STEEL-05-01 Chapter 05 · Plate Girders

Plate Girder Fundamentals, Proportioning & Flange Design

Module
Design of Steel Structures (IS 800:2007)
Chapter 05
Design of Plate Girders & Industrial Trusses
Topic Code
STEEL-05-01
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE/JE, RRB JE

1. Topic Overview & Engineering Significance

When structural steel spans exceed 12 to 15 m12\text{ to }15\text{ m} or when applied bending moments and shear forces surpass the capacity of standard hot-rolled I-sections (such as ISMB 600 or ISHB 450), engineers turn to built-up flexural members known as Plate Girders. A plate girder is fabricated by welding two flange plates to a central web plate, producing deep, customized cross-sections optimized for heavy railway bridges, highway flyovers, industrial transfer girders, and overhead travelling crane runways.

Under IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.6, the design of a welded plate girder differs fundamentally from that of a standard rolled beam:

  1. Geometric Separation of Functions: The deep, thin web plate (d/twd/t_w typically 100 to 300+100\text{ to }300+) is proportioned primarily to resist transverse shear forces (VV), while the wide, thick flange plates are proportioned to resist the bending moment (MM) as an internal axial force couple (C=T=M/dC = T = M / d).
  2. Optimum Economical Proportioning: The total steel volume is minimized by selecting an optimum depth dopt=(k⋅M⋅γm0fy)1/3d_{opt} = \left(\frac{k \cdot M \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y}\right)^{1/3}, where k=d/twk = d/t_w. At this optimum depth, a fundamental structural theorem dictates that the weight of the web plate equals the total weight of both flanges (Aw=2AfA_w = 2 A_f).
  3. Web Slenderness Hierarchy: Because the web is thin, out-of-plane serviceability buckling and shear buckling are strictly controlled through a code-mandated hierarchy of slenderness limits (d/tw≤200ϵ,250ϵ,400ϵd/t_w \le 200\epsilon, 250\epsilon, 400\epsilon), dictating whether the web can remain unstiffened or requires transverse and longitudinal stiffeners.
  4. Flange Curtailment: Because bending moments peak at midspan and diminish towards supports, outer flange plates are terminated (curtailed) along the span to save substantial material.

Mastery of plate girder proportioning, web slenderness regimes, and flange curtailment mechanics is essential for large-scale infrastructure design and is among the most heavily tested topics in UPSC ESE, GATE CE, and State AE/JE examinations.


2. Code Provisions & Theoretical Derivations

2.1 Derivation of Economical Depth & Weight Equality Theorem

Consider a simply supported welded plate girder subjected to a maximum factored bending moment MM. Let:

  • dd = clear web depth
  • twt_w = web thickness
  • k=dtwk = \frac{d}{t_w} = web slenderness ratio (aspect ratio)   ⟹  tw=dk\implies t_w = \frac{d}{k}
  • Af=bf⋅tfA_f = b_f \cdot t_f = area of one flange plate
  • fyd=fyγm0f_{yd} = \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = design yield stress

Assuming conservatively that the flanges resist the entire bending moment as an axial couple with lever arm approximately equal to dd:

M≈Af⋅d⋅fyd  ⟹  Af≈Md⋅fydM \approx A_f \cdot d \cdot f_{yd} \implies A_f \approx \frac{M}{d \cdot f_{yd}}

The total cross-sectional steel area AA of the girder (ignoring welds and stiffeners) is:

A=2Af+Aw=2(Md⋅fyd)+d⋅tw=2Md⋅fyd+d2kA = 2 A_f + A_w = 2 \left( \frac{M}{d \cdot f_{yd}} \right) + d \cdot t_w = \frac{2 M}{d \cdot f_{yd}} + \frac{d^2}{k}

To find the depth dd that minimizes the total material consumption, differentiate AA with respect to dd and set dAdd=0\frac{dA}{dd} = 0:

dAdd=−2Md2⋅fyd+2dk=0\frac{dA}{dd} = -\frac{2 M}{d^2 \cdot f_{yd}} + \frac{2 d}{k} = 0 2dk=2Md2⋅fyd  ⟹  d3=k⋅Mfyd=k⋅M⋅γm0fy\frac{2 d}{k} = \frac{2 M}{d^2 \cdot f_{yd}} \implies d^3 = \frac{k \cdot M}{f_{yd}} = \frac{k \cdot M \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y} dopt=(k⋅M⋅γm0fy)1/3\mathbf{d_{opt} = \left( \frac{k \cdot M \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y} \right)^{1/3}}

Corresponding optimum web thickness:

tw,opt=doptk=(M⋅γm0k2⋅fy)1/3t_{w,opt} = \frac{d_{opt}}{k} = \left( \frac{M \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{k^2 \cdot f_y} \right)^{1/3}

The Golden Weight Equality Theorem:

Substitute doptd_{opt} into the web area AwA_w and the combined flange area 2Af2 A_f:

Aw=dopt2k=1k(kMfyd)2/3=(M2k⋅fyd2)1/3A_w = \frac{d_{opt}^2}{k} = \frac{1}{k} \left( \frac{k M}{f_{yd}} \right)^{2/3} = \left( \frac{M^2}{k \cdot f_{yd}^2} \right)^{1/3} 2Af=2Mdopt⋅fyd=2Mfyd(fydkM)1/3=2(M2k⋅fyd2)1/3=2Aw2 A_f = \frac{2 M}{d_{opt} \cdot f_{yd}} = \frac{2 M}{f_{yd}} \left( \frac{f_{yd}}{k M} \right)^{1/3} = 2 \left( \frac{M^2}{k \cdot f_{yd}^2} \right)^{1/3} = 2 A_w

(Notice: If moment of resistance includes the web's contribution Zw=twd26Z_w = \frac{t_w d^2}{6}, exact derivation gives Aw=2AfA_w = 2 A_f. Therefore, in an economically proportioned plate girder, the weight of the web plate is equal to the total weight of both flanges!)


2.2 Web Slenderness Limits (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.6.1)

To prevent serviceability web wrinkling under self-weight, out-of-plane distortion during fabrication, and premature elastic shear buckling:

ϵ=250fy\epsilon = \sqrt{\frac{250}{f_y}}
Structural Configuration Code Requirement / Limiting Web Slenderness (d/twd/t_w) Governing Mechanics
No Intermediate Transverse Stiffeners dtw≤200ϵ\mathbf{\frac{d}{t_w} \le 200\epsilon} Maximum limit for unstiffened web serviceability.
Intermediate Transverse Stiffeners (c≥dc \ge d) dtw≤200ϵ\mathbf{\frac{d}{t_w} \le 200\epsilon} Vertical stiffeners spaced widely (c≥dc \ge d).
Intermediate Transverse Stiffeners (c<dc < d) dtw≤250ϵ\mathbf{\frac{d}{t_w} \le 250\epsilon} Vertical stiffeners spaced closely (c<dc < d).
Transverse Stiffeners + 1 Longitudinal Stiffener at 0.2d0.2 d dtw≤400ϵ\mathbf{\frac{d}{t_w} \le 400\epsilon} Horizontal stiffener at 0.2d0.2 d prevents bending compressive buckling.
Transverse + 2 Longitudinal Stiffeners (0.2d0.2 d and 0.5d0.5 d) dtw≤400ϵ\mathbf{\frac{d}{t_w} \le 400\epsilon} Second stiffener at neutral axis prevents shear + axial buckling.
Absolute Code Upper Bound (dtw)max⁡=400ϵ\mathbf{\left(\frac{d}{t_w}\right)_{\max} = 400\epsilon} Under no circumstances shall d/twd/t_w exceed 400ϵ400\epsilon!

2.3 Flange Design & Cross-Section Classification (IS 800 Cl. 8.6.1.2 & Table 2)

1. Flange Outstand Ratio (b/tfb / t_f):

For a welded I-girder, the outstand bb is the projection from the web face to the flange edge:

b=bf−tw2b = \frac{b_f - t_w}{2}

From IS 800:2007 Table 2 (Limiting Width-to-Thickness Ratios):

  • Class 1 (Plastic): btf≤8.4ϵ\frac{b}{t_f} \le 8.4\epsilon
  • Class 2 (Compact): btf≤9.4ϵ\frac{b}{t_f} \le 9.4\epsilon
  • Class 3 (Semi-Compact): btf≤13.6ϵ\frac{b}{t_f} \le 13.6\epsilon

2. Design Moment Resistance (MdM_d):

For Class 1 and Class 2 sections under low shear (V≤0.60VdV \le 0.60 V_d):

Md=βb⋅Zp⋅fyγm0M_d = \beta_b \cdot Z_p \cdot \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}

Where βb=1.0\beta_b = 1.0, and the plastic modulus ZpZ_p of the built-up section is:

Zp=bf⋅tf⋅(d+tf)+tw⋅d24Z_p = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (d + t_f) + \frac{t_w \cdot d^2}{4}

(Notice that the web contributes Zpw=twd24Z_{pw} = \frac{t_w d^2}{4}, which typically provides 15% to 25%15\%\text{ to }25\% of the total plastic bending resistance!)


2.4 Flange Curtailment Mechanics (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.6.3)

In simply supported plate girders subjected to uniformly distributed loads, the bending moment follows a parabola:

M(x)=wu⋅x2(L−x)=4Mmax⁡x(L−x)L2M(x) = \frac{w_u \cdot x}{2} (L - x) = 4 M_{\max} \frac{x(L - x)}{L^2}

At sections away from midspan, the bending moment decreases rapidly. Flange plates are fabricated with multiple plates (e.g., one continuous base plate plus one or more outer cover plates). Outer plates are terminated where the remaining section can safely resist the applied moment.

1. Theoretical Cutoff Point (x1x_1):

Equating the moment capacity of the curtailed section Mc1M_{c1} to the applied moment M(x1)M(x_1):

M(x1)=Mc1  ⟹  wu⋅x12(L−x1)=Mc1M(x_1) = M_{c1} \implies \frac{w_u \cdot x_1}{2}(L - x_1) = M_{c1} x12−L⋅x1+2Mc1wu=0x_1^2 - L \cdot x_1 + \frac{2 M_{c1}}{w_u} = 0 x1=L2[1−1−Mc1Mmax⁡](measured from left support)\mathbf{x_1 = \frac{L}{2} \left[ 1 - \sqrt{1 - \frac{M_{c1}}{M_{\max}}} \right]} \quad (\text{measured from left support})

The theoretical length of the curtailed plate is:

Ltheo=L−2x1L_{theo} = L - 2 x_1

2. Actual Cutoff Point & Code Extension (IS 800 Cl. 8.6.3.2):

A curtailed flange plate cannot be abruptly terminated at the theoretical cutoff point because the plate carries a large axial force that must be developed and transferred back into the girder through weld shear. IS 800:2007 requires that the curtailed plate extend beyond the theoretical cutoff point by an extension length LextL_{ext}:

Lext≥max⁡(bf,12tf)L_{ext} \ge \max(b_f, 12 t_f)

Where bfb_f is the flange width and tft_f is the thickness of the curtailed plate.

The actual length of the curtailed plate is:

Lact=Ltheo+2LextL_{act} = L_{theo} + 2 L_{ext}

And the actual cutoff distance from the support is:

xact=x1−Lextx_{act} = x_1 - L_{ext}

3. Weld Connection Detailing (Cl. 8.6.3.3):

  • Terminal End Fillet Weld: Provided across the full width bfb_f at each end of the curtailed plate.
  • Side Fillet Welds: Continuous longitudinal welds designed to transmit the horizontal shear flow qq: q=V⋅Ac⋅yˉIzq = \frac{V \cdot A_c \cdot \bar{y}}{I_z} Where AcA_c is the area of the curtailed plate, and yˉ\bar{y} is the distance from the neutral axis to the centroid of the curtailed plate.

3. Visual Diagrams & Structural Behavior

Figure 1: Welded Plate Girder Anatomy & Web Slenderness Limits

The diagram below illustrates the cross-sectional anatomy, golden proportioning parameters, and the statutory web slenderness spectrum hierarchy.

Plate Girder Cross-Section Proportions and Slenderness Limits

Figure 2: Flange Curtailment Envelope & Welded Joint Detailing

The figure below depicts the parabolic moment diagram, the stepped moment capacity envelope, theoretical vs actual cutoff locations, and the 1:4 taper weld detail.

Flange Curtailment Bending Moment Envelope and Weld Detailing

4. Mathematical Formulations & Design Procedures

+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|            FLOWCHART: WELDED PLATE GIRDER PROPORTIONING ALGORITHM               |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 1: Input Factored Actions ]
                         Design Moment: Mu ; Design Shear: Vu ; Span: L
                         Material: fy, gm0 = 1.10, E = 2e5 MPa
                                         |
                                         v
                     [ Step 2: Select Web Aspect Ratio k = d/tw ]
                     Unstiffened web:              k = 150 to 180 (<= 200)
                     Transverse stiffened web:     k = 180 to 220 (<= 250)
                     Longitudinal stiffened web:   k = 250 to 350 (<= 400)
                                         |
                                         v
                    [ Step 3: Compute Economical Depth d_opt ]
                           d_opt = [ (k * Mu * gm0) / fy ]^(1/3)
                           tw_opt = d_opt / k
                           Round off d and tw to standard plate sizes
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 4: Verify Web Slenderness ]
                         Check d / tw <= 200 epsilon (if unstiffened)
                         Check d / tw <= 250 epsilon (transverse stiffeners)
                         Check d / tw <= 400 epsilon (transverse + longitudinal)
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 5: Design Flange Plates ]
                         Af_req ≈ Mu / [ d * (fy / gm0) ]
                         Select bf and tf such that:
                         - bf ≈ 0.25 d to 0.35 d
                         - Outstand b = (bf - tw) / 2
                         - Check b / tf <= 8.4 epsilon (Class 1) or 9.4 epsilon (Class 2)
                                         |
                                         v
                     [ Step 6: Verify Moment & Shear Capacities ]
                     Zp = bf * tf * (d + tf) + (tw * d^2) / 4
                     Md = Zp * fy / gm0 >= Mu
                     Vd = (d * tw * fy) / [ sqrt(3) * gm0 ] >= Vu
                     Check if V <= 0.60 Vd (Low Shear)
                                         |
                                         v
                       [ Step 7: Flange Curtailment (if multi-plate) ]
                       Compute Mc1 for single plate section
                       Theoretical cutoff: x1 = (L/2) [ 1 - sqrt(1 - Mc1/Mmax) ]
                       Extension: Lext = max(bf, 12 tf)
                       Actual cutoff: x_act = x1 - Lext
                       Design terminal end and side fillet welds

5. Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Complete Optimum Proportioning of a Welded Plate Girder

Statement:
A welded plate girder is to be designed for a factory building to support a maximum factored bending moment Mu=4500 kN⋅mM_u = 4500\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} and a factored shear force Vu=900 kNV_u = 900\text{ kN}. Steel grade is E250 (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, ϵ=1.0\epsilon = 1.0).

  1. Determine the optimum economical depth doptd_{opt} and web thickness twt_w assuming a web aspect ratio k=d/tw=180k = d/t_w = 180.
  2. Adopt practical plate dimensions and verify web slenderness.
  3. Design the flange plates satisfying Class 2 (Compact) outstand limits.
  4. Calculate the plastic moment capacity MdM_d and design shear resistance VdV_d of the final section.

Solution:

Step 1: Economical Web Depth (doptd_{opt}) Design yield strength:

fyd=fyγm0=250.01.10=227.273 MPaf_{yd} = \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{250.0}{1.10} = 227.273\text{ MPa}

Using the economical depth formula with k=180k = 180:

dopt=(k⋅Mu⋅106fyd)1/3=(180×4500×106×106227.273×106)1/3=(810,000×106227.273)1/3d_{opt} = \left( \frac{k \cdot M_u \cdot 10^6}{f_{yd}} \right)^{1/3} = \left( \frac{180 \times 4500 \times 10^6 \times 10^6}{227.273 \times 10^6} \right)^{1/3} = \left( \frac{810,000 \times 10^6}{227.273} \right)^{1/3} dopt=(3.564×109)1/3=1527.5 mmd_{opt} = \left( 3.564 \times 10^9 \right)^{1/3} = 1527.5\text{ mm}

Theoretical optimum web thickness:

tw,opt=doptk=1527.5180=8.49 mmt_{w,opt} = \frac{d_{opt}}{k} = \frac{1527.5}{180} = 8.49\text{ mm}

Step 2: Practical Adoption & Web Slenderness Check

  • Adopt clear web depth: d=1500.0 mmd = 1500.0\text{ mm}
  • Adopt standard web plate thickness: tw=10.0 mmt_w = 10.0\text{ mm}
  • Actual web aspect ratio: dtw=1500.010.0=150.0\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{1500.0}{10.0} = 150.0
  • Slenderness limit check (IS 800 Cl. 8.6.1): dtw=150.0≤200ϵ=200.0×1.0=200.0\frac{d}{t_w} = 150.0 \le 200\epsilon = 200.0 \times 1.0 = 200.0 The web satisfies the serviceability slenderness limit without requiring intermediate transverse stiffeners!

Step 3: Flange Design

  • Approximate required flange area:

    Af,req≈Mu×106d⋅fyd=4500×1061500.0×227.273=4,500,000340.91=13,200.0 mm2A_{f,req} \approx \frac{M_u \times 10^6}{d \cdot f_{yd}} = \frac{4500 \times 10^6}{1500.0 \times 227.273} = \frac{4,500,000}{340.91} = 13,200.0\text{ mm}^2
  • Select flange width bfb_f: Typically bf≈0.30d=0.30×1500=450.0 mmb_f \approx 0.30 d = 0.30 \times 1500 = 450.0\text{ mm}.
    Adopt bf=450.0 mmb_f = 450.0\text{ mm}.

  • Outstand of flange from web face:

    b=bf−tw2=450.0−10.02=220.0 mmb = \frac{b_f - t_w}{2} = \frac{450.0 - 10.0}{2} = 220.0\text{ mm}
  • Flange thickness to satisfy Class 2 (Compact) limit (Table 2):

    btf≤9.4ϵ=9.4  ⟹  tf≥b9.4=220.09.4=23.40 mm\frac{b}{t_f} \le 9.4\epsilon = 9.4 \implies t_f \ge \frac{b}{9.4} = \frac{220.0}{9.4} = 23.40\text{ mm}

    Adopt flange plate thickness: tf=25.0 mmt_f = 25.0\text{ mm}.

    btf=220.025.0=8.80≤9.40(Class 2 Compact Flange! Safe)\frac{b}{t_f} = \frac{220.0}{25.0} = 8.80 \le 9.40 \quad (\text{Class 2 Compact Flange! Safe})
  • Provided flange area:

    Af,prov=bf⋅tf=450.0×25.0=11,250.0 mm2A_{f,prov} = b_f \cdot t_f = 450.0 \times 25.0 = 11,250.0\text{ mm}^2

(Notice that Af,prov=11,250 mm2A_{f,prov} = 11,250\text{ mm}^2 is slightly less than the crude 13,200 mm213,200\text{ mm}^2 estimate because the web plate has Aw=15,000 mm2A_w = 15,000\text{ mm}^2 and carries substantial bending moment! Let us verify the exact plastic moment capacity).

Step 4: Plastic Section Modulus & Moment Capacity (MdM_d) Center-to-center distance between flanges:

hf=d+tf=1500.0+25.0=1525.0 mmh_f = d + t_f = 1500.0 + 25.0 = 1525.0\text{ mm}

Plastic modulus of the cross-section:

Zp=bf⋅tf⋅(d+tf)+tw⋅d24Z_p = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (d + t_f) + \frac{t_w \cdot d^2}{4} Zpf=450.0×25.0×1525.0=17,156,250 mm3Z_{pf} = 450.0 \times 25.0 \times 1525.0 = 17,156,250\text{ mm}^3 Zpw=10.0×(1500.0)24=10.0×2,250,0004=5,625,000 mm3Z_{pw} = \frac{10.0 \times (1500.0)^2}{4} = \frac{10.0 \times 2,250,000}{4} = 5,625,000\text{ mm}^3 Zp=17,156,250+5,625,000=22,781,250 mm3=22,781.25×103 mm3Z_p = 17,156,250 + 5,625,000 = 22,781,250\text{ mm}^3 = 22,781.25 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3

Design bending strength MdM_d:

Md=1.0×Zp⋅fyγm0=22,781.25×103×2501.10×106=5177.56 kN⋅mM_d = \frac{1.0 \times Z_p \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{22,781.25 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 5177.56\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Verification:

Mu=4500.0 kN⋅m≤Md=5177.56 kN⋅m(Safe! Capacity margin =+15.06%)M_u = 4500.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \le M_d = 5177.56\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \quad (\text{Safe! Capacity margin } = +15.06\%)

Step 5: Design Web Shear Capacity (VdV_d) For a welded I-girder, the effective shear area is Av=d⋅twA_v = d \cdot t_w:

Av=1500.0×10.0=15,000.0 mm2A_v = 1500.0 \times 10.0 = 15,000.0\text{ mm}^2 Vd=Av⋅fy3⋅γm0=15,000.0×2503×1.10×103=3,750,0001.905256×103=1968.24 kNV_d = \frac{A_v \cdot f_y}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{15,000.0 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{3,750,000}{1.905256 \times 10^3} = 1968.24\text{ kN}

Low shear limit:

0.60Vd=0.60×1968.24=1180.94 kN0.60 V_d = 0.60 \times 1968.24 = 1180.94\text{ kN}

Verification:

Vu=900.0 kN≤0.60Vd=1180.94 kN(Safe! Low Shear Regime confirmed, no moment reduction required)V_u = 900.0\text{ kN} \le 0.60 V_d = 1180.94\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe! Low Shear Regime confirmed, no moment reduction required})

Problem 2: Flange Curtailment Analysis

Statement:
A simply supported welded plate girder of span L=24.0 mL = 24.0\text{ m} carries a total factored uniformly distributed load wu=60.0 kN/mw_u = 60.0\text{ kN/m} (inclusive of self-weight).
The girder cross-section at midspan consists of:

  • Web: 1600×10 mm1600 \times 10\text{ mm} (d=1600 mm,tw=10 mmd = 1600\text{ mm}, t_w = 10\text{ mm}).
  • Flanges: Two plates of 450×16 mm450 \times 16\text{ mm} on each flange (total flange thickness tf=32 mmt_f = 32\text{ mm}). Steel grade is E250 (fy=250 MPa,γm0=1.10f_y = 250\text{ MPa}, \gamma_{m0} = 1.10).
    The outer flange plate of 450×16 mm450 \times 16\text{ mm} is to be curtailed when no longer required, leaving one continuous inner plate of 450×16 mm450 \times 16\text{ mm}.
    Determine:
  1. The moment capacity of the midspan section and the curtailed section.
  2. The theoretical cutoff distance x1x_1 from the support.
  3. The actual length LactL_{act} of the curtailed plate in accordance with IS 800:2007.

Solution:

Step 1: Applied Maximum Moment

Mmax⁡=wu⋅L28=60.0×(24.0)28=60.0×576.08=4320.0 kN⋅mM_{\max} = \frac{w_u \cdot L^2}{8} = \frac{60.0 \times (24.0)^2}{8} = \frac{60.0 \times 576.0}{8} = 4320.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Step 2: Moment Capacity of Midspan & Curtailed Sections Design yield stress: fyd=250/1.10=227.273 MPaf_{yd} = 250 / 1.10 = 227.273\text{ MPa}. Web plastic modulus:

Zpw=tw⋅d24=10.0×(1600.0)24=6.40×106 mm3Z_{pw} = \frac{t_w \cdot d^2}{4} = \frac{10.0 \times (1600.0)^2}{4} = 6.40 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3
  • Midspan Section (2 plates: bf=450 mm,tf=32 mmb_f = 450\text{ mm}, t_f = 32\text{ mm}):

    Zpf,mid=bf⋅tf⋅(d+tf)=450.0×32.0×(1600.0+32.0)=14,400.0×1632.0=23.5008×106 mm3Z_{pf,\text{mid}} = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (d + t_f) = 450.0 \times 32.0 \times (1600.0 + 32.0) = 14,400.0 \times 1632.0 = 23.5008 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 Zp,mid=23.5008×106+6.40×106=29.9008×106 mm3Z_{p,\text{mid}} = 23.5008 \times 10^6 + 6.40 \times 10^6 = 29.9008 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 Md,mid=29.9008×106×227.273106=6795.64 kN⋅m≥4320.0 kN⋅m(Safe)M_{d,\text{mid}} = \frac{29.9008 \times 10^6 \times 227.273}{10^6} = 6795.64\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \ge 4320.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \quad (\text{Safe})
  • Curtailed Section (1 plate: bf=450 mm,tf=16 mmb_f = 450\text{ mm}, t_f = 16\text{ mm}):

    Zpf,curt=bf⋅tf⋅(d+tf)=450.0×16.0×(1600.0+16.0)=7200.0×1616.0=11.6352×106 mm3Z_{pf,\text{curt}} = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (d + t_f) = 450.0 \times 16.0 \times (1600.0 + 16.0) = 7200.0 \times 1616.0 = 11.6352 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 Zp,curt=11.6352×106+6.40×106=18.0352×106 mm3Z_{p,\text{curt}} = 11.6352 \times 10^6 + 6.40 \times 10^6 = 18.0352 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3 Mc1=18.0352×106×227.273106=4098.91 kN⋅mM_{c1} = \frac{18.0352 \times 10^6 \times 227.273}{10^6} = 4098.91\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Step 3: Theoretical Cutoff Distance (x1x_1) Equating applied moment to Mc1M_{c1}:

M(x1)=4098.91 kN⋅mM(x_1) = 4098.91\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} x1=L2[1−1−Mc1Mmax⁡]=24.02[1−1−4098.914320.0]x_1 = \frac{L}{2} \left[ 1 - \sqrt{1 - \frac{M_{c1}}{M_{\max}}} \right] = \frac{24.0}{2} \left[ 1 - \sqrt{1 - \frac{4098.91}{4320.0}} \right] Mc1Mmax⁡=4098.914320.0=0.94882\frac{M_{c1}}{M_{\max}} = \frac{4098.91}{4320.0} = 0.94882 x1=12.0[1−1−0.94882]=12.0[1−0.05118]=12.0[1−0.22623]=12.0×0.77377=9.285 mx_1 = 12.0 \left[ 1 - \sqrt{1 - 0.94882} \right] = 12.0 \left[ 1 - \sqrt{0.05118} \right] = 12.0 [1 - 0.22623] = 12.0 \times 0.77377 = 9.285\text{ m}

The theoretical cutoff point is located at x1=9.285 mx_1 = 9.285\text{ m} from each support. Theoretical length of the outer curtailed plate:

Ltheo=L−2x1=24.0−2(9.285)=24.0−18.570=5.430 mL_{theo} = L - 2 x_1 = 24.0 - 2(9.285) = 24.0 - 18.570 = 5.430\text{ m}

Step 4: Code Extension & Actual Length (LactL_{act}) From IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.6.3.2, the curtailed plate must extend beyond the theoretical cutoff point by:

Lext≥max⁡(bf,12tf)=max⁡(450.0 mm,12×16.0=192.0 mm)=450.0 mm=0.450 mL_{ext} \ge \max(b_f, 12 t_f) = \max(450.0\text{ mm}, 12 \times 16.0 = 192.0\text{ mm}) = 450.0\text{ mm} = 0.450\text{ m}

Actual length of curtailed plate:

Lact=Ltheo+2Lext=5.430+2(0.450)=5.430+0.900=6.330 mL_{act} = L_{theo} + 2 L_{ext} = 5.430 + 2(0.450) = 5.430 + 0.900 = 6.330\text{ m}

The actual cutoff point from the support:

xact=x1−Lext=9.285−0.450=8.835 mx_{act} = x_1 - L_{ext} = 9.285 - 0.450 = 8.835\text{ m}

Conclusion:
The outer 450×16 mm450 \times 16\text{ mm} cover plate has an actual total length of 6.330 m6.330\text{ m}, centered symmetrically at midspan (extending from x=8.835 mx = 8.835\text{ m} to x=15.165 mx = 15.165\text{ m} from the left support).


Problem 3: Slenderness Regimes & Stiffener Provision Hierarchy

Statement:
A plate girder web has a clear depth d=1800 mmd = 1800\text{ mm} and is fabricated from Fe 410 steel (fy=250 MPa,ϵ=1.0f_y = 250\text{ MPa}, \epsilon = 1.0).
Categorize the web slenderness and state the mandatory stiffener requirements for:

  1. tw=12.0 mmt_w = 12.0\text{ mm}
  2. tw=8.0 mmt_w = 8.0\text{ mm}
  3. tw=5.0 mmt_w = 5.0\text{ mm}

Solution:

  • Case 1 (tw=12.0 mmt_w = 12.0\text{ mm}):

    dtw=1800.012.0=150.0\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{1800.0}{12.0} = 150.0

    Since 67ϵ<150.0≤200ϵ67\epsilon < 150.0 \le 200\epsilon:
    Classification: Shear buckling occurs, but the web satisfies the serviceability limit without intermediate stiffeners. Transverse stiffeners are optional for serviceability, but are required if Tension Field Action (TFA) is to be mobilized.

  • Case 2 (tw=8.0 mmt_w = 8.0\text{ mm}):

    dtw=1800.08.0=225.0\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{1800.0}{8.0} = 225.0

    Since 200ϵ<225.0≤250ϵ200\epsilon < 225.0 \le 250\epsilon:
    Classification: Intermediate Transverse Stiffeners are MANDATORY (spaced at c≤1.5dc \le 1.5 d) to prevent out-of-plane serviceability web buckling. No longitudinal stiffener is required.

  • Case 3 (tw=5.0 mmt_w = 5.0\text{ mm}):

    dtw=1800.05.0=360.0\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{1800.0}{5.0} = 360.0

    Since 250ϵ<360.0≤400ϵ250\epsilon < 360.0 \le 400\epsilon:
    Classification: Highly slender web!
    Mandatory Stiffeners:

    1. Intermediate Transverse Stiffeners.
    2. One Longitudinal Stiffener at 0.2d=360 mm0.2 d = 360\text{ mm} from the compression flange (to prevent bending compressive buckling).
      (If d/twd/t_w exceeded 400ϵ400\epsilon, it would be strictly prohibited by IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.6.1).

6. Comparative Engineering Analysis

Attribute Hot-Rolled I-Beam (e.g. ISMB 600) Welded Plate Girder
Span Range Economical up to 10−12 m10 - 12\text{ m} Economical for 12 m to 40+ m12\text{ m to } 40+\text{ m}
Cross-Section Depth Standardized, fixed (D≤600 mmD \le 600\text{ mm}) Tailored, arbitrary depth (d=1000−3000+ mmd = 1000 - 3000+\text{ mm})
Web Slenderness (d/twd/t_w) Low to moderate (30 to 55≤67ϵ30\text{ to } 55 \le 67\epsilon) Very high (100 to 300+>67ϵ100\text{ to } 300+ > 67\epsilon)
Shear Failure Mode Plastic shear yielding (VpV_p) Elastic/inelastic shear buckling (τb\tau_b or TFA)
Stiffener Requirements None (except at heavy point loads) Systematic network of transverse & longitudinal stiffeners
Material Distribution Fixed flange/web proportion Optimized: Aw≈2AfA_w \approx 2 A_f with curtailed flanges

7. Design Pitfalls & Practical Field Considerations

  1. Abrupt Curtailment without Extension Length (LextL_{ext}):
    Fabricators occasionally terminate cover plates at the exact theoretical cutoff point. At this point, the outer plate is carrying massive tension/compression forces. Without extending by Lext=bfL_{ext} = b_f and detailing the end fillet weld, the cover plate peels away from the inner plate, causing catastrophic joint failure.

  2. Neglecting the Web's Contribution to Plastic Moment Capacity:
    While approximate hand calculations assume M≈AfdfydM \approx A_f d f_{yd}, computerized or exact limit state design per IS 800 must include Zpw=twd2/4Z_{pw} = t_w d^2 / 4. Neglecting the web can underestimate the section's plastic capacity by 15% to 25%15\%\text{ to }25\%, leading to oversized flanges.

  3. Exceeding the 400ϵ400\epsilon Absolute Slenderness Ceiling:
    Some designers attempt to save steel by reducing web thickness in very deep girders (d>2.5 md > 2.5\text{ m}) beyond d/tw=400d/t_w = 400. Even with multiple longitudinal stiffeners, IS 800:2007 strictly prohibits d/tw>400ϵd/t_w > 400\epsilon due to dynamic vibration and excessive out-of-plane web "oil-canning".

  4. Fatigue at Cover Plate Terminations:
    In railway and crane bridge girders subjected to cyclic fatigue, squared cutoffs create severe notch stress concentrations. Flange cover plates must be provided with a 1:41:4 chamfered / tapered end to ensure smooth stress flow and prevent fatigue crack initiation.


8. Summary of Critical Formulae

========================================================================================
                      PLATE GIRDER DESIGN FORMULAE CHEAT SHEET
========================================================================================
• Optimum Economical Depth:
    d_opt = [ (k * Mu * gm0) / fy ]^(1/3)    (where k = d / tw)
    t_w_opt = d_opt / k

• Golden Rule of Economical Plate Girders:
    Aw = 2 Af    (Weight of web = Weight of both flanges)

• Flange Outstand Limits (Welded Sections, Table 2):
    Class 1 (Plastic):     b / tf <= 8.4 epsilon
    Class 2 (Compact):     b / tf <= 9.4 epsilon
    Class 3 (Semi-Compact): b / tf <= 13.6 epsilon
    (where b = (bf - tw) / 2)

• Web Slenderness Hierarchy (Cl. 8.6.1):
    d / tw <= 67 epsilon   --> Stocky Web (Full plastic shear, no buckling)
    d / tw <= 200 epsilon  --> Unstiffened Web (Serviceability limit)
    d / tw <= 250 epsilon  --> Transverse Stiffeners Mandatory (c <= 1.5 d)
    d / tw <= 400 epsilon  --> Transverse + Longitudinal Stiffener at 0.2 d Mandatory
    d / tw > 400 epsilon   --> STRICTLY PROHIBITED

• Flange Curtailment (Under Factored UDL):
    Theoretical Cutoff:    x1 = (L / 2) [ 1 - sqrt(1 - Mc1 / Mmax) ]
    Code Extension:        Lext >= max(bf, 12 tf)
    Actual Cutoff:         x_act = x1 - Lext
========================================================================================

9. Exam Traps & Tricks

  1. The Weight Equality Question:
    Question: "In an economically designed plate girder, the weight of the web plate is equal to:"
    Options: (A) Weight of one flange (B) Weight of both flanges (C) Half the weight of one flange (D) Twice the weight of both flanges
    Answer: (B) Weight of both flanges (Aw=2AfA_w = 2 A_f).

  2. The Maximum Permissible Slenderness:
    Question: "What is the absolute maximum limit of d/twd/t_w for a plate girder web with transverse and longitudinal stiffeners?"
    Answer: 400ϵ400\epsilon (for E250 steel, 400400).

  3. The Longitudinal Stiffener Level:
    Question: "The first longitudinal stiffener in a plate girder is provided at what distance from the compression flange?"
    Answer: 0.2d0.2 d (or d/5d/5). If a second longitudinal stiffener is provided, it is at the neutral axis (0.5d0.5 d).

  4. Extension Length Trap:
    In competitive exam MCQs, the extension length beyond the theoretical cutoff point is bfb_f or 12tf12 t_f (whichever is greater), NOT span/10 and NOT dd!


  1. IS 800:2007: General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi. (Sections 8.6, 8.7, and Table 2).
  2. Subramanian, N.: Design of Steel Structures (Limit State Method), Oxford University Press.
  3. Duggal, S.K.: Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education.
  4. Bhavikatti, S.S.: Design of Steel Structures (IS: 800-2007), I.K. International Publishing House.

11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys

Problem 1 (GATE CE Objective)

In a welded plate girder, if the maximum factored bending moment is MM, web aspect ratio is k=d/twk = d/t_w, and design yield stress is fydf_{yd}, the economical depth of the web is proportional to:
(A) (kM/fyd)1/2(k M / f_{yd})^{1/2}
(B) (kM/fyd)1/3(k M / f_{yd})^{1/3}
(C) (M/kfyd)1/3(M / k f_{yd})^{1/3}
(D) (k2M/fyd)1/4(k^2 M / f_{yd})^{1/4}
Answer: (B)
Hint: From optimization derivation, dopt=(kM/fyd)1/3d_{opt} = (k M / f_{yd})^{1/3}.

Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Objective)

As per IS 800:2007, an unstiffened web plate in a plate girder can have a maximum clear depth to thickness ratio (d/twd/t_w) of:
(A) 67ϵ67\epsilon
(B) 84ϵ84\epsilon
(C) 200ϵ200\epsilon
(D) 250ϵ250\epsilon
Answer: (C)
Hint: Cl. 8.6.1 specifies d/tw≤200ϵd/t_w \le 200\epsilon as the maximum serviceability limit without intermediate transverse stiffeners. (Note: 67ϵ67\epsilon is the threshold for shear buckling, but unstiffened webs are permitted up to 200ϵ200\epsilon using post-critical shear resistance).

Problem 3 (GATE CE Numerical Answer Type)

A plate girder flange consists of an inner continuous plate and an outer curtailed plate of width 400 mm400\text{ mm} and thickness 20 mm20\text{ mm}. The theoretical cutoff point is located at 6.5 m6.5\text{ m} from the support. The minimum distance from the support at which the curtailed plate can actually be terminated (in m\text{m}, rounded to two decimal places) is ______.
Answer: 6.10
Hint: Lext=max⁡(bf,12tf)=max⁡(400 mm,12×20=240 mm)=400 mm=0.40 mL_{ext} = \max(b_f, 12 t_f) = \max(400\text{ mm}, 12 \times 20 = 240\text{ mm}) = 400\text{ mm} = 0.40\text{ m}.
xact=x1−Lext=6.50−0.40=6.10 mx_{act} = x_1 - L_{ext} = 6.50 - 0.40 = 6.10\text{ m}.


12. Cross-Topic Linkages & Forward References