GEOTECH-02-02 Chapter 02 · Foundation Engineering

Stability of Slopes

Discipline
Civil Engineering | Geotechnical Engineering
Curriculum Mapping
GATE CE, UPSC ESE (Paper-II), SSC JE, State AE/JE, RRB JE
Technical Standards & Reference Codes
IS 7894:1975 (Code of practice for stability analysis of earth dams), IS 1498:1970, Terzaghi (1943), Taylor (1937, 1948), Bishop (1955), Fellenius (1936), Janbu (1973)
In this chapter (5 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Module Overview & Learning Objectives
  2. Primary Learning Objectives:
  3. 2. Principles of Slope Stability & Infinite vs. Finite Slopes
  4. Definition of Factor of Safety (FOS)
  5. 3. Infinite Slope Analysis in Cohesionless Soils (c = 0)
  6. Geometric & Equilibrium Fundamentals:
  7. Case A: Completely Dry or Submerged Slope (Hydrostatic Regime)
  8. Case B: Steady Seepage Parallel to the Slope (Water Table at Ground Surface)
  9. Case C: Seepage Parallel to Slope with Water Table at Depth h Below Surface (z > h)
  10. 4. Infinite Slope Analysis in Cohesive-Frictional Soils (c - φ) & Critical Depth
  11. Case A: Dry or Uniformly Moist Soil
  12. Critical Depth of Failure (zc or Hc):
  13. Case B: Cohesive Soil with Steady Seepage Parallel to Slope
  14. 5. Finite Slope Failure Mechanisms
  15. 1. Classification of Rotational Failure Surfaces:
  16. Depth Factor (Df):
  17. 6. Swedish Slip Circle Method for Pure Clay (φu = 0)
  18. Theoretical Assumptions:
  19. Mathematical Formulation:
  20. Tension Crack Mechanics & Water Thrust:
  21. 7. Ordinary Method of Slices (Fellenius / OMS) for c - φ Soils
  22. Formulation for Slice i:
  23. Fellenius Assumptions (OMS):
  24. 8. Bishop's Simplified Method of Slices
  25. Key Assumption:
  26. Vertical Equilibrium of Slice i:
  27. Bishop's Factor of Safety Equation:
  28. 9. Critical Stability Conditions in Earth Dams & Embankments
  29. 1. End of Construction:
  30. 2. Steady Seepage (Reservoir Full):
  31. 3. Sudden (Rapid) Drawdown:
  32. 10. Taylor's Stability Number (Sn) & Chart Formulation
  33. Critical Height (Hc) & Height Factor of Safety (FH):
  34. Special Values & Engineering Rules for Sn:
  35. 11. Solved Numerical Problems
  36. Problem 1: Infinite Slope Stability Across Dry, Submerged, and Seepage Regimes
  37. Problem 2: Swedish Slip Circle Analysis with Dry vs. Water-Filled Tension Cracks
  38. Problem 3: Taylor's Stability Number & Ordinary Method of Slices (OMS)
  39. Summations:
  40. 12. Comparative Engineering Analysis Across Syllabi
  41. 13. Common Misconceptions & Examination Pitfalls
  42. 14. Key Reference Formulas & Summary Table

1. Module Overview & Learning Objectives

The evaluation of the stability of natural slopes, engineered cuts, railway and highway embankments, and earth dams forms a cornerstone of geotechnical engineering. Slope failure occurs when the mobilizing shear stresses induced along a potential slip surface by gravity, seepage forces, seismic acceleration, or external surcharges exceed the available shear strength of the soil mass.

                                  SLOPE STABILITY ANALYSES
                                             │
                  ┌──────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────┐
                  ▼                                                     ▼
        INFINITE SLOPE ANALYSIS                               FINITE SLOPE ANALYSIS
     (Planar Slip Surfaces, L >> H)                     (Curved / Rotational Slip Surfaces)
                  │                                                     │
        ┌─────────┴─────────┐                         ┌─────────────────┴─────────────────┐
        ▼                   ▼                         ▼                                   ▼
 Cohesionless Soils     c-φ Soils              Total Stress Analysis            Effective Stress Analysis
 (Dry, Submerged,     (Critical Depth        (Swedish Arc Method, φ_u = 0)     (Method of Slices: OMS vs Bishop)
  Parallel Seepage)      z_c, H_c)                    │                                   │
                                                      ▼                                   ▼
                                           Tension Crack Mechanics &           Taylor's Stability Number
                                            Hydrostatic Water Thrust          (End-of-Const, Steady Seepage,
                                                                                    Sudden Drawdown)

Primary Learning Objectives:

  1. Derive from First Principles: The governing factor of safety equations for infinite slopes in dry, submerged, and steady seepage regimes, proving why seepage cuts the factor of safety of sand slopes by approximately 50%50\%.
  2. Formulate the Critical Depth (zcz_c or HcH_c): For cohesive-frictional soils undergoing planar slip, establishing why safety decreases with depth.
  3. Classify Finite Rotational Failures: Differentiate between slope (face) failure, toe failure, and base failure as controlled by slope inclination β\beta and depth factor DfD_f.
  4. Master the Swedish Slip Circle Method (ϕu=0\phi_u = 0): Compute driving moments, resisting moments, and incorporate the deleterious effects of dry and water-filled tension cracks.
  5. Analyze Frictional Soils via the Method of Slices: Formulate the Ordinary Method of Slices (Fellenius / OMS) and Bishop's Simplified Method, analyzing the role of interslice normal forces and iterative convergence.
  6. Evaluate Critical Dam Operations: Formulate the geotechnical behavior during End of Construction, Steady Seepage, and Sudden (Rapid) Drawdown.
  7. Apply Taylor's Stability Number (SnS_n): Utilize dimensionless charts, differentiate between factor of safety with respect to cohesion (FcF_c) and friction (FϕF_\phi), and adjust for submerged unit weights during drawdown.

2. Principles of Slope Stability & Infinite vs. Finite Slopes

A slope is defined as an unsupported, inclined surface of a soil mass. Slopes are categorized based on boundary geometry into:

  1. Infinite Slopes: A slope where the boundary surface is planar and extends indefinitely in all directions, such that soil properties, depth to a rigid bedrock or failure plane, and pore pressure regimes are identical along any vertical line. Failure occurs along a plane parallel to the slope face. This idealization accurately models surficial soil slips, colluvial covers over bedrock, and long continuous embankment blankets.
  2. Finite Slopes: A slope bounded by an upper horizontal crest and a lower horizontal toe or base, with a definite height HH. Failure occurs along curved, rotational surfaces (approximated as circular arcs, log-spirals, or composite non-circular surfaces). This geometry governs cuts, retaining embankments, flood levees, and earth-fill dams.

Definition of Factor of Safety (FOSFOS)

In slope stability, the factor of safety is universally defined with respect to the shear strength of the soil:

FOS=τfτmob=Available Shear StrengthMobilized Shear Stress to Maintain EquilibriumFOS = \frac{\tau_f}{\tau_{\text{mob}}} = \frac{\text{Available Shear Strength}}{\text{Mobilized Shear Stress to Maintain Equilibrium}}

According to the Mohr-Coulomb effective stress criterion:

τf=c′+σ′tan⁡ϕ′\tau_f = c' + \sigma' \tan\phi'

If a uniform factor of safety is applied to both cohesion and friction:

τmob=cm′+σ′tan⁡ϕm′=c′FOS+σ′tan⁡ϕ′FOS\tau_{\text{mob}} = c_m' + \sigma' \tan\phi_m' = \frac{c'}{FOS} + \sigma' \frac{\tan\phi'}{FOS}

where:

  • cm′=c′/Fcc_m' = c' / F_c is the mobilized cohesion.
  • tan⁡ϕm′=tan⁡ϕ′/Fϕ\tan\phi_m' = \tan\phi' / F_\phi is the mobilized friction angle.
  • When Fc=Fϕ=FOSF_c = F_\phi = FOS, the safety factor is homogeneous across strength parameters.

3. Infinite Slope Analysis in Cohesionless Soils (c=0c = 0)

Consider an infinite slope inclined at angle β\beta to the horizontal. A potential failure plane exists at depth zz parallel to the slope face. Consider a vertical slice of soil of width bb and unit thickness perpendicular to the plane.

Infinite Slope Stability Mechanics

Geometric & Equilibrium Fundamentals:

  • Volume of vertical slice: V=b×z×1=bzV = b \times z \times 1 = b z.
  • Total weight of slice: W=γzbW = \gamma z b.
  • Base length of slice along failure plane: Δl=bcos⁡β\Delta l = \frac{b}{\cos\beta}.
  • Normal force on base: N=Wcos⁡β=γzbcos⁡βN = W \cos\beta = \gamma z b \cos\beta.
  • Tangential driving force down the slope: T=Wsin⁡β=γzbsin⁡βT = W \sin\beta = \gamma z b \sin\beta.

Dividing forces by base area (Δl×1=b/cos⁡β\Delta l \times 1 = b / \cos\beta):

  • Total normal stress on failure plane: σ=NΔl=γzbcos⁡βb/cos⁡β=γzcos⁡2β\sigma = \frac{N}{\Delta l} = \frac{\gamma z b \cos\beta}{b / \cos\beta} = \gamma z \cos^2\beta
  • Mobilized driving shear stress along failure plane: τ=TΔl=γzbsin⁡βb/cos⁡β=γzsin⁡βcos⁡β\tau = \frac{T}{\Delta l} = \frac{\gamma z b \sin\beta}{b / \cos\beta} = \gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta

Case A: Completely Dry or Submerged Slope (Hydrostatic Regime)

  • In a dry slope: σ′=σ=γdzcos⁡2β\sigma' = \sigma = \gamma_d z \cos^2\beta.
  • In a fully submerged slope under static water (no seepage flow): pore pressure u=γwzcos⁡2βu = \gamma_w z \cos^2\beta, giving effective normal stress σ′=σ−u=(γsat−γw)zcos⁡2β=γ′zcos⁡2β\sigma' = \sigma - u = (\gamma_{\text{sat}} - \gamma_w) z \cos^2\beta = \gamma' z \cos^2\beta.
  • Available shear strength: τf=σ′tan⁡ϕ′=γzcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′(or γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′)\tau_f = \sigma' \tan\phi' = \gamma z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi' \quad (\text{or } \gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi')
  • Mobilized driving shear stress: τ=γzsin⁡βcos⁡β(or γ′zsin⁡βcos⁡β)\tau = \gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta \quad (\text{or } \gamma' z \sin\beta \cos\beta)

Taking the ratio:

FOS=τfτ=σ′tan⁡ϕ′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS = \frac{\tau_f}{\tau} = \frac{\sigma' \tan\phi'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} FOSdry=FOSsubmerged=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β\boxed{FOS_{\text{dry}} = FOS_{\text{submerged}} = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}}

Fundamental Invariant: For a dry or submerged cohesionless slope, the factor of safety is entirely independent of depth zz and unit weight γ\gamma. The slope is unconditionally stable if β≤ϕ′\beta \le \phi', and unstable if β>ϕ′\beta > \phi'. The angle of repose of dry cohesionless sand is identically equal to its internal friction angle ϕ′\phi'.


Case B: Steady Seepage Parallel to the Slope (Water Table at Ground Surface)

When heavy rainfall causes steady groundwater seepage flowing parallel to the slope face, and the phreatic surface coincides with the ground surface:

  • Flow lines are parallel to the slope face inclined at β\beta.
  • Equipotential lines are perpendicular to the slope face.
  • Hydraulic gradient: i=sin⁡βi = \sin\beta.
  • Pore water pressure at depth zz: u=γwzcos⁡2βu = \gamma_w z \cos^2\beta
  • Total normal stress on slip plane: σ=γsatzcos⁡2β\sigma = \gamma_{\text{sat}} z \cos^2\beta
  • Effective normal stress on slip plane: σ′=σ−u=γsatzcos⁡2β−γwzcos⁡2β=(γsat−γw)zcos⁡2β=γ′zcos⁡2β\sigma' = \sigma - u = \gamma_{\text{sat}} z \cos^2\beta - \gamma_w z \cos^2\beta = (\gamma_{\text{sat}} - \gamma_w) z \cos^2\beta = \gamma' z \cos^2\beta
  • Available shear strength: τf=σ′tan⁡ϕ′=γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′\tau_f = \sigma' \tan\phi' = \gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'
  • Mobilized driving shear stress: Because gravity acts on the entire water-soil mass, the total saturated unit weight drives the downslope sliding force: τ=γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β\tau = \gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta

Formulating the factor of safety:

FOS=τfτ=γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β=(γ′γsat)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS = \frac{\tau_f}{\tau} = \frac{\gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}\right) \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} FOSseepage=(γ′γsat)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β≈0.50⋅tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β\boxed{FOS_{\text{seepage}} = \left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}\right) \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} \approx 0.50 \cdot \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}}

Critical Design Takeaway: Since γ′≈γsat/2\gamma' \approx \gamma_{\text{sat}} / 2 for typical soils (γsat≈20 kN/m3,γw=9.81 kN/m3  ⟹  γ′≈10.19 kN/m3\gamma_{\text{sat}} \approx 20\text{ kN/m}^3, \gamma_w = 9.81\text{ kN/m}^3 \implies \gamma' \approx 10.19\text{ kN/m}^3), steady seepage parallel to the face cuts the factor of safety of a sand slope by approximately 50%50\%. To prevent flow slides during monsoons, an unreinforced granular cut subjected to emergent seepage must have a slope angle of β≤12ϕ′\beta \le \frac{1}{2}\phi'.


Case C: Seepage Parallel to Slope with Water Table at Depth hh Below Surface (z>hz > h)

When the upper soil of thickness hh is moist (γ\gamma) and the lower soil of thickness (z−h)(z - h) is saturated (γsat\gamma_{\text{sat}}) with parallel seepage:

  • Total normal stress: σ=[γh+γsat(z−h)]cos⁡2β\sigma = [\gamma h + \gamma_{\text{sat}}(z - h)] \cos^2\beta.
  • Pore water pressure: u=γw(z−h)cos⁡2βu = \gamma_w (z - h) \cos^2\beta.
  • Effective normal stress: σ′=[γh+γ′(z−h)]cos⁡2β\sigma' = [\gamma h + \gamma'(z - h)] \cos^2\beta.
  • Driving shear stress: τ=[γh+γsat(z−h)]sin⁡βcos⁡β\tau = [\gamma h + \gamma_{\text{sat}}(z - h)] \sin\beta \cos\beta.
  • Factor of safety: FOS=[γh+γ′(z−h)]cos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′[γh+γsat(z−h)]sin⁡βcos⁡β=γh+γ′(z−h)γh+γsat(z−h)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS = \frac{[\gamma h + \gamma'(z - h)] \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{[\gamma h + \gamma_{\text{sat}}(z - h)] \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{\gamma h + \gamma'(z - h)}{\gamma h + \gamma_{\text{sat}}(z - h)} \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}

4. Infinite Slope Analysis in Cohesive-Frictional Soils (c−ϕc - \phi) & Critical Depth

For soils possessing both effective cohesion c′c' and internal friction ϕ′\phi':

τf=c′+σ′tan⁡ϕ′\tau_f = c' + \sigma' \tan\phi'

Case A: Dry or Uniformly Moist Soil

With σ′=γzcos⁡2β\sigma' = \gamma z \cos^2\beta and τ=γzsin⁡βcos⁡β\tau = \gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta:

FOS=c′+γzcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β=c′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β+tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS = \frac{c' + \gamma z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{c'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} + \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} FOS=c′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β+tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β\boxed{FOS = \frac{c'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} + \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}}

Depth-Dependency & Mechanics of Failure:

  • Unlike cohesionless soil, FOSFOS is strongly depth-dependent.
  • At z→0z \to 0, FOS→∞FOS \to \infty (soil is ultra-stable at the surficial skin due to cohesion).
  • As depth zz increases, the first term c′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β→0\frac{c'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} \to 0, causing FOSFOS to asymptotically approach tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β\frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}.
  • If β>ϕ′\beta > \phi', the slope will inevitably fail once a critical depth is reached!

Critical Depth of Failure (zcz_c or HcH_c):

Setting FOS=1.0FOS = 1.0:

1.0=c′γzcsin⁡βcos⁡β+tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β1.0 = \frac{c'}{\gamma z_c \sin\beta \cos\beta} + \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}

Multiplying both sides by γzcsin⁡βcos⁡β\gamma z_c \sin\beta \cos\beta:

γzcsin⁡βcos⁡β=c′+γzccos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′\gamma z_c \sin\beta \cos\beta = c' + \gamma z_c \cos^2\beta \tan\phi' γzccos⁡2β[tan⁡β−tan⁡ϕ′]=c′\gamma z_c \cos^2\beta [\tan\beta - \tan\phi'] = c' zc=c′γcos⁡2β(tan⁡β−tan⁡ϕ′)\boxed{z_c = \frac{c'}{\gamma \cos^2\beta (\tan\beta - \tan\phi')}}

For a pure clay (ϕ=0\phi = 0):

zc=cγsin⁡βcos⁡β=2cγsin⁡(2β)\boxed{z_c = \frac{c}{\gamma \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{2c}{\gamma \sin(2\beta)}}

Case B: Cohesive Soil with Steady Seepage Parallel to Slope

Under full saturation with water table at the surface:

σ′=γ′zcos⁡2β,τ=γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β\sigma' = \gamma' z \cos^2\beta, \quad \tau = \gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta FOS=c′+γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β=c′γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β+(γ′γsat)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS = \frac{c' + \gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{c'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta} + \left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}\right)\frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta}

Critical failure depth under steady seepage:

zc=c′cos⁡2β[γsattan⁡β−γ′tan⁡ϕ′]\boxed{z_c = \frac{c'}{\cos^2\beta [\gamma_{\text{sat}}\tan\beta - \gamma'\tan\phi']}}

5. Finite Slope Failure Mechanisms

In finite slopes, rotational shear failure dominates. The sliding mass separates from the stable ground along a curved shear surface.

Finite Slope Failure Modes & Slices

1. Classification of Rotational Failure Surfaces:

  1. Slope Failure (Face Failure):
    • The failure surface intersects the slope face above the toe.
    • Typically occurs when the slope is steep (β>53∘\beta > 53^\circ) or where a hard stratum exists directly at the toe level, preventing deeper shear arc propagation.
  2. Toe Failure:
    • The failure surface passes precisely through the toe of the slope.
    • This is the most common failure mode for slopes with moderate inclination (β≈53∘\beta \approx 53^\circ) in homogeneous soils.
  3. Base Failure:
    • The failure surface passes significantly below the toe, penetrating deep into the foundation soil and tangent to a firm rigid stratum.
    • Occurs when the slope angle is flat (β<53∘\beta < 53^\circ) and the foundation soil below the toe is softer or has lower shear strength than the embankment fill.

Depth Factor (DfD_f):

The geometry of base circles is quantified by the depth factor:

Df=D+HHD_f = \frac{D + H}{H}

where:

  • HH is the height of the slope.
  • DD is the depth from the toe to the firm, impermeable stratum.
  • For a toe circle: Df=1.0D_f = 1.0.
  • For a base circle: Df>1.0D_f > 1.0.

6. Swedish Slip Circle Method for Pure Clay (ϕu=0\phi_u = 0)

The Swedish Slip Circle method (also known as the ϕu=0\phi_u = 0 total stress analysis or Fellenius circular arc method) is the standard method for short-term undrained stability of saturated clay slopes.

Theoretical Assumptions:

  1. The potential slip surface is a circular cylindrical arc of radius RR centered at OO.
  2. The soil behaves in an undrained manner with friction angle ϕu=0\phi_u = 0 and constant undrained shear strength τf=cu\tau_f = c_u.
  3. The sliding mass acts as a rigid body rotating about center OO.

Mathematical Formulation:

  • Arc length of slip circle: La=R⋅θL_a = R \cdot \theta (where θ\theta is the central subtended angle in radians).
  • Resisting shear force along arc: S=cu⋅La⋅1=cuRθS = c_u \cdot L_a \cdot 1 = c_u R \theta.
  • Resisting moment about rotation center OO: Mr=S⋅R=(cuRθ)R=cuR2θM_r = S \cdot R = (c_u R \theta) R = c_u R^2 \theta
  • Driving (overturning) moment about OO: Md=W⋅xˉM_d = W \cdot \bar{x} where WW is the total weight of the sliding mass of cross-sectional area AA (W=γAW = \gamma A), and xˉ\bar{x} is the horizontal lever arm from OO to the center of gravity of the sliding mass.

The factor of safety is the ratio of resisting to driving moments:

FOS=MrMd=cuR2θW⋅xˉ\boxed{FOS = \frac{M_r}{M_d} = \frac{c_u R^2 \theta}{W \cdot \bar{x}}}

Tension Crack Mechanics & Water Thrust:

In cohesive soils, tension cracks develop near the crest to a theoretical depth:

z0=2cuγz_0 = \frac{2 c_u}{\gamma}

The presence of a tension crack modifies the stability in two critical ways:

  1. Loss of Resisting Arc: Soil cannot sustain tensile stress; hence, the portion of the circular arc located within the depth z0z_0 contributes zero shear resistance. The subtended central angle is reduced from θ\theta to θ′\theta', where the arc terminates at the bottom of the crack: Mr=cuR2θ′M_r = c_u R^2 \theta'
  2. Hydrostatic Water Thrust (Rainfall Condition): If heavy rains fill the crack with water to depth z0z_0:
    • Hydrostatic thrust: Pw=12γwz02P_w = \frac{1}{2} \gamma_w z_0^2.
    • This horizontal thrust acts at z0/3z_0 / 3 from the crack base, exerting an additional overturning driving moment ΔMd=Pw⋅yw\Delta M_d = P_w \cdot y_w about OO, where ywy_w is the vertical lever arm from OO to the line of action of PwP_w.
    • The total driving moment becomes: Md=W′⋅xˉ′+12γwz02⋅ywM_d = W' \cdot \bar{x}' + \frac{1}{2}\gamma_w z_0^2 \cdot y_w where W′W' and xˉ′\bar{x}' represent the weight and centroid of the reduced soil mass excluding the tension crack wedge.
FOSrain=cuR2θ′W′⋅xˉ′+12γwz02⋅yw\boxed{FOS_{\text{rain}} = \frac{c_u R^2 \theta'}{W' \cdot \bar{x}' + \frac{1}{2}\gamma_w z_0^2 \cdot y_w}}

7. Ordinary Method of Slices (Fellenius / OMS) for c−ϕc - \phi Soils

When the slope consists of cohesive-frictional soil (c′−ϕ′c' - \phi') or non-homogeneous stratified strata with pore water pressure, shear strength varies along the slip circle. The sliding mass is discretized into nn vertical slices.

Formulation for Slice ii:

  • Slice width: bib_i.
  • Average height: hih_i.
  • Total weight: Wi=γibihiW_i = \gamma_i b_i h_i.
  • Base inclination angle to horizontal: αi\alpha_i.
  • Base length: Δli=bicos⁡αi\Delta l_i = \frac{b_i}{\cos\alpha_i}.
  • Pore water pressure at slice base: uiu_i.

Fellenius Assumptions (OMS):

The Ordinary Method of Slices assumes that interslice forces (Ei,Ei+1E_i, E_{i+1} and Xi,Xi+1X_i, X_{i+1}) are parallel to the slice base and cancel each other out:

  • Normal force on base: Ni=Wicos⁡αiN_i = W_i \cos\alpha_i.
  • Pore water force on base: Ui=uiΔliU_i = u_i \Delta l_i.
  • Effective normal force: Ni′=Ni−Ui=Wicos⁡αi−uiΔliN_i' = N_i - U_i = W_i \cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i.
  • Available shear resistance along base: ΔRi=c′Δli+Ni′tan⁡ϕ′=c′Δli+(Wicos⁡αi−uiΔli)tan⁡ϕ′\Delta R_i = c' \Delta l_i + N_i' \tan\phi' = c' \Delta l_i + (W_i \cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i)\tan\phi'
  • Tangential driving force along base: Ti=Wisin⁡αiT_i = W_i \sin\alpha_i

Summing over all nn slices gives the Fellenius Factor of Safety:

FOSOMS=∑i=1n[c′Δli+(Wicos⁡αi−uiΔli)tan⁡ϕ′]∑i=1nWisin⁡αi\boxed{FOS_{\text{OMS}} = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^n \left[c' \Delta l_i + (W_i \cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i)\tan\phi'\right]}{\sum_{i=1}^n W_i \sin\alpha_i}}

Limitation of OMS: Neglecting interslice forces violates horizontal and moment equilibrium for individual slices. For deep slip circles with high pore pressures, (Wicos⁡αi−uiΔli)(W_i \cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i) can become artificially negative near the toe. Consequently, OMS underestimates the true factor of safety by 5%5\% to 15%15\%, providing an overly conservative design.


8. Bishop's Simplified Method of Slices

Alan W. Bishop (1955) resolved the inaccuracies of OMS by satisfying vertical force equilibrium for each slice while including horizontal interslice normal forces (Ei,Ei+1E_i, E_{i+1}).

Key Assumption:

The shear forces between adjacent slices are approximately equal (Xi−Xi+1=0X_i - X_{i+1} = 0).

Vertical Equilibrium of Slice ii:

Resolving forces vertically:

Wi=Nicos⁡αi+Tisin⁡αiW_i = N_i \cos\alpha_i + T_i \sin\alpha_i

Substituting Ni=Ni′+uiΔliN_i = N_i' + u_i \Delta l_i and mobilized shear Ti=1FOS(c′Δli+Ni′tan⁡ϕ′)T_i = \frac{1}{FOS}(c' \Delta l_i + N_i' \tan\phi'):

Wi=(Ni′+uiΔli)cos⁡αi+1FOS(c′Δli+Ni′tan⁡ϕ′)sin⁡αiW_i = (N_i' + u_i \Delta l_i)\cos\alpha_i + \frac{1}{FOS}(c' \Delta l_i + N_i' \tan\phi')\sin\alpha_i

Noting that Δli=bi/cos⁡αi\Delta l_i = b_i / \cos\alpha_i and solving explicitly for Ni′N_i':

Ni′=Wi−uibi−c′biFOStan⁡αicos⁡αi+sin⁡αitan⁡ϕ′FOS=Wi−uibi−c′biFOStan⁡αimα,iN_i' = \frac{W_i - u_i b_i - \frac{c' b_i}{FOS}\tan\alpha_i}{\cos\alpha_i + \frac{\sin\alpha_i \tan\phi'}{FOS}} = \frac{W_i - u_i b_i - \frac{c' b_i}{FOS}\tan\alpha_i}{m_{\alpha, i}}

where the dimensionless geometric coefficient mα,im_{\alpha, i} is defined as:

mα,i=cos⁡αi(1+tan⁡αitan⁡ϕ′FOS)\boxed{m_{\alpha, i} = \cos\alpha_i \left(1 + \frac{\tan\alpha_i \tan\phi'}{FOS}\right)}

Bishop's Factor of Safety Equation:

Equating overall driving and resisting moments about the rotation center OO:

FOSBishop=1∑i=1nWisin⁡αi∑i=1n[c′bi+(Wi−uibi)tan⁡ϕ′mα,i]\boxed{FOS_{\text{Bishop}} = \frac{1}{\sum_{i=1}^n W_i \sin\alpha_i} \sum_{i=1}^n \left[\frac{c' b_i + (W_i - u_i b_i)\tan\phi'}{m_{\alpha, i}}\right]}

Characteristics of Bishop's Simplified Method:

  1. Iterative Nature: Because FOSFOS appears on both the left-hand side and within mα,im_{\alpha, i}, solution requires iteration. Assuming an initial FOS0≈1.2−1.5FOS_0 \approx 1.2 - 1.5, convergence to four decimal places occurs within 2 to 3 iterations.
  2. High Precision: Despite neglecting interslice shear forces, extensive comparisons with rigorous limit equilibrium methods (Spencer, Morgenstern-Price) prove that Bishop's Simplified method predicts FOSFOS with an error of less than 1%1\% to 2%2\%.

9. Critical Stability Conditions in Earth Dams & Embankments

Under IS 7894:1975, earth dams and reservoir embankments must be evaluated for three distinct, governing operational phases:

┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                    CRITICAL OPERATIONAL PHASES IN EARTH DAMS                          │
├──────────────────────────┬─────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┤
│ Operational Phase        │ Critical Slope Analyzed     │ Governing Stress Regime      │
├──────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────┤
│ 1. End of Construction   │ Both Upstream & Downstream  │ Total Stress (Undrained,     │
│                          │ Slopes                      │ Excess Pore Pressure Δu > 0) │
├──────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────┤
│ 2. Steady Seepage        │ Downstream Slope Critical   │ Effective Stress (Drained,   │
│    (Full Reservoir)      │ (Phreatic Line Emerges)     │ Flow Net Pore Pressures)     │
├──────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────────┤
│ 3. Sudden Drawdown       │ Upstream Slope Critical     │ Effective / Undrained Surge  │
│    (Rapid Reservoir Drop)│ (Water Support Removed)     │ (High u remains trapped)     │
└──────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────────┘

1. End of Construction:

  • Construction of a large dam involves rapid compaction of cohesive fill.
  • Low permeability prevents immediate dissipation of pore water; high excess pore pressures Δu\Delta u develop.
  • Analysis: Performed using total stress parameters (cu,ϕuc_u, \phi_u) or effective stress with estimated pore pressure ratio ru=uγh≈0.3−0.5r_u = \frac{u}{\gamma h} \approx 0.3 - 0.5. Minimum required FOS≥1.30FOS \ge 1.30.

2. Steady Seepage (Reservoir Full):

  • Reservoir has been at full supply level (FSL) for sufficient time to establish a steady-state phreatic surface.
  • Upstream slope is stabilized by the hydrostatic reservoir water pool.
  • Downstream slope is critical due to horizontal seepage forces acting outward and upward, increasing driving shear and reducing effective normal stress.
  • Analysis: Effective stress parameters (c′,ϕ′c', \phi') with pore pressures obtained directly from flow net equipotential lines. Minimum required FOS≥1.50FOS \ge 1.50.

3. Sudden (Rapid) Drawdown:

  • Reservoir water level drops rapidly (e.g., during emergency discharge or power generation).
  • Upstream slope soil remains fully saturated because clay/silt drains orders of magnitude slower than the reservoir water drops.
  • Upstream slope is critical:
    1. The stabilizing hydrostatic water pressure on the slope face is abruptly removed.
    2. Trapped internal pore water pressures remain exceptionally high.
    3. Seepage flow reverses direction, flowing outward toward the reservoir.
  • Analysis: Effective stress with steady seepage from drawdown flow net, or modified total stress. Minimum required FOS≥1.30FOS \ge 1.30.

10. Taylor's Stability Number (SnS_n) & Chart Formulation

Donald W. Taylor (1937) established that for a homogeneous slope of height HH and angle β\beta in a c−ϕc-\phi soil, the required cohesive resistance to prevent failure can be expressed as a dimensionless ratio termed Taylor's Stability Number (SnS_n):

Sn=cmγH=cFc⋅γ⋅H\boxed{S_n = \frac{c_m}{\gamma H} = \frac{c}{F_c \cdot \gamma \cdot H}}

where:

  • cmc_m is the mobilized cohesion required for equilibrium.
  • FcF_c is the factor of safety with respect to cohesion.
  • HH is the actual height of the slope.
  • γ\gamma is the unit weight of the soil.

Critical Height (HcH_c) & Height Factor of Safety (FHF_H):

If cohesion is fully mobilized (Fc=1.0F_c = 1.0), the slope can stand to a maximum critical height HcH_c:

Sn=cγHc  ⟹  Hc=cSn⋅γS_n = \frac{c}{\gamma H_c} \implies \boxed{H_c = \frac{c}{S_n \cdot \gamma}}

The factor of safety with respect to height is:

FH=HcH=c/(Snγ)H=cSnγH=FcF_H = \frac{H_c}{H} = \frac{c / (S_n \gamma)}{H} = \frac{c}{S_n \gamma H} = F_c

Special Values & Engineering Rules for SnS_n:

  1. Pure Cohesive Soil (ϕ=0\phi = 0):
    • For a vertical cut (β=90∘\beta = 90^\circ): Sn=0.261  ⟹  Hc=c0.261γ=3.83cγ≈4cγS_n = 0.261 \implies H_c = \frac{c}{0.261 \gamma} = 3.83 \frac{c}{\gamma} \approx 4\frac{c}{\gamma}.
    • For β=45∘\beta = 45^\circ: Sn=0.181  ⟹  Hc=5.52cγS_n = 0.181 \implies H_c = 5.52 \frac{c}{\gamma}.
    • For β=30∘\beta = 30^\circ: Sn=0.156  ⟹  Hc=6.41cγS_n = 0.156 \implies H_c = 6.41 \frac{c}{\gamma}.
    • Maximum theoretical stability number for base failure in soft clay with hard layer at infinity (Df→∞D_f \to \infty): Sn=0.181S_n = 0.181 (for β≤53∘\beta \le 53^\circ).
  2. Submerged Slopes:
    • In a fully submerged slope under static water, replace γ\gamma with the submerged unit weight γ′\gamma': Sn=cFc⋅γ′⋅HS_n = \frac{c}{F_c \cdot \gamma' \cdot H}
  3. Sudden Drawdown Formulation:
    • For sudden drawdown in cohesive-frictional soils, the pore pressure remaining trapped inside the embankment acts as an effective surcharge. Taylor derived the modified stability number Sn′S_n': Sn′=Sn(γsatγ′)S_n' = S_n \left(\frac{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}{\gamma'}\right) Fc=cSn′⋅γsat⋅H=cSn⋅γsat⋅(γsatγ′)HF_c = \frac{c}{S_n' \cdot \gamma_{\text{sat}} \cdot H} = \frac{c}{S_n \cdot \gamma_{\text{sat}} \cdot \left(\frac{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}{\gamma'}\right) H}
    • Because γsat/γ′≈2.0\gamma_{\text{sat}} / \gamma' \approx 2.0, sudden drawdown substantially increases the required stability number, drastically reducing safety.

11. Solved Numerical Problems

Problem 1: Infinite Slope Stability Across Dry, Submerged, and Seepage Regimes

Statement: A continuous natural hillside cut in cohesionless sand is inclined at β=22∘\beta = 22^\circ. Geotechnical laboratory testing on undisturbed samples yielded:

  • Effective internal friction angle: ϕ′=32∘\phi' = 32^\circ
  • Dry unit weight: γd=18.0 kN/m3\gamma_d = 18.0\text{ kN/m}^3
  • Saturated unit weight: γsat=20.0 kN/m3\gamma_{\text{sat}} = 20.0\text{ kN/m}^3
  • Water unit weight: γw=9.81 kN/m3  ⟹  γ′=10.19 kN/m3\gamma_w = 9.81\text{ kN/m}^3 \implies \gamma' = 10.19\text{ kN/m}^3

(a) Determine the Factor of Safety (FOSFOS) when the slope is completely dry.
(b) Determine the FOSFOS when the hillside is completely submerged under static flood water.
(c) Determine the FOSFOS during a prolonged torrential monsoon that induces steady groundwater seepage parallel to the slope face with the water table at the ground surface.
(d) In a second location, the slope has β=28∘\beta = 28^\circ, γsat=19.5 kN/m3\gamma_{\text{sat}} = 19.5\text{ kN/m}^3, but possesses cohesion c′=15.0 kPac' = 15.0\text{ kPa} and ϕ′=25∘\phi' = 25^\circ. Under steady parallel seepage with water table at the surface, determine the critical depth zcz_c where failure initiates (FOS=1.0FOS = 1.0), and find the FOSFOS at depth z=4.0 mz = 4.0\text{ m}.

Solution:

(a) Dry Slope Analysis: For a dry cohesionless slope (c=0c = 0):

FOSdry=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β=tan⁡(32∘)tan⁡(22∘)FOS_{\text{dry}} = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} = \frac{\tan(32^\circ)}{\tan(22^\circ)} tan⁡(32∘)=0.624869,tan⁡(22∘)=0.404026\tan(32^\circ) = 0.624869, \quad \tan(22^\circ) = 0.404026 FOSdry=0.6248690.404026=1.5466FOS_{\text{dry}} = \frac{0.624869}{0.404026} = \mathbf{1.5466}

(b) Submerged Slope Analysis: For static submergence without seepage:

FOSsubmerged=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β=1.5466FOS_{\text{submerged}} = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} = \mathbf{1.5466}

(c) Steady Seepage Parallel to Slope Analysis: Under parallel steady seepage with water table at ground level:

FOSseepage=(γ′γsat)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS_{\text{seepage}} = \left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}\right) \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} γ′=20.0−9.81=10.19 kN/m3\gamma' = 20.0 - 9.81 = 10.19\text{ kN/m}^3 γ′γsat=10.1920.0=0.5095\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}} = \frac{10.19}{20.0} = 0.5095 FOSseepage=0.5095×1.5466=0.7880FOS_{\text{seepage}} = 0.5095 \times 1.5466 = \mathbf{0.7880}

Interpretation: The slope transforms from stable (FOS=1.55FOS = 1.55) in dry conditions to actively failing (FOS=0.79<1.0FOS = 0.79 < 1.0) upon saturation and emergent seepage!

(d) Cohesive-Frictional Soil under Steady Seepage: Given: β=28∘\beta = 28^\circ, ϕ′=25∘\phi' = 25^\circ, c′=15.0 kPac' = 15.0\text{ kPa}, γsat=19.5 kN/m3\gamma_{\text{sat}} = 19.5\text{ kN/m}^3, γ′=19.5−9.81=9.69 kN/m3\gamma' = 19.5 - 9.81 = 9.69\text{ kN/m}^3.

The governing factor of safety equation under seepage is:

FOS=c′+γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡βFOS = \frac{c' + \gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta}

At critical depth zcz_c, FOS=1.0FOS = 1.0:

1.0=c′+γ′zccos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′γsatzcsin⁡βcos⁡β1.0 = \frac{c' + \gamma' z_c \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}} z_c \sin\beta \cos\beta} zc[γsatsin⁡βcos⁡β−γ′cos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′]=c′z_c \left[\gamma_{\text{sat}} \sin\beta \cos\beta - \gamma' \cos^2\beta \tan\phi'\right] = c'

Evaluating trigonometric functions:

sin⁡(28∘)=0.469472,cos⁡(28∘)=0.882948,cos⁡2(28∘)=0.779596,tan⁡(25∘)=0.466308\sin(28^\circ) = 0.469472, \quad \cos(28^\circ) = 0.882948, \quad \cos^2(28^\circ) = 0.779596, \quad \tan(25^\circ) = 0.466308 Driving term=γsatsin⁡βcos⁡β=19.5×0.469472×0.882948=8.0831 kPa/m\text{Driving term} = \gamma_{\text{sat}} \sin\beta \cos\beta = 19.5 \times 0.469472 \times 0.882948 = 8.0831\text{ kPa/m} Frictional term=γ′cos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′=9.69×0.779596×0.466308=3.5226 kPa/m\text{Frictional term} = \gamma' \cos^2\beta \tan\phi' = 9.69 \times 0.779596 \times 0.466308 = 3.5226\text{ kPa/m} Denominator=8.0831−3.5226=4.5605 kPa/m\text{Denominator} = 8.0831 - 3.5226 = 4.5605\text{ kPa/m} zc=15.04.5605=3.289 mz_c = \frac{15.0}{4.5605} = \mathbf{3.289\text{ m}}

Evaluating FOSFOS at z=4.0 mz = 4.0\text{ m} (z>zcz > z_c):

Numerator τf=15.0+3.5226×4.0=15.0+14.0904=29.0904 kPa\text{Numerator } \tau_f = 15.0 + 3.5226 \times 4.0 = 15.0 + 14.0904 = 29.0904\text{ kPa} Denominator τ=8.0831×4.0=32.3324 kPa\text{Denominator } \tau = 8.0831 \times 4.0 = 32.3324\text{ kPa} FOS(z=4.0 m)=29.090432.3324=0.8997(Unstable)FOS(z = 4.0\text{ m}) = \frac{29.0904}{32.3324} = \mathbf{0.8997} \quad (\text{Unstable})

Problem 2: Swedish Slip Circle Analysis with Dry vs. Water-Filled Tension Cracks

Statement: A railway cutting of depth H=10.0 mH = 10.0\text{ m} is excavated in a saturated homogeneous clay stratum having unit weight γ=19.0 kN/m3\gamma = 19.0\text{ kN/m}^3 and undrained shear strength cu=35.0 kPac_u = 35.0\text{ kPa} (ϕu=0\phi_u = 0).
A trial circular slip surface is analyzed:

  • Radius of rotation: R=14.5 mR = 14.5\text{ m}
  • Subtended central angle (uncracked): θ=72∘=72×π180=1.25664 rad\theta = 72^\circ = 72 \times \frac{\pi}{180} = 1.25664\text{ rad}
  • Cross-sectional area of potential failure wedge: A=70.0 m2A = 70.0\text{ m}^2
  • Center of gravity is located horizontally at xˉ=5.2 m\bar{x} = 5.2\text{ m} from the vertical axis passing through rotation center OO.

(a) Calculate the Factor of Safety neglecting tension crack formation.
(b) A tension crack of theoretical depth z0=2cu/γz_0 = 2c_u / \gamma forms at the crest. If the crack remains completely dry, the central subtended arc angle reduces to θ′=64∘=1.11701 rad\theta' = 64^\circ = 1.11701\text{ rad}, the sliding mass area reduces to A′=65.0 m2A' = 65.0\text{ m}^2, and its centroid shifts to xˉ′=5.0 m\bar{x}' = 5.0\text{ m}. Compute the modified FOSFOS.
(c) Following a cloudburst, the tension crack fills with rainwater to its entire depth. Given that the vertical lever arm of the resultant water thrust about center OO is yw=8.5 my_w = 8.5\text{ m}, calculate the new FOSFOS and determine the percentage reduction in stability caused by the rainwater surge.

Solution:

(a) Analysis Neglecting Tension Crack:

  • Weight of sliding mass per meter width: W=γ×A=19.0 kN/m3×70.0 m2=1330.00 kN/mW = \gamma \times A = 19.0\text{ kN/m}^3 \times 70.0\text{ m}^2 = 1330.00\text{ kN/m}
  • Driving overturning moment about center OO: Md=W⋅xˉ=1330.00 kN/m×5.2 m=6916.00 kN⋅m/mM_d = W \cdot \bar{x} = 1330.00\text{ kN/m} \times 5.2\text{ m} = 6916.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Resisting moment developed by undrained shear along circular arc: Mr=cu⋅R2⋅θ=35.0 kPa×(14.5 m)2×1.25664 rad=9247.28 kN⋅m/mM_r = c_u \cdot R^2 \cdot \theta = 35.0\text{ kPa} \times (14.5\text{ m})^2 \times 1.25664\text{ rad} = 9247.28\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Factor of Safety: FOS=MrMd=9247.286916.00=1.3371FOS = \frac{M_r}{M_d} = \frac{9247.28}{6916.00} = \mathbf{1.3371}

(b) Analysis with Dry Tension Crack:

  • Theoretical depth of tension crack: z0=2cuγ=2×35.019.0=3.684 mz_0 = \frac{2 c_u}{\gamma} = \frac{2 \times 35.0}{19.0} = 3.684\text{ m}
  • Weight of reduced sliding mass: W′=γ×A′=19.0×65.0=1235.00 kN/mW' = \gamma \times A' = 19.0 \times 65.0 = 1235.00\text{ kN/m}
  • Driving moment: Md′=W′⋅xˉ′=1235.00×5.0=6175.00 kN⋅m/mM_d' = W' \cdot \bar{x}' = 1235.00 \times 5.0 = 6175.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Resisting moment along reduced arc: Mr′=cu⋅R2⋅θ′=35.0×(14.5)2×1.11701 rad=8219.80 kN⋅m/mM_r' = c_u \cdot R^2 \cdot \theta' = 35.0 \times (14.5)^2 \times 1.11701\text{ rad} = 8219.80\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Factor of Safety: FOSdry crack=Mr′Md′=8219.806175.00=1.3311FOS_{\text{dry crack}} = \frac{M_r'}{M_d'} = \frac{8219.80}{6175.00} = \mathbf{1.3311}

(c) Analysis with Water-Filled Tension Crack:

  • Resultant horizontal hydrostatic water thrust acting inside the crack: Pw=12γwz02=12×9.81 kN/m3×(3.684 m)2=66.578 kN/mP_w = \frac{1}{2}\gamma_w z_0^2 = \frac{1}{2} \times 9.81\text{ kN/m}^3 \times (3.684\text{ m})^2 = 66.578\text{ kN/m}
  • Overturning moment exerted by water thrust about OO: Mw=Pw⋅yw=66.578 kN/m×8.5 m=565.91 kN⋅m/mM_w = P_w \cdot y_w = 66.578\text{ kN/m} \times 8.5\text{ m} = 565.91\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Total driving moment: Md,total=Md′+Mw=6175.00+565.91=6740.91 kN⋅m/mM_{d,\text{total}} = M_d' + M_w = 6175.00 + 565.91 = 6740.91\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}
  • Resisting moment remains Mr′=8219.80 kN⋅m/mM_r' = 8219.80\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m/m}.
  • Factor of Safety: FOSrain=Mr′Md,total=8219.806740.91=1.2194FOS_{\text{rain}} = \frac{M_r'}{M_{d,\text{total}}} = \frac{8219.80}{6740.91} = \mathbf{1.2194}
Percentage Reduction in FOS=1.3371−1.21941.3371×100%=8.80%\text{Percentage Reduction in } FOS = \frac{1.3371 - 1.2194}{1.3371} \times 100\% = \mathbf{8.80\%}

Problem 3: Taylor's Stability Number & Ordinary Method of Slices (OMS)

Statement: An embankment slope of height H=15.0 mH = 15.0\text{ m} is designed with an inclination of β=30∘\beta = 30^\circ. The soil properties are:

  • Cohesion: c′=30.0 kPac' = 30.0\text{ kPa}
  • Internal friction: ϕ′=15∘\phi' = 15^\circ
  • Saturated unit weight: γsat=20.0 kN/m3\gamma_{\text{sat}} = 20.0\text{ kN/m}^3
  • Bulk unit weight: γ=19.0 kN/m3\gamma = 19.0\text{ kN/m}^3
  • Submerged unit weight: γ′=20.0−9.81=10.19 kN/m3\gamma' = 20.0 - 9.81 = 10.19\text{ kN/m}^3

(a) For β=30∘\beta = 30^\circ and ϕ′=15∘\phi' = 15^\circ, Taylor's chart gives stability number Sn=0.083S_n = 0.083. Determine the Factor of Safety with respect to cohesion (FcF_c) assuming friction is fully mobilized, and calculate the critical height HcH_c.
(b) If the reservoir undergoes rapid/sudden drawdown, calculate the revised factor of safety using Taylor's modified stability number.
(c) For an alternative non-homogeneous slice geometry, the critical trial circle is discretized into 4 vertical slices. The soil shear parameters along the slip base are c′=28.0 kPac' = 28.0\text{ kPa} and ϕ′=28∘\phi' = 28^\circ (tan⁡ϕ′=0.53171\tan\phi' = 0.53171). The slice data is given in the table below:

Slice ii Width bib_i (m) Base Inclination αi\alpha_i (deg) Total Weight WiW_i (kN/m) Pore Pressure uiu_i (kPa) Base Length Δli=bi/cos⁡αi\Delta l_i = b_i/\cos\alpha_i (m)
1 2.5 12∘12^\circ 240.0 12.0 2.556
2 3.0 26∘26^\circ 390.0 22.0 3.338
3 3.0 38∘38^\circ 420.0 18.0 3.807
4 2.5 52∘52^\circ 210.0 0.0 4.061

Calculate the overall Factor of Safety of the slope using the Ordinary Method of Slices (Fellenius / OMS).

Solution:

(a) Taylor's Stability Analysis: Given: Sn=0.083S_n = 0.083, H=15.0 mH = 15.0\text{ m}, γ=19.0 kN/m3\gamma = 19.0\text{ kN/m}^3, c=30.0 kPac = 30.0\text{ kPa}.

  • Mobilized cohesion required: cm=Sn⋅γ⋅H=0.083×19.0×15.0=23.655 kPac_m = S_n \cdot \gamma \cdot H = 0.083 \times 19.0 \times 15.0 = 23.655\text{ kPa}
  • Factor of Safety with respect to cohesion: Fc=ccm=30.023.655=1.268F_c = \frac{c}{c_m} = \frac{30.0}{23.655} = \mathbf{1.268}
  • Critical Height HcH_c: Hc=cSn⋅γ=30.00.083×19.0=19.02 mH_c = \frac{c}{S_n \cdot \gamma} = \frac{30.0}{0.083 \times 19.0} = \mathbf{19.02\text{ m}} FH=HcH=19.0215.0=1.268=FcF_H = \frac{H_c}{H} = \frac{19.02}{15.0} = \mathbf{1.268} = F_c

(b) Sudden Drawdown Analysis: During sudden drawdown, internal pore pressure remains high while external pool support vanishes.

  • Modified stability number: Sn′=Sn(γsatγ′)=0.083×(20.010.19)=0.083×1.9627=0.1629S_n' = S_n \left(\frac{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}{\gamma'}\right) = 0.083 \times \left(\frac{20.0}{10.19}\right) = 0.083 \times 1.9627 = 0.1629
  • Factor of safety during sudden drawdown: Fc,dd=cSn′⋅γsat⋅H=30.00.1629×20.0×15.0=30.048.87=0.614F_{c,\text{dd}} = \frac{c}{S_n' \cdot \gamma_{\text{sat}} \cdot H} = \frac{30.0}{0.1629 \times 20.0 \times 15.0} = \frac{30.0}{48.87} = \mathbf{0.614}

Critical Safety Assessment: FOS=0.614≪1.0FOS = 0.614 \ll 1.0, indicating that sudden drawdown will trigger catastrophic upstream slope failure unless the slope is flattened to ≈1V:3H\approx 1\text{V}:3\text{H} or protected with free-draining rockfill riprap!

(c) Ordinary Method of Slices (OMS) Computation: For each slice ii:

  • Driving force: Ti=Wisin⁡αiT_i = W_i \sin\alpha_i
  • Base normal force: Ni=Wicos⁡αiN_i = W_i \cos\alpha_i
  • Base pore water force: Ui=uiΔliU_i = u_i \Delta l_i
  • Effective normal force: Ni′=Ni−Ui=Wicos⁡αi−uiΔliN_i' = N_i - U_i = W_i \cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i
  • Resisting shear force: ΔRi=c′Δli+Ni′tan⁡ϕ′\Delta R_i = c' \Delta l_i + N_i' \tan\phi'

Tabulating slice by slice:

  1. Slice 1: (α1=12∘,sin⁡12∘=0.20791,cos⁡12∘=0.97815\alpha_1 = 12^\circ, \sin 12^\circ = 0.20791, \cos 12^\circ = 0.97815)

    • Driving force: T1=240.0×0.20791=49.90 kN/mT_1 = 240.0 \times 0.20791 = 49.90\text{ kN/m}
    • N1=240.0×0.97815=234.76 kN/mN_1 = 240.0 \times 0.97815 = 234.76\text{ kN/m}
    • U1=12.0×2.556=30.67 kN/mU_1 = 12.0 \times 2.556 = 30.67\text{ kN/m}
    • N1′=234.76−30.67=204.09 kN/mN_1' = 234.76 - 30.67 = 204.09\text{ kN/m}
    • ΔR1=28.0×2.556+204.09×0.53171=71.57+108.52=180.09 kN/m\Delta R_1 = 28.0 \times 2.556 + 204.09 \times 0.53171 = 71.57 + 108.52 = 180.09\text{ kN/m}
  2. Slice 2: (α2=26∘,sin⁡26∘=0.43837,cos⁡26∘=0.89879\alpha_2 = 26^\circ, \sin 26^\circ = 0.43837, \cos 26^\circ = 0.89879)

    • Driving force: T2=390.0×0.43837=170.96 kN/mT_2 = 390.0 \times 0.43837 = 170.96\text{ kN/m}
    • N2=390.0×0.89879=350.53 kN/mN_2 = 390.0 \times 0.89879 = 350.53\text{ kN/m}
    • U2=22.0×3.338=73.44 kN/mU_2 = 22.0 \times 3.338 = 73.44\text{ kN/m}
    • N2′=350.53−73.44=277.09 kN/mN_2' = 350.53 - 73.44 = 277.09\text{ kN/m}
    • ΔR2=28.0×3.338+277.09×0.53171=93.46+147.33=240.79 kN/m\Delta R_2 = 28.0 \times 3.338 + 277.09 \times 0.53171 = 93.46 + 147.33 = 240.79\text{ kN/m}
  3. Slice 3: (α3=38∘,sin⁡38∘=0.61566,cos⁡38∘=0.78801\alpha_3 = 38^\circ, \sin 38^\circ = 0.61566, \cos 38^\circ = 0.78801)

    • Driving force: T3=420.0×0.61566=258.58 kN/mT_3 = 420.0 \times 0.61566 = 258.58\text{ kN/m}
    • N3=420.0×0.78801=330.96 kN/mN_3 = 420.0 \times 0.78801 = 330.96\text{ kN/m}
    • U3=18.0×3.807=68.53 kN/mU_3 = 18.0 \times 3.807 = 68.53\text{ kN/m}
    • N3′=330.96−68.53=262.43 kN/mN_3' = 330.96 - 68.53 = 262.43\text{ kN/m}
    • ΔR3=28.0×3.807+262.43×0.53171=106.60+139.54=246.14 kN/m\Delta R_3 = 28.0 \times 3.807 + 262.43 \times 0.53171 = 106.60 + 139.54 = 246.14\text{ kN/m}
  4. Slice 4: (α4=52∘,sin⁡52∘=0.78801,cos⁡52∘=0.61566\alpha_4 = 52^\circ, \sin 52^\circ = 0.78801, \cos 52^\circ = 0.61566)

    • Driving force: T4=210.0×0.78801=165.48 kN/mT_4 = 210.0 \times 0.78801 = 165.48\text{ kN/m}
    • N4=210.0×0.61566=129.29 kN/mN_4 = 210.0 \times 0.61566 = 129.29\text{ kN/m}
    • U4=0.0U_4 = 0.0
    • N4′=129.29−0.0=129.29 kN/mN_4' = 129.29 - 0.0 = 129.29\text{ kN/m}
    • ΔR4=28.0×4.061+129.29×0.53171=113.71+68.74=182.45 kN/m\Delta R_4 = 28.0 \times 4.061 + 129.29 \times 0.53171 = 113.71 + 68.74 = 182.45\text{ kN/m}

Summations:

  • Total driving force: ∑i=14Ti=49.90+170.96+258.58+165.48=644.92 kN/m\sum_{i=1}^4 T_i = 49.90 + 170.96 + 258.58 + 165.48 = \mathbf{644.92\text{ kN/m}}
  • Total resisting shear resistance: ∑i=14ΔRi=180.09+240.79+246.14+182.45=849.47 kN/m\sum_{i=1}^4 \Delta R_i = 180.09 + 240.79 + 246.14 + 182.45 = \mathbf{849.47\text{ kN/m}}

Overall Factor of Safety:

FOSOMS=∑ΔRi∑Ti=849.47644.92=1.3172FOS_{\text{OMS}} = \frac{\sum \Delta R_i}{\sum T_i} = \frac{849.47}{644.92} = \mathbf{1.3172}

12. Comparative Engineering Analysis Across Syllabi

┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                        SYLLABUS EMPHASIS & EXAMINATION FOCUS MATRIX                            │
├─────────────┬─────────────────────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ Examination │ High-Yield Core Focus Areas                     │ Typical Question Typology              │
├─────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ GATE CE     │ • Infinite slopes: dry vs submerged vs seepage  │ 1-2 mark MCQs/NATs on ratio            │
│             │ • Critical depth z_c for c-φ infinite slopes    │ γ'/γ_sat = 0.5; Taylor stability       │
│             │ • Taylor's Sn formulas & sudden drawdown factor │ number calculations; Bishop m_α        │
├─────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ UPSC ESE    │ • Swedish circle derivations (φ_u = 0) with     │ 10-20 mark conventional proofs of      │
│             │   tension cracks and water thrust M_w           │ Bishop vertical equilibrium; full      │
│             │ • Earth dam critical phases (IS 7894)           │ tabular method of slices problems      │
├─────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ SSC JE &    │ • Angle of repose = internal friction φ'        │ Rapid objective MCQs on failure        │
│ RRB JE      │ • Infinite slope seepage cuts FOS by 50%        │ circle types (toe vs base), D_f > 1,   │
│             │ • Depth factor D_f = (H+D)/H classification     │ vertical cut H_c = 4c/γ                │
├─────────────┼─────────────────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ State AE/JE │ • Taylor's Sn = c / (Fc · γ · H) calculations   │ Direct formula substitutions,          │
│             │ • End of construction vs drawdown conditions    │ definitions of mobilized cohesion c_m  │
└─────────────┴─────────────────────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

13. Common Misconceptions & Examination Pitfalls

  1. Submerged vs. Seepage Invariant:

    • Trap: Assuming that a fully submerged slope has a reduced factor of safety compared to a dry slope.
    • Reality: For static water (no flow), FOSsubmerged=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β=FOSdryFOS_{\text{submerged}} = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} = FOS_{\text{dry}}. The buoyant reduction applies equally to both resisting friction (γ′zcos⁡2βtan⁡ϕ′\gamma' z \cos^2\beta \tan\phi') and driving shear (γ′zsin⁡βcos⁡β\gamma' z \sin\beta \cos\beta), leaving the ratio unchanged. Only seepage flow (gradient ii) reduces the factor of safety!
  2. Total vs. Submerged Unit Weight in Seepage Driving Stress:

    • Trap: Using submerged unit weight γ′\gamma' to calculate the driving shear stress during steady seepage.
    • Reality: In steady seepage, gravity acts on the total mass (soil + pore water). Hence, the driving shear stress is τ=γsatzsin⁡βcos⁡β\tau = \gamma_{\text{sat}} z \sin\beta \cos\beta, while effective normal stress is σ′=γ′zcos⁡2β\sigma' = \gamma' z \cos^2\beta. This asymmetry is precisely why FOSFOS is reduced by γ′/γsat≈0.5\gamma' / \gamma_{\text{sat}} \approx 0.5.
  3. Depth Factor DfD_f Definition:

    • Trap: Defining Df=D/HD_f = D / H.
    • Reality: By international standard, Df=D+HH=1+DHD_f = \frac{D + H}{H} = 1 + \frac{D}{H}. Thus, Df=1.0D_f = 1.0 represents a toe circle; Df>1.0D_f > 1.0 represents a base circle.
  4. Tension Crack Hydrostatic Lever Arm:

    • Trap: Taking the lever arm of the water thrust PwP_w from the base of the crack rather than about the center of rotation OO.
    • Reality: In moment equilibrium, moments must be taken strictly about the center of rotation OO. If OO has vertical coordinate yOy_O and the crest is at ycresty_{\text{crest}}, the line of action of PwP_w is at ycrest−23z0y_{\text{crest}} - \frac{2}{3}z_0, giving vertical lever arm yw=yO−(ycrest−23z0)y_w = y_O - (y_{\text{crest}} - \frac{2}{3}z_0).
  5. Taylor's Stability Number during Sudden Drawdown:

    • Trap: Using the dry/bulk unit weight in Sn=cγHS_n = \frac{c}{\gamma H} during drawdown.
    • Reality: During sudden drawdown, the effective stability number is Sn′=Sn×(γsat/γ′)S_n' = S_n \times (\gamma_{\text{sat}} / \gamma'). The denominator must utilize γsat\gamma_{\text{sat}}.

14. Key Reference Formulas & Summary Table

Slope ConditionGoverning EquationKey Design NoteInfinite Slope: Dry / Submerged (c=0)FOS=tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βIndependent of z and γ; stable if β≤ϕ′Infinite Slope: Seepage Parallel to Face (c=0)FOS=(γ′γsat)tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡β≈0.50tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βSeepage reduces FOS by ∼50%Infinite Slope: c−ϕ SoilFOS=c′γzsin⁡βcos⁡β+tan⁡ϕ′tan⁡βFOS decreases with depth zCritical Depth: Dry c−ϕ Slopezc=c′γcos⁡2β(tan⁡β−tan⁡ϕ′)Depth where FOS=1.0Critical Depth: Pure Clay (ϕ=0)zc=cγsin⁡βcos⁡β=2cγsin⁡(2β)For vertical cut (β=90∘):Hc=4cγSwedish Slip Circle (ϕu=0)FOS=cuR2θW⋅xˉTotal stress analysis; circular arcTension Crack Depthz0=2cuγWater thrust: Pw=12γwz02Ordinary Method of Slices (OMS)FOS=∑[c′Δli+(Wicos⁡αi−uiΔli)tan⁡ϕ′]∑Wisin⁡αiNeglects interslice forces; conservativeBishop’s Simplified MethodFOS=∑[{c′bi+(Wi−uibi)tan⁡ϕ′}/mα,i]∑Wisin⁡αimα,i=cos⁡αi[1+(tan⁡αitan⁡ϕ′)/FOS]Taylor’s Stability NumberSn=cFc⋅γ⋅HHc=cSnγ; pure clay vertical: Sn=0.261Drawdown Stability NumberSn′=Sn(γsatγ′)Critical for upstream dam slope\begin{array}{|l|l|l|} \hline \textbf{Slope Condition} & \textbf{Governing Equation} & \textbf{Key Design Note} \\ \hline \text{Infinite Slope: Dry / Submerged } (c = 0) & FOS = \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} & \text{Independent of } z \text{ and } \gamma; \text{ stable if } \beta \le \phi' \\ \hline \text{Infinite Slope: Seepage Parallel to Face } (c=0) & FOS = \left(\frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}\right)\frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} \approx 0.50 \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} & \text{Seepage reduces } FOS \text{ by } \sim 50\% \\ \hline \text{Infinite Slope: } c-\phi \text{ Soil} & FOS = \frac{c'}{\gamma z \sin\beta \cos\beta} + \frac{\tan\phi'}{\tan\beta} & FOS \text{ decreases with depth } z \\ \hline \text{Critical Depth: Dry } c-\phi \text{ Slope} & z_c = \frac{c'}{\gamma \cos^2\beta(\tan\beta - \tan\phi')} & \text{Depth where } FOS = 1.0 \\ \hline \text{Critical Depth: Pure Clay } (\phi = 0) & z_c = \frac{c}{\gamma \sin\beta \cos\beta} = \frac{2c}{\gamma \sin(2\beta)} & \text{For vertical cut } (\beta = 90^\circ): H_c = \frac{4c}{\gamma} \\ \hline \text{Swedish Slip Circle } (\phi_u = 0) & FOS = \frac{c_u R^2 \theta}{W \cdot \bar{x}} & \text{Total stress analysis; circular arc} \\ \hline \text{Tension Crack Depth} & z_0 = \frac{2 c_u}{\gamma} & \text{Water thrust: } P_w = \frac{1}{2}\gamma_w z_0^2 \\ \hline \text{Ordinary Method of Slices (OMS)} & FOS = \frac{\sum [c' \Delta l_i + (W_i\cos\alpha_i - u_i \Delta l_i)\tan\phi']}{\sum W_i \sin\alpha_i} & \text{Neglects interslice forces; conservative} \\ \hline \text{Bishop's Simplified Method} & FOS = \frac{\sum [\{c' b_i + (W_i - u_i b_i)\tan\phi'\} / m_{\alpha, i}]}{\sum W_i \sin\alpha_i} & m_{\alpha, i} = \cos\alpha_i [1 + (\tan\alpha_i\tan\phi')/FOS] \\ \hline \text{Taylor's Stability Number} & S_n = \frac{c}{F_c \cdot \gamma \cdot H} & H_c = \frac{c}{S_n \gamma}; \text{ pure clay vertical: } S_n = 0.261 \\ \hline \text{Drawdown Stability Number} & S_n' = S_n \left(\frac{\gamma_{\text{sat}}}{\gamma'}\right) & \text{Critical for upstream dam slope} \\ \hline \end{array}