequal Springings:

L1=Lh1h1+h2,L2=Lh2h1+h2L_1 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_1}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}}, \quad L_2 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_2}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}}

Horizontal Thrust under Full Uniform Load (ww):

Taking moments about crown hinge CC:

  • For segment ACAC: H⋅h1=wL122  ⟹  H=wL122h1H \cdot h_1 = \frac{w L_1^2}{2} \implies H = \frac{w L_1^2}{2 h_1}
  • For segment CBCB: H⋅h2=wL222h2  ⟹  H=wL222h2H \cdot h_2 = \frac{w L_2^2}{2 h_2} \implies H = \frac{w L_2^2}{2 h_2} Substituting L1=Lh1h1+h2L_1 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_1}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}}:
H=w2h1[L2h1(h1+h2)2]=wL22(h1+h2)2H = \frac{w}{2 h_1} \left[\frac{L^2 h_1}{(\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2})^2}\right] = \mathbf{\frac{w L^2}{2 (\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2})^2}}

3.2 Internal Force Resultants at Any Cross-Section DD (x,yx, y)

Consider an arch cross-section cut at coordinate xx with vertical ordinate yy and inclination θ\theta to the horizontal.

                  Normal Axis
                      ^
                      |  Q_x (Radial Shear)
                      |  ^
                      | /
            Rib       |/   θ
        --------------+-------------> Tangent Axis
                     /|             N_x (Normal Thrust)
                    / |
                   v  |
                  M_x
  1. Bending Moment (MxM_x):

    Mx=Mx0−H⋅yM_x = M_x^0 - H \cdot y

    where Mx0M_x^0 is the bending moment in a simply supported beam of span LL carrying the identical vertical loads.

    • Sagging Moment (Mx>0M_x > 0): Produces tension on the intrados (bottom fiber).
    • Hogging Moment (Mx<0M_x < 0): Produces tension on the extrados (top fiber).
  2. Normal Thrust (NxN_x): The resultant axial compressive force acting perpendicular to the cut cross-section (along the tangent to the rib):

    Nx=Vxsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θN_x = V_x \sin \theta + H \cos \theta

    where VxV_x is the vertical shear force in the corresponding simply supported beam at section xx.

  3. Radial Shear (QxQ_x): The transverse shear force acting parallel to the cut cross-section (along the normal to the rib):

    Qx=Vxcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θQ_x = V_x \cos \theta - H \sin \theta

3.3 Eddy's Theorem (1878)

American engineer Henry T. Eddy established an elegant graphical and analytical theorem that directly relates the bending moment at any arch cross-section to the geometry of the Line of Thrust (Funicular Polygon).

Formal Enunciation of Eddy's Theorem:

"The bending moment at any cross-section of an arch rib is directly proportional to the vertical intercept between the center-line of the arch rib and the line of thrust for the given loading system."

Rigorous Analytical Proof:

Let an arch rib have a centerline profile y(x)y(x) measured vertically above the springing line. Let the line of thrust (the funicular polygon for the given loading system, drawn with a pole distance equal to the horizontal thrust HH) have a vertical ordinate ythrust(x)y_{\text{thrust}}(x) measured above the springing line.

       Bending Moment = H · z
       
         Thrust Line y_thrust(x)
                 \
                  \   +z (Thrust line above arch -> Sagging)
                   \---\
          -------------\------- Arch Rib Axis y(x)
                        \
                         \  -z (Thrust line below arch -> Hogging)
                          \
  1. By graphic statics and the fundamental property of the funicular polygon, the beam bending moment Mx0M_x^0 at any section xx is equal to the pole distance HH multiplied by the funicular polygon ordinate: Mx0=H⋅ythrust(x)M_x^0 = H \cdot y_{\text{thrust}}(x)
  2. The actual bending moment in the arch rib is: Mx=Mx0−H⋅y(x)M_x = M_x^0 - H \cdot y(x)
  3. Substitute Mx0=H⋅ythrust(x)M_x^0 = H \cdot y_{\text{thrust}}(x): Mx=H⋅ythrust(x)−H⋅y(x)=H[ythrust(x)−y(x)]M_x = H \cdot y_{\text{thrust}}(x) - H \cdot y(x) = H \left[ y_{\text{thrust}}(x) - y(x) \right]
  4. Defining the vertical intercept z(x)=ythrust(x)−y(x)z(x) = y_{\text{thrust}}(x) - y(x): Mx=H⋅z(x)\mathbf{M_x = H \cdot z(x)}

Engineering Consequences of Eddy's Theorem:

  • Case 1: ythrust>y  ⟹  z>0y_{\text{thrust}} > y \implies z > 0: The thrust line lies above the arch rib. The bending moment is positive (Sagging), causing tension at the intrados.
  • Case 2: ythrust<y  ⟹  z<0y_{\text{thrust}} < y \implies z < 0: The thrust line lies below the arch rib. The bending moment is negative (Hogging), causing tension at the extrados.
  • Case 3: ythrust≡y  ⟹  z=0y_{\text{thrust}} \equiv y \implies z = 0: The thrust line coincides exactly with the arch rib axis. The bending moment is identically zero everywhere (Mx=0M_x = 0 for all xx). The arch rib is in a state of pure axial compression!

[!NOTE] Why Parabolic Arches Carry Uniform Gravity Loads with Zero Moment: The funicular polygon for a uniformly distributed gravity load (ww) is a parabola with central ordinate wL28H\frac{w L^2}{8 H}. If the arch rib is built to a parabolic profile of rise h=wL28Hh = \frac{w L^2}{8 H}, the line of thrust coincides perfectly with the rib axis (z=0z = 0). Hence, Mx≡0M_x \equiv 0 and Qx≡0Q_x \equiv 0 across the entire span!


3.4 Temperature Effects and Support Settlements

In statically indeterminate structures (such as two-hinged or fixed arches), a change in temperature or a settlement of the supports induces massive horizontal thrusts and severe flexural stresses.

In a Three-Hinged Arch (Ds=0D_s = 0):

  • The structure is statically determinate.
  • When the ambient temperature changes by ΔT\Delta T, or when abutment BB settles vertically or spreads horizontally, the two segments ACAC and CBCB rotate freely as rigid bodies about the hinges AA, BB, and CC.
  • No internal strain, bending moment, or thermal stress is developed anywhere in the arch!

Kinematic Crown Rise under Temperature Increase (ΔT\Delta T):

Let α\alpha be the coefficient of thermal expansion. Each half-segment of the arch (approximate chord length S0=(L/2)2+h2S_0 = \sqrt{(L/2)^2 + h^2}) expands by:

ΔS=S0⋅α⋅ΔT\Delta S = S_0 \cdot \alpha \cdot \Delta T

From the geometry of the triangle A−C−(L/2,0)A - C - (L/2, 0):

S02=(L2)2+h2=L24+h2S_0^2 = \left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^2 + h^2 = \frac{L^2}{4} + h^2

Differentiating with respect to temperature (keeping span LL constant because abutments are rigid):

2S0⋅dS=2h⋅dh  ⟹  dh=S0hdS=S0h(S0⋅α⋅ΔT)=S02hαΔT2 S_0 \cdot dS = 2 h \cdot dh \implies dh = \frac{S_0}{h} dS = \frac{S_0}{h} (S_0 \cdot \alpha \cdot \Delta T) = \frac{S_0^2}{h} \alpha \Delta T

Substitute S02=L2+4h24S_0^2 = \frac{L^2 + 4h^2}{4}:

Δh=(L2+4h24h)α⋅ΔT\mathbf{\Delta h = \left(\frac{L^2 + 4h^2}{4h}\right) \alpha \cdot \Delta T}

4. Critical Conditions & Governing Theorems

4.1 Summary of Governing Formulas for Symmetrical Three-Hinged Arches

Parameter Parabolic Arch Rib Circular (Segmental) Arch Rib
Profile Equation y(x)y(x) y=4hL2x(L−x)y = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x) y=R2−(L/2−x)2−(R−h)y = \sqrt{R^2 - (L/2 - x)^2} - (R - h)
Radius of Curvature RR Variable: Rx=[1+(dy/dx)2]3/2∣d2y/dx2∣R_x = \frac{[1 + (dy/dx)^2]^{3/2}}{|d^2y/dx^2|} Constant: R=L28h+h2R = \frac{L^2}{8h} + \frac{h}{2}
Slope Equation tan⁡θ=4hL2(L−2x)\tan \theta = \frac{4h}{L^2}(L - 2x) sin⁡θ=L/2−xR\sin \theta = \frac{L/2 - x}{R}
Thrust under Full UDL (ww) H=wL28hH = \frac{w L^2}{8h} H=wL28hH = \frac{w L^2}{8h}
Bending Moment under Full UDL Mx≡0.00\mathbf{M_x \equiv 0.00} (Zero throughout) Mx≠0\mathbf{M_x \ne 0} (Small hogging moments)
Effect of ΔT\Delta T or Sinking Zero stress; crown rises by Δh\Delta h Zero stress; crown rises by Δh\Delta h

5. Cross-Sectional & Engineering Schematics

5.1 Three-Hinged Arch Mechanics, Resultants & Eddy's Theorem

The following schematic illustrates the equilibrium of a three-hinged arch, the resolution of internal forces into Normal Thrust (NN) and Radial Shear (QQ), and the geometric proof of Eddy's Theorem:

Three-Hinged Arch Mechanics and Eddy's Theorem
Figure 1: (a) Equilibrium of a three-hinged arch showing support reactions (VA,VB,HV_A, V_B, H) and internal force transformation (N,Q,MN, Q, M); (b) Visual proof of Eddy's Theorem showing the vertical intercept z=ythrust−yz = y_{\text{thrust}} - y and its relation to sagging and hogging bending moments.

5.2 Arch with Springings at Different Levels & Thermal Response

The following diagram details the geometry of a three-hinged arch with unequal support levels, along with the kinematic deformation under temperature changes:

Arch with Unequal Levels and Thermal Response
Figure 2: (a) Three-hinged parabolic arch with springings at different levels (h1<h2h_1 < h_2) showing horizontal crown position (L1,L2L_1, L_2); (b) Kinematic response under uniform temperature rise (ΔT\Delta T) showing free rotation at hinges and crown rise (Δh\Delta h) with zero internal thermal stress.

6. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 1: Analysis of a Parabolic Arch under Combined Loading

Problem Statement: A three-hinged parabolic arch has a clear span of L=30.0 mL = 30.0\text{ m} and a central rise of h=6.0 mh = 6.0\text{ m}. The supports AA and BB are at the same level. The arch carries:

  • A concentrated point load of P=120.0 kNP = 120.0\text{ kN} at x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m} from left support AA (quarter-span).
  • A uniformly distributed load of w=20.0 kN/mw = 20.0\text{ kN/m} on the right half of the span (from x=15.0 mx = 15.0\text{ m} to x=30.0 mx = 30.0\text{ m}).

Determine:

  1. The vertical reactions VAV_A and VBV_B, and the horizontal thrust HH.
  2. The bending moment, normal thrust, and radial shear at the quarter-span section DD (x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m}) just to the left and just to the right of the concentrated load.
                   P = 120 kN          w = 20 kN/m
                       v           |=================|
                      (D)          |                 |
          Pin A (o)----+-----------+-----------------(o) Pin B
               x=0   x=7.5m      x=15m              x=30m

Solution:

Step 1: Support Reactions

Total UDL load: Wudl=20.0×15.0=300.0 kNW_{\text{udl}} = 20.0 \times 15.0 = 300.0\text{ kN}, acting at x=15.0+7.5=22.5 mx = 15.0 + 7.5 = 22.5\text{ m} from AA.

  • Vertical Reaction at AA (VAV_A): Taking moments about support BB:

    ∑MB=0  ⟹  VA×30.0−120.0×(30.0−7.5)−300.0×(30.0−22.5)=0\sum M_B = 0 \implies V_A \times 30.0 - 120.0 \times (30.0 - 7.5) - 300.0 \times (30.0 - 22.5) = 0 30.0VA=120.0×22.5+300.0×7.5=2700.0+2250.0=4950.0 kNm30.0 V_A = 120.0 \times 22.5 + 300.0 \times 7.5 = 2700.0 + 2250.0 = 4950.0\text{ kNm} VA=4950.030.0=165.0 kNV_A = \frac{4950.0}{30.0} = \mathbf{165.0\text{ kN}}
  • Vertical Reaction at BB (VBV_B):

    ∑Fy=0  ⟹  VB=(120.0+300.0)−165.0=420.0−165.0=255.0 kN\sum F_y = 0 \implies V_B = (120.0 + 300.0) - 165.0 = 420.0 - 165.0 = \mathbf{255.0\text{ kN}}
  • Horizontal Thrust (HH): Crown hinge CC is at x=15.0 m,y=6.0 mx = 15.0\text{ m}, y = 6.0\text{ m}. Consider equilibrium of left half segment ACAC (∑MC=0\sum M_C = 0):

    VA×15.0−P×(15.0−7.5)−H×h=0V_A \times 15.0 - P \times (15.0 - 7.5) - H \times h = 0 165.0×15.0−120.0×7.5−H×6.0=0165.0 \times 15.0 - 120.0 \times 7.5 - H \times 6.0 = 0 2475.0−900.0−6.0H=0  ⟹  1575.0=6.0H  ⟹  H=262.5 kN2475.0 - 900.0 - 6.0 H = 0 \implies 1575.0 = 6.0 H \implies H = \mathbf{262.5\text{ kN}}

    (Check equilibrium of right segment CBCB: VB×15.0−300.0×7.5−H×6.0=3825.0−2250.0−1575.0=0V_B \times 15.0 - 300.0 \times 7.5 - H \times 6.0 = 3825.0 - 2250.0 - 1575.0 = 0. Validated!)


Step 2: Arch Geometry at Section DD (x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m})

  • Vertical rise: y=4hL2x(L−x)=4×6.030.02×7.5×(30.0−7.5)=24.0900.0×7.5×22.5=4.50 my = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x) = \frac{4 \times 6.0}{30.0^2} \times 7.5 \times (30.0 - 7.5) = \frac{24.0}{900.0} \times 7.5 \times 22.5 = \mathbf{4.50\text{ m}}
  • Slope: tan⁡θ=4hL2(L−2x)=24.0900.0(30.0−15.0)=24.0×15.0900.0=360.0900.0=0.40\tan \theta = \frac{4h}{L^2}(L - 2x) = \frac{24.0}{900.0} (30.0 - 15.0) = \frac{24.0 \times 15.0}{900.0} = \frac{360.0}{900.0} = \mathbf{0.40} sec⁡θ=1+0.402=1.16≈1.07703\sec \theta = \sqrt{1 + 0.40^2} = \sqrt{1.16} \approx 1.07703 cos⁡θ=11.16≈0.92848,sin⁡θ=0.401.16≈0.37139\cos \theta = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1.16}} \approx \mathbf{0.92848}, \quad \sin \theta = \frac{0.40}{\sqrt{1.16}} \approx \mathbf{0.37139}

Step 3: Bending Moment at Section DD (x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m})

MD=VA×7.5−H×y=165.0×7.5−262.5×4.50M_D = V_A \times 7.5 - H \times y = 165.0 \times 7.5 - 262.5 \times 4.50 MD=1237.50−1181.25=+56.25 kNm(Sagging)M_D = 1237.50 - 1181.25 = \mathbf{+56.25\text{ kNm}} \quad (\text{Sagging})

Step 4: Normal Thrust and Radial Shear at Section DD

  1. Just to the Left of the Point Load (x=7.5− mx = 7.5^-\text{ m}): Beam vertical shear: Vleft=VA=+165.0 kNV_{\text{left}} = V_A = +165.0\text{ kN}.

    • Normal Thrust (NleftN_{\text{left}}): Nleft=Vleftsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θN_{\text{left}} = V_{\text{left}} \sin \theta + H \cos \theta Nleft=165.0×0.37139+262.5×0.92848=61.280+243.725=305.01 kN(Compression)N_{\text{left}} = 165.0 \times 0.37139 + 262.5 \times 0.92848 = 61.280 + 243.725 = \mathbf{305.01\text{ kN}} \quad (\text{Compression})
    • Radial Shear (QleftQ_{\text{left}}): Qleft=Vleftcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θQ_{\text{left}} = V_{\text{left}} \cos \theta - H \sin \theta Qleft=165.0×0.92848−262.5×0.37139=153.199−97.490=+55.71 kNQ_{\text{left}} = 165.0 \times 0.92848 - 262.5 \times 0.37139 = 153.199 - 97.490 = \mathbf{+55.71\text{ kN}}
  2. Just to the Right of the Point Load (x=7.5+ mx = 7.5^+\text{ m}): Beam vertical shear: Vright=VA−P=165.0−120.0=+45.0 kNV_{\text{right}} = V_A - P = 165.0 - 120.0 = +45.0\text{ kN}.

    • Normal Thrust (NrightN_{\text{right}}): Nright=45.0×0.37139+262.5×0.92848=16.713+243.725=260.44 kN(Compression)N_{\text{right}} = 45.0 \times 0.37139 + 262.5 \times 0.92848 = 16.713 + 243.725 = \mathbf{260.44\text{ kN}} \quad (\text{Compression})
    • Radial Shear (QrightQ_{\text{right}}): Qright=45.0×0.92848−262.5×0.37139=41.782−97.490=−55.71 kNQ_{\text{right}} = 45.0 \times 0.92848 - 262.5 \times 0.37139 = 41.782 - 97.490 = \mathbf{-55.71\text{ kN}}
  • Verification of Discontinuities (Jumps): ΔN=Nleft−Nright=305.01−260.44=44.57 kN≡Psin⁡θ=120.0×0.37139=44.57 kN\Delta N = N_{\text{left}} - N_{\text{right}} = 305.01 - 260.44 = 44.57\text{ kN} \equiv P \sin \theta = 120.0 \times 0.37139 = 44.57\text{ kN} ΔQ=Qleft−Qright=55.71−(−55.71)=111.42 kN≡Pcos⁡θ=120.0×0.92848=111.42 kN\Delta Q = Q_{\text{left}} - Q_{\text{right}} = 55.71 - (-55.71) = 111.42\text{ kN} \equiv P \cos \theta = 120.0 \times 0.92848 = 111.42\text{ kN}

Example 2: Circular Arch vs Parabolic Arch & Eddy's Theorem Verification

Problem Statement: A three-hinged circular arch has a clear span of L=40.0 mL = 40.0\text{ m} and a central rise of h=8.0 mh = 8.0\text{ m}. A uniformly distributed gravity load of w=30.0 kN/mw = 30.0\text{ kN/m} covers the entire span.

  1. Determine the radius of curvature RR and the vertical ordinate yy of the circular arch at quarter-span (x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}).
  2. Calculate the horizontal thrust HH and the bending moment at quarter-span using direct equilibrium.
  3. Apply Eddy's Theorem to compute the bending moment and verify the result.
  4. Compare the bending moment with that of a three-hinged parabolic arch of the same span and rise.

Solution:

Step 1: Circular Arch Geometry

  • Radius of curvature RR: R=L28h+h2=40.028×8.0+8.02=1600.064.0+4.0=25.0+4.0=29.0 mR = \frac{L^2}{8h} + \frac{h}{2} = \frac{40.0^2}{8 \times 8.0} + \frac{8.0}{2} = \frac{1600.0}{64.0} + 4.0 = 25.0 + 4.0 = \mathbf{29.0\text{ m}}
  • Depth of springing below center of curvature: R−h=29.0−8.0=21.0 mR - h = 29.0 - 8.0 = 21.0\text{ m}
  • Vertical ordinate ycircy_{\text{circ}} at quarter-span (x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}, distance from crown x′=20.0−10.0=10.0 mx' = 20.0 - 10.0 = 10.0\text{ m}): ycirc=R2−(x′)2−(R−h)=29.02−10.02−21.0=841.0−100.0−21.0y_{\text{circ}} = \sqrt{R^2 - (x')^2} - (R - h) = \sqrt{29.0^2 - 10.0^2} - 21.0 = \sqrt{841.0 - 100.0} - 21.0 ycirc=741.0−21.0≈27.2213−21.0=6.2213 my_{\text{circ}} = \sqrt{741.0} - 21.0 \approx 27.2213 - 21.0 = \mathbf{6.2213\text{ m}}

Step 2: Direct Equilibrium Calculation

  • Vertical reaction: VA=wL2=30.0×40.02=600.0 kNV_A = \frac{w L}{2} = \frac{30.0 \times 40.0}{2} = 600.0\text{ kN}.
  • Horizontal thrust HH: Taking moment about crown hinge CC (h=8.0 mh = 8.0\text{ m}): H⋅h=VA×20.0−w×20.0×10.0=600.0×20.0−30.0×200.0=12000.0−6000.0=6000.0 kNmH \cdot h = V_A \times 20.0 - w \times 20.0 \times 10.0 = 600.0 \times 20.0 - 30.0 \times 200.0 = 12000.0 - 6000.0 = 6000.0\text{ kNm} H=6000.08.0=750.0 kNH = \frac{6000.0}{8.0} = \mathbf{750.0\text{ kN}}
  • Beam bending moment at x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}: M100=VA×10.0−w×10.022=600.0×10.0−30.0×50.0=6000.0−1500.0=4500.0 kNmM_{10}^0 = V_A \times 10.0 - \frac{w \times 10.0^2}{2} = 600.0 \times 10.0 - 30.0 \times 50.0 = 6000.0 - 1500.0 = 4500.0\text{ kNm}
  • Actual bending moment in circular arch: Mcirc=M100−H⋅ycirc=4500.0−750.0×6.2213=4500.0−4665.98=−165.98 kNm(Hogging)M_{\text{circ}} = M_{10}^0 - H \cdot y_{\text{circ}} = 4500.0 - 750.0 \times 6.2213 = 4500.0 - 4665.98 = \mathbf{-165.98\text{ kNm}} \quad (\text{Hogging})

Step 3: Application of Eddy's Theorem

For a uniform gravity load ww, the funicular polygon (line of thrust) is a parabola passing through the three hinges:

ythrust(x)=4hL2x(L−x)y_{\text{thrust}}(x) = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x)

At x=10.0 mx = 10.0\text{ m}:

ythrust(10)=4×8.01600.0×10.0×30.0=32.0×300.01600.0=6.0000 my_{\text{thrust}}(10) = \frac{4 \times 8.0}{1600.0} \times 10.0 \times 30.0 = \frac{32.0 \times 300.0}{1600.0} = \mathbf{6.0000\text{ m}}

The vertical intercept between the arch rib and the thrust line is:

z=ythrust−ycirc=6.0000−6.2213=−0.2213 mz = y_{\text{thrust}} - y_{\text{circ}} = 6.0000 - 6.2213 = \mathbf{-0.2213\text{ m}}

(The arch rib lies 0.2213 m0.2213\text{ m} ABOVE the line of thrust!)

By Eddy's Theorem:

M=H⋅z=750.0×(−0.2213)=−165.98 kNm(Exact Match!)M = H \cdot z = 750.0 \times (-0.2213) = \mathbf{-165.98\text{ kNm}} \quad (\text{Exact Match!})

Step 4: Comparison with Parabolic Arch

For a parabolic arch of the same span and rise:

ypara(10)=6.0000 m≡ythrust(10)  ⟹  z=0.0000 my_{\text{para}}(10) = 6.0000\text{ m} \equiv y_{\text{thrust}}(10) \implies z = 0.0000\text{ m} Mpara=H⋅0=0.00 kNmM_{\text{para}} = H \cdot 0 = \mathbf{0.00\text{ kNm}}

Engineering Conclusion: Under a uniform gravity load, a parabolic arch develops zero bending moment, whereas a circular arch develops an internal hogging moment of −165.98 kNm-165.98\text{ kNm} due to geometric divergence from the funicular curve.


Example 3: Parabolic Arch with Springings at Different Levels

Problem Statement: A three-hinged parabolic arch has a clear horizontal span of L=36.0 mL = 36.0\text{ m}. The left springing AA is located at a depth of h1=4.0 mh_1 = 4.0\text{ m} below the crown hinge CC. The right springing BB is located at a depth of h2=9.0 mh_2 = 9.0\text{ m} below the crown hinge CC (level difference h′=5.0 mh' = 5.0\text{ m}). The arch supports a uniformly distributed gravity load of w=24.0 kN/mw = 24.0\text{ kN/m} across its entire horizontal span.

Determine:

  1. The horizontal position of the crown hinge CC relative to supports AA and BB (L1L_1 and L2L_2).
  2. The horizontal thrust HH.
  3. The vertical support reactions VAV_A and VBV_B.
  4. The bending moment and normal thrust at the crown hinge CC.

Solution:

Step 1: Location of Crown Hinge CC

Using the derived level-ratio formulas with L=36.0 m,h1=4.0 m,h2=9.0 mL = 36.0\text{ m}, h_1 = 4.0\text{ m}, h_2 = 9.0\text{ m}:

h1=4.0=2.0 m1/2,h2=9.0=3.0 m1/2\sqrt{h_1} = \sqrt{4.0} = 2.0\text{ m}^{1/2}, \quad \sqrt{h_2} = \sqrt{9.0} = 3.0\text{ m}^{1/2} L1=Lh1h1+h2=36.0×2.02.0+3.0=72.05.0=14.40 m from support AL_1 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_1}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}} = \frac{36.0 \times 2.0}{2.0 + 3.0} = \frac{72.0}{5.0} = \mathbf{14.40\text{ m from support } A} L2=Lh2h1+h2=36.0×3.05.0=108.05.0=21.60 m from support BL_2 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_2}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}} = \frac{36.0 \times 3.0}{5.0} = \frac{108.0}{5.0} = \mathbf{21.60\text{ m from support } B}

(Check: L1+L2=14.40+21.60=36.0 mL_1 + L_2 = 14.40 + 21.60 = 36.0\text{ m}. Correct.)


Step 2: Horizontal Thrust (HH)

H=wL122h1=24.0×14.4022×4.0=24.0×207.368.0=3.0×207.36=622.08 kNH = \frac{w L_1^2}{2 h_1} = \frac{24.0 \times 14.40^2}{2 \times 4.0} = \frac{24.0 \times 207.36}{8.0} = 3.0 \times 207.36 = \mathbf{622.08\text{ kN}}

(Check from right segment: H=wL222h2=24.0×21.6022×9.0=24.0×466.5618.0=1.3333×466.56=622.08 kNH = \frac{w L_2^2}{2 h_2} = \frac{24.0 \times 21.60^2}{2 \times 9.0} = \frac{24.0 \times 466.56}{18.0} = 1.3333 \times 466.56 = 622.08\text{ kN}. Consistent!)


Step 3: Vertical Support Reactions

For left half ACAC (segment width L1=14.40 mL_1 = 14.40\text{ m}):

VA=w⋅L1=24.0×14.40=345.60 kNV_A = w \cdot L_1 = 24.0 \times 14.40 = \mathbf{345.60\text{ kN}}

For right half CBCB (segment width L2=21.60 mL_2 = 21.60\text{ m}):

VB=w⋅L2=24.0×21.60=518.40 kNV_B = w \cdot L_2 = 24.0 \times 21.60 = \mathbf{518.40\text{ kN}}

Total vertical reaction:

VA+VB=345.60+518.40=864.00 kN≡w⋅L=24.0×36.0=864.00 kN(Balanced!)V_A + V_B = 345.60 + 518.40 = 864.00\text{ kN} \equiv w \cdot L = 24.0 \times 36.0 = 864.00\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Balanced!})

Step 4: Forces at the Crown Hinge CC

  • Bending Moment (MCM_C): By definition of the internal hinge, MC=0.00 kNm\mathbf{M_C = 0.00\text{ kNm}}.
  • Normal Thrust at Crown (NCN_C): At the crown vertex, the tangent is horizontal (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ): NC=VCsin⁡(0∘)+Hcos⁡(0∘)=0+H⋅1.0=622.08 kN(Pure Compression)N_C = V_C \sin(0^\circ) + H \cos(0^\circ) = 0 + H \cdot 1.0 = \mathbf{622.08\text{ kN}} \quad (\text{Pure Compression})
  • Radial Shear at Crown (QCQ_C): QC=VCcos⁡(0∘)−Hsin⁡(0∘)=0−0=0.00 kNQ_C = V_C \cos(0^\circ) - H \sin(0^\circ) = 0 - 0 = \mathbf{0.00\text{ kN}}

7. Engineering Design Applications & Field Practice

7.1 Masonry Arches and the Middle-Third Rule

Because unreinforced masonry (stone and brick) has negligible tensile strength, masonry arches must be detailed so that no tensile stress develops across the joints:

σ=NA±MZ=Nbd±6Mbd2=Nbd(1±6ed)\sigma = \frac{N}{A} \pm \frac{M}{Z} = \frac{N}{b d} \pm \frac{6 M}{b d^2} = \frac{N}{b d} \left(1 \pm \frac{6 e}{d}\right)

To ensure σmin⁡≥0\sigma_{\min} \ge 0 (no tension):

e=MN≤d6e = \frac{M}{N} \le \frac{d}{6}

By Eddy's Theorem, the eccentricity ee is directly related to the vertical intercept zz. The line of thrust must remain strictly within the middle third of the arch rib ring (d/3d/3) under all load cases to prevent joint opening and hinge formation.

       Extrados
     =====================
         Middle Third (d/3)  <- Line of thrust must stay inside
     ---------------------
       Intrados

7.2 Abutment Design & Tie-Rods

The massive horizontal thrust HH exerts outward horizontal force on the abutments.

  • On firm rock foundations: Heavy gravity abutments transfer HH directly into the bedrock.
  • On weak soils: A horizontal tie-rod connects springings AA and BB, absorbing the tension T=HT = H and transforming the foundation load into pure vertical bearing pressure (Tied Arch Bridge).

8. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

8.1 Comparison of Three-Hinged vs Two-Hinged vs Fixed Arches

Engineering Characteristic Three-Hinged Arch Two-Hinged Arch Fixed Arch (Hingeless)
Static Indeterminacy (DsD_s) Ds=0D_s = 0 (Determinate) Ds=1D_s = 1 Ds=3D_s = 3
Thermal Stresses (ΔT\Delta T) Zero Stress (Hinges rotate freely) High Stress (Htemp=lαΔT∫(y2/EI)dsH_{\text{temp}} = \frac{l \alpha \Delta T}{\int (y^2/EI) ds}) Extremely High Stress
Abutment Settlement Sensitivity Completely Insensitive (Zero stress) Moderately Sensitive Severely Sensitive (Cracking risk)
Bending Moment Distribution Higher positive/negative moments under live loads Lower peak moments (≈20–30%\approx 20\text{–}30\% reduction) Lowest peak moments across span
Construction Complexity Complex hinge fabrication and maintenance Standard pin bearings Monolithic, no hinge maintenance

9. Common Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls

[!CAUTION] Trap 1: Assuming That Supports at Different Levels Have Equal Spans to Crown
When springings are at different levels (h1≠h2h_1 \ne h_2), students often place the crown at midspan (L/2L/2).
Reality: The crown shifts toward the higher support (h1<h2  ⟹  L1<L2h_1 < h_2 \implies L_1 < L_2). L1L_1 and L2L_2 are proportional to h1\sqrt{h_1} and h2\sqrt{h_2}, respectively!

[!WARNING] Trap 2: Confusing Normal Thrust with Horizontal Thrust
Students frequently write Nx=HN_x = H.
Reality: Nx=Vxsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θN_x = V_x \sin \theta + H \cos \theta. NxN_x equals HH only at the crown where the tangent is horizontal (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ). At the springings, NxN_x is substantially larger than HH because of the vertical shear component Vxsin⁡θV_x \sin \theta.

[!WARNING] Trap 3: Forgetting That Circular Arches Have Bending Moments Under Full UDL
Students often generalize the zero-moment property of parabolic arches to all arches.
Reality: A circular arch rib deviates from a parabola, producing an intercept z=ythrust−y≠0z = y_{\text{thrust}} - y \ne 0. By Eddy's Theorem, circular arches develop significant hogging moments under uniform gravity loading!


10. Previous Years' Examination Analysis & Reference Questions

10.1 Typical Competitive Examination Questions

Question 1 (GATE Civil Engineering)

A three-hinged parabolic arch of span LL and rise hh carries a uniformly distributed load of ww per unit run over the entire span. The horizontal thrust at each support is:

  • (A) wL/2w L / 2
  • (B) wL2/(8h)w L^2 / (8h)
  • (C) wL2/(4h)w L^2 / (4h)
  • (D) wL2/(16h)w L^2 / (16h) Solution: Option (B).

Question 2 (UPSC ESE / IES)

According to Eddy's theorem, the bending moment at any section of an arch rib is equal to:

  • (A) The horizontal thrust multiplied by the vertical intercept between the arch axis and the line of thrust
  • (B) The vertical reaction multiplied by the span
  • (C) The normal thrust multiplied by the arch thickness
  • (D) The product of radial shear and rise Solution: Option (A).

Question 3 (SSC JE / State AE)

A three-hinged arch is:

  • (A) Statically determinate and geometrically stable
  • (B) Statically indeterminate of degree 1
  • (C) Statically indeterminate of degree 3
  • (D) Unstable under vertical loads Solution: Option (A).

11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys

Problem 1 (Parabolic Arch Radial Shear)

A three-hinged parabolic arch of span 20.0 m20.0\text{ m} and rise 4.0 m4.0\text{ m} carries a central concentrated load of 80.0 kN80.0\text{ kN} at the crown. Calculate the radial shear developed at a section 5.0 m5.0\text{ m} from the left support.

Answer Key:

  • VA=40.0 kNV_A = 40.0\text{ kN}.
  • H=VA(10)4=4004=100.0 kNH = \frac{V_A (10)}{4} = \frac{400}{4} = 100.0\text{ kN}.
  • Slope at x=5.0 mx = 5.0\text{ m}: tan⁡θ=4(4)400(20−10)=160400=0.40  ⟹  cos⁡θ=0.9285,sin⁡θ=0.3714\tan \theta = \frac{4(4)}{400}(20 - 10) = \frac{160}{400} = 0.40 \implies \cos \theta = 0.9285, \sin \theta = 0.3714.
  • Vertical shear at x=5.0 mx = 5.0\text{ m}: V=VA=40.0 kNV = V_A = 40.0\text{ kN}.
  • Radial shear: Q=Vcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θ=40.0(0.9285)−100.0(0.3714)=37.14−37.14=0.00 kNQ = V \cos \theta - H \sin \theta = 40.0(0.9285) - 100.0(0.3714) = 37.14 - 37.14 = \mathbf{0.00\text{ kN}}. (Remarkable Result: Under a central concentrated load, the funicular polygon consists of two straight chords ACAC and CBCB. At x=5 mx = 5\text{ m}, the parabolic rib slope matches the chord slope!)

Problem 2 (Thermal Crown Rise)

A three-hinged parabolic arch has a span of 50.0 m50.0\text{ m} and rise of 10.0 m10.0\text{ m}. The coefficient of thermal expansion is α=12×10−6 /∘C\alpha = 12 \times 10^{-6}\text{ /}^\circ\text{C}. Calculate the vertical rise of the crown when the temperature increases by 30∘C30^\circ\text{C}.

Answer Key:

Δh=(L2+4h24h)α⋅ΔT=(2500+40040)(12×10−6)(30)\Delta h = \left(\frac{L^2 + 4h^2}{4h}\right) \alpha \cdot \Delta T = \left(\frac{2500 + 400}{40}\right) (12 \times 10^{-6}) (30) Δh=(290040)(360×10−6)=72.5×360×10−6=0.0261 m=26.1 mm\Delta h = \left(\frac{2900}{40}\right) (360 \times 10^{-6}) = 72.5 \times 360 \times 10^{-6} = \mathbf{0.0261\text{ m}} = \mathbf{26.1\text{ mm}}

Problem 3 (Arch with Unequal Springings)

A three-hinged parabolic arch has span L=40.0 mL = 40.0\text{ m}. Left support AA is h1=4.0 mh_1 = 4.0\text{ m} below the crown, and right support BB is h2=16.0 mh_2 = 16.0\text{ m} below the crown. Find the horizontal distance of the crown from the left support.

Answer Key:

L1=Lh1h1+h2=40.0×44+16=40.0×22+4=80.06=13.33 mL_1 = \frac{L \sqrt{h_1}}{\sqrt{h_1} + \sqrt{h_2}} = \frac{40.0 \times \sqrt{4}}{\sqrt{4} + \sqrt{16}} = \frac{40.0 \times 2}{2 + 4} = \frac{80.0}{6} = \mathbf{13.33\text{ m}}

12. Comprehensive Subject & Examination Mapping

Competitive Examination Relevant Section / Paper Expected Weightage Typical Question Style
GATE CE Structural Engineering (Analysis) 2–4 Marks2\text{–}4\text{ Marks} Numerical problems on normal thrust and radial shear, Eddy's theorem applications, or arches with unequal springings.
UPSC ESE Paper-I (Structural Analysis) 8–14 Marks8\text{–}14\text{ Marks} Proof of Eddy's Theorem, derivation of thermal invariance, and complete analysis of parabolic vs circular arches.
SSC JE Theory of Structures 2–3 Marks2\text{–}3\text{ Marks} Formulas for horizontal thrust wL2/8hwL^2/8h, statement of Eddy's theorem, and middle-third rule for masonry arches.
State AE / JE Civil Engineering Paper-I 3–5 Marks3\text{–}5\text{ Marks} Calculation of normal thrust at springings and location of crown hinge for unequal springings.
RRB JE Structural Mechanics 1–2 Marks1\text{–}2\text{ Marks} Basic determinacy of three-hinged arch, role of crown hinge, and temperature behavior.