STEEL-04-02 Chapter 04 · Design of Beams

Shear Capacity, High Shear Interaction & Web Post-Buckling

Module
Design of Steel Structures (IS 800:2007)
Chapter 04
Design of Beams and Flexural Members
Topic Code
STEEL-04-02
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE/JE, RRB JE

1. Topic Overview & Engineering Significance

In structural steel flexural members, bending moment and shear force act simultaneously across the span. While flexure generates longitudinal normal stresses (σx\sigma_x) concentrated predominantly in the flanges, transverse shear force (VV) generates shear stresses (τxy\tau_{xy}) carried almost entirely by the beam web (≈85% to 95%\approx 85\% \text{ to } 95\%).

Under the Limit State Method of IS 800:2007, the design of beams in shear is governed by two fundamental physical thresholds:

  1. Web Slenderness & Shear Buckling Threshold (d/tw≤67ϵd/t_w \le 67\epsilon): If the web is stocky (d/tw≤67ϵd/t_w \le 67\epsilon), it can attain full plastic shear yielding (τyd=fy/[3γm0]\tau_{yd} = f_y / [\sqrt{3}\gamma_{m0}]) across its entire area without buckling. Conversely, if d/tw>67ϵd/t_w > 67\epsilon, elastic or inelastic out-of-plane shear buckling occurs prior to full cross-sectional shear plastification, necessitating post-buckling evaluation or transverse stiffeners.
  2. High Shear Interaction Threshold (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d): Under low shear conditions (V≤0.60VdV \le 0.60 V_d), transverse shear does not impair the plastic moment capacity of the section (MdM_d). However, when shear force exceeds 60%60\% of the design plastic shear capacity (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d, termed High Shear), the bi-axial yield criterion of von Mises dictates that yield in shear significantly reduces the capacity of the web to resist longitudinal flexural normal stresses. Consequently, the design bending resistance degrades parabolically from MdM_d down to the plastic moment capacity of the flanges alone (MfdM_{fd}).

Mastery of shear design, high shear moment-shear (M−VM-V) interaction, and web buckling criteria is critical for designing heavily loaded transfer girders, continuous bridge beams near internal supports, cantilever beams at column junctions, and built-up plate girders.


2. Code Provisions & Theoretical Derivations

2.1 Plastic Shear Capacity of Webs (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.1)

Under pure transverse shear, yielding of structural steel is governed by the von Mises (Distortion Energy) Yield Criterion. In a state of pure shear stress τ\tau, the equivalent von Mises stress σv\sigma_v is:

σv=σx2+3τ2=3τ=fy  ⟹  τy=fy3≈0.577fy\sigma_v = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 + 3\tau^2} = \sqrt{3}\tau = f_y \implies \tau_y = \frac{f_y}{\sqrt{3}} \approx 0.577 f_y

Applying the partial safety factor for material yield γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, the design plastic shear resistance VdV_d is:

Vd=Vpγm0=Av⋅fyw3⋅γm0V_d = \frac{V_p}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{A_v \cdot f_{yw}}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{m0}}

Where:

  • AvA_v is the effective shear area of the cross-section.
  • fywf_{yw} is the yield strength of the web (typically 250 MPa250\text{ MPa} for E250 steel).
  • γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10 is the partial safety factor against material yielding (Table 5).

Shear Area (AvA_v) Provisions (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.1.1):

  • Rolled I and H Sections (Major-Axis Bending): Av=h⋅twA_v = h \cdot t_w Where hh is the overall depth of the section, and twt_w is the web thickness. (Notice that rolled sections credit root fillets and web portions within flange thickness).
  • Welded I and H Sections (Major-Axis Bending): Av=d⋅twA_v = d \cdot t_w Where dd is the clear depth of the web between flanges (d=h−2tfd = h - 2 t_f).
  • Rolled Channels (Shear parallel to web): Av=h⋅twA_v = h \cdot t_w
  • Built-up Channels, Angles, and Rectangular Hollow Sections: Refer to IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.1.1 for explicit component area formulations.
  • Circular Hollow Sections (CHS): Av=2πA≈0.637AA_v = \frac{2}{\pi} A \approx 0.637 A

2.2 Threshold for Web Shear Buckling (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.2)

A flat web plate subjected to pure in-plane shear develops principal tensile and compressive stresses at 45∘45^\circ to the longitudinal axis:

σ1=+τ(Principal Tension),σ2=−τ(Principal Compression)\sigma_1 = +\tau \quad (\text{Principal Tension}), \qquad \sigma_2 = -\tau \quad (\text{Principal Compression})

The diagonal compressive stress (σ2\sigma_2) acts as an internal thrust along the web diagonal. If the web is slender, this diagonal compression causes out-of-plane lateral buckling before the material reaches plastic shear yield.

According to IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.2.1:

  • Unstiffened Webs: Web shear buckling shall be verified when: dtw>67ϵ\frac{d}{t_w} > 67\epsilon Where ϵ=250fy\epsilon = \sqrt{\frac{250}{f_y}}. For standard Fe 410 steel (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}), ϵ=1.0\epsilon = 1.0.
    • When d/tw≤67ϵd/t_w \le 67\epsilon: The web is classified as stocky. It attains its full plastic shear capacity VdV_d without buckling (Vn=VpV_n = V_p).
    • When d/tw>67ϵd/t_w > 67\epsilon: Web shear buckling governs. The nominal shear strength VnV_n must be computed using either the Simple Post-Critical Method or the Tension Field Method.

2.3 Post-Buckling Shear Resistance: Simple Post-Critical Method (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.2.2)

For unstiffened or stiffened webs where d/tw>67ϵd/t_w > 67\epsilon, the nominal shear resistance is determined by the shear buckling stress τb\tau_b:

Vcr=Av⋅τbγm0V_{cr} = \frac{A_v \cdot \tau_b}{\gamma_{m0}}

The shear buckling stress τb\tau_b depends on the non-dimensional web slenderness parameter λw\lambda_w:

λw=fyw3⋅τcr\lambda_w = \sqrt{\frac{f_{yw}}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \tau_{cr}}}

Where the elastic critical shear buckling stress of the plate panel is:

τcr=kv⋅π2⋅E12(1−μ2)⋅(dtw)2\tau_{cr} = \frac{k_v \cdot \pi^2 \cdot E}{12(1 - \mu^2) \cdot \left(\frac{d}{t_w}\right)^2}
  • E=2.0×105 MPaE = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa} (Modulus of elasticity)
  • μ=0.30\mu = 0.30 (Poisson's ratio), so 12(1−μ2)=12(1−0.09)=10.9212(1 - \mu^2) = 12(1 - 0.09) = 10.92.
  • kvk_v is the web shear buckling coefficient:
    • If c/d<1.0c/d < 1.0: kv=4.0+5.35(c/d)2k_v = 4.0 + \frac{5.35}{(c/d)^2}
    • If c/d≥1.0c/d \ge 1.0: kv=5.35+4.0(c/d)2k_v = 5.35 + \frac{4.0}{(c/d)^2}
    • For an unstiffened web (no intermediate stiffeners, c→∞c \to \infty): kv=5.35k_v = 5.35.

Evaluation of Design Shear Buckling Stress τb\tau_b:

  1. Stocky Web (λw≤0.8\lambda_w \le 0.8): τb=fyw3\tau_b = \frac{f_{yw}}{\sqrt{3}} (Full plastic shear yield; no buckling reduction).
  2. Inelastic Transition (0.8<λw<1.20.8 < \lambda_w < 1.2): τb=fyw3[1−0.8(λw−0.8)]\tau_b = \frac{f_{yw}}{\sqrt{3}} \left[ 1 - 0.8(\lambda_w - 0.8) \right]
  3. Slender Elastic Buckling (λw≥1.2\lambda_w \ge 1.2): τb=fyw3⋅λw2=τcr\tau_b = \frac{f_{yw}}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \lambda_w^2} = \tau_{cr} (Note: For λw≥1.2\lambda_w \ge 1.2, the buckling stress matches classical Euler plate shear buckling τcr\tau_{cr} exactly).

2.4 Combined Bending and Shear: Low vs High Shear (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2.1.2 & 8.2.1.3)

When bending moment MM and factored shear force VV act concurrently on a beam cross-section:

Case A: Low Shear Regime (V≤0.60VdV \le 0.60 V_d)

Under low shear, plastic stress redistribution permits the flanges and un-yielded portions of the web to develop full plastic bending capacity without interference from shear stress.

Mdv=Md=βb⋅Zp⋅fyγm0≤1.20Zefyγm0(for simply supported beams)M_{dv} = M_d = \beta_b \cdot Z_p \cdot \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} \le 1.20 Z_e \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} \quad (\text{for simply supported beams})

Case B: High Shear Regime (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d)

When the applied shear exceeds 60%60\% of the plastic shear capacity (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d), a large portion of the web is required to carry shear, and the von Mises yield criterion restricts the longitudinal normal stress that the web can sustain:

σx≤fy2−3τ2\sigma_x \le \sqrt{f_y^2 - 3\tau^2}

As τ→τy=fy/3\tau \to \tau_y = f_y / \sqrt{3}, σx→0\sigma_x \to 0. Thus, the web becomes virtually incapable of resisting bending moment.

To account for this degradation smoothly, IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2.1.3 specifies the reduced design bending strength MdvM_{dv}:

For Class 1 (Plastic) and Class 2 (Compact) Sections:
Mdv=Md−β(Md−Mfd)≤1.20Zefyγm0M_{dv} = M_d - \beta \left( M_d - M_{fd} \right) \le 1.20 Z_e \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}

Where:

  • MdM_d is the design bending strength under low shear (Md=βbZpfy/γm0M_d = \beta_b Z_p f_y / \gamma_{m0}, with βb=1.0\beta_b = 1.0 for Class 1 & 2).
  • β\beta is the non-dimensional shear interaction parameter: β=(2VVd−1)2\beta = \left( \frac{2V}{V_d} - 1 \right)^2
  • MfdM_{fd} is the design plastic resistance of the flanges alone (disregarding the web completely): Mfd=bf⋅tf⋅(D−tf)⋅fyγm0M_{fd} = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (D - t_f) \cdot \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} (Where bfb_f is flange width, tft_f is flange thickness, and (D−tf)(D - t_f) is the center-to-center distance between flanges).
Boundary Behavior of the Interaction Parameter β\beta:
  • At V=0.60VdV = 0.60 V_d: β=(2(0.60)−1)2=(1.20−1)2=0.202=0.04≈0\beta = (2(0.60) - 1)^2 = (1.20 - 1)^2 = 0.20^2 = 0.04 \approx 0 (smooth continuous tangency with low shear plateau).
  • At V=1.00VdV = 1.00 V_d: β=(2(1.00)−1)2=1.02=1.00\beta = (2(1.00) - 1)^2 = 1.0^2 = 1.00. Substituting into the equation: Mdv=Md−1.0(Md−Mfd)=MfdM_{dv} = M_d - 1.0(M_d - M_{fd}) = M_{fd} The bending capacity reduces strictly to the flange-only plastic capacity!
For Class 3 (Semi-Compact) Sections:
Mdv=Zed⋅fyγm0M_{dv} = Z_{ed} \cdot \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}

Where ZedZ_{ed} is the elastic section modulus of the reduced cross-section, determined by discounting the shear-stressed web area.


3. Visual Diagrams & Structural Behavior

Figure 1: Web Shear Stress Distribution & Slenderness Thresholds

The diagram below contrasts the classical parabolic elastic shear distribution with the Limit State plastic shear distribution and illustrates the slenderness regimes for web buckling.

Beam Web Shear Stress Distribution and Buckling Thresholds

Figure 2: High Shear Moment-Shear (M−VM-V) Interaction Domain & Stress Decomposition

The following figure illustrates the M−VM-V interaction boundary curve under IS 800:2007, showing the low-shear plateau, the parabolic capacity reduction zone, and the physical stress decomposition between web and flanges.

High Shear Moment Interaction Curves

4. Mathematical Formulations & Design Procedures

+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                   COMPLETE IS 800:2007 SHEAR DESIGN ALGORITHM                   |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 1: Factored Design Actions ]
                         Applied Shear: V ; Applied Moment: M
                                         |
                                         v
                     [ Step 2: Determine Effective Shear Area Av ]
                     Rolled I-section:  Av = h * tw
                     Welded I-section:  Av = d * tw
                                         |
                                         v
                     [ Step 3: Check Web Buckling Slenderness ]
                                   d / tw <= 67 epsilon ?
                                  /                      \
                             (YES)                        (NO)
                              /                              \
         [ Stocky Web: No Buckling ]            [ Slender Web: Buckling Governs ]
         Vd = [ Av * fy ] / [ sqrt(3) * gm0 ]   Compute kv (Cl. 8.4.2.2)
                                                Compute tau_cr and lambda_w
                                                Determine tau_b -> Vcr
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 4: Evaluate Applied Shear ]
                                   V <= Vd (or Vcr) ?
                                  /                  \
                             (YES)                    (NO)
                              /                          \
                     Proceed to Step 5              FAIL: Increase tw or
                                                    provide stiffeners
                                         |
                                         v
                       [ Step 5: Check High Shear Threshold ]
                                      V <= 0.60 Vd ?
                                     /              \
                                (YES)                (NO)
                                 /                      \
                     [ Low Shear Regime ]         [ High Shear Regime ]
                     Mdv = Md = Zp * fy / gm0     Compute beta = (2V/Vd - 1)^2
                                                  Compute Mfd = bf*tf*(D-tf)*fy/gm0
                                                  Mdv = Md - beta * (Md - Mfd)
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 6: Apply Upper Bound Limit ]
                         Simply Supported:  Mdv <= 1.20 Ze * fy / gm0
                         Cantilever:        Mdv <= 1.50 Ze * fy / gm0
                                         |
                                         v
                       [ Step 7: Final Flexural Adequacy ]
                                      M <= Mdv ?
                                     /          \
                                (YES)            (NO)
                                 /                  \
                           SAFE & VERIFIED      RE-SELECT SECTION

5. Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Laterally Supported Beam under High Shear Interaction

Statement:
A simply supported laterally supported steel beam fabricated from ISMB 500 @ 86.9 kg/m is subjected to a factored bending moment M=420 kN⋅mM = 420\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} and a concurrent factored shear force V=500 kNV = 500\text{ kN} at a critical section. Steel grade is E250 (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10).
Section properties for ISMB 500:

  • Overall depth D=500.0 mmD = 500.0\text{ mm}
  • Flange width bf=180.0 mmb_f = 180.0\text{ mm}
  • Flange thickness tf=17.2 mmt_f = 17.2\text{ mm}
  • Web thickness tw=10.2 mmt_w = 10.2\text{ mm}
  • Root radius r1=17.0 mmr_1 = 17.0\text{ mm}
  • Plastic section modulus Zp=2074.8×103 mm3Z_p = 2074.8 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3
  • Elastic section modulus Ze=1808.7×103 mm3Z_e = 1808.7 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3

Determine whether the section is adequate under combined flexure and shear in accordance with IS 800:2007.

Solution:

Step 1: Section Classification (Table 2)

ϵ=250fy=250250=1.0\epsilon = \sqrt{\frac{250}{f_y}} = \sqrt{\frac{250}{250}} = 1.0
  • Outstand of flange b=bf2=180.02=90.0 mmb = \frac{b_f}{2} = \frac{180.0}{2} = 90.0\text{ mm} btf=90.017.2=5.23≤9.4ϵ(Class 1 Plastic Flange)\frac{b}{t_f} = \frac{90.0}{17.2} = 5.23 \le 9.4\epsilon \quad (\text{Class 1 Plastic Flange})
  • Clear web depth d=D−2(tf+r1)=500.0−2(17.2+17.0)=500.0−68.4=431.6 mmd = D - 2(t_f + r_1) = 500.0 - 2(17.2 + 17.0) = 500.0 - 68.4 = 431.6\text{ mm} dtw=431.610.2=42.31≤84ϵ(Class 1 Plastic Web)\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{431.6}{10.2} = 42.31 \le 84\epsilon \quad (\text{Class 1 Plastic Web})

Hence, the cross-section is Class 1 (Plastic) with βb=1.0\beta_b = 1.0.

Step 2: Web Slenderness & Buckling Check (Cl. 8.4.2)

dtw=42.31≤67ϵ=67.0\frac{d}{t_w} = 42.31 \le 67\epsilon = 67.0

The web is stocky; web shear buckling will not occur prior to full plastic shear yielding.

Step 3: Design Plastic Shear Resistance (VdV_d) For rolled I-sections, effective shear area is Av=D⋅twA_v = D \cdot t_w:

Av=500.0×10.2=5100.0 mm2A_v = 500.0 \times 10.2 = 5100.0\text{ mm}^2 Vd=Av⋅fy3⋅γm0=5100.0×2503×1.10=1,275,0001.905256=669,201.7 N=669.20 kNV_d = \frac{A_v \cdot f_y}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{5100.0 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10} = \frac{1,275,000}{1.905256} = 669,201.7\text{ N} = 669.20\text{ kN}

Check shear strength adequacy:

V=500.0 kN≤Vd=669.20 kN(Safe in shear!)V = 500.0\text{ kN} \le V_d = 669.20\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe in shear!})

Step 4: Check for High Shear Regime

0.60Vd=0.60×669.20 kN=401.52 kN0.60 V_d = 0.60 \times 669.20\text{ kN} = 401.52\text{ kN}

Since applied shear V=500.0 kN>0.60VdV = 500.0\text{ kN} > 0.60 V_d (500.0>401.52 kN500.0 > 401.52\text{ kN}), the beam is in the High Shear Regime! Moment capacity must be reduced.

Step 5: Full Plastic Moment Capacity (MdM_d)

Md=βb⋅Zp⋅fyγm0=1.0×2074.8×103×2501.10×106=471.55 kN⋅mM_d = \frac{\beta_b \cdot Z_p \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{1.0 \times 2074.8 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 471.55\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Upper limit check (simply supported):

1.20Zefyγm0=1.20×1808.7×103×2501.10×106=493.28 kN⋅m1.20 Z_e \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{1.20 \times 1808.7 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 493.28\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Since Md=471.55≤493.28 kN⋅mM_d = 471.55 \le 493.28\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, the unreduced moment capacity is Md=471.55 kN⋅mM_d = 471.55\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.

Step 6: Flange Plastic Moment Resistance (MfdM_{fd}) Disregarding the web completely, the plastic modulus of the two flanges is:

Zfd=bf⋅tf⋅(D−tf)=180.0×17.2×(500.0−17.2)=3096.0×482.8=1,494,748.8 mm3Z_{fd} = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (D - t_f) = 180.0 \times 17.2 \times (500.0 - 17.2) = 3096.0 \times 482.8 = 1,494,748.8\text{ mm}^3 Mfd=Zfd⋅fyγm0=1,494,748.8×2501.10×106=339.72 kN⋅mM_{fd} = \frac{Z_{fd} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{1,494,748.8 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 339.72\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Step 7: Interaction Parameter β\beta and Reduced Moment Capacity MdvM_{dv}

VVd=500.0669.20=0.74716\frac{V}{V_d} = \frac{500.0}{669.20} = 0.74716 β=(2VVd−1)2=(2×0.74716−1)2=(1.49432−1)2=(0.49432)2=0.24435\beta = \left( \frac{2V}{V_d} - 1 \right)^2 = \left( 2 \times 0.74716 - 1 \right)^2 = (1.49432 - 1)^2 = (0.49432)^2 = 0.24435

The reduced design bending strength is:

Mdv=Md−β(Md−Mfd)M_{dv} = M_d - \beta (M_d - M_{fd}) Mdv=471.55−0.24435×(471.55−339.72)=471.55−0.24435×131.83=471.55−32.21=439.34 kN⋅mM_{dv} = 471.55 - 0.24435 \times (471.55 - 339.72) = 471.55 - 0.24435 \times 131.83 = 471.55 - 32.21 = 439.34\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Upper bound check:

Mdv=439.34 kN⋅m≤1.20Zefyγm0=493.28 kN⋅m(Satisfied)M_{dv} = 439.34\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \le 1.20 Z_e \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = 493.28\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \quad (\text{Satisfied})

Step 8: Final Flexural Adequacy Verification

Mapplied=420.0 kN⋅m≤Mdv=439.34 kN⋅mM_{applied} = 420.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \le M_{dv} = 439.34\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} Capacity Utilization Ratio=420.0439.34=0.956(95.6%≤100%)\text{Capacity Utilization Ratio} = \frac{420.0}{439.34} = 0.956 \quad (95.6\% \le 100\%)

Conclusion: The section ISMB 500 is SAFE and structurally adequate under combined high shear and bending moment.


Problem 2: Comparative Evaluation of Web Shear Buckling (Rolled vs Welded Web)

Statement:
Compare the shear resistance of the following two steel sections fabricated from E250 steel (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, E=2.0×105 MPaE = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa}, μ=0.30\mu = 0.30):

  1. Rolled Section A (ISMB 600): D=600 mmD = 600\text{ mm}, tw=11.8 mmt_w = 11.8\text{ mm}, clear depth d=524.6 mmd = 524.6\text{ mm}.
  2. Welded Plate Girder Web B: Clear depth d=1400 mmd = 1400\text{ mm}, web thickness tw=8.0 mmt_w = 8.0\text{ mm}, stiffened with intermediate transverse stiffeners at spacing c=1400 mmc = 1400\text{ mm} (c/d=1.0c/d = 1.0).

Evaluate whether shear buckling occurs in each section and calculate their design shear capacities.

Solution:

Section A: Rolled ISMB 600

  • Slenderness ratio: dtw=524.611.8=44.46\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{524.6}{11.8} = 44.46
  • Buckling limit: 67ϵ=67.0×1.0=67.067\epsilon = 67.0 \times 1.0 = 67.0. dtw=44.46≤67.0  ⟹  No shear buckling!\frac{d}{t_w} = 44.46 \le 67.0 \implies \text{No shear buckling!}
  • Effective shear area for rolled section: Av=D⋅tw=600×11.8=7080 mm2A_v = D \cdot t_w = 600 \times 11.8 = 7080\text{ mm}^2.
  • Plastic shear capacity: Vd=Av⋅fy3⋅γm0=7080×2503×1.10=1,770,0001.905256=929,008.9 N=929.01 kNV_d = \frac{A_v \cdot f_y}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{7080 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10} = \frac{1,770,000}{1.905256} = 929,008.9\text{ N} = 929.01\text{ kN}

Section B: Welded Plate Girder Web

  • Slenderness ratio:

    dtw=1400.08.0=175.0\frac{d}{t_w} = \frac{1400.0}{8.0} = 175.0
  • Buckling limit check:

    dtw=175.0>67ϵ=67.0  ⟹  Web Shear Buckling Governs!\frac{d}{t_w} = 175.0 > 67\epsilon = 67.0 \implies \mathbf{Web\ Shear\ Buckling\ Governs!}
  • Effective shear area for welded section: Av=d⋅tw=1400×8.0=11,200 mm2A_v = d \cdot t_w = 1400 \times 8.0 = 11,200\text{ mm}^2.

  • Theoretical plastic shear limit (if buckling were suppressed):

    Vp=Av⋅fy3⋅γm0=11,200×2503×1.10=1469.62 kNV_p = \frac{A_v \cdot f_y}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{11,200 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10} = 1469.62\text{ kN}
  • Evaluation by Simple Post-Critical Method (Cl. 8.4.2.2): With aspect ratio c/d=1400/1400=1.0≥1.0c/d = 1400 / 1400 = 1.0 \ge 1.0:

    kv=5.35+4.0(c/d)2=5.35+4.01.02=9.35k_v = 5.35 + \frac{4.0}{(c/d)^2} = 5.35 + \frac{4.0}{1.0^2} = 9.35

    Elastic critical shear stress:

    τcr=kv⋅π2⋅E12(1−μ2)⋅(d/tw)2=9.35×π2×200,00010.92×(175.0)2=18,456,864334,425=55.19 MPa\tau_{cr} = \frac{k_v \cdot \pi^2 \cdot E}{12(1 - \mu^2) \cdot (d/t_w)^2} = \frac{9.35 \times \pi^2 \times 200,000}{10.92 \times (175.0)^2} = \frac{18,456,864}{334,425} = 55.19\text{ MPa}
  • Non-dimensional web slenderness λw\lambda_w:

    τyw=fy3=2503=144.34 MPa\tau_{yw} = \frac{f_y}{\sqrt{3}} = \frac{250}{\sqrt{3}} = 144.34\text{ MPa} λw=τywτcr=144.3455.19=2.6153=1.6172\lambda_w = \sqrt{\frac{\tau_{yw}}{\tau_{cr}}} = \sqrt{\frac{144.34}{55.19}} = \sqrt{2.6153} = 1.6172
  • Shear buckling stress τb\tau_b: Since λw=1.6172≥1.2\lambda_w = 1.6172 \ge 1.2, the web is in the elastic buckling domain:

    τb=τywλw2=144.34(1.6172)2=55.19 MPa(=τcr)\tau_b = \frac{\tau_{yw}}{\lambda_w^2} = \frac{144.34}{(1.6172)^2} = 55.19\text{ MPa} \quad (= \tau_{cr})
  • Design shear buckling strength VcrV_{cr}:

    Vcr=Av⋅τbγm0=11,200×55.191.10×103=618,1281.10×103=561.93 kNV_{cr} = \frac{A_v \cdot \tau_b}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{11,200 \times 55.19}{1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{618,128}{1.10 \times 10^3} = 561.93\text{ kN}

Summary Comparison:

  • For the plate girder web, shear buckling reduces the shear capacity from 1469.62 kN1469.62\text{ kN} to 561.93 kN561.93\text{ kN}—a massive 61.76%61.76\% loss in capacity due to elastic out-of-plane web buckling!

Problem 3: Continuous M−VM-V Interaction Curve Mapping

Statement:
For an ISMB 450 @ 72.4 kg/m beam (D=450 mmD = 450\text{ mm}, bf=150 mmb_f = 150\text{ mm}, tf=17.4 mmt_f = 17.4\text{ mm}, tw=9.4 mmt_w = 9.4\text{ mm}, Zp=1533.4×103 mm3Z_p = 1533.4 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3, Ze=1350.7×103 mm3Z_e = 1350.7 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3, fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10), map the design moment capacity MdvM_{dv} across the entire shear spectrum V/Vd∈[0.60,0.70,0.80,0.90,1.00]V/V_d \in [0.60, 0.70, 0.80, 0.90, 1.00].

Solution:

Step 1: Section Capacities

Av=D⋅tw=450.0×9.4=4230.0 mm2A_v = D \cdot t_w = 450.0 \times 9.4 = 4230.0\text{ mm}^2 Vd=4230.0×2503×1.10×103=555.05 kNV_d = \frac{4230.0 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10 \times 10^3} = 555.05\text{ kN} Md=1.0×1533.4×103×2501.10×106=348.50 kN⋅mM_d = \frac{1.0 \times 1533.4 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 348.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Flange plastic moment MfdM_{fd}:

Zfd=bf⋅tf⋅(D−tf)=150.0×17.4×(450.0−17.4)=2610.0×432.6=1,129,086 mm3Z_{fd} = b_f \cdot t_f \cdot (D - t_f) = 150.0 \times 17.4 \times (450.0 - 17.4) = 2610.0 \times 432.6 = 1,129,086\text{ mm}^3 Mfd=1,129,086×2501.10×106=256.61 kN⋅mM_{fd} = \frac{1,129,086 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = 256.61\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Step 2: Parametric Spectrum Calculation

Ratio V/VdV/V_d Shear VV (kN) Regime β=(2V/Vd−1)2\beta = (2V/V_d - 1)^2 Mdv=Md−β(Md−Mfd)M_{dv} = M_d - \beta(M_d - M_{fd}) (kN-m) % of MdM_d
0.60 333.03 Low Shear Boundary 0.00000.0000 348.50 100.0%
0.70 388.54 High Shear (1.40−1)2=0.1600(1.40 - 1)^2 = 0.1600 348.50−0.1600(91.89)=333.80348.50 - 0.1600(91.89) = \mathbf{333.80} 95.8%
0.80 444.04 High Shear (1.60−1)2=0.3600(1.60 - 1)^2 = 0.3600 348.50−0.3600(91.89)=315.42348.50 - 0.3600(91.89) = \mathbf{315.42} 90.5%
0.90 499.55 High Shear (1.80−1)2=0.6400(1.80 - 1)^2 = 0.6400 348.50−0.6400(91.89)=289.69348.50 - 0.6400(91.89) = \mathbf{289.69} 83.1%
1.00 555.05 Plastic Shear Limit (2.00−1)2=1.0000(2.00 - 1)^2 = 1.0000 348.50−1.0000(91.89)=256.61348.50 - 1.0000(91.89) = \mathbf{256.61} 73.6%

Engineering Insight: Notice that between V/Vd=0.60V/V_d = 0.60 and V/Vd=1.00V/V_d = 1.00, the moment capacity drops by 26.4%26.4\%, landing exactly on the flange plastic moment Mfd=256.61 kN⋅mM_{fd} = 256.61\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.


6. Comparative Engineering Analysis

Design Parameter / Attribute Low Shear Regime (V≤0.60VdV \le 0.60 V_d) High Shear Regime (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d)
Code Clause Reference IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2.1.2 IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2.1.3
Moment Capacity Formula Md=βbZpfy/γm0M_d = \beta_b Z_p f_y / \gamma_{m0} Mdv=Md−β(Md−Mfd)M_{dv} = M_d - \beta (M_d - M_{fd})
Interaction Factor β\beta Zero (β=0\beta = 0) β=(2V/Vd−1)2∈(0,1.0]\beta = (2V/V_d - 1)^2 \in (0, 1.0]
Web Normal Stress (σw\sigma_w) Fully active; develops fyf_y in plastic hinge Degraded by von Mises yield criterion; σw→0\sigma_w \to 0 as V→VdV \to V_d
Flange Role Carries majority of moment Carries 100% of residual moment at V=VdV = V_d (MfdM_{fd})
Typical Physical Locations Midspan of simply supported beams Supports of continuous beams; root of short cantilever beams
Web Type / Buckling Method Stocky Web (d/tw≤67ϵd/t_w \le 67\epsilon) Simple Post-Critical Method (d/tw>67ϵd/t_w > 67\epsilon) Tension Field Method
Buckling Behavior Suppressed; yields plastically Elastic or inelastic buckling governs (τb\tau_b) Post-buckling diagonal tension membrane develops
Required Stiffeners None required for shear Intermediate stiffeners optional (kv=5.35k_v = 5.35) Mandatory intermediate stiffeners (c/d≥1.0c/d \ge 1.0)
Nominal Capacity Vp=Avfyw/3V_p = A_v f_{yw} / \sqrt{3} Vcr=AvτbV_{cr} = A_v \tau_b Vtf=Vcr+VtV_{tf} = V_{cr} + V_t (higher economy)
Governing Code Clause IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.1 IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.2.2 IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4.2.2 (b)

7. Design Pitfalls & Practical Field Considerations

  1. Incorrect Shear Area for Rolled vs Welded Sections:

    • For rolled sections: Av=h⋅twA_v = h \cdot t_w (overall depth hh is used).
    • For welded plate girders: Av=d⋅twA_v = d \cdot t_w (clear web depth dd between flanges is used).
      Using hh for welded sections violates Cl. 8.4.1.1 and overestimates shear resistance by 2tftw2 t_f t_w.
  2. Neglecting High Shear at Internal Supports of Continuous Beams:
    In continuous beams and frames, the location of peak negative bending moment coincides exactly with peak shear force at internal column supports. Designers frequently check bending using unreduced MdM_d while VV easily exceeds 0.60Vd0.60 V_d. This non-conservative error leads to premature hinge formation.

  3. Cantilever Root Design:
    In short cantilever beams supporting heavy point loads at the tip, shear force is uniform across the entire span while bending moment peaks at the support. Both MM and VV are maximum at the root section simultaneously. The MdvM_{dv} check is almost always governing.

  4. Serviceability Yield Check Cap (1.20Zefy/γm01.20 Z_e f_y / \gamma_{m0}):
    Even under low or high shear, the design moment capacity must never exceed 1.20Zefy/γm01.20 Z_e f_y / \gamma_{m0} (or 1.50Zefy/γm01.50 Z_e f_y / \gamma_{m0} for cantilevers) to prevent premature yielding at service loads.


8. Summary of Critical Formulae

========================================================================================
                          IS 800:2007 SHEAR DESIGN FORMULAE CHEAT SHEET
========================================================================================
• Design Shear Strength:
    Vd = [ Av * fyw ] / [ sqrt(3) * gm0 ]

• Shear Area:
    Rolled I-section:  Av = h * tw
    Welded I-section:  Av = d * tw

• Web Buckling Threshold:
    d / tw <= 67 epsilon  -->  Stocky Web (No shear buckling)
    d / tw > 67 epsilon   -->  Shear Buckling Governs (Use Simple Post-Critical / Tension Field)

• High Shear Criterion:
    V <= 0.60 Vd  -->  Low Shear:   Mdv = Md
    V > 0.60 Vd   -->  High Shear:  Mdv = Md - beta * (Md - Mfd)

• High Shear Factors:
    beta = ( 2V / Vd - 1 )^2
    Mfd  = bf * tf * (D - tf) * fy / gm0

• Upper Limit on Moment Capacity:
    Simply Supported:  Mdv <= 1.20 Ze * fy / gm0
    Cantilever:        Mdv <= 1.50 Ze * fy / gm0

• Elastic Shear Buckling Stress (Cl. 8.4.2.2):
    tau_cr = [ kv * pi^2 * E ] / [ 12(1 - mu^2) * (d/tw)^2 ]
    kv = 5.35 + 4.0 / (c/d)^2   (for c/d >= 1.0; kv = 5.35 if unstiffened)
========================================================================================

9. Exam Traps & Tricks

  1. The 0.60 Factor Trap:
    Question: "What is the limiting shear force below which bending moment capacity is not reduced?"
    Answer: Exactly 0.60Vd0.60 V_d (or 60% of Vd60\% \text{ of } V_d). In WSM (IS 800:1984), maximum shear stress was limited to 0.45fy0.45 f_y and average to 0.40fy0.40 f_y. Do not confuse WSM allowable stresses with the LSM 0.60Vd0.60 V_d interaction threshold!

  2. The Flange Plastic Modulus Formulation:
    In competitive exam MCQs, MfdM_{fd} is frequently tested. Remember that Mfd=bftf(D−tf)fy/γm0M_{fd} = b_f t_f (D - t_f) f_y / \gamma_{m0}. The lever arm is the distance between flange centroids (D−tf)(D - t_f), NOT (D−2tf)(D - 2t_f) and NOT DD!

  3. Value of β\beta at Full Shear:
    When V=VdV = V_d, β=(2(1)−1)2=1.0\beta = (2(1) - 1)^2 = 1.0, which implies Mdv=MfdM_{dv} = M_{fd}. The web contributes exactly ZERO to flexural resistance at plastic shear failure.

  4. Web Slenderness Limit for Welded Plate Girders:
    The minimum thickness of web to prevent shear buckling without stiffeners is d/67ϵd / 67\epsilon. For Fe 410 steel, this is d/67≈0.015dd / 67 \approx 0.015 d.


  1. IS 800:2007: General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice (Third Revision), Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi. (Sections 8 and 9).
  2. SP: 6 (1)-1964: ISI Handbook for Structural Engineers — Structural Steel Sections.
  3. Subramanian, N.: Design of Steel Structures (Limit State Method), Oxford University Press.
  4. Duggal, S.K.: Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education.
  5. Bhavikatti, S.S.: Design of Steel Structures (By Limit State Method as per IS: 800-2007), I.K. International Publishing House.

11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys

Problem 1 (GATE CE Objective)

An ISMB 400 section (D=400 mmD = 400\text{ mm}, tw=8.9 mmt_w = 8.9\text{ mm}, fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}) is used as a simply supported beam. What is its design shear capacity VdV_d under IS 800:2007?
(A) 388.9 kN388.9\text{ kN}
(B) 467.1 kN467.1\text{ kN}
(C) 514.8 kN514.8\text{ kN}
(D) 583.4 kN583.4\text{ kN}
Answer: (B)
Hint: Av=400×8.9=3560 mm2A_v = 400 \times 8.9 = 3560\text{ mm}^2. Vd=3560×2503×1.10×103=890,0001.905256=467.13 kNV_d = \frac{3560 \times 250}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{890,000}{1.905256} = 467.13\text{ kN}.

Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Objective)

In the design of laterally supported beams as per IS 800:2007, under high shear (V>0.60VdV > 0.60 V_d), the reduction factor β\beta for plastic moment capacity is given by:
(A) (VVd−0.6)2\left(\frac{V}{V_d} - 0.6\right)^2
(B) (2VVd−1)2\left(\frac{2V}{V_d} - 1\right)^2
(C) (VVd)2−0.36\left(\frac{V}{V_d}\right)^2 - 0.36
(D) (1.5VVd−0.5)2\left(\frac{1.5V}{V_d} - 0.5\right)^2
Answer: (B)
Hint: Directly from IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2.1.3.

Problem 3 (GATE CE Numerical Answer Type)

A laterally supported beam has Md=300 kN⋅mM_d = 300\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, Mfd=200 kN⋅mM_{fd} = 200\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, and Vd=500 kNV_d = 500\text{ kN}. At a critical section, the factored shear force is V=400 kNV = 400\text{ kN}. The reduced design bending strength MdvM_{dv} (in kN⋅m\text{kN}\cdot\text{m}, rounded off to one decimal place) is ______.
Answer: 264.0
Hint: V/Vd=400/500=0.80>0.60V/V_d = 400/500 = 0.80 > 0.60. β=(2×0.80−1)2=(1.60−1)2=0.602=0.36\beta = (2 \times 0.80 - 1)^2 = (1.60 - 1)^2 = 0.60^2 = 0.36.
Mdv=300−0.36(300−200)=300−36.0=264.0 kN⋅mM_{dv} = 300 - 0.36(300 - 200) = 300 - 36.0 = 264.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.


12. Cross-Topic Linkages & Forward References