SA-05-02 Chapter 05 · Arches & Suspension Cables

Two-Hinged and Fixed Arches: Mechanics, Thrust Derivation, and Temperature Stresses

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Executive Summary & Foundational Concepts
  2. 2. Statics, Kinematics & Degree of Indeterminacy
  3. 2.1 Degree of Static Indeterminacy (Ds)
  4. 2.2 Sign Conventions & Internal Force Signatures
  5. 3. Castigliano’s Second Theorem & Derivation of Horizontal Thrust
  6. 3.1 Total Strain Energy Formulation
  7. 3.2 Compatibility Condition via Castigliano’s Theorem
  8. 4. Secant Assumption (Ix = Ic sec θ) & Mathematical Integration for Standard Loadings
  9. 4.1 The Secant Assumption
  10. 4.2 Parabolic Profile & Denominator Evaluation
  11. 4.3 Standard Loading Cases
  12. 5. Temperature Effects, Thermal Stresses & Kinematic Restraints
  13. 5.1 Temperature Rise (+Δ T)
  14. 5.2 Temperature Fall (-Δ T)
  15. 6. Support Yielding (Abutment Spread/Settlement) & Rib Shortening Mechanics
  16. 6.1 Horizontal Yielding / Spreading of Abutments (δ)
  17. 6.2 Rib Shortening (Elastic Axial Shortening)
  18. 7. Fixed Arches (Ds = 3): Elastic Center Method & Temperature Response
  19. 7.1 Location of Elastic Center (O)
  20. 7.2 Fixed Arch Temperature Response
  21. 8. Solved Numerical Examples (Rigorous 3-Problem Set)
  22. Problem 1: Two-Hinged Parabolic Arch Under UDL & Midspan Point Load
  23. Problem 2: Temperature Rise Combined with Abutment Outward Yielding
  24. Problem 3: Point Load at Quarter-Span & Rib Shortening Loss
  25. 9. Three-Hinged vs. Two-Hinged vs. Fixed Arches: Deep Comparative Matrix
  26. 10. Common Engineering Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls
  27. Misconception 1: "Two-hinged parabolic arches always develop bending moments under gravity loads."
  28. Misconception 2: "Temperature rise produces sagging moments because the arch expands upward."
  29. Misconception 3: "Thermal thrust depends heavily on the bridge span L."
  30. Misconception 4: "Outward yielding of an abutment increases arch stresses."
  31. 11. Professional Practice, Codal Specifications & Real-World Bridge Case Studies
  32. 11.1 IRC:78 and IS 456 Provisions for Arch Bridges
  33. 11.2 Real-World Case Studies
  34. 12. Comprehensive Summary, Formula Sheet & Fast-Revision Checkpoints
  35. Master Formula Sheet
  36. Fast-Revision Key Takeaways

1. Executive Summary & Foundational Concepts

An arch is a curved structural member designed primarily to carry transverse gravitational loads via axial compression (thrust), drastically reducing bending moments compared to equivalent straight simply supported beams. While a three-hinged arch is statically determinate (Ds=0D_s = 0), the introduction of structural continuity by eliminating the crown hinge yields the two-hinged arch (Ds=1D_s = 1). Further restraining both abutments against rotation produces the fixed arch (Ds=3D_s = 3).

Determinate 3-Hinged Arch (Ds = 0)   ──>   Indeterminate 2-Hinged Arch (Ds = 1)   ──>   Fixed Arch (Ds = 3)
• Free thermal breathing                   • Statically Indeterminate (1 degree)         • Statically Indeterminate (3 degrees)
• Zero thermal stresses                    • High thermal thrust & crown hogging         • Severe thermal moments at abutments
• Free support settlement kinematics       • Abutment yield directly relieves thrust     • Highly sensitive to foundation rotation

The fundamental mechanics of indeterminate arches revolve around the elastic horizontal reaction HH developed at the springing points. In a simply supported curved beam (the primary determinate system), vertical loads cause the two supports to displace horizontally outward. When horizontal movement is rigidly restrained by unyielding abutments, an inward reactive thrust HH develops.

Because the structure possesses static indeterminacy, the magnitude of HH cannot be determined by equilibrium equations alone (ΣFx=0\Sigma F_x = 0, ΣFy=0\Sigma F_y = 0, ΣM=0\Sigma M = 0). Instead, it requires Castigliano’s Second Theorem (or the Principle of Minimum Strain Energy) enforcing compatibility of horizontal boundary displacements (ΔH=0\Delta_H = 0).

Two-Hinged Arch Thrust Derivation

2. Statics, Kinematics & Degree of Indeterminacy

2.1 Degree of Static Indeterminacy (DsD_s)

Consider a two-dimensional planar arch rib supported at both ends AA and BB:

  • Two-Hinged Arch:

    • Support Reactions: Left hinge produces (HA,VA)(H_A, V_A); right hinge produces (HB,VB)(H_B, V_B). Total reactions r=4r = 4.
    • Available Planar Equilibrium Equations: ΣFx=0\Sigma F_x = 0, ΣFy=0\Sigma F_y = 0, ΣM=0  ⟹  3\Sigma M = 0 \implies 3.
    • Special Equations of Condition (Internal Hinges): c=0c = 0.
    • Degree of Indeterminacy: Ds=r−3−c=4−3−0=1D_s = r - 3 - c = 4 - 3 - 0 = 1
    • Physical Redundant: The horizontal thrust HH acting between the two abutments.
  • Fixed Arch:

    • Support Reactions: Left fixed support (HA,VA,MA)(H_A, V_A, M_A); right fixed support (HB,VB,MB)(H_B, V_B, M_B). Total reactions r=6r = 6.
    • Internal Hinges: c=0c = 0.
    • Degree of Indeterminacy: Ds=6−3=3D_s = 6 - 3 = 3
    • Physical Redundants: Horizontal thrust HH, vertical reaction VV, and fixing moment MM (typically solved via the Elastic Center Method).

2.2 Sign Conventions & Internal Force Signatures

For any cross-section X(x,y)X(x, y) located at distance xx from the left springing AA:

  • Bending Moment (MxM_x): Mx=Mx0−H⋅yM_x = M_x^0 - H \cdot y where Mx0M_x^0 is the simply supported beam bending moment caused by external gravity loads on a span LL, and yy is the vertical rise of the rib above the springing line at distance xx.
    • Sagging moment (tension on intrados/bottom): Positive (++).
    • Hogging moment (tension on extrados/top): Negative (−-).
  • Normal Thrust (NxN_x): Nx=Hcos⁡θ+Vx0sin⁡θN_x = H \cos \theta + V_x^0 \sin \theta where θ\theta is the local inclination of the arch tangent with the horizontal (tan⁡θ=dy/dx\tan \theta = dy/dx), and Vx0V_x^0 is the vertical shear in the equivalent simply supported beam.
  • Radial Shear (QxQ_x): Qx=Vx0cos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θQ_x = V_x^0 \cos \theta - H \sin \theta

3. Castigliano’s Second Theorem & Derivation of Horizontal Thrust

Let the horizontal thrust HH be chosen as the redundant reaction. The primary determinate structure is a simply supported curved beam with a roller at support BB.

3.1 Total Strain Energy Formulation

The total internal strain energy UU stored in the arch rib consists of flexural strain energy UMU_M, axial strain energy UNU_N, and shear strain energy UQU_Q:

U=∫0SMx22EIds+∫0SNx22EAds+∫0SksQx22GAdsU = \int_0^S \frac{M_x^2}{2EI} ds + \int_0^S \frac{N_x^2}{2EA} ds + \int_0^S \frac{k_s Q_x^2}{2GA} ds

where dsds is the elemental arc length along the rib centroidal axis (ds=dx/cos⁡θ=dxsec⁡θds = dx / \cos \theta = dx \sec \theta).

In civil engineering arches, the depth-to-span ratio (d/Ld/L) is small (<1/15< 1/15), meaning flexural strain energy overwhelmingly dominates (>95%> 95\%). Neglecting axial and shear strain energy in the primary formulation (secondary effects are accounted for separately as rib shortening):

U≈∫0SMx22EIdsU \approx \int_0^S \frac{M_x^2}{2EI} ds

3.2 Compatibility Condition via Castigliano’s Theorem

According to Castigliano’s Second Theorem, the partial derivative of total strain energy with respect to a redundant force equals the displacement at the point and in the direction of that force. For rigid, unyielding abutments:

∂U∂H=ΔH=0\frac{\partial U}{\partial H} = \Delta_H = 0

Differentiating under the integral sign:

∂U∂H=∫0SMxEI(∂Mx∂H)ds=0\frac{\partial U}{\partial H} = \int_0^S \frac{M_x}{EI} \left(\frac{\partial M_x}{\partial H}\right) ds = 0

Substitute Mx=Mx0−H⋅yM_x = M_x^0 - H \cdot y, whence ∂Mx∂H=−y\frac{\partial M_x}{\partial H} = -y:

∫0SMx0−H⋅yEI(−y)ds=0\int_0^S \frac{M_x^0 - H \cdot y}{EI} (-y) ds = 0

Expanding and rearranging terms:

∫0SMx0⋅yEIds−H∫0Sy2EIds=0\int_0^S \frac{M_x^0 \cdot y}{EI} ds - H \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds = 0

Solving explicitly for the horizontal thrust HH:

H=∫0SMx0⋅yEIds∫0Sy2EIdsH = \frac{\displaystyle \int_0^S \frac{M_x^0 \cdot y}{EI} ds}{\displaystyle \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds}

4. Secant Assumption (Ix=Icsec⁡θI_x = I_c \sec \theta) & Mathematical Integration for Standard Loadings

4.1 The Secant Assumption

Evaluating the integrals along the curved arc length dsds is analytically cumbersome because both yy and the cross-sectional geometry vary along the profile. To enable closed-form solutions:

  1. Differential Arc Length Relation: ds=dx2+dy2=dx1+(dydx)2=dxsec⁡θds = \sqrt{dx^2 + dy^2} = dx \sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{dy}{dx}\right)^2} = dx \sec \theta
  2. Secant Variation of Moment of Inertia: In real bridge engineering, arch ribs are deepened near the springings to resist higher normal thrusts. Assuming the second moment of area varies as: Ix=Icsec⁡θI_x = I_c \sec \theta where IcI_c is the moment of inertia at the crown (θ=0  ⟹  sec⁡θ=1\theta = 0 \implies \sec \theta = 1).
  3. Simplifying the Integrand: dsIx=dxsec⁡θIcsec⁡θ=dxIc\frac{ds}{I_x} = \frac{dx \sec \theta}{I_c \sec \theta} = \frac{dx}{I_c} This transforms curved line integrals into standard Cartesian integrals along the span LL with constant EIcE I_c.

4.2 Parabolic Profile & Denominator Evaluation

For a parabolic arch with span LL and central rise hh:

y(x)=4hL2x(L−x)y(x) = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x)

The denominator of the horizontal thrust equation evaluates as:

∫0Sy2EIds=1EIc∫0Ly2dx=1EIc(16h2L4)∫0L(L2x2−2Lx3+x4)dx\int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds = \frac{1}{EI_c} \int_0^L y^2 dx = \frac{1}{EI_c} \left(\frac{16h^2}{L^4}\right) \int_0^L (L^2 x^2 - 2Lx^3 + x^4) dx

Integrating term by term:

∫0L(L2x2−2Lx3+x4)dx=[L2x33−2Lx44+x55]0L=L5(13−12+15)=L5(10−15+630)=L530\int_0^L (L^2 x^2 - 2Lx^3 + x^4) dx = \left[ \frac{L^2 x^3}{3} - \frac{2L x^4}{4} + \frac{x^5}{5} \right]_0^L = L^5 \left(\frac{1}{3} - \frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{5}\right) = L^5 \left(\frac{10 - 15 + 6}{30}\right) = \frac{L^5}{30}

Multiplying by the pre-factor:

∫0Ly2dx=16h2L4⋅L530=815h2L\int_0^L y^2 dx = \frac{16h^2}{L^4} \cdot \frac{L^5}{30} = \frac{8}{15} h^2 L

Thus, for any two-hinged parabolic arch under the secant assumption:

Denominator=815h2LEIc\text{Denominator} = \frac{8}{15} \frac{h^2 L}{EI_c}

4.3 Standard Loading Cases

Case A: Uniformly Distributed Load (ww) Over the Entire Span

  • Beam moment: Mx0=w2x(L−x)=wL28h⋅[4hL2x(L−x)]=wL28hyM_x^0 = \frac{w}{2} x (L - x) = \frac{w L^2}{8h} \cdot \left[ \frac{4h}{L^2} x(L - x) \right] = \frac{w L^2}{8h} y
  • Numerator: ∫0LMx0⋅y dx=wL28h∫0Ly2dx\int_0^L M_x^0 \cdot y \, dx = \frac{w L^2}{8h} \int_0^L y^2 dx
  • Horizontal Thrust: H=wL28h∫0Ly2dx∫0Ly2dx=wL28hH = \frac{\frac{w L^2}{8h} \int_0^L y^2 dx}{\int_0^L y^2 dx} = \frac{w L^2}{8h}
  • Profound Structural Result: Mx=Mx0−H⋅y=w2x(L−x)−(wL28h)[4hL2x(L−x)]≡0M_x = M_x^0 - H \cdot y = \frac{w}{2} x (L - x) - \left(\frac{w L^2}{8h}\right) \left[\frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x)\right] \equiv 0 Under a full UDL, the funicular polygon coincides exactly with the parabolic centerline. Bending moments are zero throughout the arch rib, exactly identical to a three-hinged arch!

Case B: Concentrated Point Load (WW) at Distance a=kLa = kL from Left Support

  • Vertical reactions: VA=W(1−k)V_A = W(1 - k), VB=WkV_B = Wk.

  • Beam Bending Moments:

    • For 0≤x≤a0 \le x \le a: Mx0=W(1−k)xM_x^0 = W(1 - k) x
    • For a≤x≤La \le x \le L: Mx0=Wk(L−x)M_x^0 = Wk(L - x)
  • Evaluating the Numerator:

    ∫0LMx0y dx=4hL2[W(1−k)∫0kLx2(L−x)dx+Wk∫kLLx(L−x)2dx]\int_0^L M_x^0 y \, dx = \frac{4h}{L^2} \left[ W(1 - k) \int_0^{kL} x^2(L - x) dx + Wk \int_{kL}^L x(L - x)^2 dx \right]

    Evaluating and dividing by 815h2L\frac{8}{15} h^2 L yields:

    H=58WLh(k−2k3+k4)H = \frac{5}{8} \frac{W L}{h} \left( k - 2k^3 + k^4 \right)

    or in terms of distance aa:

    H=58WhL3a(L−a)(L2+aL−a2)H = \frac{5}{8} \frac{W}{h L^3} a (L - a)(L^2 + aL - a^2)
  • Midspan Point Load (a=L/2  ⟹  k=0.5a = L/2 \implies k = 0.5):

    k−2k3+k4=12−2(18)+116=12−14+116=516k - 2k^3 + k^4 = \frac{1}{2} - 2\left(\frac{1}{8}\right) + \frac{1}{16} = \frac{1}{2} - \frac{1}{4} + \frac{1}{16} = \frac{5}{16} Hmid=58WLh(516)=25128WLh≈0.1953WLhH_{\text{mid}} = \frac{5}{8} \frac{W L}{h} \left(\frac{5}{16}\right) = \frac{25}{128} \frac{W L}{h} \approx 0.1953 \frac{W L}{h}

    (Note: In a three-hinged arch, H=WL4h=0.25WLhH = \frac{W L}{4h} = 0.25 \frac{W L}{h}. The two-hinged arch thrust is exactly 2532=78.125%\frac{25}{32} = 78.125\% of the three-hinged arch thrust!)


Case C: Uniformly Distributed Load (ww) Over Half Span (0≤x≤L/20 \le x \le L/2)

By superposition and anti-symmetry of the remaining half:

Hhalf=12Hfull=12(wL28h)=wL216hH_{\text{half}} = \frac{1}{2} H_{\text{full}} = \frac{1}{2} \left( \frac{w L^2}{8h} \right) = \frac{w L^2}{16h}

5. Temperature Effects, Thermal Stresses & Kinematic Restraints

Unlike three-hinged arches where thermal expansion causes free geometric rotation about the crown hinge (σtemp≡0\sigma_{\text{temp}} \equiv 0), a two-hinged arch develops severe internal stresses under temperature variations.

Two-Hinged Arch Temperature & Settlement

5.1 Temperature Rise (+ΔT+\Delta T)

If support BB were on rollers, a uniform temperature increase ΔT\Delta T across the span would cause free horizontal elongation:

ΔLthermal=L⋅α⋅ΔT\Delta L_{\text{thermal}} = L \cdot \alpha \cdot \Delta T

where α\alpha is the coefficient of thermal expansion of the material.

Because the abutments are unyielding, the net horizontal displacement must remain zero:

ΔH=ΔHelastic+ΔLthermal=0  ⟹  −HT∫0Sy2EIds+LαΔT=0\Delta_H = \Delta_H^{\text{elastic}} + \Delta L_{\text{thermal}} = 0 \implies - H_T \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds + L \alpha \Delta T = 0

Solving for the temperature thrust HTH_T:

HT=LαΔT∫0Sy2EIds=LαΔT815h2LEIcH_T = \frac{L \alpha \Delta T}{\displaystyle \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds} = \frac{L \alpha \Delta T}{\frac{8}{15} \frac{h^2 L}{EI_c}}

Simplifying by canceling LL:

HT=15EIcαΔT8h2H_T = \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h^2}

Critical Observations on Thermal Thrust:

  1. Independence of Span Length (LL): HTH_T depends only on flexural rigidity EIcE I_c, coefficient α\alpha, temperature rise ΔT\Delta T, and inversely on the square of the rise (h2h^2).
  2. Shallow Arch Vulnerability: As rise hh decreases, HT∝1/h2H_T \propto 1/h^2, meaning flat, shallow arches experience enormous thermal thrusts!
  3. Induced Bending Moments: Because no gravity loads act (Mx0=0M_x^0 = 0), the bending moment caused by temperature rise is: Mx=−HT⋅y(x)M_x = - H_T \cdot y(x) This moment is everywhere hogging (negative), reaching its peak magnitude at the crown (y=hy = h): Mcrown=−HT⋅h=−15EIcαΔT8hM_{\text{crown}} = - H_T \cdot h = - \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h}

5.2 Temperature Fall (−ΔT-\Delta T)

When the temperature drops, the arch attempts to contract horizontally. The rigid hinges pull the arch outward, inducing:

  • A negative (tensile) horizontal reaction ΔH=−HT\Delta H = - H_T (relieving dead-load thrust).
  • Everywhere sagging (positive) bending moments (Mx=+HT⋅yM_x = + H_T \cdot y).
  • Maximum sagging at crown: Mcrown=+15EIcα∣ΔT∣8hM_{\text{crown}} = + \frac{15 E I_c \alpha |\Delta T|}{8 h}.

6. Support Yielding (Abutment Spread/Settlement) & Rib Shortening Mechanics

6.1 Horizontal Yielding / Spreading of Abutments (δ\delta)

In actual bridge engineering, foundation ground yields under horizontal thrust. If one abutment displaces horizontally outward by an amount δ\delta:

ΔH=−H∫0Sy2EIds=δ\Delta_H = - H \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds = \delta

The change (reduction) in horizontal thrust is:

ΔHyield=−δ∫0Sy2EIds=−15EIcδ8h2L\Delta H_{\text{yield}} = - \frac{\delta}{\displaystyle \int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds} = - \frac{15 E I_c \delta}{8 h^2 L}
  • Consequence: Outward yield directly relieves horizontal thrust (ΔH<0\Delta H < 0).
  • Induced Moments: Loss of thrust creates sagging bending moments throughout the rib: ΔMx=−(ΔHyield)⋅y(x)=+(15EIcδ8h2L)y(x)\Delta M_x = - (\Delta H_{\text{yield}}) \cdot y(x) = + \left(\frac{15 E I_c \delta}{8 h^2 L}\right) y(x) Maximum sagging at the crown: ΔMcrown=+15EIcδ8hL\Delta M_{\text{crown}} = + \frac{15 E I_c \delta}{8 h L}

6.2 Rib Shortening (Elastic Axial Shortening)

The compressive normal thrust Nx≈Hcos⁡θN_x \approx H \cos \theta causes the arch rib to shorten elastically along its axis. The total axial contraction of the rib is:

ΔLaxial=∫0SNxEAds≈∫0LHcos⁡θEAx(dxsec⁡θ)=HLEAc\Delta L_{\text{axial}} = \int_0^S \frac{N_x}{EA} ds \approx \int_0^L \frac{H \cos \theta}{E A_x} (dx \sec \theta) = \frac{H L}{E A_c}

(assuming Ax=Acsec⁡θA_x = A_c \sec \theta, analogous to the secant assumption).

This axial shortening acts identically to an outward yield of the supports of magnitude δeff=H0LEAc\delta_{\text{eff}} = \frac{H_0 L}{E A_c}, where H0H_0 is the primary thrust. Equating boundary compatibility:

ΔHshort(815h2LEIc)+H0LEAc=0\Delta H_{\text{short}} \left( \frac{8}{15} \frac{h^2 L}{E I_c} \right) + \frac{H_0 L}{E A_c} = 0

Solving for the thrust reduction due to rib shortening:

ΔHshort=−H0LEAc815h2LEIc=−15Ic8h2AcH0=−15r28h2H0\Delta H_{\text{short}} = - \frac{\frac{H_0 L}{E A_c}}{\frac{8}{15} \frac{h^2 L}{E I_c}} = - \frac{15 I_c}{8 h^2 A_c} H_0 = - \frac{15 r^2}{8 h^2} H_0

where r=Ic/Acr = \sqrt{I_c / A_c} is the radius of gyration of the rib cross-section at the crown.

Key Rule of Thumb: In civil engineering arches with h/r≈20 to 40h/r \approx 20\text{ to }40, rib shortening reduces horizontal thrust by approximately 1% to 3%1\%\text{ to }3\%. For very flat arches (h/r<15h/r < 15), the reduction can exceed 5%5\%.


7. Fixed Arches (Ds=3D_s = 3): Elastic Center Method & Temperature Response

A fixed arch has degree of static indeterminacy Ds=3D_s = 3. The redundants are (H,V,M)(H, V, M). Solving the three simultaneous equations directly is coupled and tedious. The Elastic Center Method decouples these equations by transferring the origin of coordinates to the centroid of the elastic area of the arch.

7.1 Location of Elastic Center (OO)

Let elastic weight ds/EI=dx/EIcds / EI = dx / EI_c. The coordinates of the elastic center (xˉ,yˉ)(\bar{x}, \bar{y}) measured from the left springing:

xˉ=∫xdsEI∫dsEI=L2\bar{x} = \frac{\int x \frac{ds}{EI}}{\int \frac{ds}{EI}} = \frac{L}{2} yˉ=∫ydsEI∫dsEI=∫0L4hL2x(L−x)dx∫0Ldx=23hLL=23h\bar{y} = \frac{\int y \frac{ds}{EI}}{\int \frac{ds}{EI}} = \frac{\int_0^L \frac{4h}{L^2} x(L - x) dx}{\int_0^L dx} = \frac{\frac{2}{3} h L}{L} = \frac{2}{3} h

The elastic center OO lies on the centerline at a height of 23h\frac{2}{3} h above the springing line!

7.2 Fixed Arch Temperature Response

Connecting a rigid arm from the crown/springings to the elastic center O(L2,23h)O(\frac{L}{2}, \frac{2}{3}h):

  • Due to symmetry, the vertical redundant VO=0V_O = 0 and moment redundant MO=0M_O = 0.
  • The horizontal redundant at the elastic center under temperature rise ΔT\Delta T: HO=LαΔT∫(y−yˉ)2dsEI=LαΔT1EIc∫0L(y−23h)2dxH_O = \frac{L \alpha \Delta T}{\int (y - \bar{y})^2 \frac{ds}{EI}} = \frac{L \alpha \Delta T}{\frac{1}{EI_c} \int_0^L \left(y - \frac{2}{3}h\right)^2 dx}

Evaluating the integral:

∫0L(y2−43hy+49h2)dx=(815−43⋅23+49)h2L=(815−89+49)h2L=(815−49)h2L=445h2L\int_0^L \left( y^2 - \frac{4}{3}hy + \frac{4}{9}h^2 \right) dx = \left( \frac{8}{15} - \frac{4}{3} \cdot \frac{2}{3} + \frac{4}{9} \right) h^2 L = \left( \frac{8}{15} - \frac{8}{9} + \frac{4}{9} \right) h^2 L = \left(\frac{8}{15} - \frac{4}{9}\right) h^2 L = \frac{4}{45} h^2 L

Thus, the horizontal thrust in a fixed parabolic arch is:

Hfixed=LαΔT445h2LEIc=45EIcαΔT4h2H_{\text{fixed}} = \frac{L \alpha \Delta T}{\frac{4}{45} \frac{h^2 L}{EI_c}} = \frac{45 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h^2}

Comparison with Two-Hinged Arch:

HfixedHtwo-hinged=454158=454×815=6\frac{H_{\text{fixed}}}{H_{\text{two-hinged}}} = \frac{\frac{45}{4}}{\frac{15}{8}} = \frac{45}{4} \times \frac{8}{15} = 6

The horizontal thrust induced by temperature rise in a fixed arch is 6 times that in a two-hinged arch!

Bending Moments in Fixed Arch due to Temperature Rise:

  • At the elastic center, MO=0M_O = 0.
  • At the springings (y=0  ⟹  yˉ−y=23hy = 0 \implies \bar{y} - y = \frac{2}{3}h below OO): MA=MB=−Hfixed⋅yˉ=−(45EIcαΔT4h2)(23h)=−15EIcαΔT2h(Extremely severe hogging!)M_A = M_B = - H_{\text{fixed}} \cdot \bar{y} = - \left( \frac{45 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h^2} \right) \left(\frac{2}{3} h\right) = - \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{2 h} \quad \text{(Extremely severe hogging!)}
  • At the crown (y=h  ⟹  y−yˉ=13hy = h \implies y - \bar{y} = \frac{1}{3}h above OO): MC=+Hfixed⋅(h−yˉ)=+(45EIcαΔT4h2)(13h)=+15EIcαΔT4h(Sagging!)M_C = + H_{\text{fixed}} \cdot \left(h - \bar{y}\right) = + \left( \frac{45 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h^2} \right) \left(\frac{1}{3} h\right) = + \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h} \quad \text{(Sagging!)}

8. Solved Numerical Examples (Rigorous 3-Problem Set)

Problem 1: Two-Hinged Parabolic Arch Under UDL & Midspan Point Load

Statement:
A two-hinged parabolic arch has a horizontal span L=40 mL = 40\text{ m} and a central rise h=8 mh = 8\text{ m}. The moment of inertia varies according to the secant law (Ix=Icsec⁡θI_x = I_c \sec \theta). The arch carries a uniformly distributed dead load of 30 kN/m30\text{ kN/m} over the entire span, and a concentrated live load of 100 kN100\text{ kN} at midspan.
Determine:

  1. The total horizontal thrust HH.
  2. The bending moment, normal thrust, and radial shear at quarter-span (x=10 mx = 10\text{ m}).

Solution:

Step 1: Horizontal Thrust Computation

By the principle of superposition:

Htotal=Hudl+HpointH_{\text{total}} = H_{\text{udl}} + H_{\text{point}}
  • Due to full UDL: Hudl=wL28h=30×4028×8=48,00064=750.0000 kNH_{\text{udl}} = \frac{w L^2}{8h} = \frac{30 \times 40^2}{8 \times 8} = \frac{48,000}{64} = 750.0000\text{ kN}
  • Due to midspan concentrated load: Hpoint=25128WLh=25×100×40128×8=100,0001,024=97.6562 kNH_{\text{point}} = \frac{25}{128} \frac{W L}{h} = \frac{25 \times 100 \times 40}{128 \times 8} = \frac{100,000}{1,024} = 97.6562\text{ kN}
  • Total Horizontal Thrust: Htotal=750.0000+97.6562=847.6562 kNH_{\text{total}} = 750.0000 + 97.6562 = 847.6562\text{ kN}

Step 2: Vertical Reactions at Supports

By structural symmetry:

VA=VB=wL2+W2=30×402+1002=600+50=650.0000 kNV_A = V_B = \frac{w L}{2} + \frac{W}{2} = \frac{30 \times 40}{2} + \frac{100}{2} = 600 + 50 = 650.0000\text{ kN}

Step 3: Geometry and Beam Quantities at Quarter-Span (x=10 mx = 10\text{ m})

  • Vertical rise yy: y=4hL2x(L−x)=4×8402×10×(40−10)=321,600×300=6.0000 my = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x) = \frac{4 \times 8}{40^2} \times 10 \times (40 - 10) = \frac{32}{1,600} \times 300 = 6.0000\text{ m}
  • Slope tangent tan⁡θ\tan \theta: tan⁡θ=dydx=4hL2(L−2x)=321,600(40−20)=0.02×20=0.4000\tan \theta = \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{4h}{L^2}(L - 2x) = \frac{32}{1,600}(40 - 20) = 0.02 \times 20 = 0.4000 θ=arctan⁡(0.4000)≈21.8014∘  ⟹  cos⁡θ≈0.928477,sin⁡θ≈0.371391\theta = \arctan(0.4000) \approx 21.8014^\circ \implies \cos \theta \approx 0.928477, \quad \sin \theta \approx 0.371391
  • Simply Supported Beam Moment Mx=100M_{x=10}^0: M100=VA⋅x−wx22=650×10−30×1022=6,500−1,500=5,000.0000 kNmM_{10}^0 = V_A \cdot x - \frac{w x^2}{2} = 650 \times 10 - \frac{30 \times 10^2}{2} = 6,500 - 1,500 = 5,000.0000\text{ kNm}
  • Simply Supported Beam Vertical Shear Vx=100V_{x=10}^0: V100=VA−wx=650−30×10=350.0000 kNV_{10}^0 = V_A - w x = 650 - 30 \times 10 = 350.0000\text{ kN}

Step 4: Bending Moment at x=10 mx = 10\text{ m}

Mx=M100−Htotal⋅y=5,000.0000−(847.6562×6.0000)=5,000.0000−5,085.9375=−85.9375 kNmM_x = M_{10}^0 - H_{\text{total}} \cdot y = 5,000.0000 - (847.6562 \times 6.0000) = 5,000.0000 - 5,085.9375 = -85.9375\text{ kNm}

(The negative sign indicates a hogging moment of 85.9375 kNm85.9375\text{ kNm}).

Step 5: Normal Thrust and Radial Shear at x=10 mx = 10\text{ m}

  • Normal Thrust (NxN_x): Nx=Htotalcos⁡θ+Vx0sin⁡θ=(847.6562×0.928477)+(350.0000×0.371391)=787.0305+129.9869=917.0174 kNN_x = H_{\text{total}} \cos \theta + V_x^0 \sin \theta = (847.6562 \times 0.928477) + (350.0000 \times 0.371391) = 787.0305 + 129.9869 = 917.0174\text{ kN}
  • Radial Shear (QxQ_x): Qx=Vx0cos⁡θ−Htotalsin⁡θ=(350.0000×0.928477)−(847.6562×0.371391)=324.9670−314.8115=+10.1555 kNQ_x = V_x^0 \cos \theta - H_{\text{total}} \sin \theta = (350.0000 \times 0.928477) - (847.6562 \times 0.371391) = 324.9670 - 314.8115 = +10.1555\text{ kN}

Problem 2: Temperature Rise Combined with Abutment Outward Yielding

Statement:
A two-hinged parabolic arch has span L=30 mL = 30\text{ m} and central rise h=5 mh = 5\text{ m}.
The arch properties are:
E=2×105 N/mm2=2×108 kN/m2E = 2 \times 10^5\text{ N/mm}^2 = 2 \times 10^8\text{ kN/m}^2, Ic=4.5×108 mm4=4.5×10−4 m4I_c = 4.5 \times 10^8\text{ mm}^4 = 4.5 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^4, and α=12×10−6/∘C\alpha = 12 \times 10^{-6} /^\circ\text{C}.

  1. If the temperature rises by ΔT=25∘C\Delta T = 25^\circ\text{C}, compute the induced horizontal thrust HTH_T and the bending moment at the crown.
  2. If simultaneously one of the abutments yields horizontally outward by δ=6 mm\delta = 6\text{ mm} (0.006 m0.006\text{ m}), calculate the relief in thrust ΔHyield\Delta H_{\text{yield}} and the resulting net crown moment.

Solution:

Step 1: Flexural Rigidity at Crown (EIcE I_c)

EIc=(2×108 kN/m2)×(4.5×10−4 m4)=90,000 kNm2E I_c = (2 \times 10^8\text{ kN/m}^2) \times (4.5 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^4) = 90,000\text{ kNm}^2

Step 2: Thermal Thrust & Crown Moment

HT=15EIcαΔT8h2=15×90,000×(12×10−6)×258×52H_T = \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h^2} = \frac{15 \times 90,000 \times (12 \times 10^{-6}) \times 25}{8 \times 5^2} HT=15×90,000×0.00038×25=405200=2.0250 kNH_T = \frac{15 \times 90,000 \times 0.0003}{8 \times 25} = \frac{405}{200} = 2.0250\text{ kN}
  • Crown Bending Moment due to Temperature: MC,temp=−HT⋅h=−2.0250×5.0=−10.1250 kNm(Hogging)M_{C,\text{temp}} = - H_T \cdot h = - 2.0250 \times 5.0 = -10.1250\text{ kNm} \quad \text{(Hogging)}

Step 3: Reduction in Thrust Due to Support Yield

ΔHyield=−15EIcδ8h2L=−15×90,000×0.0068×25×30=−8,1006,000=−1.3500 kN\Delta H_{\text{yield}} = - \frac{15 E I_c \delta}{8 h^2 L} = - \frac{15 \times 90,000 \times 0.006}{8 \times 25 \times 30} = - \frac{8,100}{6,000} = -1.3500\text{ kN}
  • Crown Bending Moment due to Support Yield: MC,yield=−(ΔHyield)⋅h=−(−1.3500)×5.0=+6.7500 kNm(Sagging)M_{C,\text{yield}} = - (\Delta H_{\text{yield}}) \cdot h = - (-1.3500) \times 5.0 = +6.7500\text{ kNm} \quad \text{(Sagging)}

Step 4: Net Thrust and Combined Crown Moment

Hnet=HT+ΔHyield=2.0250−1.3500=+0.6750 kNH_{\text{net}} = H_T + \Delta H_{\text{yield}} = 2.0250 - 1.3500 = +0.6750\text{ kN} MC,net=MC,temp+MC,yield=−10.1250+6.7500=−3.3750 kNm(Hogging)M_{C,\text{net}} = M_{C,\text{temp}} + M_{C,\text{yield}} = -10.1250 + 6.7500 = -3.3750\text{ kNm} \quad \text{(Hogging)}

Problem 3: Point Load at Quarter-Span & Rib Shortening Loss

Statement:
A two-hinged parabolic arch of span L=30 mL = 30\text{ m} and central rise h=6 mh = 6\text{ m} carries a concentrated point load W=120 kNW = 120\text{ kN} at quarter-span (a=7.5 ma = 7.5\text{ m}, k=0.25k = 0.25).
Assuming the secant variation of inertia, find:

  1. The horizontal thrust HH.
  2. The bending moment under the load (x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m}) and at the crown (x=15 mx = 15\text{ m}).
  3. If the cross-sectional area at the crown is Ac=0.12 m2A_c = 0.12\text{ m}^2 and Ic=0.0025 m4I_c = 0.0025\text{ m}^4, determine the percentage reduction in horizontal thrust due to rib shortening.

Solution:

Step 1: Horizontal Thrust Computation

With k=a/L=7.5/30=0.25k = a/L = 7.5 / 30 = 0.25:

k−2k3+k4=0.25−2(0.25)3+(0.25)4=0.25−0.03125+0.00390625=0.22265625k - 2k^3 + k^4 = 0.25 - 2(0.25)^3 + (0.25)^4 = 0.25 - 0.03125 + 0.00390625 = 0.22265625 H=58WLh(k−2k3+k4)=58×120×306×0.22265625H = \frac{5}{8} \frac{W L}{h} (k - 2k^3 + k^4) = \frac{5}{8} \times \frac{120 \times 30}{6} \times 0.22265625 H=0.625×600×0.22265625=375×0.22265625=83.4961 kNH = 0.625 \times 600 \times 0.22265625 = 375 \times 0.22265625 = 83.4961\text{ kN}

Step 2: Vertical Reactions

VA=W(1−k)=120×0.75=90.0000 kNV_A = W(1 - k) = 120 \times 0.75 = 90.0000\text{ kN} VB=Wk=120×0.25=30.0000 kNV_B = Wk = 120 \times 0.25 = 30.0000\text{ kN}

Step 3: Bending Moments

  • Under the Load (x=7.5 mx = 7.5\text{ m}): ya=4×6302×7.5×(30−7.5)=24900×168.75=4.5000 my_a = \frac{4 \times 6}{30^2} \times 7.5 \times (30 - 7.5) = \frac{24}{900} \times 168.75 = 4.5000\text{ m} Ma0=VA⋅a=90×7.5=675.0000 kNmM_a^0 = V_A \cdot a = 90 \times 7.5 = 675.0000\text{ kNm} Ma=Ma0−H⋅ya=675.0000−(83.4961×4.5000)=675.0000−375.7325=+299.2675 kNm(Sagging)M_a = M_a^0 - H \cdot y_a = 675.0000 - (83.4961 \times 4.5000) = 675.0000 - 375.7325 = +299.2675\text{ kNm} \quad \text{(Sagging)}
  • At the Crown (x=15 mx = 15\text{ m}): yc=h=6.0000 my_c = h = 6.0000\text{ m} Mc0=VB×(L−xc)=30×(30−15)=450.0000 kNmM_c^0 = V_B \times (L - x_c) = 30 \times (30 - 15) = 450.0000\text{ kNm} Mc=Mc0−H⋅yc=450.0000−(83.4961×6.0000)=450.0000−500.9766=−50.9766 kNm(Hogging)M_c = M_c^0 - H \cdot y_c = 450.0000 - (83.4961 \times 6.0000) = 450.0000 - 500.9766 = -50.9766\text{ kNm} \quad \text{(Hogging)}

Step 4: Rib Shortening Thrust Loss

Radius of gyration squared:

r2=IcAc=0.00250.12≈0.020833 m2r^2 = \frac{I_c}{A_c} = \frac{0.0025}{0.12} \approx 0.020833\text{ m}^2

Thrust reduction:

ΔHshort=−15r28h2H=−15×0.0208338×62×83.4961=−0.3125288×83.4961=−0.0906 kN\Delta H_{\text{short}} = - \frac{15 r^2}{8 h^2} H = - \frac{15 \times 0.020833}{8 \times 6^2} \times 83.4961 = - \frac{0.3125}{288} \times 83.4961 = -0.0906\text{ kN} % Loss=0.090683.4961×100%=0.1085%\% \text{ Loss} = \frac{0.0906}{83.4961} \times 100\% = 0.1085\%

9. Three-Hinged vs. Two-Hinged vs. Fixed Arches: Deep Comparative Matrix

Parameter / Metric Three-Hinged Arch Two-Hinged Arch Fixed Arch
Static Indeterminacy (DsD_s) Ds=0D_s = 0 (Determinate) Ds=1D_s = 1 (Indeterminate) Ds=3D_s = 3 (Indeterminate)
Primary Redundant(s) None Horizontal thrust HH (H,V,M)(H, V, M) solved via Elastic Center
Bending Moment Under Full UDL Mx≡0M_x \equiv 0 everywhere Mx≡0M_x \equiv 0 everywhere Mx≡0M_x \equiv 0 everywhere
Thrust Under Full UDL (ww) H=wL28hH = \frac{w L^2}{8h} H=wL28hH = \frac{w L^2}{8h} H=wL28hH = \frac{w L^2}{8h}
Thrust Under Midspan Load (WW) H=14WLh=0.25WLhH = \frac{1}{4} \frac{WL}{h} = 0.25 \frac{WL}{h} H=25128WLh≈0.1953WLhH = \frac{25}{128} \frac{WL}{h} \approx 0.1953 \frac{WL}{h} H=45256WLh≈0.1758WLhH = \frac{45}{256} \frac{WL}{h} \approx 0.1758 \frac{WL}{h}
Thermal Stresses (σT\sigma_T) Zero (σT≡0\sigma_T \equiv 0) Severe (σT∝1/h2\sigma_T \propto 1/h^2) Extreme (6× Two-Hinged)
Thermal Thrust (HTH_T) 00 HT=15EIcαΔT8h2H_T = \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h^2} HT=45EIcαΔT4h2H_T = \frac{45 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h^2}
Crown Thermal Moment 00 −15EIcαΔT8h- \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h} (Hogging) +15EIcαΔT4h+ \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h} (Sagging)
Springing Thermal Moment 00 (Hinged) 00 (Hinged) −15EIcαΔT2h- \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{2 h} (Hogging)
Sensitivity to Foundation Settlement Insensitive (rigid-body rotation) Moderately sensitive (ΔH∝δ/L\Delta H \propto \delta/L) Extremely sensitive to differential rotation
Structural Rigidity / Deflections Most flexible Intermediate stiffness Most rigid, minimum live load deflections
Construction Complexity Requires complex crown pin Pins at springings only Monolithic casting, no maintenance hinges

10. Common Engineering Misconceptions & Exam Pitfalls

Misconception 1: "Two-hinged parabolic arches always develop bending moments under gravity loads."

Correction: Under a uniformly distributed load over the entire span, a two-hinged parabolic arch has zero bending moment everywhere (Mx≡0M_x \equiv 0). The funicular line for a UDL is a parabola, which matches the profile exactly. Moments only develop under non-uniform loads (e.g., concentrated loads, partial UDL) or thermal effects.

Misconception 2: "Temperature rise produces sagging moments because the arch expands upward."

Correction: This is the most common exam trap! Temperature rise expands the rib. Because the span length cannot increase due to fixed hinges, an inward horizontal thrust +HT+H_T is induced. Since Mx=−HT⋅yM_x = - H_T \cdot y, the induced bending moment is negative (hogging) everywhere! The crown fibers experience compression on the extrados (top) and tension on the intrados (bottom).

Misconception 3: "Thermal thrust depends heavily on the bridge span LL."

Correction: In the formula HT=15EIcαΔT8h2H_T = \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h^2}, the span length LL completely cancels out! Thermal thrust depends strictly on the central rise hh and flexural rigidity EIcE I_c. Flat arches with small rise hh suffer extreme thermal stresses regardless of whether the span is 20 m20\text{ m} or 100 m100\text{ m}.

Misconception 4: "Outward yielding of an abutment increases arch stresses."

Correction: Outward yielding δ\delta allows the arch to spread, which relieves horizontal thrust (ΔH<0\Delta H < 0). However, this loss of thrust reduces the arch action, creating large positive (sagging) bending moments that can overstress the arch rib in flexure.


11. Professional Practice, Codal Specifications & Real-World Bridge Case Studies

11.1 IRC:78 and IS 456 Provisions for Arch Bridges

  • Temperature Range: In India, IRC:6 mandates design for an overall temperature variation of ±25∘C\pm 25^\circ\text{C} to ±35∘C\pm 35^\circ\text{C} depending on the climatic zone.
  • Differential Temperature Gradient: Bridge decks exposed to direct sunlight heat up more rapidly than the arch rib below. Non-linear vertical temperature gradients induce severe secondary warping moments.
  • Rib Shortening and Creep: Concrete arches undergo long-term creep and shrinkage strains (4 to 6×10−44\text{ to }6 \times 10^{-4}). In long-span reinforced concrete arches, hydraulic flat jacks are inserted at the crown during construction (the Freyssinet Method) to forcibly open the crown and restore the designed thrust before sealing.

11.2 Real-World Case Studies

  1. Sydney Harbour Bridge, Australia:
    • A two-hinged steel through-arch with span L=503 mL = 503\text{ m} and central rise h=134 mh = 134\text{ m}.
    • By eliminating the crown hinge, the bridge achieved enormous aerodynamic and live-load stiffness for heavy commuter rail traffic. The massive pinned bearings at the springings accommodate temperature rotations while resisting a design horizontal thrust of 200,000 kN200,000\text{ kN}.
  2. Chenab Rail Bridge, Jammu & Kashmir, India:
    • The world’s highest railway arch bridge (359 m359\text{ m} above river bed), spanning 467 m467\text{ m}.
    • A two-hinged steel trussed arch. Rigorous wind tunnel testing and thermal gradient analyses were conducted to account for Himalayan extreme temperature variations (−20∘C-20^\circ\text{C} to +40∘C+40^\circ\text{C}).

12. Comprehensive Summary, Formula Sheet & Fast-Revision Checkpoints

Master Formula Sheet

Horizontal Thrust (General):H=∫0SM0yEIds∫0Sy2EIdsSecant Law Denominator:∫0Ly2dx=815h2L(for y=4hL2x(L−x))Full UDL Across Span:H=wL28h,Mx≡0Point Load at Midspan:H=25128WLh≈0.1953WLhPoint Load at Distance a=kL:H=58WLh(k−2k3+k4)Temperature Thrust (2-Hinged):HT=15EIcαΔT8h2  ⟹  Mcrown=−HT⋅h(Hogging)Temperature Thrust (Fixed Arch):Hfixed=45EIcαΔT4h2=6⋅HT,2-hingedAbutment Outward Yield δ:ΔHyield=−15EIcδ8h2L(Relief in thrust, induces Sagging)Rib Shortening Thrust Loss:ΔHshort=−15r28h2H0(r=Ic/Ac)\begin{aligned} \textbf{Horizontal Thrust (General):} \quad & H = \frac{\int_0^S \frac{M^0 y}{EI} ds}{\int_0^S \frac{y^2}{EI} ds} \\[10pt] \textbf{Secant Law Denominator:} \quad & \int_0^L y^2 dx = \frac{8}{15} h^2 L \quad \left(\text{for } y = \frac{4h}{L^2} x (L - x)\right) \\[10pt] \textbf{Full UDL Across Span:} \quad & H = \frac{w L^2}{8h}, \quad M_x \equiv 0 \\[10pt] \textbf{Point Load at Midspan:} \quad & H = \frac{25}{128} \frac{W L}{h} \approx 0.1953 \frac{W L}{h} \\[10pt] \textbf{Point Load at Distance } a = kL: \quad & H = \frac{5}{8} \frac{W L}{h} \left( k - 2k^3 + k^4 \right) \\[10pt] \textbf{Temperature Thrust (2-Hinged):} \quad & H_T = \frac{15 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{8 h^2} \quad \implies M_{\text{crown}} = - H_T \cdot h \quad (\text{Hogging}) \\[10pt] \textbf{Temperature Thrust (Fixed Arch):} \quad & H_{\text{fixed}} = \frac{45 E I_c \alpha \Delta T}{4 h^2} = 6 \cdot H_{T,\text{2-hinged}} \\[10pt] \textbf{Abutment Outward Yield } \delta: \quad & \Delta H_{\text{yield}} = - \frac{15 E I_c \delta}{8 h^2 L} \quad (\text{Relief in thrust, induces Sagging}) \\[10pt] \textbf{Rib Shortening Thrust Loss:} \quad & \Delta H_{\text{short}} = - \frac{15 r^2}{8 h^2} H_0 \quad \left(r = \sqrt{I_c / A_c}\right) \end{aligned}

Fast-Revision Key Takeaways

  1. A two-hinged arch is statically indeterminate to the 1st degree (Ds=1D_s = 1).
  2. Under full UDL on a parabolic rib, the bending moment is zero everywhere, identical to a three-hinged arch.
  3. Midspan concentrated load gives thrust H=25128WLhH = \frac{25}{128} \frac{WL}{h}, which is 78.125%78.125\% of that in a three-hinged arch.
  4. Temperature rise induces inward thrust and hogging moments throughout the rib.
  5. Thermal thrust HTH_T is completely independent of span length LL and inversely proportional to h2h^2.
  6. Outward yielding of abutments reduces thrust and causes sagging moments.
  7. In a fixed arch, temperature thrust is 6 times higher than in an equivalent two-hinged arch.